Analysis: Elizabeth Warren might have actually made things worse with her DNA gambit
Analysis by Chris Cillizza, CNN Editor-at-large
41 mins ago
Ethan Miller/Getty Images LAS VEGAS, NV - OCTOBER 04: U.S. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) speaks at The Springs Preserve on October 4, 2016 in Las Vegas, Nevada. Warren is campaigning for Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton and former Nevada Attorney General and U.S. Senate candidate Catherine Cortez Masto. (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)
Twenty-four hours after Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren shocked the political world with a five-minute video (and a mountain of documentation) aimed at putting to bed the controversy over her claims of Native American heritage, it's becoming increasingly clear the strategy amounts to a swing and a miss.
Load Error
Warren's goal was to take the issue of her heritage off the table for nervous Democrats and to show that she was ready, willing and able to stand up to President Donald Trump if and when the time came that she was the party's nominee against him in 2020. The problem is that, when you strip away all of the glitz of her well-produced video, you are left with this: There's still no certainty that Warren is, in any meaningful way, Native American.
Yes, Stanford geneticist Carlos Bustamante tells Warren in the video that "the facts suggest that you absolutely have a Native American ancestor in your pedigree." But the estimates of just how much Native American blood Warren actually possesses range from 1/64th to a whopping 1/1024th. Which, um, ain't a lot.
Trump himself picked up on that uncertainty in a series of tweets (of course) on Tuesday morning.
"Pocahontas (the bad version), sometimes referred to as Elizabeth Warren, is getting slammed," tweeted Trump. "She took a bogus DNA test and it showed that she may be 1/1024, far less than the average American. Now Cherokee Nation denies her, 'DNA test is useless.' Even they don't want her. Phony!"
(Trump is referring to this statement from Cherokee Nation Secretary of State Chuck Hoskin Jr.: "A DNA test is useless to determine tribal citizenship. Current DNA tests do not even distinguish whether a person's ancestors were indigenous to North or South America.")
Trump added: "Now that her claims of being of Indian heritage have turned out to be a scam and a lie, Elizabeth Warren should apologize for perpetrating this fraud against the American Public. Harvard called her 'a person of color' (amazing con), and would not have taken her otherwise!
(That claim is, based on available facts, untrue. There's no evidence that Warren was hired by Harvard Law School — or anywhere else — because she claimed minority status due to her Native American heritage.)
This is, of course, what Trump does. He bullies -- regardless of the facts. Ask yourself this: If Warren had produced a DNA test that confirmed she was half Native American, do you think Trump would have simply conceded the point and moved on? Of course not! He would have almost certainly sent a similar tweet to the one Tuesday in which he alleged — with no evidence — that the DNA test was "bogus."
So, if Warren thought that this video and DNA test would shut Trump up, she was dangerously mistaken. But my guess is that neither Warren nor her campaign team thought that. Because they aren't hopelessly naive.
My strong sense is that the whole presentation of facts on Monday was aimed not at Trump at all but rather at Democratic activists and donors who likely expressed some level of nervousness directly to Warren about how the whole "Pocahontas" attack could be used against her by Trump come 2020. Remember that every political party re-fights the last election in the next election. And in the last election, Democrats lost what they believed to be a sure thing because they nominated someone in Hillary Clinton who had enough political baggage to fill a train car. Trump exploited Clinton's baggage by, often untruthfully, labeling her as something close to an unconvicted criminal.
With that as a backdrop, Warren's struggle to fully explain her own claims of Native American heritage — and the fact that she was not initially entirely forthcoming when this all came out in 2012 about what she had told Harvard and the University of Pennsylvania about her minority status — is of concern for some Democrats. And that concern is something that Warren's eventual Democratic opponents will focus in on as they try to foment doubts among voters as to whether the Massachusetts senator is the right person to pick to take on Trump.
What Warren was trying to do with this video and DNA test then is show fellow Democrats that she was ready to fight back and had the firepower to rebut any attacks by Trump. A good idea — in theory! But, in practice, things are working out less well. Because Warren is not able to provide an answer on her Native American background that seems to totally and completely pass the smell test.
