Sanders' supporters are lashing out, but here's how they might be hurting his campaign
Evan Halper and Matt Pearce[email=evan.halper@latimes.com,matt.pearce@latimes.com?subject=Regarding:%20%22Sanders%27%20supporters%20are%20lashing%20out,%20but%20here%27s%20how%20they%20might%20be%20hurting%20his%20campaign%22]Contact Reporters[/email]
Shawn Bagley thought he knew what he was getting into when he was elected to become one of California’s so-called superdelegates to the Democratic National Convention, and energetic debate with other activists was part of it.
What Bagley had not anticipated was being jolted out of bed by a 2 a.m. phone call from an angry Bernie Sanders supporter. The caller accused Bagley, a retired produce broker from Salinas, of stealing democracy from the citizenry.
“Why is Bernie Sanders letting these people loose on us?” said Bagley, a Hillary Clinton backer who says he was branded corrupt, immoral and thickheaded over the course of some 200 social media posts and phone calls from Sanders fans. “He lost my vote at 2 a.m.”
Sanders supporters are known to be a spirited bunch. But as their frustration mounts over their candidate’s failure to significantly cut into Clinton’s lead, no small number of them are lashing out in ways that are not particularly helpful to his campaign.
There is the activist in Chicago who unleashed a movement to “harass” superdelegates backing Clinton, with an online “hit list” complete with delegate phone numbers and some home addresses. There are the online trolls who have come to be known as "Bernie bros," who attack journalists, politicians and fellow voters they perceive to be pro-Clinton with misogynistic, often vulgar attacks. There are the campaign surrogates -- some of them high-profile -- who use language the campaign finds itself having to walk back.
On Thursday, Sanders apologized for comments made by Paul Song, chairman of the progressive California group Courage Campaign, during Sanders’ huge rally the night before in New York’s Washington Square Park. Song railed against “corporate Democratic whores,” saying the party establishment was beholden to the pharmaceutical industry. The Clinton campaign demanded Sanders disavow Song’s words, which it did. Song himself also apologized, saying the comment was not directed at Clinton.
The hostility from some Sanders backers reflects a very different tone than what supporters projected a year ago at Sanders’ first large rally in Vermont, a lakeside park affair that resembled a peace festival. It comes as Sanders, the underdog candidate who trails in the delegate count despite a string of electoral wins in recent weeks, has stepped up his attacks on a political system he says is rigged for Clinton and a corporate media he says wants him to lose.
His increasingly hostile tone can be a combustible mix with a group of supporters who, in many cases, are new to the mechanics of party politics, delegate lobbying and campaign messaging. As a campaign so heavily focused online, it is especially vulnerable to the Internet’s darker impulses.
“People on the Internet can be jerks,” said Neil Sroka, spokesman for Democracy for America, a large grass-roots advocacy group supporting Sanders. “I don’t think that is news to anyone who has spent time reading comment sections in the average newspaper. When you have a strong online presence, you are going to have all the good and the bad that comes with it.”
Sroka says the Sanders campaign is hardly condoning the behavior, pointing to occasions where staffers and the candidate himself have scolded supporters for inappropriate remarks.
But others complain the campaign too often looks the other way, particularly in the case of antagonism toward the superdelegates who have pledged to support Clinton at the convention in Philadelphia in July.
“These people are worried someone is going to come to their house,” said Bob Mulholland, a Democratic political operative in California who supports Clinton and recently wrote an open letter to the Sanders campaign accusing it of fanning the flames of harassment. “They have been put on a ‘hit list.’”
Mulholland is talking about a database of superdelegates published online by activist Spencer Thayer, who originally called it the “Superdelegate Hitlist” and included a graphic of a donkey in cross hairs. Thayer has since toned it down, changing his site’s name to “Superdelegate List.”
But he makes no apologies for collecting and publishing the personal information of the delegates, many of whom are just regular people like Bagley. It’s uncharted territory for Democrats. The last time the votes of superdelegates mattered in a convention was in 1980, and the technology did not exist to quickly find and broadcast the personal information of these delegates to anyone who might begrudge them.
