No Purple Hearts for Fort Hood Victims, Pentagon Says
By NED BERKOWITZ | ABC News – 7 hrs ago
The Department of Defense is making it clear: The military opposes awarding Purple Hearts to the victims of the Fort Hood shooting.
A Pentagon position paper, delivered to congressional staff on Friday and obtained by ABC News, says giving the award to the Fort Hood victims could "irrevocably alter the fundamental character of this time-honored decoration" and "undermine the prosecution of Major Nidal Hasan [the alleged Fort Hood shooter] by materially and directly compromising Major Hasan's ability to receive a fair trial."
DOCUMENT: Pentagon Position on Fort Hood Purple Hearts
The Department prepared the paper in response to legislation introduced by Rep. John Carter, (R.-Texas), the Congressman whose district includes Fort Hood. The Fort Hood Families Benefits Protection Act would award both military and civilian casualties of the Fort Hood attack combatant status.
Carter re-introduced the legislation in February in the wake of an ABC News investigation detailing claims by victims that they have been neglected by the military. In a report that aired on "World News with Diane Sawyer" and "Nightline," former police sergeant Kimberly Munley, who helped stop the Ft. Hood shooting, said she felt "betrayed" by President Obama and that he broke a promise to make sure the victims would be well taken care of.
There has been no comment from the White House about Munley's allegations.
ABC News Investigation: Fort Hood Hero Says President Obama 'Betrayed' Her, Other Victims
Thirteen people were killed, including a pregnant soldier, and 32 others wounded in the Nov. 5, 2009 rampage at the Army base in Killeen, Texas. Hasan now awaits a military trial on charges of premeditated murder and attempted murder. After numerous delays, that trial is now set to begin with jury selection on May 29.
WATCH Exclusive Video of Fort Hood's Aftermath
Despite extensive evidence that Hasan was in communication with al Qaeda leader Anwar al-Awlaki prior to the attack, the military has denied the victims a Purple Heart and has treated the incident as "workplace violence" instead of "combat related" or terrorism. Last month, a spokesman for recently appointed Defense Secretary, Chuck Hagel, told ABC News the Department's position had not changed under his leadership.
In a February statement, Rep. Carter said the Fort Hood Families Benefits Protection Act "would award the military and civilian casualties of the 2009 Fort Hood attack the same status that was awarded to the casualties of the Pentagon attack on Sept. 11, 2001. All of the casualties would be eligible for the Purple Heart Award or the Department of Defense civilian equivalent."
In a new statement to ABC News, Carter said, "After additional investigation into the potential implications of pre-trial publicity, I am postponing any future publicity on these bills at this stage of Maj. Hasan's trial. However, the victims of this tragic shooting fully quality for compensation pay and purple heart recognition."
"The DOD position paper is dead wrong to oppose this legislation," Carter said. "These victims deserve recognition and compensation for the injuries and loss of life from a direct attack on a U.S. military installation."
Carter said his aim was not to undermine Hasan's trial, but said he "will not rest until these victims get the recognition they deserve."
Many of the Fort Hood victims also filed a lawsuit against the military alleging the "workplace violence" designation means that in addition to not receiving Purple Hearts, they are receiving lower priority access to medical care as veterans, and a loss of financial benefits available to those whose injuries are classified as "combat related."
The attorney for the victims, Reed Rubinstein, told ABC News, "It's a slap in the face. Given everything that has occurred over the last three and a half years, this is incomprehensible, and in many respects, not worthy of the army. It's regrettable and tremendously wrongheaded."
The position paper says awarding the victims purple hearts "will be viewed as setting the stage for a formal declaration that Major Hasan is a terrorist," and that, in turn, will allow Defense counsel to "argue that Major Hasan cannot receive a fair trial because a branch of government has indirectly declared that Major Hasan is a terrorist – that he is criminally culpable."
Nevertheless, an expert witness for the prosecution, Evan Kohlmann, has said Hasan meets six factors that indicate someone is a homegrown terrorist. Prosecutors said his testimony would show motive. But defense attorneys have tried to limit Kohlmann's testimony, saying since Hasan isn't charged with terrorism and claiming Kohlmann's testimony would be prejudicial to the military jury.
