[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]May 12, 2003
How Much Oil Does Iraq Have?
By: Gal Luft
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] Now that Iraq's oil has been secured by coalition forces and hopefully will soon be brought back on stream, it is time to solve a potentially important mystery: how much Iraqi oil is actually there?
Over the past several months, news organizations and experts have regularly cited Department of Energy (DOE) Energy Information Administration (EIA) f
igures claiming that the territory of Iraq contains over 112 billion barrels (bbl) of proven reserves—oil that has been definitively discovered and is expected to be economically producible. In addition, since Iraq is the least explored of the oil-rich countries, there have been numerous claims of huge undiscovered reserves there as well—oil thought to exist, and expected to become economically recoverable—to the tune of hundreds of billions of barrels. The respected
Petroleum Economist Magazineestimates that there may be as many as 200 bbl of oil in Iraq; the Federation of American Scientists estimates 215 bbl; a study by the Council on Foreign Relations and the James A. Baker III Institute at Rice University claimed that Iraq has 220 bbl of undiscovered oil; and another study by the Center for Global Energy Studies and Petrolog & Associates offered an even more optimistic estimate of 300 bbl—a number that would give Iraq reserves greater even than those of Saudi Arabia. In a
Guardianinterview before the war, Taha Hmud Moussa, Saddam's deputy oil minister, said that all of Iraq's oil reserves "will exceed 300bbl when all Iraq's regions are explored
If true, this would mean that Iraq has roughly a quarter of all of the world's oil. These assessments have been repeatedly cited in news articles, conferences, think tank briefings, congressional testimonies, and academic works because they raise the prospect that America's energy security could significantly improve if Iraq were able to challenge Saudi Arabia's position as the world's preeminent oil producer.
AN UNREPORTED DEBATEThere is no doubt that Iraq has a huge oil potential that still needs to be developed, and once opened for exploration, it could again be one of the world's most attractive oil domains for investors. But the reserve estimates that have so far been accepted uncritically by the public have been challenged by many petrogeologists and have yet to be substantiated. This is an important problem given the wide range of important decisions being made regarding Iraq's future and the global energy market.
It is particularly important to verify the estimates of Iraqi reserves since the DOE figures stand in contrast to those of an equally reputable U.S. government organization. In its 2000
World Petroleum Assessment, the Department of the Interior's U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) presented figures based on extensive geologic studies by a team of more than 40 geoscientists claiming that, as of the end of 1995, Iraq had 100 bbl of proven reserves, of which 22 bbl had already been recovered. Hence, according to the USGS, Iraq's current proven reserves amount to only 78 bbl—only two-thirds of the DOE's more commonly accepted 112 bbl estimate.
When it comes to assessing Iraq's undiscovered reserves, the differences between the DOE and the USGS becomes even starker. According to the USGS—which is hardly a Chicken Little when it comes to reserve predictions—there is a 95 percent probability that Iraq has at least 14 bbl, a 50 percent probability that it has at least 45 bbl, but only a 5 percent probability that it has 84 bbl of undiscovered reserves. This means that the probability that Iraq has 200 bbl or 300 bbl, as so many of the reports have suggested, is, according to USGS calculations, close to nil.
The discrepancies between the United States' two chief government agencies dealing with energy assessments are so sharp that they present entirely contradictory images of Iraq's oil potential. If the DOE data is right, then Iraq has the world's second largest proven reserves. On the other hand, if the USGS figures are right (and they are also endorsed by the 2002
Energy Outlook of the Paris-based International Energy Agency, whose projections are recognized as authoritative throughout the energy world), then Russia would be second, with roughly twice the reserves of Iraq.
TWO METHODS OF ASSESSMENTThe discrepancies between the DOE on the one hand and the USGS and IEA on the other stem from their different methods of assessment. USGS geologists prepare estimates for all nations, based on elaborate computer programs and a large body of statistics maintained by a private company, Petroconsultants, in Geneva. This information, assembled over 40 years from myriad sources, covers some 18,000 oil fields worldwide. The product is an estimate of the percentage probability of new discoveries in each petroleum system. Although this is generally the only way to assess the unknown, the method is not free of guesses, assumptions, and inaccuracies. That said, it is still far more accurate than the method the DOE has applied.
