Trump's secretary of state pick has a plan for fighting ISIS that has the same fatal flaw as Obama's strategy
Pamela Engel
Business InsiderJanuary 14, 2017
(Rex Tillerson testifies during a Senate Foreign Relations Committee confirmation hearing.REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque)
During his confirmation hearing earlier this week, President-elect Donald Trump's pick for secretary of state articulated his strategy for defeating ISIS in Syria — and it sounded very similar to what the Obama administration has been doing since the terror group established itself in the country.
Former Exxon Mobil CEO Rex Tillerson told the Senate Foreign Affairs Committee that he thinks the US should focus on wiping out the terrorist group ISIS in Syria before figuring out what to do about Syrian President Bashar al-Assad.
The civil war in Syria has been raging on for almost six years as rebels — some of whom are Islamic terrorists — fight to oust Assad, whose brutal regime has been responsible for more civilian deaths than any terror group in the country.
"We've had two competing priorities in Syria under this administration: 'Bashar al-Assad must go' and the defeat of ISIS," Tillerson said. "And the truth of the matter is, carrying both of those out simultaneously is extremely difficult because at times they conflict with one another."
He continued: "The clear priority is to defeat ISIS. We defeat ISIS, we at least create some level of stability in Syria which then lets us deal with the next priority of what is going to be the exit of Bashar al-Assad."
But while the Obama administration has indeed called for Assad to step down, the US has not made his ouster a priority. And when President Barack Obama had the chance to act on a red line he set forth in 2012, he ended up deciding not to take military action against Assad.
The clear priority for the US in Syria over the past few years has always been defeating ISIS.
"I don't see any big daylight between what Tillerson said and what Obama's administration has been doing," Robert Ford, a senior fellow at the Middle East Institute and Yale University who was the US ambassador to Syria from 2011 to 2014, told Business Insider.
Ford noted that for the last two and a half years of US involvement in Syria, "it's been abundantly clear that the Islamic State is the heavy priority and not the Assad government."
Many Syria experts say this is misguided because ISIS' presence in Syria is fostered by Assad's continued hold on power.
"The key problems we face center on the effects of Assad regime mass homicide: a recruiting bonanza for Islamist extremists, spillover effects that embolden Russia and hurt allies, and the signature humanitarian abomination (to date) of the 21st century," Fred Hof, a former special adviser for transition in Syria under Hillary Clinton, then the secretary of state, told Business Insider in an email.
"This is why a strategy that separates Assad and ISIS would be doomed to failure," he added. "Assad and ISIS are joined at the hip."
(A rebel fighter takes away a flag that belonged to Islamic State militants in Akhtarin village in northern Aleppo Governorate, Syria, October 7, 2016.REUTERS/Khalil Ashawi)
The Assad regime theoretically fights ISIS, and vice versa, but the real targets for destruction in Syria are the moderate rebel groups whose primary goal is to oust Assad.
Assad knows that ISIS and Al Qaeda-backed groups in Syria will never be able to rule the country legitimately because the West will never work with them. Therefore, the real threat to Assad come from the rebels whom the West could in theory support.
Because of this dynamic, the Assad regime and its allies aren't going to completely wipe out radical extremist groups as long as moderate rebels are still fighting.
But extremist groups are still fighting the Assad regime, and because they are often better equipped than other rebel groups, Syrians who are desperate to oust Assad join up out of practicality. Assad's regime also allowed ISIS to grow and prosper in the first place.
"The connection between Assad's atrocities against mainly Sunni Arab civilians and the ability of ISIS and other Islamist extremists to recruit and prosper is well-established," said Hof, who is now the director of the Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle East at the Atlantic Council.
Hof continued: "What's been lacking is a strategy that recognizes and acts upon the linkage — the symbiotic relationship — between a murderous Assad regime and the extremist groups it has helped spawn."
Ford said the solution to the crisis in Syria has to be both military and political.
"A lot of experts would say Assad's government itself has created a lot of the conditions that spur recruitment into Islamic terrorist groups," he said. "The problem is not so much military as it is political having to do with grievances against a brutal, repressive government."
Ford said he think it has "always made more sense to prioritize Assad over the Islamic State."
(Demonstrators hold a sign as they gather during a protest against Syria's President Bashar al-Assad and Russia in Kafranbel, near Idlib January 29, 2012.Reuters)
One victor in the Syrian civil war has been Russia, a country that has been increasingly hostile to the US. Russia entered the fray in Syria in 2015 to support the Assad regime. Since then, the Russian military has helped the regime win a series of victories against anti-Assad rebels.
