Leaked Clinton campaign memo on ‘climate change’ shows it’s really about politics, not science
From Larry Kummer at the Fabius Maximus website
Memorandum: “Climate: A unifying theory to the case“,
Emailed from John Podesta to Chris Lehane, 28 January 2014.
This memo was emailed to Podesta (a senior White House official) from Lehane (partner in the strategic communications firm Fabiani & Lehane, dissolved in Nov 2015). We have it courtesy of Wikileaks — and whoever leaked it to them.
John Podesta was Chief of staff to Bill Clinton and Counselor to the President for Obama. He is Chairman of Hillary Clinton’s campaign.
Chris Lehane – When an attorney in the White House Counsel’s office, he and his current business partner Mark Fabiani called themselves the “Masters of Disaster” for their work as a “rapid-response” team responding to the many scandals of the Clinton Administration. Lehane co-authored a book on damage control titled Masters of Disaster: The Ten Commandments of Damage Control. Jim Jordan, Kerry’s former campaign manager, called him ”a master of the political hand-to-hand” for his work as a political strategist.
——————————————-
“Thank you for asking us to share some ideas for a holistic approach to climate. Per your direction, the goal is to unify policy, politics, and communications to help the Administration best execute an informed plan over a multi-year time period. …this document is intended to provide some food for thought as the Administration refines its thinking on climate. …{it} addresses the four components that the Administration may want to consider as it seeks to lead on this issue.
“To achieve victory, we must treat climate change as an issue of historic importance that is worthy of a true political social movement to create change. This political social movement must be founded on moral principles with stark definitions of who is right and who is wrong, and it is important to outline the historically negative, irreversible implications if we were to not succeed.
“By pursuing this as a political social movement, President Obama and his Administration will best be able to assure that his legacy includes his unprecedented leadership on climate that initiated the shifting of the country’s political tectonic plates to enable transformative climate change policy, before it was too late.
“…At the end of the day, given the powerful and entrenched interests that are opposed to climate change policy, one needs to have an organizing platform that defines the Administration as being morally on the right side of the issue and, equally important, defines the opposition as morally responsible for an issue that threatens the health and welfare of the American people. …
“Define the issue as between those who believe in the science, and therefore are taking steps to respond to the scientific findings, versus those who do not believe in the science. The power of this approach is that it puts the opposition in an indefensible box (the vast majority of people believe the science that climate is changing); it fits into what we call the Troglodyte Narrative(anti-women; anti-Latino; anti-gun safety; anti-common sense fiscal policy; and anti-science) that is raising basic trust issues for the Republican Party – especially with electorally decisive voter cohorts. You either believe in basic science or you are against basic science — in which case you fail a basic requirement for being capable of occupying public office. …
“Health/Safety. The opposition is engaged in practices or holding positions that are demonstrably imperiling the health and safety of our people. This ranges from macro issues like extreme weather to local issues like drinking water, air quality and rail safety to micro issues like children’s asthma. People care when the health and safety of their families are implicated.
“Pocket Book. People care when climate impacts them economically. On the positive/aspirational front, this principle can be about whether new green jobs will be based here or overseas or how citizens are able to save money by paying less for energy. …
“Accountability/Responsibility. Follow the money. Who is accountable/responsible for the bad things that are happening, and how are they rigging the system to benefit from the bad things? …
———————— End excerpt. ————————
Conclusions
The most important thing about this memo, obvious almost three years later, is its complete failure. Few Americans consider the environment our most serious problem. It is a minor issue in the presidential election, seldom even mentioned. Climate change isn’t among our top 10 fears.
The approach is pure politics, with little mention of science. For example, the SWAT teams {as we have seen} blame all “extreme” weather on climate change — ignoring that extreme weather is normal, occurring before any anthropogenic effects. The IPCC has repeatedly explained this, not just in their regular Assessment Reports but also in the 2012 report “Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to Advance Climate Change Adaptation” (SREX).