In truth, the DOE has no method of independent evaluation at all. Its main source of public data is the
Oil & Gas Journal (OGJ), a leading trade journal of the oil industry. Over the years, the
OGJ has become the most widely quoted source of reserve assessments. Its data is used by the much quoted annual
British Petroleum Statistical Review of World Energy and by the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC). However, the reserve figures published annually by the
OGJ are hardly beyond reproach.
In fact, the
OGJ data is based on survey responses and updates released by the individual countries themselves, leaving them open to a slew of problems. First, in many cases, the countries themselves do not release new data every year, and some don't ever. But the
OGJ's policy is to alter a reserve figure "only when it receives not only evidence that a change is necessary but also a reliable new estimate." Many countries refuse to provide the
OGJ any information at all, and so their reserves are published unchanged year after year (even if they have been pumping full throttle the entire time). Half of the 67 countries listed in the 1995
OGJ report gave the identical oil reserve numbers as those for previous years—thereby omitting any production that would obviously have depleted the fields. Likewise, as many as 70 countries reported unchanged numbers in 1999, while in the 2002 report 67 out of 105 countries did not change oil values even though most of them produced at full capacity. Moreover, some countries provide misleading or outdated oil reserve data to try to gain political prestige and leverage in negotiations for OPEC production quotas or World Bank loans and grants. While this is widely suspected, from time to time hard proof surfaces. For example, last year Mexico suddenly changed its claims regarding its oil reserves from 26.9 bbl to only 12.6 bbl when Petroleos Mexicanos, Mexico's state oil monopoly, was forced to comply with U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing guidelines.
Since the
OGJ admits that it is not qualified to assess the validity of the information, its estimates should be taken with at least a grain of salt—which raises the question of why the DOE prefers to use data from a commercial publication rather than data derived in a more statistically and scientifically defensible manner by a fellow government agency.
IRAQ'S OIL RESERVESGiven Iraq's poor record of reporting on other issues of international concern, there is every reason to suspect that Saddam Hussein's regime was less than candid in its reports on oil reserve estimates—especially during the past 12 years, when Iraq's oil fields were inaccessible to reputable Western companies.
Even before the 1990-91 Gulf War, it was difficult to assess what still lay beneath the Iraqi sands. Most of the geological data about Iraq's reserves was gathered before the nationalization of the Iraq Petroleum Company in 1972. From then on, data on Iraq's oil reserves was closely guarded by Saddam's regime, which limited the ability of the international community to conduct an external audit. For the most part, Iraq's oil data has been marred with inconsistencies, gross approximations, and, at times, bold exaggerations. In 1987, for example, despite the fact that it was in the midst of war with Iran and its oil industry was mostly static, Iraq claimed to have more than doubled its reported reserves from 47 bbl to 100 bbl. The increase was a lie: it was just creative bookkeeping designed to increase Baghdad's OPEC quota rather than the result of new oil discoveries. Over the last six years, Iraq has claimed that its reserves have remained constant, despite the fact that it produced close to a billion barrels per year through the oil-for-food program and its various smuggling operations via Syria, Jordan, Turkey, and the Persian Gulf.
As for undiscovered reserves, external auditing is even more difficult and Iraq's claims are even more dubious. Issam al-Chalabi, Iraq's oil minister from 1987 to 1990, admitted in the March 24, 2003 issue of the
OGJ that Iraq's oil figures are "preliminary in nature since work was often interrupted by political problems, and the technology used is now outdated." Large parts of the country, especially in Iraq's Western Desert and its northwest, are still untapped and need to be explored. This is where the DOE and USGS really part company. According to the
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], deep oil-bearing formations located in the vast Western Desert region could possibly yield as much as 100 bbl. This again contrasts with the detailed data of the USGS, which suggests only a 50 percent possibility of 6.6 bbl in Iraq's Western Desert petroleum system. Even under its most optimistic scenario, the USGS predicts no more than 14 bbl coming from this area.
