Why Edmonton’s risky Hall-Larsson trade isn’t paying off
NHL analyst Mark Spector discusses his impression of Adam Larsson after 20 games, says he'll never be a number one, because he lacks the offense, but he's great for what he does bring to the club.
Last summer, Edmonton Oilers general manager Peter Chiarelli took a calculated risk: He traded Taylor Hall for Adam Larsson.
The calculation was that Larsson, already a veteran defensive defenceman at the age of 23, would do more to help the Oilers win hockey games than Hall. The risk was in giving up one of the league’s best five-on-five scorers for a player even Chiarelli acknowledged was more complementary piece than franchise cornerstone.
“Adam Larsson is a very good defenceman,” the GM told 630 CHED’s Bob Stauffer in October. “He may not be a ready for primetime No. 2, but he will be in our time and I feel he can grow into that.”
The final results of Chiarelli’s grand gamble will take years to play out, but already we’re starting to see the impact the trade has had on Edmonton.
If we look at goals for and against, Larsson is a failure as a stabilizing presence. Edmonton is nearly a full goal worse per hour when he’s on the ice at 5-on-5. For an analyst devoted to goal differential, the real credit on the back end must go to free agent addition Kris Russell.
Fortunately for Larsson, most analysts don’t spend a lot of time on on-ice goal differential over short time periods. The reason is that those numbers do a terrible job of predicting the future.
Larsson is actually a strong example of this. A year ago in New Jersey, the Devils had a whopping 0.946 save percentage when Larsson was on the ice, and allowed just 1.4 goals against per hour. This year in Edmonton, the Oilers have a 0.905 save percentage when Larsson is on the ice, and are allowing nearly 3.0 goals against per hour, a more than 100 per cent increase.
Studies have repeatedly shown that defencemen have virtually no control over save percentage, which is why those goal numbers tend to bounce around. It doesn’t make sense to blame Larsson for his team’s awful save percentage when he’s on the ice this year, any more than it made sense to credit him for his team’s awesome save percentage last season.
This is why shot metrics are so popular. Goal numbers may fluctuate wildly, but for the most part a player who helps his team out-shoot the opposition this year will do so again next year. More importantly, over time that goal number generally falls in line with what the shots show.
Superficially, Larsson’s numbers aren’t great, but it’s important to take context into account. He plays against top opponents. He gets more shifts starting in the defensive zone than the typical defenceman. All of these things need to be accounted for, and once they are his pairing has actually been pretty good.
The funny thing is that the Oilers already had a pretty good defensive pairing. Edmonton’s results with Larsson in that slot this year don’t look much better than their results with Mark Fayne in the same position last season:
As we’ve noted, the goal numbers aren’t especially meaningful, so Larsson badly trailing Fayne there doesn’t really say much. More telling are the shot numbers.
The Oilers are a little better at generating shots when Larsson is on the ice, but much worse at giving them up, and on balance the team takes a noticeable hit when he’s out there in tough minutes. With Fayne on the ice last season, Edmonton didn’t take that same hit.
It’s important to note that these are relative numbers — all else being equal, it’s more difficult to keep up with a good team than it is with a bad one, and the 2016-17 Oilers are a better team than the 2015-16 group. It’s also worth recognizing that Fayne tends to be underrated; although visually unimpressive his teams have a long history of being better when he’s on the ice.
Nevertheless, it’s hard to be blown away by Larsson’s early work. The Oilers’ shutdown pairing hasn’t improved by nearly as much as the rest of the team has. He doesn’t personally contribute a lot with the puck, and those tenuous hopes that his high on-ice save percentage meant he was brilliant at reducing opposition shot quality have been dashed.
That’s a difficult result to square with the price Edmonton paid to add him.
A year ago, the Oilers had a remarkably diversified attack at even strength. Connor McDavid was the second most dangerous 5-on-5 scorer in the league on a per-minute basis, and his regular linemates ranked in the top 100 of NHL players. Taylor Hall was just outside the top 10, and linemates Leon Draisaitl (21st) and Teddy Purcell (106th) were also highly dangerous.
This season, it’s a very different story.
McDavid remains lethal at both even-strength and on the power play. He’s just a whisker back of Sidney Crosby as the league’s most efficient 5-on-5 scorer. He’s also scoring more than seven points/hour on the power play, a level just three players hit last season.
