Home
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.][You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Federal Court responds to the President of the Supreme Judicial Council
2019/07/02 04:54:03
Twilight News / Federal Supreme Court dismissed a lawsuit brought by the President of the Supreme Judicial Council / in addition to the function of others to intercept the Federal Supreme Court 's decision containing the ruling unconstitutional Article 3 of Law No. (30) for the year 2005.
The official spokesman of the court Illes Acommok said that " the Federal Court Supreme Court held its session under the chairmanship of Judge Medhat al-Mahmoud and the presence of all members of the judges and considered the case of objection of others established by the President of the Supreme Judicial Council / in addition to his job.
The Samok, that "the objector objection to appeal the ruling issued by the Federal Supreme Court on 21/5/2019 number (38 / Federal / 2019) by objecting to others as a violation of the rights of the Supreme Judicial Council being the reference judges in the federal judiciary, as that provision is null "He said.
He pointed out that "the plaintiff stated that the case of the subject of the appeal in question has been set up of no interest in the case and influential in its financial, legal or social status and therefore the dispute is not directed in that case."
"The Federal Supreme Court returned to the ruling described in the appeal, and found that it ruled unconstitutionality Article (3) of the Federal Supreme Court Law No. (30) of 2005, including the nomination of the Supreme Judicial Council of the President and members of the Federal Supreme Court on the basis of his authority, which was provided for In paragraph (e) of Article (Forty-fourth) of the Transitional Administrative Law (Interim Constitution).
Al-Samok added that "the court found that the ruling objecting to the appeal against the unconstitutionality of Article 3 was based on the provisions of articles (91 / II) and (92) of the Constitution of the Republic of Iraq for the year 2005, The Supreme Federal Perspective Project in the House of Representatives, in accordance with the text of Article (92 / II) of the Constitution.
Al-Samok explained that "the Federal Supreme Court found that (the objection of others) a way of unusual appeal began to challenge the judgments issued by the courts of first instance, which are mentioned exclusively in Article 224/1 of the Civil Procedure Law No. (83) of 1969 Courts of first instance, personal status courts and appellate courts as the subject court. "
He pointed out that "the Federal Supreme Court stated that the law may not conduct this appeal to the decisions issued by the Federal Court of Cassation, even if it was dismissed in the case before it as a court subject to the validity stipulated in Article 214 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Paragraph (1) of Article (224) of the Code of Civil Procedure and this is what is settled by the judiciary and jurisprudence in Iraq and in other countries.
"The court affirmed that the Federal Supreme Court, which represents the constitutional judiciary in Iraq, is not one of the courts of first instance enumerated in Article 224 of the Civil Procedure Law exclusively by the court."
"The court said that the verdicts and decisions issued by the court are binding and binding on all authorities based on the provisions of Article (94) of the Constitution and article (5 / II) of this law in formality in relation to the third party objection filed by the plaintiff in addition to his job."
The Samok continues, that "objectively, the Federal Supreme Court found that the Constitution of the Republic of Iraq for the year 2005 has increased the competence of the Supreme Judicial Council to nominate the President and members of the Federal Supreme Court starting from the date of entry into force, as established by the provision of Article (61 / V / This authority was the Supreme Judicial Council derived from the provisions of paragraph (e) of Article (forty-fourth) of the Law of Administration of the State of the transitional phase canceled, and the day the President of the Federal Supreme Court under which the President of the Supreme Judicial Council before the issuance of the Law of the Supreme Judicial Council No. (45) 2017 ".
He also said that "the court stated that, since the Transitional Administrative Law was repealed by the Constitution of the Republic of Iraq and enforced on 28 December 2005. Whereas the powers of the Higher Judicial Council were established by the Constitution in article 91 exclusively, namely the Department of Justice and Supervision On the federal judiciary and the nomination of the President and members of the Federal Court of Cassation and the head of the Public Prosecution and the Chairman of the Judicial Supervisory Authority and submit them to the House of Representatives for approval of their appointment in those judicial positions based on the authority provided for in Article (61 / V / A) of the Constitution, Authorities who (47) of the Constitution, which can not be extended to other jurisdictions other than what is stated exclusively. "
The Supreme Federal Court confirmed that the exception to the constitutional text is the text of Article (91) and the text of Article (88) and the text of Article (92) which stipulates the independence of the judiciary as an authority besides the legislative and executive authorities, as stipulated in Article (47) It is measured in addition to the validity of the Supreme Judicial Council mentioned above has been authorized Article (91 / III) of the Constitution to propose the draft annual budget of the federal judicial authority and submitted to the House of Representatives for approval.