Some Sanders supporters point out, however, that activists sympathetic to Clinton tested the waters for a similar, unsanctioned superdelegate lobbying effort on her behalf in 2008.
Even so, the Sanders campaign has struggled for months with loutish behavior online that extends beyond a few jerks. Most any woman who “has said anything critical about Bernie or positive about Hillary” on social media has been subject to Bernie bro harassment, said Laura Olin, who advised the 2012 Obama campaign on social media.
A frequent target is Joan Walsh, a national affairs correspondent for the Nation, who is supporting Clinton for president, though the magazine has endorsed Sanders. “They never stop, and you wind up on Twitter trying to convince a BernieBro that BernieBros exist -- and even as he's being Exhibit A, he's calling you a whore, $hill, sellout and on and on,” she said in a direct message on Twitter.
Jill Filipovic, a freelance journalist and attorney who often writes positively about Sanders, said that when she criticizes him, she is subjected to “a mass dogpiling” of tweets “sort of treating you like you’re a dumb girl.… The degree to which any criticism of this candidate is met with this complete brick wall of rage -- it’s like criticizing Jesus,” she said. “It’s truly bizarre.”
She gets attacked by Clinton supporters, too, but not on the same scale, she said. “I do think it’s gotten worse as the campaign has gotten more heated,” Filipovic said.
Most of the sexist slurs directed at Clinton on social media -- such as “hag,” “shrill,” and other words too crude to print -- have come from Donald Trump supporters, according to a study by a pair of Dutch researchers published in the Washington Post in February. But 14.7% of those slurs came from Sanders supporters, and mostly from men, according to the study.
Some women who support Sanders, though, say they’ve endured boorish behavior from supporters of all the presidential campaigns. They also say the term “Bernie bro” itself diminishes the legions of feminists working for Sanders, who they argue has the best agenda for women.
The term, said Sarah Leonard, a senior editor at the Nation, “implies the more progressive candidate draws his support mainly from men, and therefore his presence in the race is the force of misogyny.”
Like other Sanders supporters, Leonard bristles at all the hostile behavior that has emerged. But she says she sees where it is coming from: The stakes are high for the left, with the candidate vying to be the first female president running against the candidate vying to be the first socialist president.
It “makes people on the left very protective of Bernie Sanders,” Leonard said, “and they can be overly aggressive.”
http://www.latimes.com/nation/politics/la-na-bernie-sanders-supporters-20160415-story.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+topoftheticket+%28Top+of+the+Ticket%29
Evan Halper and Matt Pearce[email=evan.halper@latimes.com,matt.pearce@latimes.com?subject=Regarding:%20%22Sanders%27%20supporters%20are%20lashing%20out,%20but%20here%27s%20how%20they%20might%20be%20hurting%20his%20campaign%22]Contact Reporters[/email]
Shawn Bagley thought he knew what he was getting into when he was elected to become one of California’s so-called superdelegates to the Democratic National Convention, and energetic debate with other activists was part of it.
What Bagley had not anticipated was being jolted out of bed by a 2 a.m. phone call from an angry Bernie Sanders supporter. The caller accused Bagley, a retired produce broker from Salinas, of stealing democracy from the citizenry.
“Why is Bernie Sanders letting these people loose on us?” said Bagley, a Hillary Clinton backer who says he was branded corrupt, immoral and thickheaded over the course of some 200 social media posts and phone calls from Sanders fans. “He lost my vote at 2 a.m.”
Sanders supporters are known to be a spirited bunch. But as their frustration mounts over their candidate’s failure to significantly cut into Clinton’s lead, no small number of them are lashing out in ways that are not particularly helpful to his campaign.
There is the activist in Chicago who unleashed a movement to “harass” superdelegates backing Clinton, with an online “hit list” complete with delegate phone numbers and some home addresses. There are the online trolls who have come to be known as "Bernie bros," who attack journalists, politicians and fellow voters they perceive to be pro-Clinton with misogynistic, often vulgar attacks. There are the campaign surrogates -- some of them high-profile -- who use language the campaign finds itself having to walk back.