However, there are some facts that are undisputed. First, Iraq has considerable oil reserves and low production costs. Second, because of Iraq's isolation over the last decade—during which exploration technology has greatly improved—there has been almost no use of the most sophisticated exploration techniques such as seismological surveys, magnetometers, and sniffers in Iraq. Furthermore, most of the fields have not been explored down to the deepest layers of the ground, where plenty of oil can be found. Out of the 74 fields that have been discovered and evaluated, only 15 are actually operating. In addition, there are 526 prospective drilling sites in Iraq today, but just 125 of them have actually been drilled. Of those, 90 have shown potential as oil fields, but only 30 have been even partially developed. This means that once on the ground with sophisticated exploration tools, petrogeologists could establish in relatively short time a far more accurate picture of the scope of Iraq's reserve than the one we have today.
THE STRUGGLE FOR IRAQ'S OPEC QUOTASWhy is it important to know how much oil Iraq really has? Petroleum analysis is often a fuzzy business, and there is no guarantee that one analysis regarding Iraq's reserves is closer to the truth than another. But a comprehensive assessment of Iraq's oil and gas endowment is essential not only for Iraq's future, but also for the economic and strategic security of the United States and the world at large. Iraqi reserve estimates are the basis of economic planning and a decision-making tool for investors. At a time when billions of dollars of investment are heading toward Iraq, it is critical that investors base their investment decisions on sound economic data rather than figures provided by a regime notorious for its unreliability.
Iraq's oil figures will also be used in assessing the terms for loans and grants provided to the new government. These funds will be essential for the reconstruction effort, especially in the next several years, when the country's oil infrastructure will be overhauled. No less important, in the next few months Iraq will enter negotiations with OPEC to determine its production quota. In fact, an Iraqi delegation led by Jawdat al-Obeidi, the self-proclaimed deputy governor of postwar Baghdad, and comprising senior oil officials from Iraq's deposed government, took part in OPEC consultations in Vienna in April after the fall of Baghdad.
Since Iraq has been the subject of United Nations economic sanctions since 1990, its oil exports have been overseen by the Office of the Iraq Program, and it therefore has not participated in the OPEC quota system. As soon as Iraq reactivates its participation in OPEC, this will all change. OPEC quotas are determined by consensus and based on various factors like the condition of the country's oil infrastructure, its capacity to produce and transport, the degree of the government's dependence on oil revenues, demographic and economic considerations, and the demand for a specific country's oil. But one of the most important parameters in determining the quota is the overall size of reserves. With 261 bbl of reserves, Saudi Arabia's quota stands at 8 million barrels per day (mbd). Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates each have about 95 bbl of proven reserves and their production quota is therefore only
2 mbd. Many analysts believe that with a stable political situation, heavy investment, and a political environment conducive to economic development, Iraq might be able to pump up its production to as much as 6 mbd by 2010 and 7-8 mbd by 2020.
Despite OPEC's claim that each member country retains absolute sovereignty over its oil production, OPEC members agree by unanimous vote on production ceilings. It is no secret that Saudi Arabia is likely to be the main casualty if Iraq is able to boost its production to join the small club of giant producers—especially if Iraq is able to create spare production capacity to cut into Saudi Arabia's near monopoly. Before the Gulf War, Iraq's OPEC quota was 3.
2 mbd. If Iraq's reserves are proven to be in the range claimed by Saddam's regime, Iraq will be able to demand a much higher production quota from OPEC, rivaling that of Saudi Arabia—or perhaps even higher, since Iraq's population is larger. OPEC's current total production quota stands at 25.4 mbd. Assuming that OPEC chooses to keep this constant to maintain oil prices, then a gradual increase in Iraq's quota would have to come at the expense of fellow producers, who will have an incentive to try to limit Iraq's production.
It is unlikely that Saudi Arabia, which is heavily dependent on oil revenues and in serious financial straits, would agree to transfer a significant portion of its production quota to Iraq. Riyadh's reluctance might prompt Iraq to seriously consider leaving OPEC, because Iraq will have a tremendous need to pump as much oil as possible to pay for its recovery. Moreover, Washington might strongly encourage such an Iraqi move, since any competition with OPEC would likely increase oil supplies, thereby lowering prices.
However, if Iraq remains a member of OPEC, as seems more likely, the negotiations over its quotas are likely to take years and to be tied into the gradual increase in Iraq's production capacity. Iraq is unlikely to exceed its standing but dormant 3.