While Russia initially said it was intervening in Syria to fight ISIS, it has become clear that bolstering the Assad regime is its real priority.
Tillerson himself noted that the Syrian civil war "has provided a convenient open door for Russia to now establish a presence in the Middle East, a region that it has long been absent from."
Iran, another country that is no friend to the US, has also been exerting its influence in Syria to support Assad.
Tillerson also insisted that the US must have a plan for who would replace Assad if he were to be forced from power.
"We need to answer the question, what comes next? What is going to be the government structure in Syria, and can we have any influence over that or not?" Tillerson asked.
Hof disagreed with this sentiment.
"Although it is troubling to assign stabilizing qualities to a mass murderer, the issue of who ultimately replaces Assad is a bit of a red herring: he has all-but-destroyed a state and there has been no American effort to overthrow him," he said. "Besides, did the world agonize in 1945 over who would replace Hitler?"
Pamela Engel
Business InsiderJanuary 14, 2017
(Rex Tillerson testifies during a Senate Foreign Relations Committee confirmation hearing.REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque)
During his confirmation hearing earlier this week, President-elect Donald Trump's pick for secretary of state articulated his strategy for defeating ISIS in Syria — and it sounded very similar to what the Obama administration has been doing since the terror group established itself in the country.
Former Exxon Mobil CEO Rex Tillerson told the Senate Foreign Affairs Committee that he thinks the US should focus on wiping out the terrorist group ISIS in Syria before figuring out what to do about Syrian President Bashar al-Assad.
The civil war in Syria has been raging on for almost six years as rebels — some of whom are Islamic terrorists — fight to oust Assad, whose brutal regime has been responsible for more civilian deaths than any terror group in the country.
"We've had two competing priorities in Syria under this administration: 'Bashar al-Assad must go' and the defeat of ISIS," Tillerson said. "And the truth of the matter is, carrying both of those out simultaneously is extremely difficult because at times they conflict with one another."
He continued: "The clear priority is to defeat ISIS. We defeat ISIS, we at least create some level of stability in Syria which then lets us deal with the next priority of what is going to be the exit of Bashar al-Assad."
But while the Obama administration has indeed called for Assad to step down, the US has not made his ouster a priority. And when President Barack Obama had the chance to act on a red line he set forth in 2012, he ended up deciding not to take military action against Assad.
The clear priority for the US in Syria over the past few years has always been defeating ISIS.
"I don't see any big daylight between what Tillerson said and what Obama's administration has been doing," Robert Ford, a senior fellow at the Middle East Institute and Yale University who was the US ambassador to Syria from 2011 to 2014, told Business Insider.
Ford noted that for the last two and a half years of US involvement in Syria, "it's been abundantly clear that the Islamic State is the heavy priority and not the Assad government."
Many Syria experts say this is misguided because ISIS' presence in Syria is fostered by Assad's continued hold on power.
"The key problems we face center on the effects of Assad regime mass homicide: a recruiting bonanza for Islamist extremists, spillover effects that embolden Russia and hurt allies, and the signature humanitarian abomination (to date) of the 21st century," Fred Hof, a former special adviser for transition in Syria under Hillary Clinton, then the secretary of state, told Business Insider in an email.
"This is why a strategy that separates Assad and ISIS would be doomed to failure," he added. "Assad and ISIS are joined at the hip."
(A rebel fighter takes away a flag that belonged to Islamic State militants in Akhtarin village in northern Aleppo Governorate, Syria, October 7, 2016.REUTERS/Khalil Ashawi)
The Assad regime theoretically fights ISIS, and vice versa, but the real targets for destruction in Syria are the moderate rebel groups whose primary goal is to oust Assad.
Assad knows that ISIS and Al Qaeda-backed groups in Syria will never be able to rule the country legitimately because the West will never work with them. Therefore, the real threat to Assad come from the rebels whom the West could in theory support.
Because of this dynamic, the Assad regime and its allies aren't going to completely wipe out radical extremist groups as long as moderate rebels are still fighting.
But extremist groups are still fighting the Assad regime, and because they are often better equipped than other rebel groups, Syrians who are desperate to oust Assad join up out of practicality. Assad's regime also allowed ISIS to grow and prosper in the first place.
