[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
The received wisdom in the West is that the US is the main culprit for why Iraq today is a failed state. And there is certainly plenty, well-documented evidence that the poorly-planned invasion in 2003 had set the scene for years of conflict in the country. What is less understood is that the military and diplomatic failures of the initial invasion had largely been corrected, at great financial and human cost, through the Surge and the Awakening, by 2008-2009.
The Surge, when the US recommitted itself to bringing order in the country in the wake of the Sunni-Shia insurgency — and the Awakening by which many of the militias formerly hostile to the US and the American-backed Baghdad government had been brought around and persuaded to turn their weapons on the rising al-Qaeda elements in the country — had set the scene for a functional state, and even a working democracy in Iraq.
The real failure, since 2010, has been administrative. In this, the key culprit has been the Iraqi former prime minister Nouri al-Maliki. Maliki was elevated to the post of prime minister in 2006 by the Americans, as one of the few Shia leaders of Iraq who would be able to command broad support amongst the diverse demographics of the country. And indeed, in his first years on the job he had been a major asset.
He was key to the success of the initiatives which had brought Iraq to a promising position in 2009-2010. But his commitment, it turns out, was not to a united Iraq. Apparently, his primary allegiance was to his party, the Shia Islamist Dawa party, and to his own pockets. As soon as the Americans, now under the pacifist-minded leadership of the Obama administration, looked all set to leave Iraq, Maliki moved in to capture the institutions of the Iraqi state for his Dawa party.
Nouri al-Maliki allegedly set up a system to funnel US aid funds out of the reconstruction effort and into his own private patronage network, buying the support of just enough followers – Shia, but also some Sunni and Kurdish leaders — to keep the gravy train rolling indefinitely. Some $500 billion were alleged to have been funnelled off through various schemes during his eight-year tenure as prime minister, mostly from US companies and tax-payers.
Maliki’s twin moves to monopolise the political process in Iraq, while also robbing it of the funds it needed to rebuild, seem to be the key reasons for the implosion of political consensus in the country, and the rise of violent confrontation between diverse groups. What is more, the chronically under-equipped Iraqi army was so vulnerable to the early advances of ISIS, arguably because the money it had received to buy equipment had largely been siphoned off by Maliki’s cronies.
But while the main blame falls squarely on the corrupt Iraqi political leadership for the catastrophic mismanagement of the country since 2010, the US is not without fault either. They had been warned by many of those working in the country for the American mission that Maliki was going to squander all the blood and money the US had invested in Iraq, for his own political and financial gain.
Yet, eager to leave Iraq as quickly as possible once it looked remotely stable, the Obama administration failed to heed the warnings. And, perversely, after all the Bush-era rhetoric about bringing democracy to Iraq, it was the liberal Obama administration which first signalled the catastrophic direction Iraq would take when they decided to stand by Maliki, despite the charges that he had stolen the March 2010 election, in which he had nominally lost to a moderate, pro-Western, multi-ethnic coalition.
However, he apparently managed to coerce the courts to rule in his favour. In doing so, the US, led by Obama, chose to favour corrupt autocrats for the sake of “stability” over prospects of potentially destabilising democracy. Except this time, the US has not reaped “stability” from its choices. It has reaped ISIS. The question that still remains relevant though is the following: How is Nouri al-Maliki not in prison?
Azeem Ibrahim is a Research Professor at the Strategic Studies Institute, US Army War College and an International Security Lecturer at the University of Chicago. This article first appeared on Al-Arabiya.net.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
The received wisdom in the West is that the US is the main culprit for why Iraq today is a failed state. And there is certainly plenty, well-documented evidence that the poorly-planned invasion in 2003 had set the scene for years of conflict in the country. What is less understood is that the military and diplomatic failures of the initial invasion had largely been corrected, at great financial and human cost, through the Surge and the Awakening, by 2008-2009.
The Surge, when the US recommitted itself to bringing order in the country in the wake of the Sunni-Shia insurgency — and the Awakening by which many of the militias formerly hostile to the US and the American-backed Baghdad government had been brought around and persuaded to turn their weapons on the rising al-Qaeda elements in the country — had set the scene for a functional state, and even a working democracy in Iraq.
The real failure, since 2010, has been administrative. In this, the key culprit has been the Iraqi former prime minister Nouri al-Maliki. Maliki was elevated to the post of prime minister in 2006 by the Americans, as one of the few Shia leaders of Iraq who would be able to command broad support amongst the diverse demographics of the country. And indeed, in his first years on the job he had been a major asset.
He was key to the success of the initiatives which had brought Iraq to a promising position in 2009-2010. But his commitment, it turns out, was not to a united Iraq. Apparently, his primary allegiance was to his party, the Shia Islamist Dawa party, and to his own pockets. As soon as the Americans, now under the pacifist-minded leadership of the Obama administration, looked all set to leave Iraq, Maliki moved in to capture the institutions of the Iraqi state for his Dawa party.