On Thursday, Sanders apologized for comments made by Paul Song, chairman of the progressive California group Courage Campaign, during Sanders’ huge rally the night before in New York’s Washington Square Park. Song railed against “corporate Democratic whores,” saying the party establishment was beholden to the pharmaceutical industry. The Clinton campaign demanded Sanders disavow Song’s words, which it did. Song himself also apologized, saying the comment was not directed at Clinton.
The hostility from some Sanders backers reflects a very different tone than what supporters projected a year ago at Sanders’ first large rally in Vermont, a lakeside park affair that resembled a peace festival. It comes as Sanders, the underdog candidate who trails in the delegate count despite a string of electoral wins in recent weeks, has stepped up his attacks on a political system he says is rigged for Clinton and a corporate media he says wants him to lose.
His increasingly hostile tone can be a combustible mix with a group of supporters who, in many cases, are new to the mechanics of party politics, delegate lobbying and campaign messaging. As a campaign so heavily focused online, it is especially vulnerable to the Internet’s darker impulses.
“People on the Internet can be jerks,” said Neil Sroka, spokesman for Democracy for America, a large grass-roots advocacy group supporting Sanders. “I don’t think that is news to anyone who has spent time reading comment sections in the average newspaper. When you have a strong online presence, you are going to have all the good and the bad that comes with it.”
Sroka says the Sanders campaign is hardly condoning the behavior, pointing to occasions where staffers and the candidate himself have scolded supporters for inappropriate remarks.
But others complain the campaign too often looks the other way, particularly in the case of antagonism toward the superdelegates who have pledged to support Clinton at the convention in Philadelphia in July.
“These people are worried someone is going to come to their house,” said Bob Mulholland, a Democratic political operative in California who supports Clinton and recently wrote an open letter to the Sanders campaign accusing it of fanning the flames of harassment. “They have been put on a ‘hit list.’”
Mulholland is talking about a database of superdelegates published online by activist Spencer Thayer, who originally called it the “Superdelegate Hitlist” and included a graphic of a donkey in cross hairs. Thayer has since toned it down, changing his site’s name to “Superdelegate List.”
But he makes no apologies for collecting and publishing the personal information of the delegates, many of whom are just regular people like Bagley. It’s uncharted territory for Democrats. The last time the votes of superdelegates mattered in a convention was in 1980, and the technology did not exist to quickly find and broadcast the personal information of these delegates to anyone who might begrudge them.
Some Sanders supporters point out, however, that activists sympathetic to Clinton tested the waters for a similar, unsanctioned superdelegate lobbying effort on her behalf in 2008.
Even so, the Sanders campaign has struggled for months with loutish behavior online that extends beyond a few jerks. Most any woman who “has said anything critical about Bernie or positive about Hillary” on social media has been subject to Bernie bro harassment, said Laura Olin, who advised the 2012 Obama campaign on social media.
A frequent target is Joan Walsh, a national affairs correspondent for the Nation, who is supporting Clinton for president, though the magazine has endorsed Sanders. “They never stop, and you wind up on Twitter trying to convince a BernieBro that BernieBros exist -- and even as he's being Exhibit A, he's calling you a whore, $hill, sellout and on and on,” she said in a direct message on Twitter.
Jill Filipovic, a freelance journalist and attorney who often writes positively about Sanders, said that when she criticizes him, she is subjected to “a mass dogpiling” of tweets “sort of treating you like you’re a dumb girl.… The degree to which any criticism of this candidate is met with this complete brick wall of rage -- it’s like criticizing Jesus,” she said. “It’s truly bizarre.”
She gets attacked by Clinton supporters, too, but not on the same scale, she said. “I do think it’s gotten worse as the campaign has gotten more heated,” Filipovic said.
Most of the sexist slurs directed at Clinton on social media -- such as “hag,” “shrill,” and other words too crude to print -- have come from Donald Trump supporters, according to a study by a pair of Dutch researchers published in the Washington Post in February. But 14.7% of those slurs came from Sanders supporters, and mostly from men, according to the study.
Some women who support Sanders, though, say they’ve endured boorish behavior from supporters of all the presidential campaigns. They also say the term “Bernie bro” itself diminishes the legions of feminists working for Sanders, who they argue has the best agenda for women.