Unfortunately for the Oilers, McDavid is basically a one-man show. Not one other Oiler, not even his regular linemates, ranks in the top 100 in the league by even-strength points/hour. McDavid’s 26 even-strength points are as many as Edmonton’s next two players combined—and both of those players (Draisaitl and Jordan Eberle) have spent significant time on McDavid’s line.
There isn’t much question that the Oilers needed to upgrade their blue line last summer. What is in doubt is whether Larsson was a significant enough upgrade to justify gutting the team’s secondary scoring.
It’s too early to have a definitive answer to that question. Right now, though, it looks like Edmonton paid a hefty price offensively for a comparatively small upgrade on its blue line. The Oilers’ year-over-year improvements would seem to have a lot more to do with McDavid’s maturation than they do with the GM’s signature off-season trade.
NHL analyst Mark Spector discusses his impression of Adam Larsson after 20 games, says he'll never be a number one, because he lacks the offense, but he's great for what he does bring to the club.
Last summer, Edmonton Oilers general manager Peter Chiarelli took a calculated risk: He traded Taylor Hall for Adam Larsson.
The calculation was that Larsson, already a veteran defensive defenceman at the age of 23, would do more to help the Oilers win hockey games than Hall. The risk was in giving up one of the league’s best five-on-five scorers for a player even Chiarelli acknowledged was more complementary piece than franchise cornerstone.
“Adam Larsson is a very good defenceman,” the GM told 630 CHED’s Bob Stauffer in October. “He may not be a ready for primetime No. 2, but he will be in our time and I feel he can grow into that.”
The final results of Chiarelli’s grand gamble will take years to play out, but already we’re starting to see the impact the trade has had on Edmonton.
If we look at goals for and against, Larsson is a failure as a stabilizing presence. Edmonton is nearly a full goal worse per hour when he’s on the ice at 5-on-5. For an analyst devoted to goal differential, the real credit on the back end must go to free agent addition Kris Russell.
Fortunately for Larsson, most analysts don’t spend a lot of time on on-ice goal differential over short time periods. The reason is that those numbers do a terrible job of predicting the future.
Larsson is actually a strong example of this. A year ago in New Jersey, the Devils had a whopping 0.946 save percentage when Larsson was on the ice, and allowed just 1.4 goals against per hour. This year in Edmonton, the Oilers have a 0.905 save percentage when Larsson is on the ice, and are allowing nearly 3.0 goals against per hour, a more than 100 per cent increase.
Studies have repeatedly shown that defencemen have virtually no control over save percentage, which is why those goal numbers tend to bounce around. It doesn’t make sense to blame Larsson for his team’s awful save percentage when he’s on the ice this year, any more than it made sense to credit him for his team’s awesome save percentage last season.
This is why shot metrics are so popular. Goal numbers may fluctuate wildly, but for the most part a player who helps his team out-shoot the opposition this year will do so again next year. More importantly, over time that goal number generally falls in line with what the shots show.
Superficially, Larsson’s numbers aren’t great, but it’s important to take context into account. He plays against top opponents. He gets more shifts starting in the defensive zone than the typical defenceman. All of these things need to be accounted for, and once they are his pairing has actually been pretty good.
The funny thing is that the Oilers already had a pretty good defensive pairing. Edmonton’s results with Larsson in that slot this year don’t look much better than their results with Mark Fayne in the same position last season:
As we’ve noted, the goal numbers aren’t especially meaningful, so Larsson badly trailing Fayne there doesn’t really say much. More telling are the shot numbers.
The Oilers are a little better at generating shots when Larsson is on the ice, but much worse at giving them up, and on balance the team takes a noticeable hit when he’s out there in tough minutes. With Fayne on the ice last season, Edmonton didn’t take that same hit.
It’s important to note that these are relative numbers — all else being equal, it’s more difficult to keep up with a good team than it is with a bad one, and the 2016-17 Oilers are a better team than the 2015-16 group. It’s also worth recognizing that Fayne tends to be underrated; although visually unimpressive his teams have a long history of being better when he’s on the ice.
Nevertheless, it’s hard to be blown away by Larsson’s early work. The Oilers’ shutdown pairing hasn’t improved by nearly as much as the rest of the team has. He doesn’t personally contribute a lot with the puck, and those tenuous hopes that his high on-ice save percentage meant he was brilliant at reducing opposition shot quality have been dashed.