Prior to her big Monday rollout, we knew that she had told people she was part Native American because her mother and her mother's family had told her that. Now, we have a geneticist saying "the facts suggest" that she has some Native American ancestry and the estimates of how much Indian blood Warren actually has ranged wildly — and could be as little as 1/1024th.
That's not certainty. Not close. And the uncertainty remains something that can and will be exploited — by Trump publicly and by her likely Democratic opponents in more hushed conversations with key donors and party activists.
http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/analysis-elizabeth-warren-might-have-actually-made-things-worse-with-her-dna-gambit/ar-BBOsnpN?li=BBnb7Kz&ocid=U453DHP
Analysis by Chris Cillizza, CNN Editor-at-large
41 mins ago
Ethan Miller/Getty Images LAS VEGAS, NV - OCTOBER 04: U.S. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) speaks at The Springs Preserve on October 4, 2016 in Las Vegas, Nevada. Warren is campaigning for Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton and former Nevada Attorney General and U.S. Senate candidate Catherine Cortez Masto. (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)
Twenty-four hours after Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren shocked the political world with a five-minute video (and a mountain of documentation) aimed at putting to bed the controversy over her claims of Native American heritage, it's becoming increasingly clear the strategy amounts to a swing and a miss.
Load Error
Warren's goal was to take the issue of her heritage off the table for nervous Democrats and to show that she was ready, willing and able to stand up to President Donald Trump if and when the time came that she was the party's nominee against him in 2020. The problem is that, when you strip away all of the glitz of her well-produced video, you are left with this: There's still no certainty that Warren is, in any meaningful way, Native American.
Yes, Stanford geneticist Carlos Bustamante tells Warren in the video that "the facts suggest that you absolutely have a Native American ancestor in your pedigree." But the estimates of just how much Native American blood Warren actually possesses range from 1/64th to a whopping 1/1024th. Which, um, ain't a lot.
Trump himself picked up on that uncertainty in a series of tweets (of course) on Tuesday morning.
"Pocahontas (the bad version), sometimes referred to as Elizabeth Warren, is getting slammed," tweeted Trump. "She took a bogus DNA test and it showed that she may be 1/1024, far less than the average American. Now Cherokee Nation denies her, 'DNA test is useless.' Even they don't want her. Phony!"
(Trump is referring to this statement from Cherokee Nation Secretary of State Chuck Hoskin Jr.: "A DNA test is useless to determine tribal citizenship. Current DNA tests do not even distinguish whether a person's ancestors were indigenous to North or South America.")
Trump added: "Now that her claims of being of Indian heritage have turned out to be a scam and a lie, Elizabeth Warren should apologize for perpetrating this fraud against the American Public. Harvard called her 'a person of color' (amazing con), and would not have taken her otherwise!
(That claim is, based on available facts, untrue. There's no evidence that Warren was hired by Harvard Law School — or anywhere else — because she claimed minority status due to her Native American heritage.)
This is, of course, what Trump does. He bullies -- regardless of the facts. Ask yourself this: If Warren had produced a DNA test that confirmed she was half Native American, do you think Trump would have simply conceded the point and moved on? Of course not! He would have almost certainly sent a similar tweet to the one Tuesday in which he alleged — with no evidence — that the DNA test was "bogus."
So, if Warren thought that this video and DNA test would shut Trump up, she was dangerously mistaken. But my guess is that neither Warren nor her campaign team thought that. Because they aren't hopelessly naive.
My strong sense is that the whole presentation of facts on Monday was aimed not at Trump at all but rather at Democratic activists and donors who likely expressed some level of nervousness directly to Warren about how the whole "Pocahontas" attack could be used against her by Trump come 2020. Remember that every political party re-fights the last election in the next election. And in the last election, Democrats lost what they believed to be a sure thing because they nominated someone in Hillary Clinton who had enough political baggage to fill a train car. Trump exploited Clinton's baggage by, often untruthfully, labeling her as something close to an unconvicted criminal.
With that as a backdrop, Warren's struggle to fully explain her own claims of Native American heritage — and the fact that she was not initially entirely forthcoming when this all came out in 2012 about what she had told Harvard and the University of Pennsylvania about her minority status — is of concern for some Democrats. And that concern is something that Warren's eventual Democratic opponents will focus in on as they try to foment doubts among voters as to whether the Massachusetts senator is the right person to pick to take on Trump.