Worse, the binary framing (“the vast majority of people believe the science that climate is changing”) ignores the key issues of how much change is likely from anthropogenic sources — and when. That is the area of debate among climate scientists (there is as yet no consensus), and the necessary input to make public policy decisions.
Describing climate change as a moral issue probably seemed like a sure winner to Lehane, especially with academia, journalists, and most NGOs as supporting players. But that prevented political compromise or any rational discussion of costs vs. benefits — both essential elements of successful public policy. It polarized the issue so that America has taken few measures to even prepare for the repeat of past weather (as Hurricane Matthew reminded us).
Worse, Lehane does not mention what he relies upon as the authorities for science. The IPCC? NOAA? The alarmists that journalists love for their exciting soundbites? The climate scientists who write the IPCC’s Working Group I reports devote great effort to explaining their state of knowledge — and the large uncertainties in much of it. There is a large gap between the certainty of warming since the early 19th century plus the large role of anthropogenic forcings since 1950 — and the massive unknowns driving climate during the 21st century. All that is lost when the issue is defined in purely moral terms.
So they lost. Clinton’s probable win (in March I predicted a landslide) Lehane and his fellow activists a second chance. Will they learn from their failures in the 28 years since James Hansen’s 1988 testimony to Congress ignited the movement? Or will they have sufficient political power to push through their agenda despite their weak political support and ineffective plans?
There are better ways to handle major public policy issues. Climate change, our mad foreign wars, and our mishandling of so many other key challenges — these show our dysfunctional politics in action. We can do better.
https://wattsupwiththat.com/2016/10/17/leaked-clinton-campaign-memo-on-climate-change-shows-its-really-about-politics-not-science/
From Larry Kummer at the Fabius Maximus website
Memorandum: “Climate: A unifying theory to the case“,
Emailed from John Podesta to Chris Lehane, 28 January 2014.
This memo was emailed to Podesta (a senior White House official) from Lehane (partner in the strategic communications firm Fabiani & Lehane, dissolved in Nov 2015). We have it courtesy of Wikileaks — and whoever leaked it to them.
John Podesta was Chief of staff to Bill Clinton and Counselor to the President for Obama. He is Chairman of Hillary Clinton’s campaign.
Chris Lehane – When an attorney in the White House Counsel’s office, he and his current business partner Mark Fabiani called themselves the “Masters of Disaster” for their work as a “rapid-response” team responding to the many scandals of the Clinton Administration. Lehane co-authored a book on damage control titled Masters of Disaster: The Ten Commandments of Damage Control. Jim Jordan, Kerry’s former campaign manager, called him ”a master of the political hand-to-hand” for his work as a political strategist.
——————————————-
“Thank you for asking us to share some ideas for a holistic approach to climate. Per your direction, the goal is to unify policy, politics, and communications to help the Administration best execute an informed plan over a multi-year time period. …this document is intended to provide some food for thought as the Administration refines its thinking on climate. …{it} addresses the four components that the Administration may want to consider as it seeks to lead on this issue.
- Three-Year Framework. …
- Right v. Wrong. Make the case that climate must be approached as a challenge of historical social change where progress will depend in part on successfully casting the issue in moral terms of who is right and who is wrong …
- The Big Idea. …{It} could drive an Administration-wide approach to climate for the next three years. …
- 2014 Action Plan. …
“To achieve victory, we must treat climate change as an issue of historic importance that is worthy of a true political social movement to create change. This political social movement must be founded on moral principles with stark definitions of who is right and who is wrong, and it is important to outline the historically negative, irreversible implications if we were to not succeed.
“By pursuing this as a political social movement, President Obama and his Administration will best be able to assure that his legacy includes his unprecedented leadership on climate that initiated the shifting of the country’s political tectonic plates to enable transformative climate change policy, before it was too late.
