Numbers Don't Lie: Statistics Point To Massive Fraud In Russia's Duma Vote
In-Depth Coverage
September 20, 2016
by Valentin Baryshnikov and Robert Coalson
When liberal rights activist Ella Pamfilova was named to head Russia's election commission in March, she promised to clean house and oversee transparent, democratic elections.
"We will change a lot, and radically, in the way the Central Election Commission operates. A lot and radically -- this is something I can promise you," she said at the time.
However, a statistical analysis of the official preliminary results of the country's September 18 State Duma elections points to a familiar story: massive fraud in favor of the ruling United Russia party comparable to what independent analysts found in 2007 and 2011.
"The results of the current Duma elections were falsified on the same level as the Duma and presidential elections of 2011, 2008, and 2007, the most falsified elections in post-Soviet history, as far as we can tell," physicist and data analyst Sergei Shpilkin told RFE/RL's Russian Service. "By my estimate, the scope of the falsification in favor of United Russia in these elections amounted to approximately 12 million votes."
According to the CEC's preliminary results, official turnout for the election was 48 percent, and United Russia polled 54.2 percent of the party-list vote -- about 28,272,000 votes. That total gave United Russia 140 of the 225 party-list seats available in the Duma. In addition, United Russia candidates won 203 of the 225 contests in single-mandate districts, giving the party an expected total of 343 deputies in the 450-seat house.
Shpilkin, who in 2012 won the independent PolitProsvet award for political analysis for his statistical work on the 2011 vote, posted his examination of the latest election on his blog on September 19.
Using data from the Central Election Commission's website, Shpilkin organized all 95,800 polling stations on a graph according to the turnout that they reported.
In fair elections, the graph would form a bell curve, with its peak indicating the average turnout for the entire election. Reading from left to right, Shpilkin's graph shows a relatively normal bell curve that peaks at about 36 percent turnout and then, as it moves right, shows a jagged curve that dips unevenly and then begins rising again, as vast numbers of polling stations begin reporting turnouts of 70 percent or more.
Moreover, Shpilkin shows that almost all "extra" votes from polling stations reporting higher-than-average turnout went to United Russia. That is, a party such as ultranationalist Vladimir Zhirinovsky's LDPR received virtually the same number of votes from polling stations reporting a turnout of 95 percent as it did from stations reporting turnouts of 65 percent. United Russia, by contrast, received about four times as many at the 95 percent stations.
"The easiest form of falsification in terms of cost and intellectual effort on the part of the falsifiers is simply to add votes in favor of the desired party or candidate," Shpilkin explained. "But adding votes means that the turnout changes in an upward direction from the typical distribution. ... A peculiar characteristic of these elections is that we don't see the transfer of votes from one party to another. Perhaps this is a sign of the good influence of Ella Pamfilova."
In addition, Shpilkin's graph is spiked because there were an improbable number of polling stations at the high end of the turnout scale reporting round-number turnouts ending in 5 or 0, such as 75, 80, or 85 percent. This is a phenomenon Shpilkin and other analysts noted in previous elections and dubbed "Churov's saw," after former CEC head Vladimir Churov.
In 2008, Shpilkin estimated that United Russia actually won 277 seats in the Duma instead of the constitutional majority of 315 that it was awarded.
This time around, it is somewhat more difficult to tell how the alleged falsification might have influenced the results because half of the Duma was elected from single-mandate districts, from which United Russia got a majority of its deputies. Shpilkin estimates United Russia actually got about 40 percent of the party-list vote, which would have reduced its party-list seats from 140 to around 110.
But, with a projected 343 deputies in the new parliament, United Russia once again has enough votes to unilaterally alter the constitution.
Although Pamfilova has promised to investigate reports of fraud and election officials have already annulled results in at least three polling stations, she maintains that there was no systematic falsification and that the vote was legitimate. On September 20, Russia's Prosecutor-General's Office denied there were any significant violations during the voting and said the number of complaints was "significantly lower" than for previous elections.
But videos recorded by official cameras from several polling stations seem to tell a different story. In almost all of them, local election officials can be seen working as teams to apparently stuff ballot boxes and prevent outsiders from observing their actions.
Pamfilova has said that such videos do not constitute proof of fraud and, Shpilkin recalls, courts rejected dozens of fraud cases based on similar videos in 2012.
Shpilkin hopes his analysis will help Pamfilova come to grips with what he sees as massive fraud embedded in Russia's election system from the ground up.
