Iraq’s fiscal woes
JAMAL DOUMANI
Published — Sunday 12 April 2015
For weeks recently, all eyes were on Tikrit, where 30,000 Iraqi troops, two-thirds of whom Shiite “popular mobilization” militias coordinated by Iranian military advisers, wrested that Sunni town from IS forces who had holed up there since their blitz last summer.
The campaign highlighted one crucial fact: Without the support of precision airstrikes by the US-led coalition, the advance on Tikrit subduing the town would have been impossible, though to hear some government officials tell it, as the New York Times reported last week, “Americans deserved little or no credit, and many of the militiamen involved in the fight say the coalition air campaign actually impeded their victory, even though beforehand they had spent weeks in a stalemate with IS militants holed in Tikrit. Some even accused the US of fighting on the side of IS.”
So now all eyes will be on Mosul? I would direct these eyes elsewhere. The military campaign in Tikrit against IS, whose forces continue to occupy much of the north and the west of the country, was tough indeed. But a more daunting challenge in the coming months, perhaps even years, will not be Mosul, but Iraq’s fiscal problems. Wars are costly and Iraq, though not quite broke, has a depleted treasury. And governments with depleted treasuries can act strangely, irresponsibly and even desperately.
Few analysts in the Arab media write about it, but Iraq’s economy, afflicted with as many woes as its politics, is in shambles. Look at it this way: Iraq, like other oil producing countries in the region, relies on oil for virtually 90 percent of government revenue. But unlike them, it does not these days have the reserves to cushion it against the recent, precipitous fall in the price of oil. Over the last year, as every automobile driver in America and Europe will gleefully tell you, that price has dropped by more than half.
Earlier this year, the government in Baghdad cut its budget by 16 percent, slashing spending by all its ministries, including the defense ministry, and has resorted to ineffectual, some will say mickey mouse, efforts to garner funds, such as raising taxes on mobile phones, airline tickets, automobiles and cigarettes. Clearly that will not leave much of a dent in a projected deficit of $25 billion.
The Economist, quoting from the Economist Intelligence Unit, a sister company, explained that even that projection is optimistic. The magazine’s correspondent, filing from Baghdad, reported in the last week of March: “The budget is based on an oil price of $56 a barrel, and assumes exports of 3.3m barrels a day. In January Iraq exported 2.4 million b/d, at an average price of $41 a barrel.” And there you have it — a deficit far in excess of the projected $25 billion.
To avoid a gridlock, Baghdad is resorting to desperate measures, such as selling a $6 billion bond with Citigroup, borrowing from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank, dipping into the Central Bank’s reserves (estimated at $78 billion), even urging Kuwait to defer some of the reparation payments Iraq owes Kuwait for its 1990 invasion.
According to the IMF, Iraq’s economy has shrunk by 27 percent and unemployment now stands at over 25 percent, a figure that an industrialized nation, or a Third World nation with a dynamic economy, would consider disastrous. Moreover, foreign investment in Iraq, even before IS compounded the country’s many woes, was a pitiful $2.9 billion, which, again according to the Economist, is a “fraction of what Iraq needs to rebuild its war-torn infrastructure and revive its oil industry.”
And we have not yet begun to look at the bitter, and still unresolved, dispute between the central government in Baghdad and the Kurdish regional government in the north over the issue of an equitable distribution of oil revenue between them.
To be sure, IS has contributed to the current free-fall in Iraq’s economy, whose mainstay is oil — estimated at 143 billion barrels, the fifth largest in the world and the highest in the Middle East after Saudi Arabia and Iran. Traditionally, through its control of the oil sector, the central government, which employs about 40 percent of the labor force, influences virtually all the economic activity in the country, while the private sector plays a minor role.