"The Supreme Federal Court confirmed that this authority does not include the proposal of the annual budget of the Supreme Federal Court on the basis of the provisions of paragraph (I) of Article (92) of the Constitution and the text of the (Federal Supreme Court judicial body financially and administratively independent) After the text of Article (91) of the Constitution comes to guarantee the independence of the constitutional judiciary represented by the Federal Supreme Court of the Supreme Judicial Council, one of the components of the federal judicial authority provided for in Article (89) of the Constitution and the subsequent text is restricted to the previous text.
He added that "the court confirmed that this was ruled by the Federal Supreme Court in the ruling issued by the number (19 / Federal / 2017) on 11/4/2017."
"The Court found that the presence of Article 3 of the Federal Supreme Court Law, which gave the Supreme Judicial Council the power to nominate the president and members of the Federal Supreme Court, which started under the provisions of the Transitional Administrative Law, has become contrary to the provisions of the Constitution after its entry, The Supreme Judicial Council also provides this authority, but restricts it to certain judicial titles, not including the address of the president and members of the Federal Supreme Court, where this is stipulated in this provision to the law to be enacted by the Council of Representatives in application of the provisions of Article 92 / Which determines how The nomination and appointment of the President and members of the Federal Supreme Court ".
"The court stated that it ruled unconstitutionality of Article (3) of its law in the ruling issued by the number (38 / Federal / 2019) and the date of 21/5/2019 the subject of appeal in the manner of the objection of others and preceded by a ruling issued by the number (19 / 2017) on 11/4/2017 ruled unconstitutional article (3 / third) of the law of the Supreme Judicial Council and in the case that was established by the Supreme Judicial Council and the same content of Article (3) of the Federal Supreme Court.
He added that "the court stressed that the provisions of the Supreme Federal Court as stipulated in Article 94 and Article 5 of its law are binding and binding on all authorities, regardless of who filed the case of unconstitutionality because the claim of unconstitutionality of any law or one of the texts therein is a right exercised by the citizen With regard to the laws expressing his opinion as a right within which the Constitution is in (38 / I) of it and by all legal means. "
"Based on this, and based on the above, the court decided to respond to the plaintiff's claim in both formality and objectivity and to charge the expenses in addition to his job and the fees of the lawyer of the plaintiff's agents and the amount of one hundred thousand dinars distributed among them according to the law, the agreement was issued based on the provisions of Article (94) Constitution and Article (5) of the Federal Supreme Court Act and the decision to rule in public on 2/7/2019 "
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.].
» Iraq operates 'atomic cell', nears deal to build nuclear reactor
» Strategic Planning: Ministerial Change Depends on Al-Sudani’s Vision
» Amending the Election Law... a hot issue facing the next legislative session
» Parliamentary Finance Committee considers reconsidering the price of a barrel of oil in the 2025 bud
» In the picture.. The Central Bank records sales of more than $ 295 million in the currency auction
» Rule of Law: Most political forces support the proposal to amend the electoral law
» Prime Minister: Integration between the executive and legislative authorities is the essence of our
» Central Bank Governor: Prime Minister's support accelerated progress of Rafidain Bank restructuring
» Subsidized loans for Iraqi farmers to be launched soon
» Concerning Kurdistan.. Al-Iqtisad News publishes the text of the amendment to an “important paragrap
» (59) thousand tons of various materials were transported by the land fleet during the past month.
» OPEC+ group begins meeting online
» utube 12/5/24 MM&C Iraq Dinar News-Executive & Legislative Authority Integration-Full Support-
» Protecting the digital space.. Challenges of balancing individual security and freedoms
» Parliament declares its full support for Al-Sudani's government
» Work indicates the spread of the phenomenon of child labor
» Investment contracts to develop the agricultural sector
» Infrastructure and Services
» Experts: Iraq has become an attractive environment for investment
» Al-Sudani speaks "angrily" in parliament about "espionage" and describes it as the "lie of the centu
» New parliamentary meeting to study draft amendment to the budget law
» An expanded meeting at the Central Bank to discuss the restructuring of Rafidain Bank
» Al-Sudani: Iraq is one of the first countries in the world in volunteer work
» The crisis continues... no signs of a resolution on the controversial laws
» Parliamentary Finance: Satisfaction and optimism about the government program’s achievement rate
» Apart from Halbousi, Al-Siyada reveals the imminent announcement of the formation of a new political
» Parliamentary comment after hosting Al-Sudani in Parliament
» After regional tour.. Iranian Foreign Minister visits Iraq on Friday
» What is the possibility of the success of the State Administration Coalition's call to hold an inter
» Al-Sudani explains to Parliament the reasons for amending the Federal Budget Law
» Observers assess Al-Sudani’s “secret” parliamentary session: Important and came at a dangerous time
» Call for comprehensive reform of the banking system in Iraq on the occasion of the International Ban
» Parliamentary and Federal Integrity Discuss Mechanisms for Combating Corruption and Recovering Smugg
» Minister of Planning: The government is working to count Iraqis abroad
» Al-Sudani: The importance of amending the budget to address the issue of marketing oil from the Kurd
» House of Representatives discusses amending the federal budget
» Bitcoin exceeds $100,000 for the first time in its history
» Iraq tops list of countries in number of universities ranked by Times Higher Education Arab Universi
» Government acknowledges the spread of child labor in Iraq
» Dollar exchange rates in Iraq this morning, Thursday
» Al-Samarrai calls for supporting the liberated areas and praises the government’s efforts in the reg
» Why does Iraq import large quantities of gold?