The term, said Sarah Leonard, a senior editor at the Nation, “implies the more progressive candidate draws his support mainly from men, and therefore his presence in the race is the force of misogyny.”
Like other Sanders supporters, Leonard bristles at all the hostile behavior that has emerged. But she says she sees where it is coming from: The stakes are high for the left, with the candidate vying to be the first female president running against the candidate vying to be the first socialist president.
It “makes people on the left very protective of Bernie Sanders,” Leonard said, “and they can be overly aggressive.”
http://www.latimes.com/nation/politics/la-na-bernie-sanders-supporters-20160415-story.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+topoftheticket+%28Top+of+the+Ticket%29
» After the decision of the Paris Court.. Baghdad and Erbil are looking for new mechanisms to export K
» Deputy for the coordination framework: The Presidency of Parliament did not include the budget on th
» Parliament is discussing with the World Bank the financing of projects and the shift towards the ele
» The World Bank confirms its full commitment to provide support and assistance to automate public fin
» Parliamentary condemnation of the series “London Batch” and a call to the Kuwaiti embassy to stop it
» The central bank withdraws a bank leave and three exchange companies
» Trade signs an agreement with the World Food Program to automate the ration card
» The Baghdad loan melts in the mouth of Erbil.. The suffering of the Kurds continues, and the ruling
» Parliamentarians Are Concerned About The 'Chaos' Of Market Prices... A Call To The Council Of Minist
» The Parliamentary Finance Committee Hosts The World Bank Delegation And Discusses With It A Package
» Al-Olayawi Talks About The Tourism File In Iraq: We Need Large Financial Allocations
» The Minister of Oil is discussing with the region's delegation the decision of the International Arb
» The Minister of Oil chairs a meeting with the region's delegation after the decision of the Internat
» Parliament: The region should be subject to the federal government to manage oil
» Maliki's coalition is likely to pass the election law in today's session
» The Presidency of the Region: If there is a halt to the export of Kurdistan's oil, it will resume ag
» Iraq and the World Food Program sign an agreement for the electronic ration card project
» It generates 500 million dinars per day.. Imposing the law stops 3 types of black trade in Diyala
» Repercussions of the international arbitration decision.. Alekti is resentful: Do not send delegatio
» (Baghdad Today) is unique in publishing the latest version of the House of Representatives and Local
» Electricity declares a state of alert
» urgentDetermining the date of the elections for the Parliament of the Kurdistan region
» The Council of Ministers votes to create 196 job degrees in the Ministry of Construction and Housing
» The Parliamentary Marshlands demand the formation of a fixed council that preserves Iraq's water rig
» Parliamentary law reveals the main reason for postponing the election law 3 times
» Parliamentary Finance is discussing with the World Bank the submission of a full budget and its fina
» The budget and final accounts are on the table of the World Bank in Parliament
» Integrity: Weakness of the Aviation Authority's procedures by collecting accumulated debts amounting
» With revenues amounting to 7.6 billion dollars.. Oil announces the final statistics of February expo
» Parliament discusses with the World Bank the financing of projects and the transition towards the el
» Parliamentary Finance: The budget did not reach us, and its deficit is very worrying
» A delegation from the region is visiting Baghdad today for two important reasons
» The Arab League determines the place and time of its next summit
» Al-Abadi: The violations of the US army in Iraq are massive and were the root of the problems
» Parliamentary bloc renews its accusation against Al-Halbousi of muzzling mouths
» Sudanese advisor: The constitutional amendment is much more important than passing the election law
» The turmoil in the global oil market confuses the calculations of the "triple budget"
» Integrity calls for the development of airports and the treatment of stalled and lagging projects
» Parliamentary demands to grant allocations to deal with salinity and water scarcity in Basra
» The Iraqi ambassador in Ankara: Al-Sudanese visit to Turkey paved the way for strategic agreements b
» Ihsan Al-Shammari to / NINA /: Approval of the election law .. will deepen the political crisis and
» Deputy for / NINA /: Iraq lost more than 20 billion dollars due to the delay in signing the fifth li
» Nabil Al Marsoumi to / Nina /: The three-year budget... will be economically weak and of no value