What Warren was trying to do with this video and DNA test then is show fellow Democrats that she was ready to fight back and had the firepower to rebut any attacks by Trump. A good idea — in theory! But, in practice, things are working out less well. Because Warren is not able to provide an answer on her Native American background that seems to totally and completely pass the smell test.
Prior to her big Monday rollout, we knew that she had told people she was part Native American because her mother and her mother's family had told her that. Now, we have a geneticist saying "the facts suggest" that she has some Native American ancestry and the estimates of how much Indian blood Warren actually has ranged wildly — and could be as little as 1/1024th.
That's not certainty. Not close. And the uncertainty remains something that can and will be exploited — by Trump publicly and by her likely Democratic opponents in more hushed conversations with key donors and party activists.
http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/analysis-elizabeth-warren-might-have-actually-made-things-worse-with-her-dna-gambit/ar-BBOsnpN?li=BBnb7Kz&ocid=U453DHP
Today at 5:08 am by Rocky
» Al-Hakim calls for a consensus among the Sunni forces to decide the position of Parliament Speaker
Today at 5:00 am by Rocky
» Iran exports 52 cubic meters of gas to Iraq, worth $15 billion
Today at 4:57 am by Rocky
» Jordan announces the date of electrical connection with Iraq
Today at 4:56 am by Rocky
» utube MM&C 3/26/24 Iraqi Dinar - IQD Update - Strength Dinar - Automation ASYCUDA - World Bank - D
Yesterday at 8:52 am by Rocky
» utube 3/28/24 MM&C Iraqi Dinar - IQD Update - SWIFT - Purchasing Power - Urban Renaissance - Releas
Yesterday at 8:51 am by Rocky
» Al-Mandalawi: Iraq is witnessing competition between major companies...and the House of Representati
Yesterday at 8:49 am by Rocky
» The President of the Republic stresses the importance of the role of programmers in developing the w
Yesterday at 8:46 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Industry and Minerals follows up on the technical and production performance of the
Yesterday at 8:45 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Finance is following up on the field the progress of the newly implemented ASYCUDA s
Yesterday at 8:44 am by Rocky
» Statistics: There are more than 15 million bank accounts in Iraq
Yesterday at 8:42 am by Rocky
» Representative: One paragraph hinders the passage of a general amnesty within the House of Represent
Yesterday at 8:37 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance: “The draft federal budget law will be devoid of new job grades.”
Yesterday at 8:36 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary action to resolve the fate of “food security contracts” in 15 governorates
Yesterday at 8:35 am by Rocky
» 300 factories turned into "iron scrap" in Diyala
Yesterday at 8:34 am by Rocky
» A deputy expects the dollar exchange rate to reach 140 Iraqi dinars
Yesterday at 8:32 am by Rocky
» Al-Yasiri: The American administration is working hard to destroy the Iraqi economy
Yesterday at 8:31 am by Rocky
» Infographic: The highest annual salaries of leaders of Arab countries
Yesterday at 8:30 am by Rocky
» Communications announces that the electronic signature project has reached advanced stages
Yesterday at 8:29 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Integrity presents a file related to Kuwaiti violations of Iraqi oil
Yesterday at 8:27 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary move to include amendments to Parliament’s internal regulations on the agenda (documen
Yesterday at 8:25 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi President urges the Minister of Finance to expedite the payment of salaries to the Kurdist
Yesterday at 8:23 am by Rocky
» Central Bank of Iraq sales exceeded $251 million at today’s auction
Yesterday at 8:21 am by Rocky
» The Foreign Minister questions the "Iraqi resistance" attacks against Israel: the other side did not
Yesterday at 8:20 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Labor announces progress in the electronic payment system
Yesterday at 8:17 am by Rocky
» Interior Ministry: For the first time, we controlled the smuggling of petroleum derivatives by 98 pe
Yesterday at 8:16 am by Rocky
» International companies offer offers to invest in the Dhi Qar marshes.. What distinguishes them?