"I am not entirely sure that Ella Pamfilova has a good understanding of the actions of the heads of polling stations on the ground, how they compile their protocols, how they fill in the data and submit it to their regional election commissions," Shpilkin said. "Moreover, she most likely does not understand how the results are aggregated and how many votes were added in for those 96,000 polling stations."
Shpilkin emphasizes that his analysis does not mean that the genuine opposition parties that did not get seats in the Duma would have, if not for the alleged falsification.
"It is possible that some changes might have been seen on the local level in places like Moscow and St. Petersburg on the level of single-mandate districts," he said. "But on the level of federal party lists, the position of the opposition looks entirely hopeless."
Source: http://www.rferl.org/content/statistics- point-to-massive-fraud-russia-state- duma-elections/28002750.html
http://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/news/russia/2016/russia-160920-rferl01.htm?_m=3n%2e002a%2e1823%2eqx0ao0791x%2e1odb
In-Depth Coverage
September 20, 2016
by Valentin Baryshnikov and Robert Coalson
When liberal rights activist Ella Pamfilova was named to head Russia's election commission in March, she promised to clean house and oversee transparent, democratic elections.
"We will change a lot, and radically, in the way the Central Election Commission operates. A lot and radically -- this is something I can promise you," she said at the time.
However, a statistical analysis of the official preliminary results of the country's September 18 State Duma elections points to a familiar story: massive fraud in favor of the ruling United Russia party comparable to what independent analysts found in 2007 and 2011.
"The results of the current Duma elections were falsified on the same level as the Duma and presidential elections of 2011, 2008, and 2007, the most falsified elections in post-Soviet history, as far as we can tell," physicist and data analyst Sergei Shpilkin told RFE/RL's Russian Service. "By my estimate, the scope of the falsification in favor of United Russia in these elections amounted to approximately 12 million votes."
According to the CEC's preliminary results, official turnout for the election was 48 percent, and United Russia polled 54.2 percent of the party-list vote -- about 28,272,000 votes. That total gave United Russia 140 of the 225 party-list seats available in the Duma. In addition, United Russia candidates won 203 of the 225 contests in single-mandate districts, giving the party an expected total of 343 deputies in the 450-seat house.
Shpilkin, who in 2012 won the independent PolitProsvet award for political analysis for his statistical work on the 2011 vote, posted his examination of the latest election on his blog on September 19.
Using data from the Central Election Commission's website, Shpilkin organized all 95,800 polling stations on a graph according to the turnout that they reported.
In fair elections, the graph would form a bell curve, with its peak indicating the average turnout for the entire election. Reading from left to right, Shpilkin's graph shows a relatively normal bell curve that peaks at about 36 percent turnout and then, as it moves right, shows a jagged curve that dips unevenly and then begins rising again, as vast numbers of polling stations begin reporting turnouts of 70 percent or more.
Moreover, Shpilkin shows that almost all "extra" votes from polling stations reporting higher-than-average turnout went to United Russia. That is, a party such as ultranationalist Vladimir Zhirinovsky's LDPR received virtually the same number of votes from polling stations reporting a turnout of 95 percent as it did from stations reporting turnouts of 65 percent. United Russia, by contrast, received about four times as many at the 95 percent stations.
"The easiest form of falsification in terms of cost and intellectual effort on the part of the falsifiers is simply to add votes in favor of the desired party or candidate," Shpilkin explained. "But adding votes means that the turnout changes in an upward direction from the typical distribution. ... A peculiar characteristic of these elections is that we don't see the transfer of votes from one party to another. Perhaps this is a sign of the good influence of Ella Pamfilova."
In addition, Shpilkin's graph is spiked because there were an improbable number of polling stations at the high end of the turnout scale reporting round-number turnouts ending in 5 or 0, such as 75, 80, or 85 percent. This is a phenomenon Shpilkin and other analysts noted in previous elections and dubbed "Churov's saw," after former CEC head Vladimir Churov.
In 2008, Shpilkin estimated that United Russia actually won 277 seats in the Duma instead of the constitutional majority of 315 that it was awarded.
This time around, it is somewhat more difficult to tell how the alleged falsification might have influenced the results because half of the Duma was elected from single-mandate districts, from which United Russia got a majority of its deputies. Shpilkin estimates United Russia actually got about 40 percent of the party-list vote, which would have reduced its party-list seats from 140 to around 110.
