Brett Kavanaugh pivots as Supreme Court allows one execution, stops another
Robert Barnes
11 hrs ago
Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh concurred Thursday with the Supreme Court’s liberal justices that a Buddhist man’s execution should be stopped because he was not allowed a spiritual adviser by his side, but last month he was on the other side when the court allowed the execution of a Muslim inmate in Alabama under similar circumstances.
It’s difficult to say with certainty why the Supreme Court on Thursday night stopped the execution of a Buddhist inmate in Texas because he was not allowed a spiritual adviser by his side, when last month it approved the execution of a Muslim inmate in Alabama under the almost exact circumstances.
But the obvious place to start is new Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh, who seemed to have a change of heart.
Kavanaugh on Thursday was the only justice to spell out his reasoning: Texas could not execute Patrick Murphy without his Buddhist adviser in the room because it allows Christian and Muslim inmates to have religious leaders by their sides.
]Subscribe to the Post Most newsletter: Today’s most popular stories on The Washington Post
“In my view, the Constitution prohibits such denominational discrimination,” Kavanaugh wrote.
But Kavanaugh was on the other side last month when Justice Elena Kagan and three other justices declared “profoundly wrong” Alabama’s decision to turn down Muslim Domineque Ray’s request for an imam to be at his execution, making available only a Christian chaplain.
“That treatment goes against the Establishment Clause’s core principle of denominational neutrality,” Kagan wrote then.
Kavanaugh and the court’s other conservatives did not address Kagan’s argument, saying only that Ray had brought his challenge too late.
Kavanaugh said in a footnote Thursday he was satisfied with the timing of Murphy’s litigation. But the difference in when Ray and Murphy brought their requests was not substantial.
Some critics of the court wondered if the difference was one of race and religion. Murphy is white and turned to Buddhism in prison. Ray, who was executed within hours of the court’s decision Feb. 7, was black.
But the court in just the last few years has ruled for Muslim petitioners who claimed discrimination: an inmate who was not allowed to grow a short beard because of prison policies, and a woman who was denied a job at Abercrombie & Fitch because of her hijab.
Ilya Somin, a law professor at the Antonin Scalia Law School at George Mason University and a sharp critic of the court’s decision in Dunn v. Ray, said the most logical explanation is the court was stung by the barrage of criticism it received from the left and the right.
The justices “belatedly realized they had made a mistake; and not just any mistake, but one that inflicted real damage on their and the court’s reputations,” Somin wrote on the Volokh Conspiracy blog.
“Presented with a chance to ‘correct’ their error and signal that they will not tolerate religious discrimination in death penalty administration, they were willing to bend over backwards to seize the opportunity, and not let it slip away.”
Deepak Gupta, a Washington lawyer who argues before the court and called the Ray decision “indefensible,” tweeted: “This is how the Supreme Court tries to erase a very recent and obvious moral error without admitting error. Is the Alabama case materially different? They don’t say.”
It is not clear from the ruling what role Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr., who were in the majority in the Ray case, played in the Murphy case. They did not join Kavanaugh’s opinion, nor did they note, as Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil M. Gorsuch did, that they would have allowed the execution to proceed.
Somin said he is “fairly confident Alito and Roberts switched” because they did not record themselves as objecting, as Thomas and Gorsuch did.
“In a high-profile case like this, it would be strange for some justices to clearly indicate their dissent, while others who agreed with that stance kept silent and thereby created the impression they agree with the majority,” Somin said in an email.
But that is not always the case, and Kavanaugh plus the dissenters in the Ray case would have been enough to force the outcome in the Murphy case.
The order stayed Murphy’s execution until the court decides to take up the case on its merits or Texas “permits Murphy’s Buddhist spiritual advisor or another Buddhist reverend of the state’s choosing to accompany Murphy in the execution chamber during the execution.”
The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, which filed a brief on Murphy’s behalf, said it attempted to disentangle the religious liberty issue from the last-minute attempts to stop executions that irritate the court’s conservative majority.
“This particular appeal does not present a challenge to the constitutionality of the death penalty, nor is it a challenge to Texas’ execution of Murphy,” the brief argues. “This is instead a challenge to the conditions of Murphy’s confinement immediately prior to his execution.”