“…At the end of the day, given the powerful and entrenched interests that are opposed to climate change policy, one needs to have an organizing platform that defines the Administration as being morally on the right side of the issue and, equally important, defines the opposition as morally responsible for an issue that threatens the health and welfare of the American people. …
“Define the issue as between those who believe in the science, and therefore are taking steps to respond to the scientific findings, versus those who do not believe in the science. The power of this approach is that it puts the opposition in an indefensible box (the vast majority of people believe the science that climate is changing); it fits into what we call the Troglodyte Narrative(anti-women; anti-Latino; anti-gun safety; anti-common sense fiscal policy; and anti-science) that is raising basic trust issues for the Republican Party – especially with electorally decisive voter cohorts. You either believe in basic science or you are against basic science — in which case you fail a basic requirement for being capable of occupying public office. …
“The Winning Principles
“The Big Idea will need to be animated by three principles that the wedge political policies would connect with (think of FDR’s Four Freedoms or TR’s Three C’s). In the context of being informed by various campaigns (candidate and ballot initiative) in which climate was deployed as a decisively winning political issue, there are three issues that really stand out as wedge principles that could undergird the Big Idea (whatever the Big Idea may be).“Health/Safety. The opposition is engaged in practices or holding positions that are demonstrably imperiling the health and safety of our people. This ranges from macro issues like extreme weather to local issues like drinking water, air quality and rail safety to micro issues like children’s asthma. People care when the health and safety of their families are implicated.
“Pocket Book. People care when climate impacts them economically. On the positive/aspirational front, this principle can be about whether new green jobs will be based here or overseas or how citizens are able to save money by paying less for energy. …
“Accountability/Responsibility. Follow the money. Who is accountable/responsible for the bad things that are happening, and how are they rigging the system to benefit from the bad things? …
“2014 Action Plan
“…Establishment of an extreme weather SWAT team prepared to work together and engage when extreme weather happens — including response; local outreach; media; science information about historic nature of the event; and coordinating possible principal travel (POTUS, FLOTUS, VPOTUS, Cabinet).”———————— End excerpt. ————————
Conclusions
The most important thing about this memo, obvious almost three years later, is its complete failure. Few Americans consider the environment our most serious problem. It is a minor issue in the presidential election, seldom even mentioned. Climate change isn’t among our top 10 fears.
The approach is pure politics, with little mention of science. For example, the SWAT teams {as we have seen} blame all “extreme” weather on climate change — ignoring that extreme weather is normal, occurring before any anthropogenic effects. The IPCC has repeatedly explained this, not just in their regular Assessment Reports but also in the 2012 report “Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to Advance Climate Change Adaptation” (SREX).
Worse, the binary framing (“the vast majority of people believe the science that climate is changing”) ignores the key issues of how much change is likely from anthropogenic sources — and when. That is the area of debate among climate scientists (there is as yet no consensus), and the necessary input to make public policy decisions.
Describing climate change as a moral issue probably seemed like a sure winner to Lehane, especially with academia, journalists, and most NGOs as supporting players. But that prevented political compromise or any rational discussion of costs vs. benefits — both essential elements of successful public policy. It polarized the issue so that America has taken few measures to even prepare for the repeat of past weather (as Hurricane Matthew reminded us).
Worse, Lehane does not mention what he relies upon as the authorities for science. The IPCC? NOAA? The alarmists that journalists love for their exciting soundbites? The climate scientists who write the IPCC’s Working Group I reports devote great effort to explaining their state of knowledge — and the large uncertainties in much of it. There is a large gap between the certainty of warming since the early 19th century plus the large role of anthropogenic forcings since 1950 — and the massive unknowns driving climate during the 21st century. All that is lost when the issue is defined in purely moral terms.
So they lost. Clinton’s probable win (in March I predicted a landslide) Lehane and his fellow activists a second chance. Will they learn from their failures in the 28 years since James Hansen’s 1988 testimony to Congress ignited the movement? Or will they have sufficient political power to push through their agenda despite their weak political support and ineffective plans?