» The Industrial Estates Authority is discussing with Wasit Governorate the completion of the procedur
» Framework: We will not back down from the investigation of the US nuclear contamination file in Iraq
» Disclosure of the agendas of the Kurdistan delegation's visit to Baghdad
» Al-Sudani to the French President: Iraq is continuing to establish effective economic relations
» With the participation of Iraq, a quartet meeting will discuss in Damascus tomorrow the promotion of
» Member of Parliamentary Finance: There is a possibility to pass a law amending the salary scale
» Through the "Tamkeen" initiative... Baghdad is on a date with a "major campaign" to revive heritage
» Kurdistan government: The decision of the French court will not hinder our relations with Baghdad
» Parliamentary movement to reduce the allocations of ministries in the budget
» Planning: Iraq maintains the pace of population increase
» North Refineries adds two refining units to Haditha refinery
» Parliamentary energy: Iraq suffers from a production gap of about 11,000 megawatts, which must be pr
» After the international resolution... What is the secret of Erbil's silence and its "oil" submission
» An economist expects the dry canal's revenues to reach $100 billion annually
» Transport clarifies the details of the development road project and announces the approval of its pr
» Al-Darraji: The government's measures stopped the exchange rate's plan to reach 200,000 dinars
» The first response from Barzani after the decision to stop production from the region to Turkey
» Details of the Sudanese meeting with the British ambassador
» Parliament is looking for resources to bridge the budget deficit of 64 trillion dinars
» Human rights recommend monitoring the promotion of drugs on social media
» The President of the Republic and the Secretary-General of the United Nations discuss the phenomenon
» Experts call for a comprehensive strategic agreement with Turkey
» An Iraqi technical delegation to Turkey next month to discuss the water file
» Parliamentary efforts to include a budget for social welfare
» Plans to use waste to generate electricity
» The Iraqi "Dry Canal" is a path of gold
» Planning: Iraq maintains the pace of population increase
» An international network: The French court ordered Turkey to pay 1.4 billion dollars in "fines" to I
» A parliamentary bloc demands a refund of the revenues from the sale of the region's oil to Turkey
» Source: Continuing negotiations without an agreement impede the convening of the "St. Lego" session
» Erbil is moving towards Baghdad following the decision to stop oil exports to activate this file
» 5 months after its distribution.. 70% of the population of Kurdistan have not yet received the white
» An economist reveals the size of compensation as a result of international arbitration between Iraq
» Barti: The French court's decision is "old" and will not change anything
» More than half.. the decline in Iraq's oil exports to America
» The Central Bank of Iraq decides to withdraw the license of an Islamic bank for its involvement in t
» Central bank sales of dollars reach more than 200 million
» A significant decrease in the exchange rates of the dollar in the Baghdad markets
» The decline in gold prices in the markets of Baghdad and its stability in the markets of Erbil
» The Turkish Statistical Authority … the Iraqis’ desire to buy homes in Turkey has declined since the
» The Central Bank of Iraq announces the withdrawal of the license of a mediation company for the sale
» Representative Ali Shaddad links the development of the urban and economic realities in Iraq to the
» Four experts on the Iraq war and its repercussions now: Democracy has shrunk and parties exclude cit
» American report: Oil waste exacerbates cancerous diseases in Basra
» Representatives of Nineveh: The factions prevent the return of 75% of the residents of Sinjar
» Parliamentary meeting on rising prices
» Representatives: The real budget deficit will decrease to 40 trillion dinars
» Al-Sadr disturbs the joy of the Shiite alliance with St. Lego
» The Ministry of Oil sets a date for circulating the electronic payment system at gas stations in Bag
» From the port of Al-Faw to Turkey.. Transport details the development road project and confirms the
» Al-Sudani receives the delegation of our youth team and directs to honor the players
» Al-Sudani confirms that Iraq will continue to establish effective economic relations
» Al-Sudani and the British ambassador are discussing ways to enhance bilateral cooperation between th
» The regional government affirms its firm position not to give up the constitutional rights of the Ku
» Barzani comments on the arbitration court's decision and announces the visit of a Kurdish delegation