Home
Kirkuk's "Achilles' heel" since 2003: A European report warns of escalating tension and suggests solutions
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]Kirkuk city
2023-10-03 05:00
Share
Font
Shafaq News/ The European Council on Foreign Relations Institute confirmed that the recent escalation in the disputed city of Kirkuk reveals structural tensions within the government coalition in Baghdad, warning that this tension raises the risk of intervention by Turkey and Iran that would spark instability on a broader scale in Region.
The European report, translated by Shafaq News Agency, explained that Kirkuk had been, throughout the past century, a place of ethnic tension, and continued, saying that since the American invasion of Iraq in 2003 in particular, control of the disputed oil-rich governorate, inhabited by Kurds, Arabs and Turkmen, was one of the The most controversial and destabilizing issue in the country.
The report pointed out that, while the Kurdistan Region asserts that Kirkuk should be part of the regions of the region, the Iraqi constitution stipulates the necessity of determining the status of Kirkuk through a referendum after conducting a population census, but that has not happened yet, indicating that after the failure of the party’s referendum The Kurdistan Democratic Party gained independence. In September 2017, the central government in Baghdad placed Kirkuk under its direct control.
However, the report indicated a recent escalation of hostilities after the sudden decision taken by Iraqi Prime Minister Muhammad Shia al-Sudani last month to allow the Kurdistan Democratic Party to resume control of its political offices and military base in the city of Kirkuk, a decision that sparked protests from Arab and Turkmen residents, and then counter-protests from The Kurdish population accepted, as 4 people were killed in the unrest, prompting the Federal Supreme Court to stop implementing the decision.
The report saw these events as highlighting the dangers of Kirkuk's unresolved situation, which could be exacerbated by the upcoming local elections in December, and the spillover of tensions into neighboring Turkey and Iran, which have Kurdish populations, which will exacerbate the regional turmoil.
According to the European report, the events that took place in Kirkuk reflect the ethnic divisions that may paralyze the movement of Iraq, indicating that this country is governed by a complex network of alliances that the Sudanese must navigate in order to be able to maintain the continuity of his coalition government.
After the report described Kirkuk as "the Achilles' heel of every Iraqi leader since 2003," it pointed out that the federal government had managed, until recently, to avoid any major escalation in tensions after regaining control over it from the Kurdistan Regional Government in 2017.
In this context, he pointed to Al-Sudani’s “relatively effective” handling of the challenges facing the country, in addition to what the report sees as the weak position that the Kurdistan Democratic Party has suffered from since the ill-fated 2017 referendum, adding that Al-Sudani, in this context, made a decision to allow the Kurdistan Democratic Party to return. To Kirkuk, which subsequently rocked the boat unexpectedly.
The report considered that Sudanese's "weak position" seemed to be driven by the need to achieve balance in his divided coalition government, adding that, in contrast to the prevailing myth that the Iraqi prime minister is beholden only to the Shiite parties (and therefore Iran), he is facing pressure from all the parties that helped form The coalition government, including the Kurdish parties.
He pointed out that Al-Sudani has since clarified that he was implementing one of the understandings within this coalition, but the Arab parties in it, which had a feeling that the Kurdistan Democratic Party was weak, now do not want to support this step.
According to the report, the recent Kirkuk disaster was a clear mistake for a seasoned politician like Al-Sudani, noting that the killing of 4 citizens could have been avoided in the clashes that broke out between Kurdish demonstrators and security forces, adding that it was a “costly mistake” in addition to that, as expected, it provoked his allies. The Arabs in the coalition have long been trying to consolidate federal government control over Kirkuk.
In addition, the report said that according to observers, Al-Sudani’s term would face challenges from the dissatisfied Muqtada al-Sadr, or through new demonstrations related to demanding jobs in the public sector, or due to a power outage. However, these observers did not expect that he would face a challenge through the return of... Ethnic divisions in Kirkuk, which Al-Sudani seems to have unwittingly brought upon himself.
The report continued, while Kirkuk remains a subject of dispute, the risk of destabilization will remain pending before Iraq and the Sudanese government, and that although the Prime Minister was able to maintain the cohesion of his government and lead Iraq through continuing challenges, the reality is that the deep questions, such as the fate of Kirkuk and the relationship Between Baghdad and the Kurdistan Regional Government, it is the one that remains untreated.
Regarding Baghdad, a report says that there is a belief that if Kirkuk joins the Kurdistan Region, it will leave Iraq in one way or another, while with regard to the Kurdistan Region, annexing Kirkuk will lead to launching the process of independence that it desires.