There are better ways to handle major public policy issues. Climate change, our mad foreign wars, and our mishandling of so many other key challenges — these show our dysfunctional politics in action. We can do better.
https://wattsupwiththat.com/2016/10/17/leaked-clinton-campaign-memo-on-climate-change-shows-its-really-about-politics-not-science/
Today at 4:53 am by Rocky
» utube 10/31/24 MM&C Central Bank Governor of Iraq-Monetary Stability Directly Stimulating the Econom
Today at 4:53 am by Rocky
» utube 11/2/24 MM&C Report-Iraq 3 Presidents-National-Constitutional Entitlements-Open Market Operati
Today at 4:50 am by Rocky
» Türkiye and Iraq.. Coordination against the Kurdistan
Today at 4:43 am by Rocky
» Qatar affirms its aspiration to participate effectively in the path of development
Today at 4:42 am by Rocky
» Amidst air alert, US forces resume training activity at Harir base
Today at 4:40 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani's advisor reveals the positives of the Central Bank's interest rate cut
Today at 4:39 am by Rocky
» Leader in the framework: Ankara has 75 illegal military sites inside Iraq
Today at 4:38 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Committee Reveals New Details on Oil Smuggling
Today at 4:36 am by Rocky
» Al-Sahaf: America relies on deception regarding the withdrawal of its forces from Iraq
Today at 4:35 am by Rocky
» "It failed in its work".. Al-Salihi calls on Al-Sudani to include the defense in the ministerial cha
Today at 4:34 am by Rocky
» With more than a billion dollars, Iraq is the fourth country that imports the most from Türkiye duri
Today at 4:32 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Committee announces seeking to amend the Oil Ministry Law
Today at 4:29 am by Rocky
» Türkiye: Development Road Designs 90% Complete
Today at 4:28 am by Rocky
» Al-Azzawi on the “Baghdadna” platform: It supports digital transformation files and provides service
Today at 4:27 am by Rocky
» What are the positives of the Central Bank reducing interest rates? Al-Sudani’s advisor explains
Today at 4:25 am by Rocky
» Foreign Report: A major Chinese company is exploring an oil field in central Iraq
Today at 4:23 am by Rocky
» Governmental move to establish an administrative capital in Baghdad
Today at 4:22 am by Rocky
» Al-Mandlawi and Al-Hakim agree to proceed with the legislation of important laws and activate the su
Today at 4:19 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Education Committee acquits the “education sector” of the spread of poverty and unempl
Today at 4:17 am by Rocky
» The Ministry of Electricity denies the increase in tariffs and confirms the continuation of support
Today at 4:14 am by Rocky
» MP calls for not passing the partnership contract between Iraq and the International Finance Corpora
Today at 4:13 am by Rocky
» “A fraudulent maze” reveals “thorny” files that swallow the pockets of Iraqis
Today at 4:10 am by Rocky
» "Sudanese Meter" .. Failure to achieve 57% of promises, and full and partial implementation reaches
Today at 4:09 am by Rocky
» Al-Maliki's coalition denies that Halbousi supports Al-Mashhadani in reaching the parliament preside
Today at 4:08 am by Rocky
» State of Law: Ministerial change is currently ruled out
Today at 4:07 am by Rocky
» Independent candidates in Sulaymaniyah and Halabja reject the results of the Kurdistan Parliament el
Today at 4:05 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani and Erdogan discuss unifying positions on regional developments
Today at 4:04 am by Rocky
» Iraq reduces oil exports and domestic consumption
Today at 4:03 am by Rocky
» Parliament is unaware of the details of the 2025 budget and fears of a “shock” in oil prices
Today at 4:02 am by Rocky
» Al-Mashhadani and Barzani stress the need to resolve pending issues and pass laws that serve the int
Today at 4:00 am by Rocky
» The President of the Republic congratulates the Mandaeans on the occasion of the Prosperity Festival
Today at 3:58 am by Rocky
» After meeting Erdogan, Al-Sudani concludes his visit to Türkiye and returns to Baghdad
Today at 3:54 am by Rocky
» Israel sends a strong warning message to Iraq
Today at 3:53 am by Rocky
» US officials: Israel is exposed to daily attacks by drones from Iraq
Today at 3:51 am by Rocky
» Dollar exchange rates in Iraq today
Today at 3:50 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani opens two factories to produce medicines and intravenous solutions in Baghdad
Today at 3:49 am by Rocky
» How ‘Rare’ Are Sex-Trait Modification Surgeries on Children?