The position paper also states, "The Government has vigilantly tended to the needs of the victims and their families since the tragic events of November 5, 2009."
Attorney Rubinstein, noting that a majority of the victims have joined the lawsuit alleging precisely the opposite, asked ABC News, "Who are they kidding?"
Army officials declined to comment further for this report, saying they didn't want to jeopardize the case.
Also Read
http://news.yahoo.com/no-purple-hearts-fort-hood-victims-pentagon-says-152503982--abc-news-topstories.html
» Parliamentary Finance reveals the possibilities of approving the salary scale law
» "Despite the protests"...a parliamentary committee rules out an amendment to the election law and qu
» Ramadan revives the shopping movement in the largest commercial center in Iraq (photos)
» Parliamentary Energy Committee: Al-Faw port will include 6 oil export berths with a capacity of 350,
» A government bank warns of fake pages impersonating its name and publishes an official link
» The Ministry of Communications reveals the results of the investigation committee for the appointmen
» With documents.. Khashan presents a proposal on amending the election law
» Bigger than an Emirati.. Revealing new details about the great port of Faw
» Iraq wins an arbitration case against Turkey regarding oil exports from the north of the country
» Sudanese advisor recommends the formation of a Consumer Protection Council to deter price manipulato
» Without a sponsor.. A new statement from the Rafidain Bank regarding the advances of employees and a
» With the participation of Iraq.. Damascus hosts the fourth Arab quartet meeting of ministers of agri
» The Parliamentary Oil and Gas Committee explains the importance of the great port of Faw to the oil
» More than 800 million dollars sales of the Central Bank of Iraq during the past week
» Arar port with Saudi Arabia records a significant decrease in trade exchange
» Disclosure of Iraqi endeavors to export gas to Europe via Turkey during the next year
» Parliamentary Finance: The budget did not reach us, and its deficit is very worrying
» Deputy: Al-Kazemi's government used the Yazidis as a political card for blackmail
» Al-Rafidain: advances of employees and retirees electronically and without a guarantor
» The frame on the Russian report: America's crimes against Iraq are catastrophic.. they will not go u
» Parliamentary Integrity: Al-Halbousi Yousuf presented the “Theft of the Century” report, due to the
» Framework: We will not back down from the investigation of the US nuclear contamination file in Iraq
» The budget law is imprisoned in solitary confinement.. and the accused is the speaker of parliament
» Among them are corruption issues.. A parliamentarian calls for support for the Sudanese reform steps
» The President of the Republic reviews with Guterres the burdens borne by Iraq from the water crisis
» The President of the Republic: All sources of Iraq's rivers lie outside the country, which necessita
» Mahmoud Othman warns via / NINA / against approving the amendment of the election law without agreem
» The Iraqi Turkmen Front calls for the inclusion of Article (35) related to the Kirkuk governorate in
» Al-Araji chairs a meeting with several major multidisciplinary Indian companies
» Al-Rafidain Bank: Electronic advances of employees and retirees without a sponsor
» The Central Bank of Iraq decides to withdraw the license of an Islamic bank for its involvement in t
» Parliamentarian: We are moving towards activating Parliament's decision to achieve sovereignty by ex
» Parliamentary Health: Courtesies and nepotism impede the opening of corruption files in the ministry
» A parliamentary committee reveals Turkey's conditions for returning water releases to Iraq
» “Our covenant and our agreement with the state alliance.” Al-Khanjar calls for the approval of the a
» A politician warns of attempts by Washington and its arms to thwart the railway link project with Tu
» Al-Sudani inaugurates the National Health Factory for the production of sterilization materials and
» Parliamentary Planning: The election law will pass today's session
» Economist: Inflation in Iraq has risen to the highest level in years
» American report: The Kurds have transcended the story of "oppressed" and turned to the stage of "str
» Document .. The Central Bank of Iraq withdraws the license of an Islamic bank and appoints a trustee
» Iraqis make profits from money transfers to Turkey
» The United Nations: joint programs with the Iraqi judiciary to combat corruption
» Electricity is preparing for the "summer peak loads".. Directive to complete rehabilitation work bef