But, with a projected 343 deputies in the new parliament, United Russia once again has enough votes to unilaterally alter the constitution.
Although Pamfilova has promised to investigate reports of fraud and election officials have already annulled results in at least three polling stations, she maintains that there was no systematic falsification and that the vote was legitimate. On September 20, Russia's Prosecutor-General's Office denied there were any significant violations during the voting and said the number of complaints was "significantly lower" than for previous elections.
But videos recorded by official cameras from several polling stations seem to tell a different story. In almost all of them, local election officials can be seen working as teams to apparently stuff ballot boxes and prevent outsiders from observing their actions.
Pamfilova has said that such videos do not constitute proof of fraud and, Shpilkin recalls, courts rejected dozens of fraud cases based on similar videos in 2012.
Shpilkin hopes his analysis will help Pamfilova come to grips with what he sees as massive fraud embedded in Russia's election system from the ground up.
"I am not entirely sure that Ella Pamfilova has a good understanding of the actions of the heads of polling stations on the ground, how they compile their protocols, how they fill in the data and submit it to their regional election commissions," Shpilkin said. "Moreover, she most likely does not understand how the results are aggregated and how many votes were added in for those 96,000 polling stations."
Shpilkin emphasizes that his analysis does not mean that the genuine opposition parties that did not get seats in the Duma would have, if not for the alleged falsification.
"It is possible that some changes might have been seen on the local level in places like Moscow and St. Petersburg on the level of single-mandate districts," he said. "But on the level of federal party lists, the position of the opposition looks entirely hopeless."
Source: http://www.rferl.org/content/statistics- point-to-massive-fraud-russia-state- duma-elections/28002750.html
http://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/news/russia/2016/russia-160920-rferl01.htm?_m=3n%2e002a%2e1823%2eqx0ao0791x%2e1odb
Yesterday at 7:49 am by Rocky
» The Council of Ministers exempts the Gulf Interconnection Authority from guarantee fees: it is a gov
Yesterday at 7:48 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi government raises the size of the 2024 budget, and Parliament is “surprised”
Yesterday at 7:46 am by Rocky
» Popular Movement: We have many economic options away from American hegemony
Yesterday at 7:42 am by Rocky
» The Oil Parliament stresses the need to transfer part of the revenues to the producing governorates
Yesterday at 7:41 am by Rocky
» It will cover 14 regions in eastern Iraq.. A deputy reveals the “border electricity” project
Yesterday at 7:40 am by Rocky
» Experts Warn Mass Migration Threatens US Food Security
Yesterday at 7:37 am by Bama Diva
» Al-Fateh: America occupies Iraq through agreements
Yesterday at 7:37 am by Rocky
» Anger in Iraq over a "sudden decision"... and a reminder of a "general strike" that paralyzed the co
Yesterday at 7:34 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Committee: Parliament is discussing today a decision that “disturbed” the Iraqis
Yesterday at 7:33 am by Rocky
» Ministry of Electricity: Our production will reach 27 thousand megawatts by May
Yesterday at 7:31 am by Rocky
» Diagnosing the “most important” problems in the oil file between Baghdad and Erbil.. What is the rel
Yesterday at 7:30 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi Fiqh Academy and the Sunni Endowment issue a fatwa to pay Zakat al-Fitr
Yesterday at 7:28 am by Rocky
» The National Bank of Iraq continues its digital transformation by launching its new banking system a
Yesterday at 7:26 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Investment and the Central Bank are discussing the housing initiative
Yesterday at 7:25 am by Rocky
» The Prime Minister announces the restart of 500 suspended projects
Yesterday at 7:23 am by Rocky
» Al-Barti assesses the region's employees: Your salaries are insured and will be paid after resettlem
Yesterday at 7:21 am by Rocky
» Iraqi-American discussions in anticipation of the Sudanese visit
Yesterday at 7:20 am by Rocky
» Iraq and Turkey hold meetings in Ankara to discuss technical issues related to the development road
Yesterday at 7:17 am by Rocky
» A government parliamentary agreement to support budget revenues and governorate allocations for inve
Yesterday at 7:16 am by Rocky
» Oil: The gas sector is witnessing great development
Yesterday at 7:15 am by Rocky
» A Kurdish-French agreement to develop trade and economic relations
Yesterday at 7:13 am by Rocky