Nouri al-Maliki allegedly set up a system to funnel US aid funds out of the reconstruction effort and into his own private patronage network, buying the support of just enough followers – Shia, but also some Sunni and Kurdish leaders — to keep the gravy train rolling indefinitely. Some $500 billion were alleged to have been funnelled off through various schemes during his eight-year tenure as prime minister, mostly from US companies and tax-payers.
Maliki’s twin moves to monopolise the political process in Iraq, while also robbing it of the funds it needed to rebuild, seem to be the key reasons for the implosion of political consensus in the country, and the rise of violent confrontation between diverse groups. What is more, the chronically under-equipped Iraqi army was so vulnerable to the early advances of ISIS, arguably because the money it had received to buy equipment had largely been siphoned off by Maliki’s cronies.
But while the main blame falls squarely on the corrupt Iraqi political leadership for the catastrophic mismanagement of the country since 2010, the US is not without fault either. They had been warned by many of those working in the country for the American mission that Maliki was going to squander all the blood and money the US had invested in Iraq, for his own political and financial gain.
Yet, eager to leave Iraq as quickly as possible once it looked remotely stable, the Obama administration failed to heed the warnings. And, perversely, after all the Bush-era rhetoric about bringing democracy to Iraq, it was the liberal Obama administration which first signalled the catastrophic direction Iraq would take when they decided to stand by Maliki, despite the charges that he had stolen the March 2010 election, in which he had nominally lost to a moderate, pro-Western, multi-ethnic coalition.
However, he apparently managed to coerce the courts to rule in his favour. In doing so, the US, led by Obama, chose to favour corrupt autocrats for the sake of “stability” over prospects of potentially destabilising democracy. Except this time, the US has not reaped “stability” from its choices. It has reaped ISIS. The question that still remains relevant though is the following: How is Nouri al-Maliki not in prison?
Azeem Ibrahim is a Research Professor at the Strategic Studies Institute, US Army War College and an International Security Lecturer at the University of Chicago. This article first appeared on Al-Arabiya.net.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
» Militia Man & Crew An economic expert explains the importance of Iraq's gold reserves
» The Minister of Resources announces the immediate implementation of the critical part of the Basra P
» Prime Minister: We call for the establishment of a regional grouping that includes the countries of
» Advisor Al-Rikabi: Al-Sudani at the United Nations calls on the world to cooperate to recover those
» Al-Sudani: The Iraqi decision is national and does not implement the wishes of America, Iran, or Tür
» Al-Sudani reveals the latest details of the cessation of the region’s oil via Turkey and clarifies t
» Saleh reveals an important “advantage” of the development path
» Al-Sudani declares Iraq's commitment to all international agreements and calls on neighboring countr
» “Before 2003”.. Al-Sudani: We do not deny the existence of relations of some political forces with c
» Al-Sudani: Within two years, we will depend on Iraqi gas to operate power stations
» Al-Sudani talks about projects that “will change the shape of Iraq” with a new and diversified econo
» Al-Sudani: We plan to be a gas exporting country, and it is time for American companies to enter the
» With the euphoria of oil...the World Bank advises Iraq to be careful with its budget and warns of a
» Al-Sudani: We are working to organize the 2023 Baghdad Conference for economic integration and regio
» Al-Sudani: There are fears among some Iraqi components about returning to the presidential system
» Al-Sudani: Fears among components about the return of the presidential system and the theft of the c
» Iraqi official: Al-Sudani asked the Iranians in New York to ease the pressure
» A parliamentarian sends an invitation to the Council of Ministers regarding Kurdistan’s debts (tweet
» Sudanese Advisor: Iraq will defend its vision on oil prices to ensure the stability of the global ec
» Al-Sudani talks about projects that “will change the shape of Iraq” with a new and diversified econo
» Artificial crises fill the pockets of corruption parties.. “Ali Baba’s Cave” is an example
» Al-Sudani from New York: The Development Road Project constitutes an effective space available for i
» The Foreign Minister talks about the Iraqi-American discussions and the reality of the agreement wit
» Fear of exploiting political money in elections
» Iraq confirms its support for multilateral dialogue within the framework of the United Nations
» Al-Sudani talks about an existential challenge in Iraq: We went through a painful experience
» International Monetary Fund: Dependence on oil and corruption threaten Iraq's future
» Identifying the parties behind the rise in the exchange rate in the parallel market
» Al-Sudani to the heads of American companies: Iraq is prepared to attract all types of investments
» Al-Sudani: We are preparing a draft of the economic reform law and concluding a trade and investment
» Hussein: We discussed with Washington linking the market and the dinar to the dollar... and it revea
» Al-Sudani calls on Malaysia to contribute to development... and his counterpart invites him to visit
» Parliamentarians: There is almost an agreement between representatives, especially bloc leaders, to
» Al-Muttalabi: Al-Kadhimi moves between countries, and the Iraqi judiciary issued a recruitment warra
» Revealing the volume of trade exchange at the Al-Qaim border crossing with Syria