However, the European report considered that "both beliefs are misplaced, because if Kirkuk remains an independent governorate, or becomes a region in its own right, or joins the pre-existing Kurdistan region, then it is part of a unified federal Iraqi state."
The report called on political actors in Iraq not to deal with Kirkuk as a zero-sum game, and instead to realize that its status must be chosen by its citizens through a referendum, as stipulated in the Iraqi constitution.
But now, the current situation is that the unresolved situation of Kirkuk represents a looming factor of turmoil in relations between Baghdad and the regional government, and that even if it does not currently represent the current crisis, it always remains a hotbed of tension and ready to be exploited politically.
In this context, the report pointed out that while the announcement of Kirkuk’s participation in the provincial elections in December, for the first time since 2005, is considered a limited step towards a representative path forward, it, at the same time, constitutes a danger that it will continue. Political parties are using recent events to mobilize their voter base, and are working to exacerbate polarization and ethnic tensions, which will only enhance the security threat posed by ISIS sleeper cells, which often exploit such situations.
At the same time, the report considers that recent events have revealed the weakness of Sudanese’s ability to coordinate dealing with divisions within his coalition, which enhances the fragility of the Sudanese government.
He added that in light of the escalation of tensions between Baghdad and the regional government, this makes the Kurdistan Region vulnerable to interventions by Turkey and Iran, which are concerned that feelings of independence in Kirkuk will extend to their Kurdish population, pointing, for example, to the two countries’ already militarily intervening in the north. Iraq against Kurdish opposition forces stationed there.
In an invitation addressed to Europe, the report warned that any further escalation of tensions in Kirkuk could have destabilizing effects throughout the region and beyond. Therefore, it is imperative for European foreign ministries and their missions in Iraq to take advantage of their projects aimed at strengthening democracy, in order to assure Iraqi politicians that However, their parties are partners in a coalition government and in a federal state, which requires them to adhere to democratic federalism.
The report continued its implicit warning, saying that “without social harmony among Iraq’s multi-ethnic population, the Global Coalition to Defeat ISIS and the NATO mission in Iraq, along with other European missions, will never achieve their goal.”
The European report concluded by saying that although Kirkuk is a single governorate, it serves as a "regional fault line" that can cause turmoil throughout the Middle East.
He added that Sudanese has so far been able to continue developing relations with his neighbors despite having to overcome internal divisions in his coalition government, but this work becomes more difficult and dangerous when it comes to addressing old issues such as Kirkuk.
After the report indicated that this issue is internal and sensitive, it stressed the importance of European missions providing assistance in order to create the conditions conducive to reaching a solution by emphasizing their support for the federal system and democracy in Iraq. The report considered that this could reduce concerns regarding the status of Kirkuk within the Iraqi state, calm relations with neighboring Turkey and Iran, and prevent harm to the security operations of the international coalition and the NATO mission in Iraq.
Translated by Shafaq News Agency
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]Kirkuk city
2023-10-03 05:00
Share
Font
Shafaq News/ The European Council on Foreign Relations Institute confirmed that the recent escalation in the disputed city of Kirkuk reveals structural tensions within the government coalition in Baghdad, warning that this tension raises the risk of intervention by Turkey and Iran that would spark instability on a broader scale in Region.
The European report, translated by Shafaq News Agency, explained that Kirkuk had been, throughout the past century, a place of ethnic tension, and continued, saying that since the American invasion of Iraq in 2003 in particular, control of the disputed oil-rich governorate, inhabited by Kurds, Arabs and Turkmen, was one of the The most controversial and destabilizing issue in the country.
The report pointed out that, while the Kurdistan Region asserts that Kirkuk should be part of the regions of the region, the Iraqi constitution stipulates the necessity of determining the status of Kirkuk through a referendum after conducting a population census, but that has not happened yet, indicating that after the failure of the party’s referendum The Kurdistan Democratic Party gained independence. In September 2017, the central government in Baghdad placed Kirkuk under its direct control.
However, the report indicated a recent escalation of hostilities after the sudden decision taken by Iraqi Prime Minister Muhammad Shia al-Sudani last month to allow the Kurdistan Democratic Party to resume control of its political offices and military base in the city of Kirkuk, a decision that sparked protests from Arab and Turkmen residents, and then counter-protests from The Kurdish population accepted, as 4 people were killed in the unrest, prompting the Federal Supreme Court to stop implementing the decision.