Yesterday at 2:55 pm by Bama Diva
» US Calls on China to ‘Curb’ North Korean Involvement in Russia–Ukraine War
Yesterday at 2:27 pm by Bama Diva
» The Great Prosecutor’s record EXPOSED: ‘She’s never prosecuted a single case from beginning to end’
Yesterday at 2:13 pm by Bama Diva
» The Arab Dinar: A Strategic Tool for Arab Economic Integration
Yesterday at 2:03 pm by Rocky
» In cooperation with a foreign advisor.. A parliamentary committee announces its efforts to amend the
Yesterday at 8:04 am by Rocky
» Iraq’s Ministry of Electricity and GE Vernova complete construction and operation of several importa
Yesterday at 8:02 am by Rocky
» "A fraudulent maze".. Shafaq News reveals "thorny" files that swallow the pockets of Iraqis
Yesterday at 7:59 am by Rocky
» Oil Products announces the distribution of nearly 300,000 fuel cards in Kirkuk
Yesterday at 7:58 am by Rocky
» Reuters: Al-Sudani's government seeks to avoid Israeli response to the bombing of the factions
Yesterday at 4:35 am by Rocky
» Trump.. “The Man of Maximum Pressure”.. Is Iraq Prepared for the Possibility of His Return?
Yesterday at 4:34 am by Rocky
» Why did Halbousi choose to support Al-Mashhadani.. and will he benefit from him to enhance his influ
Yesterday at 4:33 am by Rocky
» Legal expert notes on draft law to return properties to their owners
Yesterday at 4:31 am by Rocky
» Abu Saeeda warns of an American scenario that creates a new crisis inside Iraq
Yesterday at 4:29 am by Rocky
» Al-Karawi: America seeks to keep Iraq weak in terms of armament
Yesterday at 4:28 am by Rocky
» Meet the oldest speaker who will convene the first session of the Kurdistan Parliament
Yesterday at 4:26 am by Rocky
» Minister of Transport: We have completed the designs for the railway link and 84% of the land link f
Yesterday at 4:24 am by Rocky
» The Prime Minister chairs a meeting to follow up on the implementation of agreements and memoranda o
Yesterday at 4:23 am by Rocky
» Baghdad Governor: Advanced completion rates exceed 85% in Al-Shaab General Hospital
Yesterday at 4:21 am by Rocky
» The CEO of the Iraq Stock Exchange has been relieved of his post.
Yesterday at 4:19 am by Rocky
» New Zealand reaches trade agreement with Gulf countries
Yesterday at 4:18 am by Rocky
» In two separate meetings, the President of the Olympic Committee accepts the invitation of the Iraqi
Yesterday at 4:15 am by Rocky
» Rafidain Bank grants more than 5,000 loans within the (Riyada) initiative
Yesterday at 4:13 am by Rocky
» The President of the Republic and the Prime Minister hold a meeting to discuss the preparations for
Yesterday at 4:12 am by Rocky
» Turkish Transport Minister: “Development Road” Project of Strategic Importance for the Region
Yesterday at 4:11 am by Rocky
» Al-Mashhadani: I pledge to you that we will work as a cohesive team to legislate laws that serve the
Yesterday at 4:09 am by Rocky
» Al-Hakim congratulates Al-Mashhadani: We hope to improve parliamentary performance
Yesterday at 4:07 am by Rocky
» Turkmen call to revive Talabani initiative: Key to resolving Kirkuk crisis and achieving justice - U
Yesterday at 4:06 am by Rocky
» MP comments on possibility of Sudanese breaking "restrictions" to carry out ministerial reshuffle
Yesterday at 4:05 am by Rocky
» The Ministry of Migration distributes (checks) of the four million dinar grant among (241) families
Yesterday at 4:02 am by Rocky
» In the presence of President Barzani and Masrour Barzani.. Mesopotamia Medical Conference kicks off
Yesterday at 4:01 am by Rocky
» The President of the Kurdistan Region issues an order to create three districts in Duhok Governorate
Yesterday at 4:00 am by Rocky
» Informed source: No legal problems for my accounting project in Baghdad, and the Patriotic Union rum
Yesterday at 3:59 am by Rocky
» The volume of trade exchange between the Kurdistan Region and Turkey is nearly 10 billion dollars in
Yesterday at 3:57 am by Rocky