2 mbd OPEC production for roughly five years, pushing off the need for the kind of hard choices that will be required to deal with this thorny issue. As this process unfolds, it is essential to engage in a comprehensive evaluation of Iraq's oil endowment to put the record straight using fresh, reliable, and widely accepted information produced by scientific methodology, not the wishful thinking of a deceitful regime.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]This was written in 2003.
» Rental sources for the legitimacy of achievement and governance in Iraq
» Parliamentary Foreign Ministry: Al-Sudani will present in Turkey the file of dollar smuggling throug
» Sudanese advisor reveals the most important axes of the decision table between Iraq and Turkey
» Parliamentary Oil announces the direct study of a very important controversial law
» Cabinet Secretariat: We look forward to the development projects support platform being an opportuni
» Member of Parliament Finance: We have not seen the budget yet
» What is the truth about the dispute between Exxon Mobil and Iraq? .. An expert answers
» Enhancing the role of the private sector and digitizing the economy at the Iraqi-European negotiatio
» The House of Representatives intends to host the Sudanese government
» The Foreign Minister stresses the importance of the European Union's role in promoting democracy in
» Saudi Arabia resumes its flights with Iraq and is considering opening new consulates and ports
» Sudanese advisor: The "dream" project from FAO to Europe is on the discussion table with Erdogan
» The Parliamentary Finance details its "criticisms" on the budget: serious consequences and its defic
» The head of the Investment Authority puts Turkey in front of the "water for investment" equation
» Parliamentary Finance: The return of stability in the exchange rate of the dollar depends on taking
» Al Mandalawi calls on the Businessmen Council to encourage their counterparts to invest in Iraq
» MilitiaMan and Crew: 3-19-2023 U-tube
» Monday Night KTFA CC "The Whale Song" 3-20-2023
» Iraq is heading to offer a sixth licensing round for oil exploration in the west of the country
» American analyzes compare the wars in Iraq and Ukraine and reveal that Saddam fell into the trap of
» Among them is the end-of-service reward.. The Retirement Authority reveals paragraphs that need lega
» A report questioning the economic feasibility of Iraqi ports, including Al-Faw, for several reasons
» Al-Sudani congratulated Newroz: Our Iraq is moving towards the sustainability of civil peace and the
» Opening a center for the Pension Authority at the headquarters of the Ministry of Education to compl
» Retirement and social security..important laws awaiting legislation in Parliament
» Al-Shabki: The oil and gas law will impose the region's authority over areas belonging to Nineveh
» A political warning of rising tensions over the election law
» Expert: The US Secretary of Defense visited Iraq to ensure the survival of his forces
» Al-Rafidain: 5-year period for repayment of advances to employees and retirees
» An economist diagnoses a major imbalance in the budget
» The ports announce the timelines for the completion of the projects of the great port of Faw
» A warning against dragging Iraq towards normalization through the Aqaba oil pipeline
» Parliamentary criticism of passing the election law at dawn and leaving the budget discussion
» Al-Sudani overthrows the Al-Halbousi Secrets and Corruption Fund, amid calls for the arrest of more
» Kurdish dissatisfaction with the continued presence of Turkish forces in northern Iraq to revive the
» The dollar opens trading on Tuesday, exceeding 156 thousand dinars
» Energy Police seize a den for recycling and smuggling of oil derivatives in Anbar
» Parliamentary Committee: The Industrial Investment Law provides a safe and attractive environment fo
» Why does not Iraq re-adopt the coin?