In 2003, when the Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA) was established, its innocent experts, with doctorates in the discipline of economics, who knew, say, all about the co-efficient of cross elasticity but little about the Sunni-Shiite divide in Iraqi society, had a grand vision of an Iraq with a transformed, vibrant, diversified and modern economy, led by the private sector, and to that extent outlined the institutional reforms that would bring about that idealized outcome. All that came to naught, and as the Atlantic Council averred in a report last August, that same economy “remains virtually unchanged from the economy of Saddam Hussein days.”
Sadly, the conviction — or at least hope — that we all embraced at the end of 2011, when American forces ended their occupation and left it to Iraqis to run their own country, namely that Iraq will move on, has now crumbled to dust. IS, lest we forget, first emerged in Iraq, initially as a response to the sectarianism of a Shiite ruling elite that refused to believe that pluralism, along with social equity, not the domination of one sect or one tribe or one ethnic group over another, is the major building block of a stable, dynamic nation. Now we instead embrace the conviction that sometimes the chickens will come home to roost.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Today at 1:18 pm by wciappetta
» utube 5/23/24 MM&C Iraq Dinar - IQD Related Update - Global Interconnectivity - Timing - Delete Ze
Today at 12:13 pm by Rocky
» utube 5/21/24 MM&C Oil - Revenues - Exchange Rate Recovery - IQD Inevitable
Today at 12:10 pm by Rocky
» An economic expert calls on the government to extinguish private sector debt
Today at 12:07 pm by Rocky
» Sanad: The government reduced provincial budgets to 2.5 trillion dinars
Today at 12:06 pm by Rocky
» Increase in foreign remittance sales at the Central Bank of Iraq auction
Today at 12:04 pm by Rocky
» Minister: The development road project will pass through the Kurdistan Region
Today at 12:03 pm by Rocky
» Al-Handal stresses Iraq's commitment to combating money laundering.. What about inflation?
Today at 12:01 pm by Rocky
» A parliamentarian acknowledges that the development path is exposed to international and regional pr
Today at 12:00 pm by Rocky
» Electricity announces the stability of the arrival of Iranian gas quantities
Today at 11:59 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance reveals the Kurdistan region's share of the budget
Today at 11:58 am by Rocky
» Hussein Al-Shahristani, head of an international organization concerned with nuclear disarmament
Today at 11:56 am by Rocky
» Advisor to the Prime Minister: A major campaign to reconstruct all affected areas will be launched s
Today at 11:54 am by Rocky
» The Prime Minister calls on the private industrial sector to invest in the raw materials available i
Today at 11:52 am by Rocky
» Association of Private Banks: Iraq is committed to combating money laundering and the banking sector
Today at 11:51 am by Rocky
» Khamenei to Al-Sudani: An informant will continue to cooperate with the Iraqi government
Today at 11:47 am by Rocky
» A new meeting of Parliamentary Finance to discuss the details of the budget schedules
Today at 11:45 am by Rocky
» Barzani calls on Washington for help: The Kurdistan region is in danger
Today at 11:44 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Immigration emphasizes solving the problems of the displaced areas before finalizing t
Today at 11:39 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance: We are determined to complete the budget schedules before the start of the le
Today at 11:37 am by Rocky
» An economic expert depends on the speed of approval of the budget schedules on the number of its art
Today at 11:36 am by Rocky
» A Sudanese advisor expects Parliament to approve the budget schedules before Eid... and warns of del
Today at 11:34 am by Rocky
» Its government's crisis... Kirkuk does not move and waits for the Sudanese
Today at 10:26 am by Rocky
» The Shiites are moving to remove him.. The parliamentary presidency is held by Al-Halbousi’s bullyin
Today at 10:25 am by Rocky
» With the Sunni consensus... Al-Maliki's coalition comments on the crisis of the presidency of Parlia
Today at 10:24 am by Rocky
» Observer: Parliament management needs broader powers
Today at 10:23 am by Rocky
» A politician calls for confronting Biden's decision on Iraq
Today at 10:22 am by Rocky
» Fair competition, where are we?