The report saw these events as highlighting the dangers of Kirkuk's unresolved situation, which could be exacerbated by the upcoming local elections in December, and the spillover of tensions into neighboring Turkey and Iran, which have Kurdish populations, which will exacerbate the regional turmoil.
According to the European report, the events that took place in Kirkuk reflect the ethnic divisions that may paralyze the movement of Iraq, indicating that this country is governed by a complex network of alliances that the Sudanese must navigate in order to be able to maintain the continuity of his coalition government.
After the report described Kirkuk as "the Achilles' heel of every Iraqi leader since 2003," it pointed out that the federal government had managed, until recently, to avoid any major escalation in tensions after regaining control over it from the Kurdistan Regional Government in 2017.
In this context, he pointed to Al-Sudani’s “relatively effective” handling of the challenges facing the country, in addition to what the report sees as the weak position that the Kurdistan Democratic Party has suffered from since the ill-fated 2017 referendum, adding that Al-Sudani, in this context, made a decision to allow the Kurdistan Democratic Party to return. To Kirkuk, which subsequently rocked the boat unexpectedly.
The report considered that Sudanese's "weak position" seemed to be driven by the need to achieve balance in his divided coalition government, adding that, in contrast to the prevailing myth that the Iraqi prime minister is beholden only to the Shiite parties (and therefore Iran), he is facing pressure from all the parties that helped form The coalition government, including the Kurdish parties.
He pointed out that Al-Sudani has since clarified that he was implementing one of the understandings within this coalition, but the Arab parties in it, which had a feeling that the Kurdistan Democratic Party was weak, now do not want to support this step.
According to the report, the recent Kirkuk disaster was a clear mistake for a seasoned politician like Al-Sudani, noting that the killing of 4 citizens could have been avoided in the clashes that broke out between Kurdish demonstrators and security forces, adding that it was a “costly mistake” in addition to that, as expected, it provoked his allies. The Arabs in the coalition have long been trying to consolidate federal government control over Kirkuk.
In addition, the report said that according to observers, Al-Sudani’s term would face challenges from the dissatisfied Muqtada al-Sadr, or through new demonstrations related to demanding jobs in the public sector, or due to a power outage. However, these observers did not expect that he would face a challenge through the return of... Ethnic divisions in Kirkuk, which Al-Sudani seems to have unwittingly brought upon himself.
The report continued, while Kirkuk remains a subject of dispute, the risk of destabilization will remain pending before Iraq and the Sudanese government, and that although the Prime Minister was able to maintain the cohesion of his government and lead Iraq through continuing challenges, the reality is that the deep questions, such as the fate of Kirkuk and the relationship Between Baghdad and the Kurdistan Regional Government, it is the one that remains untreated.
Regarding Baghdad, a report says that there is a belief that if Kirkuk joins the Kurdistan Region, it will leave Iraq in one way or another, while with regard to the Kurdistan Region, annexing Kirkuk will lead to launching the process of independence that it desires.
However, the European report considered that "both beliefs are misplaced, because if Kirkuk remains an independent governorate, or becomes a region in its own right, or joins the pre-existing Kurdistan region, then it is part of a unified federal Iraqi state."
The report called on political actors in Iraq not to deal with Kirkuk as a zero-sum game, and instead to realize that its status must be chosen by its citizens through a referendum, as stipulated in the Iraqi constitution.
But now, the current situation is that the unresolved situation of Kirkuk represents a looming factor of turmoil in relations between Baghdad and the regional government, and that even if it does not currently represent the current crisis, it always remains a hotbed of tension and ready to be exploited politically.
In this context, the report pointed out that while the announcement of Kirkuk’s participation in the provincial elections in December, for the first time since 2005, is considered a limited step towards a representative path forward, it, at the same time, constitutes a danger that it will continue. Political parties are using recent events to mobilize their voter base, and are working to exacerbate polarization and ethnic tensions, which will only enhance the security threat posed by ISIS sleeper cells, which often exploit such situations.
At the same time, the report considers that recent events have revealed the weakness of Sudanese’s ability to coordinate dealing with divisions within his coalition, which enhances the fragility of the Sudanese government.
He added that in light of the escalation of tensions between Baghdad and the regional government, this makes the Kurdistan Region vulnerable to interventions by Turkey and Iran, which are concerned that feelings of independence in Kirkuk will extend to their Kurdish population, pointing, for example, to the two countries’ already militarily intervening in the north. Iraq against Kurdish opposition forces stationed there.