» Exchange companies in Mosul demand that they be entered into the currency selling window
Yesterday at 7:12 am by Rocky
» Minister of Finance to the Czech Ambassador: Iraq enjoys a more attractive business environment and
Yesterday at 7:10 am by Rocky
» Iraq and Britain sign an agreement in the field of the stock market
Yesterday at 7:08 am by Rocky
» A new parliamentary meeting with the Minister of Finance to discuss these files
Yesterday at 7:07 am by Rocky
» A parliamentary committee discusses these files with the Director of the Projects Department in the
Yesterday at 7:06 am by Rocky
» Central Bank sales exceed $257 million today
Yesterday at 7:05 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance and the Minister of Planning discuss governorate allocations and investment bu
Yesterday at 7:04 am by Rocky
» Planning: We are discussing with representatives of the World Bank the work plan of the Social Fund
Yesterday at 7:02 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary meeting with the Governor of the Central Bank and the Director of the Real Estate Bank
Yesterday at 7:01 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance: The 2024 budget reached 228 trillion dinars
Yesterday at 6:57 am by Rocky
» Barzani "gives good news" to Kurdistan's employees: salaries, land, and loan exemptions
Yesterday at 6:57 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Economy: The decision to raise fuel prices targets this class
Yesterday at 6:54 am by Rocky
» The President of the Republic: Iraq is an important investment environment
Yesterday at 6:53 am by Rocky
» From the accounts of Saddam's Republican Guard... Iraq returns approximately 7 billion dinars to the
Yesterday at 6:52 am by Rocky
» Al-Abadi: Muqtada al-Sadr did not leave politics.. He reached a dead end
Yesterday at 6:49 am by Rocky
» Nassif: The leaders of the framework abandoned Al-Sudani because of his recent successes
Yesterday at 6:48 am by Rocky
» Baghdad stresses the continued danger of ISIS and the importance of Washington's efforts to combat i
Yesterday at 6:47 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Oil: It is necessary to transfer part of the revenues to the oil-producing governorate
Yesterday at 6:45 am by Rocky
» The Sudanese government zeroes in on the legacy of its predecessors
Yesterday at 5:28 am by Rocky
» The Human Organ and Tissue Transplantation Law is ready for its second reading
Yesterday at 5:26 am by Rocky
» 1,500 active civil organizations in Iraq
Yesterday at 5:25 am by Rocky
» The position of Speaker of Parliament awaits decision
Yesterday at 5:23 am by Rocky
» Water for peace...the water crisis in Iraq
Yesterday at 5:21 am by Rocky
» Fiscal and monetary policies succeed in undermining the parallel dollar
Yesterday at 5:20 am by Rocky
» Kurdistan.. Attempts to circumvent the "Federal" decision and an invitation to the Baghdad governmen
Yesterday at 5:17 am by Rocky
» “Iraq warned the US Treasury to leave the dollar.” Parliamentary Finance: The exchange rate will con
Yesterday at 5:16 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi government issues new decisions
Yesterday at 5:14 am by Rocky
» Barzani: We will not give up our constitutional rights, and tomorrow we will take a decision that is
Yesterday at 5:12 am by Rocky
» A researcher in political and security affairs describes the decision to increase the price of gasol
Yesterday at 5:11 am by Rocky
» The Council of Ministers addresses the Finance Ministry to appoint the families of those who died du
Yesterday at 5:09 am by Rocky
» 100 thousand dinars as a “Eid gift” for retirees.. A parliamentary request before the Sudanese (docu
Yesterday at 5:08 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani confirms that more than 490 projects have been moved and returned to work in record time
Yesterday at 5:07 am by Rocky
» Parliament reveals three facts about the decision to raise the price of fuel: It targeted “luxury” w
Yesterday at 5:05 am by Rocky
» In detail...the problems of the oil file between Baghdad and Erbil
Yesterday at 5:04 am by Rocky
» International skepticism about Iraqi agriculture... Modern irrigation succeeds, but it will not be e
Yesterday at 5:02 am by Rocky
» For those who love traveling by the Iraqi train... buy the ticket with your mobile phone and 50 new
Yesterday at 5:00 am by Rocky
» Regional and international challenges hinder the path of the Iraqi economy towards stability
Yesterday at 4:59 am by Rocky
» A severe educational crisis threatens Iraqi children with a “bleak future”
Yesterday at 4:57 am by Rocky
» Investing in Iraq's natural wealth is a step towards economic integration
Yesterday at 4:56 am by Rocky
» Revealing the advantages of the “Hasabe” project: It is safe and provides great services to employee
Yesterday at 4:55 am by Rocky
» Iraq seeks to strengthen its air defenses.. All eyes turn to South Korea
