What Will You Do When The Lights Go Out? The Inevitable Failure Of The US Grid - better read, during the windstorm last November, we had no electric power for 3/4 days - never been so cold in my life
By Julianne Geiger - Aug 12, 2016, 5:27 PM CDT
Delta Airlines recently experienced what it called a power outage in its home base of Atlanta, Georgia, causing all the company’s computers to go offline—all of them. This seemingly minor hiccup managed to singlehandedly ground all Delta planes for six hours, stranding passengers for even longer, as Delta scrambled to reshuffle passengers after the Monday debacle.
Where Delta blamed its catastrophic systems-wide computer failure vaguely on a loss of power, Georgia Power, their power provider, placed the ball squarely in Delta’s court, saying that “other Georgia Power customers were not affected”, and that they had staff on site to assist Delta.
Whether it was a true power outage, or an outage unique to Delta is fairly insignificant. The incident was a single company without power for six measly hours, yet it wreaked much havoc. Which brings to mind (or at least it should) what happens when the lights really go out—everywhere? And just how dependent is the U.S. on single-source power?
When you hear about the possible insufficiency, unreliability, or lack of resiliency of the U.S. power grid, your mind might naturally move toward the extreme, perhaps National Geographic’s Doomsday Preppers. Talks about what a U.S. power grid failure could really mean are also often likened to survivalist blogs that speak of building faraday cages and hoarding food, or possibly some riveting blockbuster movie about a well-intentioned government-sponsored genetically altered mosquito that leads to some zombie apocalypse.
But in the event of a power grid failure—and we have more than our fair share here in the U.S.—your survivalist savvy may be all for naught.
This horror story doesn’t need zombies or genetically altered mosquitos in order to be scary. Using data from the United States Department of Energy, the International Business Times reported in 2014 that the United States suffers more blackouts than any other developed country in the world.
Unfortunately, not much has been done since then to alleviate the system’s critical vulnerabilities.
In theory, we all understand the wisdom about not putting all our eggs in one basket, as the old-adage goes. Yet the U.S. has done just that with our U.S. power grid. Sadly, this infrastructure is failing, and compared to many other countries, the U.S. is sauntering slowly behind many other more conscientious countries, seemingly unconcerned with its poor showing.
The Grid, by Geography and Geopolitics
According to the United States Department of Energy, the American power grid is made up of three smaller grids, known as interconnections, which transport energy all over the country. The Eastern Interconnection provides electricity to states to the east of the Rocky Mountains, while the Western interconnection serves the Rocky Mountain states and those that border the Pacific Ocean.
The Texas Interconnected System is the smallest grid in the nation, and serves most of Texas, although small portions of the Lone Star state benefit from the other two grids.
And if you’re wondering why Texas gets a grid of its own, according to the Texas Tribune they have their own grid “to avoid dealing with the feds.” Now that’s true survivalist savvy—in theory.
When you look at the layout of the grid above, it’s easy to see that a single grid going offline would disrupt a huge segment of North America.
Wait—make that all of North America.
To give it to you straight, our national electrical grid works as an interdependent network. This means that the failure of any one part would trigger the borrowing of energy from other areas. Whichever grid attempts to carry the extra load would likely be overtaxed, as the grid is already taxed to near max levels during peak hot or cold seasons.
The aftermath of a single grid going down could leave millions of residents without power for days, weeks or longer depending on the scope of the failure.
So although on the surface it looks like the U.S. has wisely put its eggs into three separate baskets for safer keeping, the U.S. has in essence, lined up our baskets so that if one were to drop, or if the bottom were to fall out, the eggs from basket #1 would fall into basket #2. Which would break from the load, falling into basket #3—eventually scrambling all the eggs. Sorry, Texas. Related: Is Saudi Arabia About To Cry Uncle In The Oil Price War?
When multiple parts of the grid fail at the same time, it’s not necessarily more catastrophic—the catastrophe just happens more quickly.
According to Jon Wellinghoff, chairman of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, in an interview with USA Today, "You have a very vulnerable system that will continue to be vulnerable until we figure out a way to break it out into more distributed systems."