In an invitation addressed to Europe, the report warned that any further escalation of tensions in Kirkuk could have destabilizing effects throughout the region and beyond. Therefore, it is imperative for European foreign ministries and their missions in Iraq to take advantage of their projects aimed at strengthening democracy, in order to assure Iraqi politicians that However, their parties are partners in a coalition government and in a federal state, which requires them to adhere to democratic federalism.
The report continued its implicit warning, saying that “without social harmony among Iraq’s multi-ethnic population, the Global Coalition to Defeat ISIS and the NATO mission in Iraq, along with other European missions, will never achieve their goal.”
The European report concluded by saying that although Kirkuk is a single governorate, it serves as a "regional fault line" that can cause turmoil throughout the Middle East.
He added that Sudanese has so far been able to continue developing relations with his neighbors despite having to overcome internal divisions in his coalition government, but this work becomes more difficult and dangerous when it comes to addressing old issues such as Kirkuk.
After the report indicated that this issue is internal and sensitive, it stressed the importance of European missions providing assistance in order to create the conditions conducive to reaching a solution by emphasizing their support for the federal system and democracy in Iraq. The report considered that this could reduce concerns regarding the status of Kirkuk within the Iraqi state, calm relations with neighboring Turkey and Iran, and prevent harm to the security operations of the international coalition and the NATO mission in Iraq.
Translated by Shafaq News Agency
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
» utube 12/03/23 Militia Man & Crew World Wide - Iraq Dinar - Private Sector - Industrial -Internat
» For three categories: 75% of the grant amounts have been completed by the Culture Ministry and are a
» Despite the crisis, the Kurdistan government spends millions of dinars as rewards for members of the
» After strict measures... the Interior Ministry monitors a decline in the phenomenon of “foreign work
» Government recommendations regarding procedures for tracking the entry of imported goods into local
» Al-Maliki: The imbalance in the salary scale must be addressed and studied again
» The railways announces the preparation of preliminary designs for a development road of about 600 km
» The President of the Republic: There is no dollar crisis in Iraq
» Work: Directed to include all workers, contracts, and wage earners in the Social Security Law
» Zain Cash relaunches the “Western Union” service
» The head of the Integrity Commission calls for increased international support for training investig
» Environment: Launching the Green Bank is considered an advanced step towards a sustainable green eco
» OPEC Secretary General: Saying that oil should remain underground leads to chaos
» A parliamentarian responds to an Iranian official: Iraq does not need an external force to defend it
» Al-Sudani directs finance to allocate a budget for the Kurdistan Parliament elections
» Border crossings: The government took decisions to control revenues and transfers
» The Iraqi Stock Exchange closed down by 4.76%
» The Agricultural Bank announces the activation of the MasterCard deposit service
» The Minister of Transport reveals his discussions with the region’s delegation regarding the path to
» The Prime Minister's Office determines the mechanism for regulating the work of generators
» Al-Sudani confirms the government’s keenness to improve the living conditions of citizens in the Kur
» Finance clarifies the choice of Ernst & Young to review its data
» The Sudanese and the Azerbaijani ambassador discuss holding the third session of the joint bilateral
» Petroleum products set the date for ending cash circulation at fuel filling stations
» Corruption in contracts swallows up millions of dollars...and questions about the mechanism of myste
» Two people who traded in unregistered SIM cards were overthrown, and this is the outcome of the blac
» Monday window.. The Central Bank’s dollar sales decrease by 8% compared to yesterday
» Parliamentary Finance: No deficit in the two budgets for the next two years and larger allocations a
» A parliamentary committee confirms the government's seriousness in reviving alternative energy
» An economic expert identifies a number of treatments for the parallel market dollar
» Al-Halbousi is under investigation on charges of collaborating with the Zionist entity
» Parliamentary accusations against America of standing against the Belt and Road Initiative
» Parliamentary Integrity forms a committee to follow up on the dollar file
» Parliamentary calls to put pressure on Türkiye economically to force it to release water quotas
» A political movement demanding a response to the American and Zionist massacres