» The Council of Ministers approves six recommendations to support and localize the pharmaceutical ind
» He Ruled Out Voting On It Soon.. Al-Maliki Reveals The Secrets Of The Struggle Over The Budget
» Al-Mandalawi: We reached understandings with the Jordanian side regarding the Iraqi community and fa
» Representative of the Prime Minister: Newroz celebrations are an opportunity to take care of the env
» Al-Sudani: Nowruz passes us by this year, and our Iraq is taking important steps towards sustaining
» Moayad Al-Lami at the "Baghdad International Dialogue" Conference: The procedures of the Joint Opera
» Chihoud: The one-constituency election law will achieve the public interest of the Iraqi people
» Al-Rafidain determines the amounts of loans granted to employees, employees of the Ministry of Inter
» Baghdad and Riyadh are discussing the mechanisms of the Saudi soft loan for the reconstruction of Ir
» The Central Bank launches a new electronic platform
» Central Bank: We have large allocations to support and finance green economy projects
» In pictures, the Central Bank launches the e_Donate platform application
» Al-Mandalawi calls on the Businessmen Council to encourage their counterparts from countries of the
» After the Minister of Interior's directive.. How are the Iraqi security services involved in drug us
» NATO assures Fouad Hussein of its full respect for Iraq's sovereignty and territorial integrity
» Basra crude prices drop by more than 4%
» An Iraqi association launches the first financial electronic application in Iraq related to humanita
» Integrity: Saad Kambesh committed violations in a hotel purchase contract worth 47 billion dinars
» Service Issues administrative orders to those covered by appointment in 9 institutions and ministrie
» American leaders: American forces will remain in Iraq forever to protect his government
» The stability of oil prices.. Brent records 73.84 dollars per barrel
» A slight rise in the exchange rates of the dollar in the local markets
» The arrest of the former head of the Sunni Endowment Office, on the background of corruption files
» Low gold prices in Baghdad markets
» A stabilizing factor.. European praise for Iraq's role in the region
» Al-Sudani assures the Saudi Trade Minister of openness towards developing partnership with the Kingd
» The Iraqi government issues a number of decisions - Urgent
» The governor of Karbala defends the provincial councils and denies the interference of any party by
» To participate in the water conference.. The President of the Republic leaves Iraq for America
» Al-Sistani refused to meet him.. Details of Bremer’s rule in Iraq: I made two mistakes and the decis
» Bakhtiar Hajji visits the Ministry of Trade and Industry of the Kurdistan Regional Government
» The Minister of Immigration announces the launch of an electronic service to communicate with Iraqi
» A new decision from the Ministry of Interior regarding granting licenses to possess and carry weapon
» Al-Sudani: Our visit to Turkey assumes special importance at this particular time, with the positive
» Parliament sets next Saturday to complete the vote on the provisions of the election law
» Globally.. Iraq climbs one rank with the cheapest price of gasoline
» Twenty years ago, in April 2003, American soldiers toppled the statue of Saddam Hussein in Al-Firdou
» How did the invasion of Iraq change the American military doctrine?
» Bush wanted to send an army to overthrow Saddam and an army to rebuild Iraq
» One of them is related to end-of-service benefits.. Retirement talks about paragraphs that need lega
» Advisor to the Prime Minister: This is the government's message to all countries
» OPEC Secretary General from Baghdad: Achieving stability and balance between supply and demand is on
» Al-Rafidain determines the period for repaying the advances of employees and retirees
» Demonstrations in central Baghdad.. Demands to amend the salary scale of employees
» Sudanese headed by an official delegation leaving the country for Turkey
» An American institution reveals secret Iranian documents regarding the results of the Iraq war
» Qubad Talabani calls for transforming the current rapprochement with Baghdad into a permanent agreem
» Cabinet Secretariat: Tomorrow, Tuesday, will be an official holiday on the occasion of Nowruz holida
» A historian reveals the intentions of the American invasion of Iraq: the establishment of the “Great
» Parliamentary investment: a number of amendments that will occur in the investment law in the countr
» Warnings of the consequences of neglecting the Chinese agreement on the Iraqi economy
» Because of corruption.. Middle East: Iraq lost 320 billion dollars
» An Iraqi-Jordanian agreement to coordinate the work of the Chambers of Commerce and Industry and to
» Efforts to attract Saudi capital and investors to the Iraqi market
» Political insistence on enacting a "delayed" law 16 years ago - urgent
» Continuous meetings of the investment chief in Saudi Arabia...and agreements on the way to implement
» Iraq sells its oil below the planned price. The deficit increases before the budget sees the light
» After the Council of Ministers' decision... What is the story of the "settlement" with the Korean Ko
» Salaries and entitlements... A bond reveals exciting details about the Kurdistan region's share of t