The Grid, by the Numbers
Let’s look at the math behind the power grid, and what the U.S. is doing to improve it.
1. Through the Recovery Act, the DOE invested about $4.5 billion in the power grid since 2010 to modernize it and “increase its reliability”. $4.5 billion seems like a fairly large number, unless you’re talking about a single machine that serves as the lifeblood to nearly every human in North America—a machine that was conceived in 1882 by Thomas Edison—with little changed since then, conceptually speaking. For people who reside in weather-challenged areas, such as my home state of Michigan, a home generator is almost as necessary of an appliance as a microwave, and people are scrambling to go “off-grid” with alternative energy solutions—an act that will not provide them immunity should the lights go out everywhere else. And for what it’s worth, for those of you sporting solar and wind energy, you’re further taxing the grid—the grid just wasn’t designed to accommodate the surges and lulls of such systems, however green you find them.
2. Power outages—just the ones due to severe weather—cost the U.S. economy between $18 and $33 billion annually in spoiled inventory, delayed production, grid damage, lost wages and output. Despite a few billion dollars being thrown at the grid to improve its resiliency or reliability, the number of outages due to weather is expected to increase, assuming that climate change will indeed intensify extreme weather, as some predict.
3. The total annual cost from power outages, per federal data published in The Smart Grid: An Introduction, is a whopping $150 billion.
4. As of 2014, the DOE had generously spent $100 million (million, not billion) into modernizing the grid for the specific purposes of surviving a cyber incident by maintaining critical functions. This would be measures separate from making the grid more reliable.
5. The American Society of Civil Engineers gave the electrical grid a grade of D+ in early 2014 after evaluating the grid for security and other vulnerabilities.
6. The average age of large power transformers (LPTs) in the US is [url=http://energy.gov/sites/prod/files/Large Power Transformer Study - June 2012_0.pdf]40 years[/url], with 70 percent of all large power transformers being 25 years or older. According to the DOE, “aging power transformers are subject to increased risk of failure.”
7. LPTs cannot be easily replaced. They are custom built, have long lead times (even 20 months, in some cases), cost millions of dollars, are usually purchased from foreign entities due to limited U.S. capacity, and weigh up to 400 tons. All this means that patching and fixing is likely to be favored over replacement, despite their age and associated risk.
Working with those figures, most of which are provided by federal sources, this means the U.S. invested, from 2010 to 2014, $4.5 billion to modernize the grid, along with an additional $100 million to stave off cyber threats. That’s $4.6 billion over four years, or $1.15 billion per year in upgrades. Next to the $150 billion lost each year due to outages, it looks like someone has done some subpar calculating.
The security of the power grid, which is a separate issue from the reliability of the power grid, is a whole other issue that concerns itself with hypothetical one-off scenarios—albeit terrible one-off scenarios. But at least there’s a chance that those one-off scenarios, such as a cyber-attack on the grid or some terrorist activity, would not come to fruition. A chance, at least.
What we are certain of, is that severe weather will continue to stress and threaten our power grid. And unless something changes, ultimately, it will fail. So when we talk about reliability, we’re talking about “when” and “for how long” scenarios, not “what if”.
The how-long factor plays a huge role into how bad is “bad”; not because of the events that one knows will follow, which includes mass food spoilage, deaths due to overheating in the hot summer months, deaths due to freezing in the cold regions, and the halting of everything we take for granted these days—airlines, internet and most other forms of communication.
All that sounds pretty bleak, but when you throw into the mix the mania and hysteria that would ensue shortly after such catastrophic events, it will be so much worse. Best-selling author Charles Mackay, in his book Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, does a pretty good job describing, through example, how crowd decisions and reactions are significantly less sensible than individual decisions—sometimes downright nutty, as evidenced by Tulip Mania, where supply and demand—or in this case scarcity and demand, drove up the prices of tulip bulbs to ridiculous levels.
In the context of blackouts, we saw this in 1977, when a lightning strike in New York on a Hudson River substation tripped two circuit breakers, causing power to be diverted in order to protect the circuit. The chain of events that followed ended in an entire blackout for the area, which led to mass rioting, over 1000 deliberately set fires, the looting of 1600 stores, and the eventual arrest of 4,500 perpetrators and the injury of 550 officers, according to some estimates. The power was only out for 25 hours, and in one area.