Yesterday at 8:15 am by Rocky
» “Tough” comments on interest rates raise the dollar globally
Yesterday at 8:14 am by Rocky
» Iraq is the fifth largest oil supplier to South Korea in a month
Yesterday at 8:12 am by Rocky
» Recovering more than 100 billion as a result of more than 200,000 employees on social welfare
Yesterday at 8:11 am by Rocky
» The Sudanese consultant announces the completion of Baghdad Metro track designs
Yesterday at 8:08 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani stresses ending the problem of triple-shift schools
Yesterday at 8:07 am by Rocky
» Iraq begins building two new tankers to transport petroleum products
Yesterday at 8:06 am by Rocky
» Forming a council for “competition and preventing monopoly”
Yesterday at 8:04 am by Rocky
» Features of an Iraqi-Turkish agreement regarding the status of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party
Yesterday at 8:02 am by Rocky
» {Al-Buzrajiya} between the hammer of fraud and the power of the owners
Yesterday at 8:01 am by Rocky
» Ministry of Oil: The gas sector is witnessing great development
Yesterday at 7:59 am by Rocky
» An agreement with Britain in the field of securities
Yesterday at 7:58 am by Rocky
» Discussions between Baghdad and Ankara to open a new port
Yesterday at 7:57 am by Rocky
» Trade: About 11 million citizens updated their new card information
Yesterday at 7:56 am by Rocky
» Electronic payment is sustainable growth
Yesterday at 7:55 am by Rocky
» Experts: Iraq qualifies to be an important tourist country
Yesterday at 7:54 am by Rocky
» Amending the Health Professions Law “robs” scientists of the central appointment 3 years after it wa
Yesterday at 6:20 am by Rocky
» Is the “blessings package” that Erbil paid to the citizens of Kurdistan related to the elections?
Yesterday at 6:19 am by Rocky
» Exceeded 5,000 projects.. Allocating 10 trillion dinars to support governorate reconstruction plans
Yesterday at 6:18 am by Rocky
» “His need no longer exists.” Parliamentary Finance confirms the necessity of returning the retiremen
Yesterday at 6:17 am by Rocky
» To communicate with the bases... 12 directives from Al-Sadr, including blocking numbers for non-gove
Yesterday at 6:15 am by Rocky
» In an interview with "Baghdad Today"... an Iranian researcher reveals the importance of Haniyeh's vi
Yesterday at 6:14 am by Rocky
» After it was 63 trillion in 2023... the 2024 budget deficit will rise to 80 trillion dinars
Yesterday at 6:13 am by Rocky
» Parliament reveals the date of the first evaluation of the governors and determines the party respon
Yesterday at 6:11 am by Rocky
» The President of the Republic informs Al-Araji and Al-Basri: Momentum must be mobilized to eliminate
Yesterday at 6:10 am by Rocky
» Can the Federal Court sue others? A legal clarification of its response mechanism to abuse
Yesterday at 6:09 am by Rocky
» Despite promises to soon stop burning gas.. What is the secret behind Iraq renewing the Iranian gas
Yesterday at 6:07 am by Rocky
» Advisor to Al-Sudani: The dollar is on the way to further decline, and 70% of Iraqi traders have ent
Yesterday at 6:06 am by Rocky
» Iraq exported more than 99 million barrels of oil last February
Yesterday at 6:04 am by Rocky
» Barzani “gives good news” to Kurdistan employees: salaries, land, and loan exemptions
Yesterday at 6:03 am by Rocky
» Alia Nassif: Nour Zuhair returned to the port of Umm Qasr to make deals.. An influential Shiite forc
Yesterday at 6:02 am by Rocky
» The Prime Minister announces the movement of nearly 500 stalled projects
Yesterday at 6:00 am by Rocky
» A government strategy to enhance investments.. Iraq is on the verge of a new era of economic develop
Yesterday at 5:59 am by Rocky
» Ranging between 20% and 50%.. The Kurdistan government decides to reduce service fees, customs dutie
Yesterday at 5:58 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The reform approach in the security services is an integral part of reform in other secto
Yesterday at 5:56 am by Rocky
» Everyone in Iraq wants the Sudanese visit to Washington to be successful, even the factions!