» The coordination committee meets to discuss a “Sunni” alternative to Al-Halbousi
» Foreign dollar transfers increased by 87% in the Iraqi currency auction
» “Sulaimaniyah Room Girl”: The doors of trade will open to the women of Kurdistan
» Martyrs Foundation: A vertical residential complex in Baghdad for the Foundation’s beneficiaries
» Iraq is the second largest importer of Iranian goods within 8 months
» Ports: Berths 1 and 2 at Al-Faw Port will enter service by the end of 2025
» Resources are preparing a plan to construct 6 dams in the coming years
» Minister of Construction: The government is working to prepare a civilized design for both sides of
» Planning identifies 6 government measures that contributed to the decline in poverty rates
» Difficulties facing water collection plans in Iraq... and optimism about the agricultural season
» Finance returns general managers to their positions and positions
» Electricity: Turkmen gas will meet the needs of 6 stations by 100 percent
» {Bilateral Defense} is the focus of the Iraqi-Iranian talks
» Najaf is building low-cost homes for people with limited income
» {Half a century} to complete the work of the Article 140 Committee
» No deficit in next year's budget
» Al-Shuhada: a vertical residential complex in Baghdad
» Al-Sudani: Low levels of poverty in Iraq
» Experts: Boycotting elections does not take away their legitimacy
» Employees demand that the federal government hand over their salaries through its banks in Kurdistan
» Lawmakers: Some laws need to be amended
» Israeli newspaper: Al-Sudani warned Blinken of the consequences of targeting factions in Iraq and vi
» Electing a new Speaker of Parliament at the political negotiating table.. The coordination framework
» The President of the Republic: Iraq lost a third of the country due to terrorism, and the war in Gaz
» A person close to the movement explains why Al-Sadr resorts to religious rather than political disco
» Framework leaders discuss the names of candidates for presidency of the House of Representatives
» Al-Barti is dissatisfied with Baghdad's "renunciation" of a previous agreement: Armed groups create
» Parliament Finance is “optimistic” about government bank measures: We do not have accurate numbers f
» Al-Rafidain launches social protection salaries
» For the first time since May 2022.. “Bitcoin” exceeds the $40,000 barrier
» A new rise in dollar prices in Iraq
» American Studies Center: Iraq's growth and stability in adapting to climate change
» More violent attacks after the truce.. Iraq’s 2024 forecast: American forces will remain and the fac
» Entry into force of the Retirement and Social Security Law
» Al-Sudani agrees to launch the return to school initiative
» Al-Mandalawi stresses the necessity of activating the joint agreements between Iraq and Iran
» Parliamentary Finance: There is no deficit in next year’s budget
» The Iraqi President: The crisis is over, Baghdad is safe, and the dryness of the marshes is caused b
» Parliamentary Agriculture: The necessity of using the economic card against Turkey to force it to re
» Government efforts to pass the People with Disabilities Law in the next cabinet session
» The President of the Republic: Iraq has resolved its problems with neighboring countries and is play
» Government expectations: 48 million people in Iraq in 2028
» The 2023 budget loses its “explosive” character: the year will end with only 58% of it being spent
» Saudi Arabia advises avoiding travel to Iraq due to the spread of two “infectious diseases”
» Jokes
» Just a few short jokes.
» Federal Prime Minister: The Retirement and Social Security Law comes into effect
» Reducing the “Iraqi Food Basket” plan to only 15%
» United Nations: 6 million Iraqis suffer from some form of disability
» China announces an increase in the volume of trade exchange with Iraq
» utube 12/03/23 Al_Sudani Take Action About IQD / Iraqi Dinar News Today / currency exchange
» utube 12/03/23 Iraqi Dinar Finally 5 December Is Day Of Revaluation-Iraqi Dinar News Today - Rv Up
» utube 12/03/23 Iraqi dinar Iraqi dinar Al Sudani Signs shift to money related power Iraqi Dina
» Those who do not carry cash may be embarrassed by “malfunctions”.. How will Oil Oil overcome the obs
» Militia Man & Crew Top 10 Best Forex Brokers in iraq 2024
» After Iraq refused to attack its territory.. Will Washington inform Baghdad of its upcoming strikes?
» The Ministry of Oil talks about the goal of Iraq’s participation in the COP28 conference and plans t
» The Minister of Industry announces reaching agreements and understandings to establish partnerships
» Entering a commodity-for-gas swap agreement between Iraq and Iran
» Iraq calls for an emergency session of Arab parliaments to stop the genocide of the Palestinian peop
» State of Law: America tampered with the file of depositing money from the sale of Iraqi oil
» Progress reveals the transfer of the “al-Halbousi replacement” file until after the local elections
» The Foreign Ministry explains the reason for suspending the ambassadors file: half of them are party