In all likelihood, the haves (those who have removed themselves from the grid and prepared accordingly) will soon be overrun by the have-nots in the event of any extended blackout, with heavily populated areas taking the brunt of the chaos—and your solar roof panels or generator will not suffice as your savior.
The U.S. would be wise to follow the lead of some other countries, such as Denmark, which has decentralized its grid, but we doubt the cash exists to fund such an ambitious overhaul of an archaic system that has been left essentially unattended for decades upon decades.
(Click to enlarge)
By Julianne Geiger for Oilprice.com
Yesterday at 12:49 pm by Diamond
» Judy, MilitiaMan, Walkingstick and more......Wednesday AM 3-29-2023
Yesterday at 10:40 am by rocky
» The Turkish Energy Minister denies fining his country $1.4 billion in the case of exporting Kurdista
Yesterday at 7:54 am by rocky
» Integrity: the arrest of a wanted former trade official after his return from outside Iraq
Yesterday at 7:53 am by rocky
» Report: Paving the Silk Road passes through pumping more Chinese loans to transit countries
Yesterday at 7:51 am by rocky
» The Finance Committee breaks its silence: Al-Halbousi is alone discussing the budget in his private
Yesterday at 7:46 am by rocky
» What is the benefit of the return of Iranian-Saudi relations to Iraq? Parliament answers
Yesterday at 7:45 am by rocky
» Ports: 3 Travelers Were Arrested In Possession Of 522 Master Card Cards Intended For Smuggling
Yesterday at 7:42 am by rocky
» Seizing A Factory For Industrial Fraud And Counterfeiting Trademarks, And Arresting Its Owner In Bag
Yesterday at 7:41 am by rocky
» Iraq and Romania are discussing a mechanism for mutual coordination to support expertise between the
Yesterday at 7:39 am by rocky
» The Agricultural Bank launches car purchase advances
Yesterday at 7:37 am by rocky
» Al-Sudani calls for solving citizens' problems without waiting for the Prime Minister's directives
Yesterday at 7:34 am by rocky
» Parliamentary Work: We have obligated local and foreign companies to employ the Iraqi workforce and
Yesterday at 7:32 am by rocky
» Iraq Ports Company: The completion rate of the Al-Faw Grand Port project has reached more than 44.5%
Yesterday at 7:30 am by rocky
» The head of the Service Council mortgages the launch of appointments to two issues and talks about t
Yesterday at 7:29 am by rocky
» The Iraq Stock Exchange ends the day's trading, down 0.49%
Yesterday at 7:28 am by rocky
» The arrest of a former official in the Ministry of Commerce after his return from abroad
Yesterday at 7:27 am by rocky
» “Al-Kazemi incites Washington by inciting against Al-Sudani.” An American network warns the former p
Yesterday at 7:24 am by rocky
» Deputy likely date of inclusion of the draft budget law on the agenda of Parliament
Yesterday at 7:20 am by rocky
» The Central Bank of Iraq announces the imminent issuance of a decision regarding the possibility of
Yesterday at 7:19 am by rocky
» Rashid: The United Nations has shown interest in helping Iraq solve water problems
Yesterday at 7:17 am by rocky
» Exposing corruption and waste of public money worth 123 billion dinars in Basra (documents)
Yesterday at 7:16 am by rocky
» After abolishing it years ago.. Restoring the provincial councils for the benefit or for the interes
Yesterday at 5:44 am by rocky
» With rising prices, drought and lack of subsidies threaten the livestock market in Iraq
Yesterday at 5:42 am by rocky
» The Iraqi Central Bank wants to issue a denomination of 20,000 dinars: we will issue a decision to p
Yesterday at 5:41 am by rocky
» International trade obliges Iraq to pay compensation to Ankara in the arbitration case
Yesterday at 5:39 am by rocky
» Declining Central Bank of Iraq sales of dollars
Yesterday at 5:38 am by rocky
» An Iraqi bank launches car purchase advances
Yesterday at 5:37 am by rocky
» International Trade orders Iraq to pay compensation to Ankara in the arbitration case
Yesterday at 5:34 am by rocky
» Experts: Growing crude sales to China reflect positively on the economy
Yesterday at 5:33 am by rocky
» Integrity monitors 5,000 lagging projects worth $20 billion over 5 years
Yesterday at 5:32 am by rocky