Becket’s First Amendment argument hinged on a point that often separates the court’s liberals and conservatives.
Ray’s lawyers, and the appeals court that at first held up his execution, said Alabama’s policy of only employing a Christian chaplain and making him the only cleric available at executions violates the prohibition on government endorsement of one religion over another.
Becket and Murphy’s lawyers argued that the constitutional right at issue was the inmate’s ability to practice his religion.
“The right of a condemned person to the comfort of clergy — and the rights of clergy to comfort the condemned — are among the longest-standing and most well-recognized forms of religious exercise known to civilization,” Becket’s brief said.
http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/brett-kavanaugh-pivots-as-supreme-court-allows-one-execution-stops-another/ar-BBVq6fF?li=BBnb7Kz&ocid=U453DHP
Today at 5:16 am by Rocky
» MM&C 11/8/24 Does printing the currency in Iraq cost huge amounts?.. An expert answers
Today at 5:15 am by Rocky
» utube 11/9/2 MM&C News Reporting-Sudani Art IV IMF-Port Faw Open-CBI Governor-No Room for Tw
Today at 5:15 am by Rocky
» To approve controversial laws... new political understandings between the blocs
Today at 5:09 am by Rocky
» TBI opens two branches in Sulaymaniyah and Erbil and distributes 10,000 bank cards in Kurdistan
Today at 5:07 am by Rocky
» Private Banks Association: The rate of financial inclusion for electronic payment is increasing
Today at 5:03 am by Rocky
» Following the extension of the legislative term... a representative of "Al-Jabal": More than 120 law
Today at 5:01 am by Rocky
» The leak of “billion-dollar bribes” shakes the atmosphere... Al-Sudani’s advisor is in the eye of th
Today at 4:56 am by Rocky
» Central Statistical Organization: $24.6 billion in Iraqi imports in 2023
Today at 4:52 am by Rocky
» Operating Iraqi factories... citizens' hope and influential merchants' obstacle
Today at 4:48 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani Office: Spreading lies is the weapon of the bankrupt
Today at 4:47 am by Rocky
» Al-Maliki: The government and political forces must abide by the statement of the authority
Today at 4:46 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Security: US forces entered Iraq for the purpose of occupation
Today at 4:44 am by Rocky
» Politician: Next year's budget will face several challenges
Today at 4:43 am by Rocky
» White House Position Awaits Iraqi Beauty Who Helped Trump Return to Presidency
Today at 4:41 am by Rocky
» Dana Gas achieves $112 million in profits in nine months in Kurdistan
Today at 4:40 am by Rocky
» Al-Maliki warns against the explosion of internal crises and the activity of Baath Party cells in Ir
Today at 4:39 am by Rocky
» Find out Iraq's global and Arab ranking with the highest average per capita wealth for the year 2024
Today at 4:38 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani's advisor: We have put in place a mechanism to provide loans to these groups
Today at 4:36 am by Rocky
» A set of recommendations from Al-Sudani to reform the financial and banking system in Iraq
Today at 4:35 am by Rocky
» Economist: Mistakes are being made in dealing with Basra crude prices
Today at 4:34 am by Rocky
» MP reveals reason behind rising real estate prices in Basra
Today at 4:32 am by Rocky
» Private Banks Association: Financial inclusion rate rose to 48%
Today at 4:31 am by Rocky
» Economic Center Proposes Establishing a Ministry or Authority for Artificial Intelligence in Iraq
Today at 4:30 am by Rocky
» Head of the "Homeland" coalition to "Nina": New understandings between parliamentary blocs to pass c
Today at 4:28 am by Rocky
» Interior Minister chairs meeting to discuss preparations for securing Arab Summit in Baghdad
Today at 4:27 am by Rocky
» The Prime Minister of the Kurdistan Regional Government discusses with the Japanese Ambassador to Ir
Today at 4:25 am by Rocky
» Al-Maliki: Iraq is a key country in the region, not a marginal one
Today at 4:24 am by Rocky
» Al-Araji discusses with the Iranian military attaché in Baghdad ways to enhance the security and sta
Today at 4:23 am by Rocky
» Expectations of delaying the formation of the regional government until next year due to the lack of
Today at 4:21 am by Rocky
» Tens of thousands of victims.. Will Iraq be able to remove mines before the end of 2028?