» President Barzani: The next regional government must be one government and the law must prevail
Yesterday at 3:56 am by Rocky
» MP calls for not passing the partnership contract between Iraq and the International Finance Corpora
Yesterday at 3:55 am by Rocky
» Iraq thwarts smuggling of Captagon shipment through foreign carrier
Yesterday at 3:54 am by Rocky
» Transparency: Sulaymaniyah and Halabja imports during last October amounted to more than 63 billion
Yesterday at 3:50 am by Rocky
» Al-Mashhadani's first comment after being elected as Parliament Speaker
Yesterday at 3:48 am by Rocky
» Al-Jaberi counts the size of Iraq's losses due to oil smuggling from the region
Yesterday at 3:47 am by Rocky
» Citizenship withdrawal continues...this time for 489 people awaiting Cabinet approval
Yesterday at 3:45 am by Rocky
» Tax evasion and non-compliance with contracts.. The Chinese dragon swallows $ 180 million from Iraq
Yesterday at 3:44 am by Rocky
» What ministries are included in the ministerial reshuffle?
Yesterday at 3:42 am by Rocky
» Loans up to 20 million dinars for the unemployed
Yesterday at 3:41 am by Rocky
» What did Hadi al-Amiri say to Alsumaria after Al-Mashhadani was elected Speaker of Parliament?
Yesterday at 3:39 am by Rocky
» Central Bank Governor reveals important figures about Iraq's economy and foreign reserves
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 9:18 am by Rocky
» utube 10/29/24 MM&C MM&C News Report on Iraq Dinar-2024 Budget Focus-Oil & Gas Export Ceyhan Port-
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 7:06 am by Rocky
» utube 10/28/24 MM&C News Reporting-Politics-Financial Reform-Billions Lost-P
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 7:05 am by Rocky
» Al-Mashhadani awaits the wrestling ring between Halbousi, Al-Issawi and Al-Khanjar
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 5:06 am by Rocky
» MP identifies 3 options for Sunni forces to elect Parliament Speaker
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 5:04 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Committee: The region continues to smuggle 300,000 barrels of oil per day
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 5:03 am by Rocky
» Al-Mandlawi calls on MPs to attend the session to elect the Speaker of Parliament
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 5:02 am by Rocky
» Political concern and parliamentary fear of the failure of the House of Representatives to choose it
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 5:01 am by Rocky
» The Democratic Bloc confirms that it will go with the Sunni majority to vote for the Parliament Spea
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:59 am by Rocky
» Masoud Barzani sets out principles for forming new Kurdistan Regional Government
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:58 am by Rocky
» Hours before the session... Sovereignty decides its position and "accepts" Al-Mashhadani as Parliame
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:57 am by Rocky
» The President of the Kurdistan Region issues a decision to establish three districts in Dohuk
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:56 am by Rocky
» Supreme Council for Youth: We are about to launch 10 new programs
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:54 am by Rocky
» Minister of Health: 19 contracts signed with “Private Wings”
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:53 am by Rocky
» Transport begins unifying Green Bird models
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:52 am by Rocky
» $6 billion is the volume of trade exchange between Iran and the Kurdistan Region
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:51 am by Rocky
» After years of controversy, Iran lifts the ban on iPhone customs
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:50 am by Rocky
» Environment: We have not yet controlled waste burning sites and landfill sites
Thu 31 Oct 2024, 4:48 am by Rocky