» The maximum limit is 150 million.. An Iraqi company determines deposit compensation rates
Yesterday at 5:30 am by rocky
» DNO begins closing oil fields in Kurdistan
Yesterday at 5:29 am by rocky
» New talk from the Central Bank regarding the exchange rate and the possibility of printing a denomin
Yesterday at 5:28 am by rocky
» Minister of Labor We await approval of the budget to include 600,000 families with social protection
Yesterday at 5:27 am by rocky
» Al-Sudani calls for expediting registration for health insurance: services at subsidized prices
Yesterday at 5:26 am by rocky
» Investors Association: Foreign investors are now selling their shares from Iraqi companies
Yesterday at 5:25 am by rocky
» Baghdad and Muscat are finalizing the memorandum of understanding in the field of combating corrupti
Yesterday at 5:24 am by rocky
» Parliament hosts the representative of the International Monetary Fund
Yesterday at 5:22 am by rocky
» Parliamentary Oil confirms its intention to dismiss a number of officials of the Iraqi Oil Marketing
Yesterday at 5:21 am by rocky
» The Iraqi charge d'affaires in Manama (tickles) the King of Bahrain, and its government officially p
Yesterday at 5:20 am by rocky
» Al-Rafidain launches a new meal from the predecessors of employees and associates electronically
Yesterday at 5:18 am by rocky
» The start of the tasks of the government services team in Baghdad
Yesterday at 5:16 am by rocky
» Amending the election law raises controversy
Yesterday at 5:15 am by rocky
» Parliamentary Committee: Basra Oil incurred 10 billion dinars as delay fines
Yesterday at 5:13 am by rocky
» Lawmakers: The three-year budget cuts the path of corruption
Yesterday at 5:12 am by rocky
» Kurdistan parties do not agree on an electoral system
Yesterday at 5:11 am by rocky
» The central bank records the highest cash reserve in its history
Yesterday at 5:09 am by rocky
» Kurdistan loses its most prominent supporters.. Washington is "angry" with its Kurdish allies, and t
Yesterday at 5:05 am by rocky
» The Sudanese registers in the health insurance electronic form
Yesterday at 5:02 am by rocky
» With a value of 123 billion dinars.. Parliamentary integrity reveals corruption and waste of public
Yesterday at 5:01 am by rocky
» With fears of disruption to Kurdistan's supplies, oil is approaching $79 a barrel
Yesterday at 4:59 am by rocky
» The President of the Republic stresses the need to support the oil industry
Yesterday at 4:57 am by rocky
» Oil: directives to expedite the investment of 200 cubic meters per day of associated gas in Dhi Qar
Yesterday at 4:56 am by rocky
» A Norwegian oil company closes wells and withdraws from the Kurdistan region
Yesterday at 4:55 am by rocky
» Dollar prices recorded a noticeable decline in Baghdad markets
Yesterday at 4:54 am by rocky
» The Iraqi Central Bank’s sales of dollars reach more than 200 million
Yesterday at 4:53 am by rocky
» In numbers.. the new taxes in the budget and its “citizen victim”
Yesterday at 4:49 am by rocky
» Oil: directives to expedite the investment of 200 cubic meters per day of associated gas in Dhi Qar
Yesterday at 4:48 am by rocky
» On his visit to the Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).. The Minister of Education discusses the developmen
Yesterday at 4:46 am by rocky
» The Iraqi government withdraws the bill to confiscate the funds of the pillars of Saddam's regime
Yesterday at 4:45 am by rocky
» Parliament passes the election law with security intervention after chaos
Yesterday at 4:44 am by rocky
» Iraq makes the water file sovereign and tends to store the Turkish increase in releases
Yesterday at 4:43 am by rocky
» An international report: 75% of the displaced farming families did not return to their homes
Yesterday at 4:42 am by rocky
» The delegation of the Kurdistan region returns to Baghdad to discuss the settlement of previous diff
Yesterday at 4:41 am by rocky
» The coordination framework is preparing to abolish the Judicial Commission and the Kirkuk elections
Yesterday at 4:39 am by rocky
» Central Bank: Our measures contributed to the stability of the exchange rate
Yesterday at 4:38 am by rocky
» The general amnesty returns to the fore... and a political consensus to speed up its approval
Yesterday at 4:37 am by rocky