That’s a difficult result to square with the price Edmonton paid to add him.
A year ago, the Oilers had a remarkably diversified attack at even strength. Connor McDavid was the second most dangerous 5-on-5 scorer in the league on a per-minute basis, and his regular linemates ranked in the top 100 of NHL players. Taylor Hall was just outside the top 10, and linemates Leon Draisaitl (21st) and Teddy Purcell (106th) were also highly dangerous.
This season, it’s a very different story.
McDavid remains lethal at both even-strength and on the power play. He’s just a whisker back of Sidney Crosby as the league’s most efficient 5-on-5 scorer. He’s also scoring more than seven points/hour on the power play, a level just three players hit last season.
Unfortunately for the Oilers, McDavid is basically a one-man show. Not one other Oiler, not even his regular linemates, ranks in the top 100 in the league by even-strength points/hour. McDavid’s 26 even-strength points are as many as Edmonton’s next two players combined—and both of those players (Draisaitl and Jordan Eberle) have spent significant time on McDavid’s line.
There isn’t much question that the Oilers needed to upgrade their blue line last summer. What is in doubt is whether Larsson was a significant enough upgrade to justify gutting the team’s secondary scoring.
It’s too early to have a definitive answer to that question. Right now, though, it looks like Edmonton paid a hefty price offensively for a comparatively small upgrade on its blue line. The Oilers’ year-over-year improvements would seem to have a lot more to do with McDavid’s maturation than they do with the GM’s signature off-season trade.
Today at 7:04 am by Rocky
» utube MM&C 4/16/24 IQD Update - Iraq Dinar - America - Activate - Massive Economic Deals -
Today at 7:02 am by Rocky
» utube MM&c 4/19/24 Iraqi Dinar - Private Sector - Economic Stability - Financial Reform - Al Sudan
Today at 7:01 am by Rocky
» Iraq officially signs the “Singapore” agreement to resolve trade disputes
Today at 6:59 am by Rocky
» Parliament Finance advises raising exchange rates again... What about oil revenues?
Today at 6:55 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: Iraq is in the process of recovery and has taken its leading position that attracts work
Today at 6:54 am by Rocky
» Al-Araji: Iraq is prepared to deal with all circumstances and seeks partnership with the United Stat
Today at 6:52 am by Rocky
» Sudanese from Michigan: The government represents all components and is keen to take care of the aff
Today at 6:50 am by Rocky
» Democratic Party: The "new generation" is the most corrupt and has dozens of cases in court
Today at 6:47 am by Rocky
» What is the benefit of Iraq establishing a petrochemical plant in Egypt?!.. An oil expert explains
Today at 6:46 am by Rocky
» A judicial delegation participates in the Permanent International Forum for Commercial Courts in Qat
Today at 6:43 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The government follows a balanced policy that makes Iraq a station for security
Today at 6:42 am by Rocky
» Deduction of 160 million dinars from the salaries of MPs absent from Parliament sessions
Today at 6:40 am by Rocky
» Central Bank: Washington praised Iraq's measures to resolve 80% of the financial transfer file
Today at 5:13 am by Rocky
» Voices of Resilience: Al-Sudani’s frankness embarrasses the White House
Today at 5:12 am by Rocky
» Al-Alaq confirms the formation of a committee between Baghdad and Washington regarding sanctions on
Today at 5:10 am by Rocky
» Former MP: The Democrat will not hand over power after the regional elections
Today at 5:07 am by Rocky
» Document/allocation of 20% of the lands of Al-Jawahiri Complex to employees of the Ministry of Defen
Today at 5:06 am by Rocky
» Al-Hakim: Al-Sudani’s visit to Washington was a protocol and missed the two most important files
Today at 5:05 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Security: The National Security Service law will be voted on by Parliament soon
Today at 5:04 am by Rocky
» Reconstruction and Housing: Zarbatieh residential project completed by 82%
Today at 5:01 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani reveals an intention to establish Al-Faw refinery with a capacity of 300 thousand barrels
Today at 5:00 am by Rocky
» Government readiness to move the Doura refinery to an alternative location.. What are the conditions
Today at 4:59 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani’s visit to Washington.. Implications and results