Today at 10:20 am by Rocky
» The service effort ends its work in one of the neighborhoods of the capital, Baghdad
Today at 10:18 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance identifies the most prominent budget problems: Reducing the deficit requires a
Today at 10:17 am by Rocky
» Al-Handal stresses Iraq's commitment to combating money laundering.. What about inflation?
Today at 10:16 am by Rocky
» A huge government campaign to reconstruct the affected areas is about to be launched
Today at 10:15 am by Rocky
» Minister of Communications: The fiber optic project will be an alternative to WiFi towers
Today at 10:14 am by Rocky
» Maysan Oil implements 40 projects for the social benefits program
Today at 10:12 am by Rocky
» The Intelligence and Air Defense laws are on the parliamentary security table
Today at 10:11 am by Rocky
» Planning: The population will keep pace with global technological technologies
Today at 10:10 am by Rocky
» Work: Oil companies cheat with the number of foreign workers
Today at 10:09 am by Rocky
» Investment projects in Samarra
Today at 10:07 am by Rocky
» Combating terrorism is a five-year strategy to confront challenges
Today at 10:05 am by Rocky
» Iraq and the international economic map
Today at 10:04 am by Rocky
» Measures to prevent stock manipulation
Today at 10:02 am by Rocky
» Mazhar Muhammad Saleh: Increased bank lending activity increases growth and prosperity
Today at 10:00 am by Rocky
» Car specification
Today at 9:59 am by Rocky
» Experts: Iraq is outside the global inflation cycle
Today at 9:58 am by Rocky
» Iraq is discussing with the International Civil Aviation Organization the import of foreign experts
Today at 9:57 am by Rocky
» After its acceptance by the Financial Action Task Force, the Anti-Money Laundering Council reviews t
Today at 9:55 am by Rocky
» Within the 2024 budget.. Sudanese announces a package of projects for the upper threshold
Today at 9:53 am by Rocky
» Regional elections: warnings that the democratic process is at risk and demands for Washington’s int
Today at 9:52 am by Rocky
» High exchange rates in Baghdad...more than 145 thousand for every 100 dollars
Today at 9:51 am by Rocky
» More than 64 trillion... An economist indicates the risks of the 2024 budget deficit - urgent
Today at 9:50 am by Rocky
» Kurdish industrialists and professionals receive privileges from their counterparts in Baghdad
Today at 9:47 am by Rocky
» Planning: 78 patent certificates have been granted since the beginning of this year
Today at 9:47 am by Rocky
» The Ministry of Education and the European Union, together with UNESCO and UNICEF, launched the Equi
Today at 9:45 am by Rocky
» Deleting the 3 most important days in the history of Iraq.. The “religious holidays” law is an ackno
Today at 9:44 am by Rocky
» The blacklist for the “theft of the century” rises to nine names... secret investigations and waitin
Today at 9:43 am by Rocky
» International organization: 62% of displaced people and returnees in Nineveh have no source of incom
Today at 9:42 am by Rocky
» Neither military nor security...Biden's decision to extend the emergency in Iraq protects Baghdad's
Today at 9:40 am by Rocky
» In Al-Sumaria bulletin.. Parliament enacts the “Ghadir Holiday” and moves towards the 2024 budget
Today at 9:38 am by Rocky
» The Anti-Money Laundering and Terrorism Financing Council discusses the state’s efforts to combat cr
Today at 9:36 am by Rocky
» A government committee issues guidance regarding those who are hesitant about the issue of the Iraqi
Today at 9:34 am by Rocky
» From UNESCO.. The head of the Information Commission confirms Iraq’s commitment to media conventions
Today at 9:33 am by Rocky
» Is Iraq conducting negotiations with Germany to return its refugees?