» Al-Sudani conveys the issue of water from his artistic side and makes it a sovereign file
Yesterday at 4:36 am by rocky
» The Minister of Foreign Affairs directs to return the Iraqi Chargé d'Affairs to Bahrain to Baghdad
Yesterday at 4:34 am by rocky
» The Minister of Finance is discussing cooperation with France and Britain in 3 sectors
Yesterday at 4:33 am by rocky
» Electricity announces the operation of a crutch generation station on free national gas
Yesterday at 4:30 am by rocky
» Al-Mandalawi and Al-Hakim stress the need to expedite the legislation of the budget law
Yesterday at 4:28 am by rocky
» Retirement begins with the disbursement of the second meal for the beneficiaries of the category of
Yesterday at 4:27 am by rocky
» Agriculture shows the mechanism of importing crops
Yesterday at 4:26 am by rocky
» The Central Bank expects a decrease in the difference between the official and parallel exchange rat
Yesterday at 4:25 am by rocky
» Deputy: It is expected that 15 laws will be presented to Parliament during the coming weeks
Yesterday at 4:23 am by rocky
» Social protection: transgressors are held accountable and the money they received is returned
Yesterday at 4:18 am by rocky
» Cabinet decisions at its meeting today
Yesterday at 4:17 am by rocky
» The Social Protection Authority clarifies the mechanism for recovering money from those who violated
Yesterday at 4:15 am by rocky
» Sudanese advisor: Central Bank reserves reached 115 billion dollars
Yesterday at 4:14 am by rocky
» International oil prices continue to rise and are approaching $78 a barrel
Yesterday at 4:12 am by rocky
» Demands for Iraq to move to put pressure on Türkiye to obtain its share of water
Yesterday at 4:10 am by rocky
» Among them is the budget.. Al-Mandalawi and Al-Hakim discuss the importance of approving legislation
Yesterday at 4:09 am by rocky
» KTFA Monday Night CC "Don't Go Chasing Waterfalls" 3-27-2023
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:52 am by rocky
» The House of Representatives is close to approving a law that has been suspended for more than a dec
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:48 am by rocky
» Advisor to the Prime Minister: Iraq's economy is strong and moving towards improvement
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:46 am by rocky
» Sudanese advisor: The official exchange rate will match the parallel exchange rate within a few week
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:43 am by rocky
» The most prominent of which is the discussion of the oil file.. A delegation from the regional gover
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:35 am by rocky
» Parliamentary Finance: We have received the draft budget and it is not necessary to return it to the
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:33 am by rocky
» Parliamentary mobilization for statement "One" against the dictatorship of Al-Halbousi during the se
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:28 am by rocky
» Framework: We will not make any concessions in order to pass the election law
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:27 am by rocky
» Al-Bayati: The budget will be decided during next April, and the Kurds will not hinder its passage
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:26 am by rocky
» With an area of 330 dunums.. revealed the details of an economic and commercial city project in Ba
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:25 am by rocky
» Framework: Reviewing the strategic agreement with America will be a next priority after its failure
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:24 am by rocky
» A parliamentary move to host the Minister of Commerce due to the delay in disbursing the ration card
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:23 am by rocky
» Kurdistan's oil is stacked in storage tanks after exports to Turkey stopped
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:22 am by rocky
» Parliament was surprised by Al-Halbousi's behavior by hiding the budget and putting forward politica
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:20 am by rocky
» Expert: The American presence on the borders undermines the country's security and threatens its saf
Tue 28 Mar 2023, 5:19 am by rocky