» The Sudanese advisor talks about oil prices and the possibility of distributing salaries in dollars
» “Waiting for the budget.” The President of the Republic: High-level plans to address the water crisi
» Iraqi efforts to export gas to Europe via Turkey next year
» Al-Rafidain: advances of employees and retirees electronically and without a guarantor
» Al-Sudani: The volume of the pharmaceutical market exceeded $3 billion
» Al-Araji chairs a meeting with 10 major multidisciplinary Indian companies
» Mishaan Al-Jubouri: Muhammad Shia Al-Sudani is 100 times better than Saddam
» Deputy: Turkey is bargaining with Iraq over the water file to liquidate the PKK
» An economic center: Iraq recorded, in January 2023, its highest rise in inflation rates in years
» Parliamentary Finance: Associated gas revenues will enter imports for the next two years
» Covering about 600,000 citizens with social protection in 2023
» Procedures for terminating the contract with the executing company of Al-Amriya Residential Complex
» Electricity forms a work cell to complete its projects in Dhi Qar
» Kurdistan evaluates more than three decades of federalism
» Najaf sets its summer plan exclusively for the crop of rice
» Experts call for a comprehensive strategic agreement with Turkey
» Federation of Industries: Iraq issues (60) articles for all countries of the world
» Desertification threatens the agricultural reality and portends great economic losses
» Al-Yakti supports an American report on the "collapse of the Kurdish house of cards"
» “The Kurds reject it.” The Turkmens renew their demand for the inclusion of Article (35) in the elec
» Al-Sudani: The opening of the national factory is a message to localize the pharmaceutical industry
» Sources: Turkey prevents the region's oil exports through the port of Ceyhan without Baghdad's appro
» A slight rise in the exchange rates of the dollar in the local markets
» Shaswar Abdul Wahed to “Jarida”: Mafias rule Erbil and Sulaymaniyah, and the future of Kurdistan is
» Three newly-made aircraft joined the Iraqi Airways fleet
» Soon.. the electronic passport in four governorates
» The Iraqi Media Authority directs to stop the series "offending" tribal sheikhs in southern Iraq
» "St. Lego" closes the green gates in central Baghdad
» An economic institution indicates a rise in the inflation rate, which is the "highest" in Iraq in ye
» The Khalisi reference confirms that the political process in Iraq is clinically dead, but the hypocr
» The Ministry of Industry and Minerals organizes a training workshop on franchise licensing
» To support the electricity sector … Ur State Company continues to supply central electricity with el
» The Ministry of Oil sets a date for circulating the electronic payment system at gas stations
» The President of the Republic receives the Turkish Minister of Agriculture and Forestry
» Ministry of Education: The decision to reduce working hours does not include school attendance
» The Border Ports Authority clarifies its procedures against smugglers of alcoholic beverages to Iraq
» Al-Araji is looking with major Indian companies to revitalize the Iraqi industry
» The President of the Republic discusses with the Secretary-General of the United Nations the global
» Closing one of the entrances to the Green Zone in central Baghdad for this reason
» For employees and retirees... Good news from Al-Rafidain Bank regarding advances
» Oil prices continue to decline, the largest decline in months
» Al-Sudani opens the National Health Factory for the production of medical supplies
» Al-Sudani on the occasion of the opening of the medical factory: a message from the government to lo
» Basra.. Poverty floats above the sea of oil and the population suffers from deprivation.. Figures
» India is ready to open joint lines with Iraq in the field of various industries
» What did the US State Department annual report say about the crowd and the Peshmerga?
» An American magazine presents proposals to restore Iraq from the grip of Iran after America lost the
» Economist: Inflation in Iraq has risen to the highest level in years
» A government advisor expects the stability of commodity prices to return with the distribution of fo
» Goldilocks, MilitiaMan , Nader and more....Thursday Afternoon 3-23-2023
» 03/22/2023- MilitiaMan and Crew THE NEXT PHASE - PRIVATE SECTOR - ECONOMIC REFORMS
» The popular movement for the Silk Road brings together the elites of 11 provinces and affirms: Ameri
» Al-Hakim: The new election law encourages the merger of the big powers with the small ones
» Economist: Working power stations in the simple cycle is a waste of money