Today at 4:20 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary satisfaction with intelligence efforts: The quality of information contributed to dire
Today at 4:18 am by Rocky
» Trump wants to meet Sudani soon
Today at 4:17 am by Rocky
» Kurdistan Finance delegation in Baghdad to discuss October salaries
Today at 4:16 am by Rocky
» Voting this week.. Political dialogues to resolve differences over controversial laws in parliament
Today at 4:14 am by Rocky
» Oil: Associated gas investment in the north reached 410 MCM
Today at 4:13 am by Rocky
» With a length of (2444) meters.. Transport explains the strategic importance of the submerged tunnel
Today at 4:11 am by Rocky
» Government Media: 670 model schools completed in all governorates
Today at 4:10 am by Rocky
» For these reasons, Al-Mashhadani came to power as Speaker of Parliament.
Today at 4:08 am by Rocky
» For these reasons, Al-Mashhadani came to power as Speaker of Parliament.
Today at 4:06 am by Rocky
» Iraq reveals Iranian pledges not to use its territory in any attack
Today at 4:05 am by Rocky
» Al-Mashhadani’s first test: “One month” before the Iraqi parliament to decide on “controversial” law
Today at 4:04 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani directs Jordanians to enter Iraq without a visa
Today at 4:03 am by Rocky
» Wasted wealth.. More than 50% of Iraqi factories are out of operation
Today at 4:02 am by Rocky
» Saleh Al-Mutlaq: “General amnesty” is designed for thieves
Today at 4:01 am by Rocky
» Parliamentarian: Cancellation of the international coalition withdrawal agreement from Iraq is possi
Today at 4:00 am by Rocky
» Government 'furious' at spreading lies: Law will take its right course
Today at 3:58 am by Rocky
» Baghdad Mayor launches new phase to achieve sustainable development at Cairo Urban Forum
Today at 3:57 am by Rocky
» Spreading lies is the weapon of the bankrupt.. The government: We will continue the war on corruptio
Today at 3:56 am by Rocky
» Chairman of the Advisory Board of the Council of Ministers denies an audio recording attributed to h
Today at 3:55 am by Rocky
» Installing GPRS systems in tankers transporting products to combat smuggling in Iraq
Today at 3:53 am by Rocky
» With a length of (2444) meters.. Transport explains the strategic importance of the submerged tunnel
Today at 3:51 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani threatens: We will take revenge on anyone who tamperes with Iraq's security
Today at 3:48 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani calls Trump.. Agreement on coordination to end the war in the region
Today at 3:46 am by Rocky
» Economic calls for Iraq to withdraw from OPEC.. What are the reasons?
Today at 3:44 am by Rocky
» Dollar exchange rates in Iraqi markets this morning
Today at 3:43 am by Rocky
» Disagreements and quarrels.. What happened in the last meeting of the State Administration Coalition
Today at 3:41 am by Rocky
» What are the possible scenarios for forming the regional government?
Today at 3:39 am by Rocky
» Proposal to establish a ministry or body dedicated to artificial intelligence in Iraq
Today at 3:37 am by Rocky
» Urgent | Including increasing the number of branches.. Al-Sudani issues 6 directives to develop the
Yesterday at 5:15 am by Rocky
» Al-Alaq describes the parallel dollar as “abnormal”: There is great stability in prices
Yesterday at 5:14 am by Rocky
» utube 11/5/24 MM&C MM&C News Report-ICC-Investors-RIYADA BANK-Port of Faw-3 Presidents Seated-Removi
Yesterday at 5:05 am by Rocky
» Foreign Ministry: Iraqi-Saudi Coordination Council to convene in Baghdad next month
Yesterday at 5:04 am by Rocky
» Travelers demand cancellation of electronic reservations by government banks in selling them dollars
Yesterday at 5:03 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani directs to increase bank branches to expand financial services and modernize buildings in
Yesterday at 5:01 am by Rocky
» Census Without Nationalities: An Attempt to Write a New Narrative of Iraq’s Unity
Yesterday at 4:59 am by Rocky
» Diplomatic Embrace or the Specter of Sanctions: Iraq Sways in Positions towards Trump
Yesterday at 4:58 am by Rocky
» The National: The British Army Returns to Iraq Under New Pretext
Yesterday at 4:57 am by Rocky
» Zidane and Al-Mandlawi discuss the issue of approving laws related to the work of the judiciary
Yesterday at 4:55 am by Rocky
» MP: The ministerial change is not linked to a specific component or party
Yesterday at 4:54 am by Rocky
» For these reasons, Al-Mashhadani came to power as Speaker of Parliament.