Today at 9:30 am by Rocky
» The sources of power and authority in Iraq are a deep, not deep, country
Today at 9:29 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Health sounds the alarm: influential figures protect unlicensed beauty centers
Today at 9:28 am by Rocky
» From Najaf.. Al-Sudani reiterates: Infrastructure projects must be implemented
Today at 9:26 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani launches work on the plate glass production project in Najaf Industrial City
Today at 9:26 am by Rocky
» Iraq extends the memorandum to supply oil to Jordan
Today at 9:24 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary finances regarding the region’s share of the budget: amounted to 20 trillion dinars
Today at 9:23 am by Rocky
» utube 5/22/24 Iraqi Dinar $3.90 STARTS ON FOREX News Guru Intel Update Value IQD Exchange R
Yesterday at 1:15 pm by Rocky
» Political bloc: Progress has lost all its cards in the House of Representatives
Yesterday at 11:56 am by Rocky
» The Finance Committee holds its first meeting to study the budget schedules
Yesterday at 11:54 am by Rocky
» Agricultural associations demand penalties against those who market spoiled wheat
Yesterday at 11:52 am by Rocky
» Central Bank sales increased at today's auction
Yesterday at 11:50 am by Rocky
» Iraq is close to completing a final plan to develop Baghdad International Airport
Yesterday at 11:48 am by Rocky
» The government takes a number of new decisions
Yesterday at 11:46 am by Rocky
» The first parliamentary meeting to discuss the general budget schedules... agreeing to host two mini
Yesterday at 11:43 am by Rocky
» Learn about dollar sales outlets for pilgrims
Yesterday at 11:40 am by Rocky
» It includes 6 paragraphs... The House of Representatives holds a new session
Yesterday at 11:33 am by Rocky
» The House of Representatives votes on the proposed Second Amendment Law to the Election Commission L
Yesterday at 11:31 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance: Voting on the budget tables will not exceed next June 9
Yesterday at 10:22 am by Rocky
» Al-Rafidain Bank: Launching the process of selling the dollar to pilgrims exclusively at 3 thousand
Yesterday at 10:21 am by Rocky
» The rise of Bitcoin, the second largest cryptocurrency, jumps by more than 22%
Yesterday at 10:20 am by Rocky
» A representative from the front: Al-Halbousi directed the representatives to create chaos in Parliam
Yesterday at 10:17 am by Rocky
» Dhi Qar Energy announces the imminent establishment of a private company for the governorate’s elect
Yesterday at 10:14 am by Rocky
» The Sunnis are calling on the Shiites for help to resolve their differences, and Big Brother is resp
Yesterday at 10:12 am by Rocky
» A former MP reveals: Türkiye ignored solving the problem of oil exports... for this reason
Yesterday at 10:11 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Legal: Political differences hinder the passage of important laws
Yesterday at 10:09 am by Rocky
» MP: Parliament does not have the right to propose amending the salary scale...for this reason
Yesterday at 10:08 am by Rocky
» Deputy: Parliament continues to perform its oversight and legislative duties
Yesterday at 10:07 am by Rocky
» Khamenei to Al-Sudani: Mokhbar has a great responsibility and will continue to cooperate with the Ir
Yesterday at 10:05 am by Rocky
» "Al-Eqtisad News" publishes the full decisions of the Council of Ministers session
Yesterday at 10:04 am by Rocky
» The Central Bank determines the branches for selling dollars to pilgrims
Yesterday at 10:02 am by Rocky
» Iraq intends to deliver the capacity of the northern refineries to 600 thousand barrels per day
Yesterday at 10:00 am by Rocky
» Referring the 2024 budget tables to Parliamentary Finance
Yesterday at 9:59 am by Rocky
» Former MP: Türkiye ignored solving the oil exports problem for this reason
Yesterday at 9:58 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Electricity expects: power supply will reach 16 hours this summer
Yesterday at 9:57 am by Rocky
» In the document... Al-Mandalawi refers the draft Federal Budget Law 2024 to the Parliamentary Financ
Yesterday at 9:55 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance Committee to / NINA /: Today the committee meetings will begin to discuss the
Yesterday at 9:54 am by Rocky
» Opening of the optical access network project today in Basra
Yesterday at 9:47 am by Rocky