"The connection between Assad's atrocities against mainly Sunni Arab civilians and the ability of ISIS and other Islamist extremists to recruit and prosper is well-established," said Hof, who is now the director of the Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle East at the Atlantic Council.
Hof continued: "What's been lacking is a strategy that recognizes and acts upon the linkage — the symbiotic relationship — between a murderous Assad regime and the extremist groups it has helped spawn."
Ford said the solution to the crisis in Syria has to be both military and political.
"A lot of experts would say Assad's government itself has created a lot of the conditions that spur recruitment into Islamic terrorist groups," he said. "The problem is not so much military as it is political having to do with grievances against a brutal, repressive government."
Ford said he think it has "always made more sense to prioritize Assad over the Islamic State."
(Demonstrators hold a sign as they gather during a protest against Syria's President Bashar al-Assad and Russia in Kafranbel, near Idlib January 29, 2012.Reuters)
One victor in the Syrian civil war has been Russia, a country that has been increasingly hostile to the US. Russia entered the fray in Syria in 2015 to support the Assad regime. Since then, the Russian military has helped the regime win a series of victories against anti-Assad rebels.
While Russia initially said it was intervening in Syria to fight ISIS, it has become clear that bolstering the Assad regime is its real priority.
Tillerson himself noted that the Syrian civil war "has provided a convenient open door for Russia to now establish a presence in the Middle East, a region that it has long been absent from."
Iran, another country that is no friend to the US, has also been exerting its influence in Syria to support Assad.
Tillerson also insisted that the US must have a plan for who would replace Assad if he were to be forced from power.
"We need to answer the question, what comes next? What is going to be the government structure in Syria, and can we have any influence over that or not?" Tillerson asked.
Hof disagreed with this sentiment.
"Although it is troubling to assign stabilizing qualities to a mass murderer, the issue of who ultimately replaces Assad is a bit of a red herring: he has all-but-destroyed a state and there has been no American effort to overthrow him," he said. "Besides, did the world agonize in 1945 over who would replace Hitler?"
Today at 8:33 am by Rocky
» Will he hand over the authority of the region peacefully? ...The Democrat is mixing the political ca
Today at 8:32 am by Rocky
» Politician: 99% of the Kurdish parties will not suspend their participation in the region’s election
Today at 8:31 am by Rocky
» The disputes between the Kirkuk forces are approaching a solution
Today at 8:29 am by Rocky
» To remove the foreigner... the first round negotiations between Iraq and the coalition continue
Today at 8:28 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Committee: The region continues to export oil through Turkish Ceyhan
Today at 8:27 am by Rocky
» To cover salaries.. Baghdad sends 1.5 billion dinars to Kurdistan
Today at 8:24 am by Rocky
» In less than 12 hours, 19,000 Iranians entered Iraq
Today at 8:22 am by Rocky
» In exchange for completing transactions, government employees taking bribes were arrested
Today at 8:21 am by Rocky
» Iraq is moving to build the largest solar energy station
Today at 8:19 am by Rocky
» Amending the budget for social care and the disabled
Today at 8:18 am by Rocky
» A proposal to appoint social welfare beneficiaries to the security services
Today at 8:17 am by Rocky
» Calls for “regionalization” are outbidding and personal interests
Today at 8:15 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance: Traffic fines will increase the state budget
Today at 8:14 am by Rocky
» Support the agricultural engineer
Today at 8:13 am by Rocky
» Experts: Activating the industrial and agricultural sectors stops 80% of imports
Today at 8:12 am by Rocky
» Central Bank sales exceed $245 million today
Today at 8:09 am by Rocky
» Today's newspapers are interested in Al-Sudani's assertion that the state of stability achieved in I
Today at 6:16 am by Rocky
» Al-Badran: The reason for postponing the Basra Council session is to give members sufficient time to
Today at 6:14 am by Rocky
» The Contractors Registration and Classification Committee at the Ministry of Planning completed more
Today at 6:13 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Foreign Affairs: We discussed these files with the Romanian Senate
Today at 6:12 am by Rocky
» Baghdad Investment Authority to / Nina /: We will adopt future programming to implement projects and
Today at 6:10 am by Rocky