Today at 4:56 am by Rocky
» Association of Iraqi Private Banks: The suspension of some electronic payment services yesterday was
Today at 4:55 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary memorandum.. Two solutions were before the Federal Court instead of removing the compo
Today at 4:53 am by Rocky
» Blue fuel... Iraqi steps towards inexhaustible wealth for a century
Today at 4:51 am by Rocky
» For fear of being "upset"... MPs "evade" signing to host Al-Sudani in Parliament
Today at 4:50 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani’s statement to convert 40% of Iraq’s exports into derivatives.. What does it have to do wi
Today at 4:48 am by Rocky
» An Iraqi-American partnership to benefit from oil field gas
Today at 4:46 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Commerce announces the distribution of the first payments of farmers’ dues for the 2
Today at 4:45 am by Rocky
» Sudanese to members of the Iraqi community in the American city of Houston: Iraq has regained its he
Today at 4:43 am by Rocky
» Romanski announces loans worth $50 million to support the Iraqi private sector
Today at 4:42 am by Rocky
» Prime Minister: We plan to invest production capacities for export
Today at 4:41 am by Rocky
» “Something happened” in Iran and no one is talking about Iraq and Syria. This is what we have so far
Today at 4:38 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani asks the American Baker Institute for assistance in preparing studies related to the oil m
Today at 4:36 am by Rocky
» The Interior Ministry denies the occurrence of explosions inside Iraqi territory and diagnoses “the
Today at 4:35 am by Rocky
» Tensions between Najaf and Baghdad over the airport... the rule of law over “military force” and the
Today at 4:34 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani from Washington: We agreed with Abu Dhabi on joint management of Al-Faw Port
Today at 4:33 am by Rocky
» "Al-Party" talks about the region's elections and reveals the reason for refusing to pay salaries di
Today at 4:31 am by Rocky
» Russia's oil is taking more of the Middle East's shares in the Indian market.. How much has Iraq los
Today at 4:29 am by Rocky
» Early next month.. Traffic confirms that the electronic payment system is working only
Today at 4:27 am by Rocky
» The Service Council accuses state departments of refraining from disbursing bonuses because of the m
Today at 4:25 am by Rocky
» Electricity: The Baghdad street lighting campaign will be completed before the middle of this year
Today at 4:24 am by Rocky
» Oil poses two conditions for moving the Doura refinery to an alternative location
Today at 4:23 am by Rocky
» The Foreign Minister reveals the truth about his resignation and the reason for his departure to Erb
Today at 4:22 am by Rocky
» Progress: Al-Halbousi’s acquittal has become conclusive, and his return to the presidency of Parliam
Today at 4:20 am by Rocky
» Disagreements strike Al-Maliki's coalition over choosing the governor of Diyala
Today at 4:19 am by Rocky
» The Union accuses Türkiye of exploiting the political situation for a ground incursion into Iraq
Today at 4:18 am by Rocky
» The Democratic Party: Barzani is eagerly awaiting the results of Al-Sudani’s visit to Washington
Today at 4:17 am by Rocky
» Frame: Al-Halbousi in the news and his return has become a pipe dream
Today at 4:16 am by Rocky
» A parliamentary request to capitalize on Erdogan’s visit to Baghdad to end the water crisis
Today at 4:15 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani urges the US corporation Honeywell to help finish the Basra refinery
Yesterday at 2:48 pm by Rocky
» Al-Sudani Meets with Representatives of Western Media Outlets in Washington
Yesterday at 2:46 pm by Rocky
» Chairman of the Investment Authority signs the United Nations Convention on International Mediation
Yesterday at 2:44 pm by Rocky
» PM: We will sign a contract to establish the Al-Faw refinery with a Chinese company
Yesterday at 2:42 pm by Rocky
» PM arrives in Houston as part of his visit to USA
Yesterday at 2:41 pm by Rocky
» Militia Man & Crew 4/18/24 Bush signed it and all presidents implemented it. Iraq’s funds have been
Yesterday at 1:46 pm by Rocky
» Iraq is close to launching the electronic signature
Yesterday at 7:12 am by Rocky
» The Basra government discusses with an international oil company the implementation of social benefi
Yesterday at 7:11 am by Rocky