» utube 1/3/24 MM&C-Iraq Dinar News-CBI Gov Monetary Position Excellent-Stop Gov Loans-Private Secto
» utube 1/2/24 Huge Event Coming: Currency Auction EndingRV/RI by Christmas?Dinar RV Updates [IQD Re
» utube 12/1/24 MM&C MM&C-Iraq Dinar News-Non-Oil Revenue-$62 Billion Investment-Halt Credit Activit
» The Minister of Labor announces the launch of the (My Protection Plus) application to submit the ann
» With Document.. Parliamentary Finance Committee Submits Retirement Age Amendment to First Reading
» Basra demands government for its revenues from ports and petrodollars
» About $280 million.. The Central Bank of Iraq’s foreign sales rise
» Al-Sudani and his ministers in a "secret" session in Parliament
» Parliamentary Finance Moves to Amend Retirement Age in Iraq
» Iraq officially signs a memorandum of understanding with Vodafone International to operate "5G"
» Bitcoin stabilizes near historic level, markets await Trump's moves
» Today.. Al-Sudani under the dome of Parliament to discuss these files
» Azerbaijan counts the value of trade exchange with Iraq and confirms its interest in these areas
» Al-Sudani in Parliament.. The economic file is on the agenda and the numbers "highlight" the reality
» Banks are the most traded sector in the Iraqi market in terms of value.
» Specialized Center for Combating Intellectual Terrorism
» The Council of Ministers takes a package of important decisions
» Coordination between electricity and oil to compensate for the shortage of Iranian gas
» Wasit Industrial City to be handed over to Turkish company
» Solving the problems of the private sector in Kirkuk
» Next year.. Establishment of the National Register of Missing Persons
» Transportation: Construction of a railway around Baghdad by 2025
» Alia Nassif demands the dismissal of the Iraqi ambassador to Kuwait and holding him accountable for
» Commerce holds the second specialized working session to update the Harmonized System
» Al-Ghariri calls on Turkish companies and institutions to benefit from available investment opportun
» Rafidain Bank warns its customers against dealing with fake pages and websites on social media
» Parliamentary meeting with the director of SOMO to discuss the kerosene crisis
» Postponing the "Pardon, Personal Status and Real Estate" Laws to Next Year.. MP Reveals the Reasons
» Official statement.. Al-Sudani as a guest of Parliament
» Iraqi analysis of the "mysterious" events in Syria: An American plan to "drain" Russia and the resis
» Reasons for delaying the passage of the new regional government.. The regional and international equ
» What is the possibility of the success of the State Administration Coalition's call to hold an inter
» State of Law Coalition rejects inclusion of 4 crimes in general amnesty
» General Amnesty.. “Progress” objects to two paragraphs and Al-Maliki’s coalition refuses to compromi
» Parliament announces details of hosting Al-Sudani
» Cabinet sets wages for employees outside working hours
» We will not stand idly by while extremist organizations and ethnic and sectarian cleansing operation
» Government Financial Advisor: Budget awaits amendments to conform to government program
» “A grave danger threatens our security”.. The Iraqi parliament directs an appeal to the countries of
» Mawazine News publishes the full decisions of the Cabinet session
» Iraqi Exhibitions: Extensive preparations to host the international session and complete constructio
» Southern Refineries announces resumption of production and confirms no gasoline crisis
» The government takes a decision on the port of Faw and its affiliated projects
» Al-Sudani's office issues a statement on what will be discussed during his hosting in Parliament
» MP: There is no complete law and there are many objections to controversial laws
» Governmental date to establish a national registry for missing persons and create a department for t
» Find out the exchange rates of the dollar against the dinar in Iraq
» Mr. Al-Hakim renews call to revive the "Made in Iraq" label
» On the occasion of World Banking Day.. A call for a comprehensive review of the work of banks in Ira
» A high-ranking security delegation arrives at the Iraqi-Syrian border strip
» Top 5 Leaps of Sustainable Economic Crises in Iraq.. Al-Sudani Speaks with “Numbers” as a Guest in P
» Parliamentary expectations that "all" controversial laws will not be passed in one session
» The Council of Ministers decides to suspend official work next Tuesday
» Emir of Kuwait calls on Iraq to correct usage in Khor Abdullah
» Echoes of Trump’s Threats: Iraq Considers Its Future Away from the Dollar
» Al-Maliki reveals changes in the general amnesty law