» Their arms are "electronic flies"... Personalities who lost their positions seek to stir up strife b
Today at 6:08 am by Rocky
» Decrease in dollar exchange rates in morning trading in Baghdad markets
Today at 6:06 am by Rocky
» An international organization: Plans to enhance the livelihood of affected displaced and returning f
Today at 6:04 am by Rocky
» Dozens of factories are halted... Industry: We went into partnership with the private sector to rest
Today at 6:03 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi Communist criticizes the decision to abolish the Kurdistan Parliament quota: positive disc
Today at 6:01 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani confirms Iraq's aspiration for the participation of Azerbaijani companies in construction
Today at 6:00 am by Rocky
» An initiative by the President of the Republic to solve the problem of the region’s salaries
Today at 5:59 am by Rocky
» The Kurdistan government complains about Baghdad’s finances: It is ready to pay 59% of the salaries
Today at 5:58 am by Rocky
» Al-Khanjar: The Democratic boycott of the elections puts the future of Iraq in danger
Today at 5:55 am by Rocky
» Iraq is ranked seventh in the Arab world and 33rd globally in the misery index
Today at 5:54 am by Rocky
» Trade announces the achievement of self-sufficiency in ration card materials
Today at 5:52 am by Rocky
» Finance releases funding for state employees’ salaries for the month of March
Today at 5:51 am by Rocky
» Elon Musk: 20 seats won by Biden and his party with the votes of “illegal immigrants”
Today at 5:50 am by Rocky
» A "paradigm shift" awaits the regions of the belt and outskirts of Baghdad
Today at 5:47 am by Rocky
» “Speicher and Malwiya Fund”..Parliamentary Finance talks about “illegal fees” in state departments
Today at 5:46 am by Rocky
» Government admission of the failure of the meter campaign: Generators’ compliance is “almost non-exi
Today at 5:44 am by Rocky
» Iraq is proceeding with the zero nuclear reactor project.. Find out its details
Today at 5:42 am by Rocky
» The decision to “reduce exports”... “unplanned” production for Kurdistan will cost Baghdad half a bi
Today at 5:41 am by Rocky
» The powers of Kurdistan.. The Federal Court confirms its commitment to what was agreed upon by the “
Today at 5:39 am by Rocky
» Launching funding for state employees’ salaries for the month of March
Today at 5:38 am by Rocky
» Iraq and Syria top the "least safe" Arab countries
Yesterday at 8:23 am by Rocky
» Governor of Baghdad: 20 projects will be included during the current year in the city of Nahrawan
Yesterday at 8:20 am by Rocky
» More than $242 million in central bank sales today
Yesterday at 8:17 am by Rocky
» Advisor: Sudanese is determined to close the displacement file
Yesterday at 8:14 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The implementation of the 2023 budget witnessed a success that must be invested in
Yesterday at 8:13 am by Rocky
» The Baghdad Council will decide on the nomination of the committees in the coming days
Yesterday at 8:10 am by Rocky
» Al-Samarrai: The Sunni community is not in favor of removing American forces
Yesterday at 8:08 am by Rocky
» A warning from Al-Rasheed to those wishing to apply for advances and loans
Yesterday at 8:06 am by Rocky
» Azerbaijan expresses its desire to participate in the implementation of joint projects in the oil an
Yesterday at 8:05 am by Rocky
» Fuel cards arouse citizens' discontent
Yesterday at 8:03 am by Rocky
» utube 3/18/24 MM&C Iraqi Dinar-- IQD-- Dinar Update -100% Electronic - Real Effective Exchange Rat
Yesterday at 6:21 am by Rocky
» utube MM&C 3/16/24 0:05 / 18:16 Iraq Federal Court Brings - Strength to Financial - Politic
Yesterday at 6:18 am by Rocky
» MM&C 3/18/24 Sudanese Advisor: Iraq will leave government monetary dealing in mid-2024
Yesterday at 6:17 am by Rocky
» A delegation from the Kurdistan government visits Baghdad to discuss the issue of localization of sa
Yesterday at 6:11 am by Rocky
» Director of the Central Oil Company: We are keen to provide the appropriate investment environment
Yesterday at 6:10 am by Rocky
» The Energy Parliament calls for reporting generators violating government pricing
Yesterday at 6:08 am by Rocky
» A representative reveals the fate of the laws of “previous sessions”
Yesterday at 6:07 am by Rocky
» Politician: Coordination holds the keys to resolving the “Parliament Presidency” conflict
Yesterday at 6:05 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: Iraq wants to carry out its peaceful activity in the field of atomic energy
Yesterday at 6:04 am by Rocky
» Including a minister and a parliamentarian... 38 arrest and recruitment orders were issued against t
Yesterday at 6:02 am by Rocky
» Integrity: Citizens’ cooperation resulted in detecting inflation and returning state funds