Yesterday at 4:53 am by Rocky
» Al-Kroui to Al-Maalouma: 4 oil and gas fields on the table of the upcoming licensing rounds
Yesterday at 4:51 am by Rocky
» Raouf: The region needs more time to form the new government
Yesterday at 4:50 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani issues 6 directives to increase financial inclusion and raise its indicators in all govern
Yesterday at 4:49 am by Rocky
» Kurdistan Men's Union Diagnoses Danger Threatening Society's "Collapse" and Proposes Polygamy
Yesterday at 4:47 am by Rocky
» Anbar explains details of the Western Desert irrigation project and sets its opening date
Yesterday at 4:46 am by Rocky
» Large ships at the five berths of Al-Faw Port
Yesterday at 4:44 am by Rocky
» Al-Marsoumi: Faw Port and Development Road will generate revenues worth 6 trillion dinars in 2038
Yesterday at 4:43 am by Rocky
» Nearly half of Iraq's factories are "stopped"... moves to rescue them
Yesterday at 4:42 am by Rocky
» Gulf central banks follow the Federal Reserve and cut interest rates
Yesterday at 4:41 am by Rocky
» Iraqis are the most likely to buy real estate in Jordan in 2024
Yesterday at 4:39 am by Rocky
» Iranian-Sudanese agreement to expand economic and trade cooperation
Yesterday at 4:38 am by Rocky
» Completion of 670 schools in all Iraqi governorates
Yesterday at 4:38 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani's advisor: We have put in place a mechanism to provide loans to these groups
Yesterday at 4:37 am by Rocky
» A set of recommendations from Al-Sudani to reform the financial and banking system in Iraq
Yesterday at 4:36 am by Rocky
» A dialogue seminar in Basra discusses the anti-torture file and fair trial mechanisms
Yesterday at 4:33 am by Rocky
» The conclusion of the Ninth International Scientific Conference of the College of Veterinary Medicin
Yesterday at 4:32 am by Rocky
» Minister of Interior from Amman: The government has launched a major campaign to improve the service
Yesterday at 4:31 am by Rocky
» Al-Bujari: The Grand Faw Port Project is an opportunity to do justice to graduates of maritime speci
Yesterday at 4:29 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani announces a package of new banking directives to enhance financial inclusion in the govern
Yesterday at 4:27 am by Rocky
» Iraqi oil returns to gains as Iran-Israel tensions escalate
Yesterday at 4:25 am by Rocky
» Next week... Parliament is close to resolving the controversial laws
Yesterday at 4:22 am by Rocky
» Zidane discusses with Mandalawi and Maliki cooperation between the judicial and legislative authorit
Yesterday at 4:21 am by Rocky
» Al-Atwani to Al-Maliki: We have embarked on a new philosophy for managing the financial sector based
Yesterday at 4:20 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani issues a set of recommendations to reform the financial and banking system in Iraq
Yesterday at 4:18 am by Rocky
» Iraq's Maritime Future.. Everything You Need to Know About Faw Port and Completion Rates (Video)
Yesterday at 4:17 am by Rocky
» Trump poses a threat to Iraq's budget
Yesterday at 4:16 am by Rocky
» A detailed explanation of the implications of Trump’s victory on Iraqi oil policy
Yesterday at 4:14 am by Rocky
» Minister of Interior inaugurates the unified card system at the Iraqi Consulate in Jordan
Yesterday at 4:13 am by Rocky