» The Prime Minister confirms to an American company: Gas projects in Iraq are a priority for the gove
Yesterday at 7:10 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Planning discusses with the World Bank mechanisms for scheduling external loans
Yesterday at 7:09 am by Rocky
» Oil sets the twenty-seventh of this month as the date for opening contracts for the fifth complement
Yesterday at 7:08 am by Rocky
» “Electronic begging”...professionalism and fabrication of stories” generates millions of dinars dail
Yesterday at 7:05 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani calls on the American company Hanwell to contribute to the completion of the Basra refiner
Yesterday at 7:03 am by Rocky
» An American company expresses its willingness to establish LED lighting production lines in Iraq
Yesterday at 7:02 am by Rocky
» Including Iraq.. Iran announces the possibility of exporting 300 megawatts of “renewable electricity
Yesterday at 7:01 am by Rocky
» Political forces present two options to find an alternative to Al-Halbousi
Yesterday at 6:58 am by Rocky
» Parliament is awaiting the arrival of the budget schedules and the government is studying higher spe
Yesterday at 6:56 am by Rocky
» The International Monetary Fund adjusts its expectations for the development of the world’s economie
Yesterday at 6:54 am by Rocky
» A representative talks about the difficulty of finalizing the file of “electing the Speaker of Parli
Yesterday at 6:50 am by Rocky
» Work on preparing a law for diplomatic passports
Yesterday at 6:49 am by Rocky
» A female representative accuses the Ministry of Immigration of corruption
Yesterday at 6:47 am by Rocky
» Minister: Solving the Kurdistan salaries problem is the beginning of addressing other disputes betwe
Yesterday at 6:45 am by Rocky
» About 270 million dollars were sold by the Central Bank of Iraq in the currency auction
Yesterday at 6:42 am by Rocky
» The volume of trade exchange between Jordan and Iraq will exceed 800 million dinars in 2023
Yesterday at 6:41 am by Rocky
» Iraq signs memorandums of understanding with American companies in the fields of electricity, oil an
Yesterday at 5:31 am by Rocky
» The American company that manufactures the F16 expresses its readiness to implement the terms of con
Yesterday at 5:30 am by Rocky
» The volume of expected Qatari investments for the Iraq Fund for Development exceeds $3.5 billion
Yesterday at 5:29 am by Rocky
» Decrease in dollar prices in Baghdad and Erbil
Yesterday at 5:27 am by Rocky
» The President of the Region brings together the Kurdish parties to resolve the election file
Yesterday at 5:26 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani receives in Washington the Chairman of JPMorgan
Yesterday at 5:25 am by Rocky
» Transport is starting to transform its ports into smart ones
Yesterday at 5:23 am by Rocky
» Sudanese reveals the volume of exchange with America
Yesterday at 5:22 am by Rocky
» "Al-Eqtisad News" publishes the memorandums of understanding signed between the Iraqi delegation and
Yesterday at 5:21 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani urges an American company to contribute to establishing a chemical materials factory
Yesterday at 5:20 am by Rocky
» Iraq stresses the importance of Lockheed Martin's commitment to opening military aircraft maintenanc
Yesterday at 5:19 am by Rocky
» Iraq is on the verge of a “water disaster” by 2035
Yesterday at 5:18 am by Rocky
» Great satisfaction and optimism with the results of Sudanese’s visit to Washington
Yesterday at 5:16 am by Rocky
» Transport is beginning to adopt a plan to transform its ports into smart ones
Yesterday at 5:15 am by Rocky
» Completed 8,000 loan transactions at the Housing Bank
Yesterday at 5:14 am by Rocky
» Prime Minister: We plan to invest production capacities for export
Yesterday at 5:12 am by Rocky
» Transformation and partnership...a new horizon in Iraqi-American relations
Yesterday at 5:10 am by Rocky
» What is new in the economic dimension of the Washington visit?
Yesterday at 5:09 am by Rocky
» Two letters to the future
Yesterday at 5:08 am by Rocky
» National interests first
Yesterday at 5:06 am by Rocky
» Iraqi-American rapprochement...a national necessity
Yesterday at 5:05 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani’s visit to Washington and the course of Iraqi-American relations
Yesterday at 5:04 am by Rocky
» Sudanese carries security, economic and development files to Washington
Yesterday at 5:03 am by Rocky