Yesterday at 6:01 am by Rocky
» Agriculture presents 97 projects to the Ministerial Council for the Economy
Yesterday at 5:59 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: We succeeded in implementing the 2023 budget, and we must continue to complete economic p
Yesterday at 5:58 am by Rocky
» Labor adopts new mechanisms to reduce the phenomenon of begging
Yesterday at 5:57 am by Rocky
» Electronically.. directing the collection of fees tomorrow in an Iraqi governorate
Yesterday at 5:56 am by Rocky
» Held in Brussels.. Iraq receives an official invitation to attend the Nuclear Energy Summit
Yesterday at 5:55 am by Rocky
» Kurdistan has been paralyzed. There has been no liquidity in hand for 50 days, and the truth has bee
Yesterday at 5:53 am by Rocky
» The dollar continues to decline against the Iraqi dinar on the stock exchange and exchange offices
Yesterday at 5:52 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Oil reveals the reasons for Shell’s withdrawal from Nebras: It will be divided into
Yesterday at 5:51 am by Rocky
» The Housing Fund advises loan applicants and launches a link for inquiries
Yesterday at 5:50 am by Rocky
» He stressed that the government’s vision is to make one class not exceed 25 students...Government me
Yesterday at 5:48 am by Rocky
» Al-Hakim and Al-Halbousi stress the importance of choosing a speaker for Parliament in accordance wi
Yesterday at 5:47 am by Rocky
» Iron and Steel Company: Iraq is on the verge of a major industrial revolution
Yesterday at 5:46 am by Rocky
» Economists: Citizens still prefer cash transactions over electronic transactions
Yesterday at 5:45 am by Rocky
» The compass of Iraq's foreign policy in a world of turbulent polarization
Yesterday at 5:43 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance: The federal budget is in the corridors of the Council of Ministers, and there
Yesterday at 5:42 am by Rocky
» Integrity calls on citizens to report the inflation of funds in the sector of the Ministry of Labor
Yesterday at 5:40 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani directs the launch of initiatives for young businessmen and investors
Yesterday at 5:38 am by Rocky
» Representative agriculture emphasizes taking supportive measures for the local product
Yesterday at 5:37 am by Rocky
» An economist calls on the government to support and stimulate the private sector
Yesterday at 5:36 am by Rocky
» Al-Ittihad: Employees and retirees in Kurdistan paid the price of political differences with Baghdad
Yesterday at 5:34 am by Rocky
» Al-Samarrai and Al-Hakim discuss the importance of achieving political and constitutional entitlemen
Yesterday at 5:32 am by Rocky
» Only 23 million dunums. Iraq exploits approximately 50% of its arable land
Yesterday at 5:30 am by Rocky
» Türkiye considers it a political issue.. Where have the negotiations reached regarding Iraq’s water
Yesterday at 5:29 am by Rocky
» Sudanese receives an invitation to attend the Nuclear Energy Summit in Brussels - Urgent
Yesterday at 5:27 am by Rocky
» Central Bank sales exceed $240 million today
Sun Mar 17, 2024 7:52 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance calls on the government to expedite sending the 2024 budget to Parliament
Sun Mar 17, 2024 7:47 am by Rocky
» ‘We’re So Sick of It’: Northern Border Crisis Gets Worse
Sun Mar 17, 2024 7:35 am by Bama Diva
» A representative holds Kurdistan responsible for the faltering legislation of the oil and gas law
Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:27 am by Rocky
» Warnings of the danger of the increase in foreign labor in Iraq
Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:26 am by Rocky
» Iraq's oil exports to America decreased within a week
Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:25 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani chairs an “important” meeting to form the Kirkuk government
Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:23 am by Rocky
» Investment confirms the adoption of a new method in new residential cities and explains its details
Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:21 am by Rocky
» For the first time in 2024.. exchange rates fall to the threshold of 149 thousand in Baghdad
Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:19 am by Rocky
» Including gold.. An increase in exports of 3 Turkish products to Iraq during 2024
Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:18 am by Rocky
» A detailed integrity report regarding the Housing Fund... called for this matter
Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:17 am by Rocky
» Resources count the number of trespassers in Baghdad.. What about restaurants?
Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:16 am by Rocky