» Parliamentary Finance: The issue of increasing the salaries of retirees depends on this point
» Al-Sudani: The wrong path in wasting burned gas will stop within 2-3 years
» The overthrow of two high-ranking government impersonators
» Parliamentarian: The interest of Kurdistan requires him to deal positively with Baghdad
» To zero in on crises...a political vision on the importance of knowing the numbers of Kurdistan empl
» Al-Sudani: Within two years, we will depend on Iraqi gas to operate power stations
» Al-Sudani talks about the importance of restoring the relationship between Iran and America
» Parliament sets 3 months to restore the dollar exchange rate to its official rate
» Al-Abadi: This is why I joined the third blocking against Muqtada al-Sadr's project
» Al-Khazali discusses with the Russian Ambassador the maintenance of military equipment in the Minist
» His popularity is rising and the return is a “mortgage” decision.. Will Al-Sadr “take revenge” or re
» Erbil's "arrogance" strikes the Kurdish citizen, and the secession referendum "weakens the region"
» The highlights of the press interview conducted by Prime Minister Muhammad Shiaa Al-Sudani, in New Y
» Minister of Labor: Nearly 800 million dollars a month are given to foreign workers in Iraq
» Al-Sudani holds a meeting with the American Chamber of Commerce in New York
» The launch of the 32nd session of the Executive Committee of the Arab Parliamentary Union in Baghdad
» Iraq faces drought by digging hundreds of wells: drinking water is a priority
» Barzani agrees with the international coalition that those liberated from ISIS must be rehabilitated
» Integrity: Six years imprisonment for impersonating work in the Authority
» Oil confirms the obligation of foreign companies to adopt Iraqi workers at a rate of more than 85%
» The arrest of someone impersonating the relatives of the Prime Minister and the Secretary-General of
» Al-Abadi comments on Kirkuk and reveals the reasons for the increase in dollar prices
» Al-Sudani: The relationship between Iraq and America cannot remain limited to the security aspect
» The Iranian President expresses his position on the security agreement with Iraq
» Al-Sudani sends messages to Turkey, Iran and the Russian tourist and calls an existential danger t
» Iraq is studying a draft regulation for smart applications
» Vice: Traders’ refusal to enter the platform caused the dollar crisis
» An economist explains the reasons for delaying the implementation of the general budget
» Minister of Labor: Mafia in the Ministry blackmails beneficiaries in exchange for speeding up the re
» Al-Sudani: The meeting is being arranged with Biden, and we will call for the formation of an intern
» In the document: administrative changes in Rafidain Bank that contradict the decision of the Ministe
» The Sudanese government agrees with an Israeli international financing institution to rehabilitate B
» The Gulf Cooperation Council abandons cooperation and supports Kuwait at the expense of Iraq
» Observers: The rise of the dollar will not stop, and most travelers resort to the parallel market
» Experts: Hard currency speculation and smuggling threaten the value of the Iraqi dinar
» Al-Sudani: We are awaiting the actions of the Turkish side to resume exports through Kurdistan
» The US House of Representatives will hold a session next week to cancel the authorization for the in
» The Service Council extends the period for updating and confirming the data of certificate holders a
» Israeli-American protest about Tsurkov: The Iraqi government must feel responsible
» Minister of Water Resources: The marshes need approximately 6 billion cubic meters of water as a min
» Disclosure of an expected increase of 100 thousand dinars for the salaries of this category
» Al-Sudani: Within two years, we will depend on Iraqi gas to operate power stations
» A deputy reveals the imminent decline in the price of the dollar after the Washington meetings
» What is the relationship between the agreement between Baghdad and the region?.. Elekti accuses Turk
» Jordan holds Iraq responsible for postponing the electrical connection and determines who is disrupt
» “When is the payment due?”.. A new comment regarding visiting the salaries of a group of retirees
» The Iraqi Chambers of Commerce and the Japanese JICA discuss developing the private sector
» Al-Abadi: The success of the current government does not depend on pleasing America
» 9/19/23 Militia Man & Crew Iraq Dinar - Militia Man & Angel1 - Update on Iraq's Progress - Al-Suda
» 9/21/23 Militia Man & Crew IRAQ DINAR - Global Financial System - Liquidity = INTERNATIONAL EXCHA
» Parliamentary integrity aims at the governor of the Central Bank: his management is bad and his mand
» Parliamentary Services: The government is continuing to complete the New Sadr City project
» Minister of Oil: We give exceptional attention to the development of national companies and the nati
» The Prime Minister's advisor explains the spending priorities in the budget
» Parliamentary hosting of the Chairman of the Retirement Authority regarding overcoming obstacles and
» Sheikh Al-Karbalai: We seek to return Iraq to what it was before in a number of sectors, including h
» The representative of the Emir of Kuwait meets Al-Sudani: The Iraqi judiciary committed a historical
» Al-Sudani: We will direct quantities of oil to operate Iraqi refineries abroad
» Al-Sudani confirms Iraq's commitment to Security Council resolutions related to Iraq and Kuwait
» Washington played a role in the salary agreement between Baghdad and Erbil
» Foreign Minister: Iraq opened the doors of the economy to Gulf investment, and there are clear misun
» Planning discloses the details of the Baghdad-Babylon road project.
» Al-Sultani reveals violations of the number of employees in Kurdistan