Yesterday at 4:53 am by Rocky
» Residents of Souq Al-Shuyoukh and Al-Fahd renew their demand for the dismissal of officials and hold
Yesterday at 4:52 am by Rocky
» The government's mood swings turn employees' dreams into nightmares of additional taxes and collecti
Yesterday at 4:50 am by Rocky
» Deputy: Al-Sudani will raise the issue of lifting sanctions against Iraqi banks in Washington
Yesterday at 4:49 am by Rocky
» Kurdish MP: The Shiite authority wants to restore the central system to Iraq
Yesterday at 4:47 am by Rocky
» A Kurdish leader attacks the Federal Court: it is unconstitutional and its decisions are against the
Yesterday at 4:47 am by Rocky
» Talabani Party: Al-Halbousi poses a danger to himself and not just his opponents
Yesterday at 4:45 am by Rocky
» Deputy: The rule of law is trying to return Al-Maliki to power
Yesterday at 4:45 am by Rocky
» Barzani accuses parties of trying to pave the way for the elimination of the region
Yesterday at 4:44 am by Rocky
» BRICS adopts a payment system that is not linked to the dollar
Yesterday at 4:42 am by Rocky
» Tax Authority: Fines imposed on colleges reach one billion dollars
Yesterday at 4:40 am by Rocky
» Sanad: Washington is blackmailing Baghdad with dollars, and the Sudanese government must end the san
Yesterday at 4:39 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance hosts the Minister of Planning to end the crisis in disbursing governorates’ d
Yesterday at 4:38 am by Rocky
» Service effort: The housing crisis in Iraq is disastrous
Yesterday at 4:37 am by Rocky
» A deputy accuses the director of ports: He wasted 20 trillion dinars and exceeded the authorities
Yesterday at 4:35 am by Rocky
» Including raising the price of gasoline and working hours... the full decisions of the Prime Ministe
Yesterday at 4:33 am by Rocky
» Nassif reveals the files that will be presented when the Roads Director comes to Parliament
Yesterday at 4:31 am by Rocky
» Protests and suspension of work... Kurdistan employees await the completion of resettlement procedur
Yesterday at 4:30 am by Rocky
» The Iraq Recovery Fund returns approximately (7) billion dinars
Yesterday at 4:28 am by Rocky
» About 6,000 civil organizations have registered in Iraq.. What about the effectiveness on the ground
Yesterday at 4:27 am by Rocky
» Registering 80,000 private companies under the new retirement and social security law
Yesterday at 4:25 am by Rocky
» Iraq refuses to approve the construction of the Turkish Jazra Dam on the Tigris River Basin
Yesterday at 4:24 am by Rocky
» With the presence of Iraq... a list of countries most vulnerable to water shortages by 2050
Yesterday at 4:23 am by Rocky
» utube 3/25/24 MM&C IQD Update - Iraqi Dinar - Al-Sudani - Faud Hussein - Taif Sami - Iraq's Ex
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:19 am by Rocky
» Despite Sudanese directives, government banks are continuing to adopt a “fixed rate” on loans
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:15 am by Rocky
» Stability of dollar prices against the dinar in Baghdad and Erbil
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:14 am by Rocky
» SWIFT is working on creating a digital currency platform for central banks
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:13 am by Rocky
» Parliament is in the process of amending the People with Disabilities and Special Needs Law, and the
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:12 am by Rocky
» Iraq praises Turkey's "serious" interaction with the development road project
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:10 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Education approves the names of supervisors of the Creativity, Challenge, Peace and
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:08 am by Rocky
» Losses for most Gulf markets with the expiration of eligibility for cash dividends
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:06 am by Rocky
» Government source: All government banks adopted the simple decreasing interest method instead of fix
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:05 am by Rocky
» Justice clarifies the mechanism for requesting real estate bonds via the Ur platform
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:03 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance: We are putting pressure on the government to approve a new fair salary scale
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:02 am by Rocky
» International Organization for Migration: Iraqi agriculture has suffered from a recession
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:01 am by Rocky
» Central Bank: Inflation drops to 4%
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 5:00 am by Rocky
» Transportation: Reducing flight prices with the advent of Eid al-Fitr
Tue 26 Mar 2024, 4:59 am by Rocky