Yesterday at 5:55 am by Rocky
» Sources and experts expect the agenda.. in his bag is the Baghdad dollar and the factions’ truce, bu
Yesterday at 5:54 am by Rocky
» The decision to raise gasoline prices arouses the ire of drivers...a reminder of the large demonstra
Yesterday at 5:53 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary services: 3 important hospitals in Baghdad will enter service at the end of the year
Yesterday at 5:52 am by Rocky
» Iraq signs a contract to supply Iranian gas for a period of five years
Yesterday at 5:50 am by Rocky
» Parliament adds a voting paragraph on amending the Penal Code to its agenda
Yesterday at 5:49 am by Rocky
» His political advisor: We are not afraid of Sudanese entering the elections alone
Yesterday at 5:48 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary services explain the reasons for the rise in real estate prices in Baghdad
Yesterday at 5:46 am by Rocky
» Attia, criticizing the government's decisions: "The citizen's feathers will be ruffled without servi
Yesterday at 5:45 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Communications: Zain Iraq and Asiacell did not pay their debts
Yesterday at 5:44 am by Rocky
» The Governor of Karbala announces the imminent establishment of the largest industrial city in the c
Yesterday at 5:43 am by Rocky
» A government determination to end the issue of displaced persons in the middle of this year
Yesterday at 5:42 am by Rocky
» Iraq buys gas from Kurdistan to generate electricity
Yesterday at 5:41 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary signatures to include an amendment to the internal regulations to decide the choice of
Yesterday at 5:40 am by Rocky
» In Basra.. a demonstration against foreign workers in Iraqi companies (video)
Yesterday at 5:38 am by Rocky
» Al-Samarrai: Presidency of Parliament is an entitlement to the constituents, and calling it a “frame
Yesterday at 5:36 am by Rocky
» Electronic food supplies in 6 governorates... covering 11 million Iraqis and “writing off” about 700
Yesterday at 5:34 am by Rocky
» Corruption of the Ministry of Transport.. Representatives express their surprise at the minister’s s
Yesterday at 5:32 am by Rocky
» The biggest supporter of the invasion of Iraq.. The death of former US Senator Joe Lieberman
Yesterday at 5:31 am by Rocky
» Iraq is ranked “late.” A list of the most and least safe Arab countries for women
Yesterday at 5:30 am by Rocky
» The Council of Ministers exempts the Gulf Interconnection Authority from guarantee fees: it is a gov
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:48 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi government raises the size of the 2024 budget, and Parliament is “surprised”
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:46 am by Rocky
» Popular Movement: We have many economic options away from American hegemony
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:42 am by Rocky
» The Oil Parliament stresses the need to transfer part of the revenues to the producing governorates
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:41 am by Rocky
» It will cover 14 regions in eastern Iraq.. A deputy reveals the “border electricity” project
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:40 am by Rocky
» Experts Warn Mass Migration Threatens US Food Security
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:37 am by Bama Diva
» Al-Fateh: America occupies Iraq through agreements
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:37 am by Rocky
» Anger in Iraq over a "sudden decision"... and a reminder of a "general strike" that paralyzed the co
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:34 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Committee: Parliament is discussing today a decision that “disturbed” the Iraqis
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:33 am by Rocky
» Ministry of Electricity: Our production will reach 27 thousand megawatts by May
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:31 am by Rocky
» Diagnosing the “most important” problems in the oil file between Baghdad and Erbil.. What is the rel
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:30 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi Fiqh Academy and the Sunni Endowment issue a fatwa to pay Zakat al-Fitr
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:28 am by Rocky
» The National Bank of Iraq continues its digital transformation by launching its new banking system a
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:26 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Investment and the Central Bank are discussing the housing initiative
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:25 am by Rocky
» The Prime Minister announces the restart of 500 suspended projects
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:23 am by Rocky
» Al-Barti assesses the region's employees: Your salaries are insured and will be paid after resettlem
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:21 am by Rocky
» Iraqi-American discussions in anticipation of the Sudanese visit
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:20 am by Rocky
» Iraq and Turkey hold meetings in Ankara to discuss technical issues related to the development road
Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:17 am by Rocky