Home
When the crypto crisis hits (and it soon will), the U.S. will be forced to strip away the cloak of anonymity that facilitates criminal acts and which gives crypto its allure
Kenneth Rogoff 4 hrs ago
Getty Images/iStockphotoPROJECT SYNDICATE
CAMBRIDGE, Mass. (Project Syndicate)—With cryptocurrency prices plummeting as central banks start to raise interest rates, many are wondering if this is the beginning of the end of the bubble.
Video: Crypto Creeps Out From Crisis (Bloomberg)
Skip Ad
5Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Ad
Current Time 0:00
/
Duration 0:00
Loaded: 0%
Mute
100
Caption
- captions and subtitles off, selected
[size]
Full screen
This is a modal window.
No compatible source was found for this media.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
TextColorWhiteBlackRedGreenBlueYellowMagentaCyanTransparencyOpaqueSemi-TransparentBackgroundColorBlackWhiteRedGreenBlueYellowMagentaCyanTransparencyOpaqueSemi-TransparentTransparentWindowColorBlackWhiteRedGreenBlueYellowMagentaCyanTransparencyTransparentSemi-TransparentOpaque
Font size50%75%100%125%150%175%200%300%400%Text edge styleNoneRaisedDepressedUniformDropshadowFont FamilyProportional Sans-SerifMonospace Sans-SerifProportional SerifMonospace SerifCasualScriptSmall Caps
Reset Restore all settings to the default values
Done
Close
End of dialog window.
Crypto Creeps Out From Crisis
Crypto Creeps Out From Crisis
Bloomberg See more videosSHARE
SHARE
TWEET
SHARE
What to watch next
[/size]
Making Profitability Is Top Priority: China's Netflix
Bloomberg
SpaceX Launches 59 Smaller Spacecraft
Bloomberg
How Solv Diversified Its Cap Table with All Female Round
Bloomberg
Google Cloud CEO on Momentum, Saudi Aramco
Bloomberg
A Digital Dollar Needs to Be Safe and Private: Lynch
Bloomberg
Charting Cloud Growth For Businesses, Startups
Bloomberg
Terra Blockchain to Split, Abandon Collapsed UST Stablecoin
Bloomberg
Twitter's Dorsey Exits Board; Durban Fails Re-Election Bid
Bloomberg
Key Takeaway's From the Twitter Shareholder Meeting
Bloomberg
Regulating Crypto Spot Markets and Stablecoins
Bloomberg
CA Board Diversity Law Struck Down, Despite Progress
Bloomberg
China Ride-Hailing Giant Didi Gets Green Light for New York Delisting
Bloomberg
Inflation Battle Continues
Bloomberg
Be Careful of "Hipster Antitrust" Push
Bloomberg
How Founders Can Navigate the Market Downturn
Bloomberg
Twitter Deal Is Going Ahead, Executives Say
Bloomberg
Perhaps not yet. But a higher opportunity cost of money disproportionately drives down the prices of assets whose main uses lie in the future. Ultralow interest rates flattered crypto, and young investors are now getting a taste of what happens when interest rates go up.
Load Error
A more interesting question is what will happen when governments finally get serious about regulating bitcoin and its brethren. Of the major economies, only China has so far begun to do so. Most policy makers have instead tried to change the topic by talking about central bank-issued digital currencies (CBDCs).
But this is something of a non sequitur.
President Biden’s cryptocurrency executive order may have produced more questions than it’s answered: What’s a central bank digital currency? How is it different from crypto? And why hasn’t the Fed introduced a digital dollar? WSJ’s Dion Rabouin explains. Photo composite: David Fang A growing problem
Although CBDCs are likely to include privacy features for small transactions, larger transactions will almost certainly require individuals to reveal their identity. In contrast, one of the biggest attractions of private cryptocurrencies is the opportunity they offer to bypass governments. True, cryptocurrency transactions are completely traceable through the blockchain ledger, but users typically set up accounts under pseudonyms and are therefore difficult to identify without other information, which is expensive to obtain.
Some economists naively argue that there is no particular urgency to regulate bitcoin and the like, because cryptocurrencies are difficult and costly to use for transactions. Try telling that to policy makers in developing economies, where crypto has become a significant vehicle for avoiding taxes, regulations, and capital controls.
Investing in some advanced-economy crypto vehicles is in a sense no different from investing in conflict diamonds.
For poorer countries with limited state capacity, crypto is a growing problem. Citizens don’t need to be computer whizzes to circumvent the authorities. They can just access one of several simple “off-chain” exchanges. Although cryptocurrency transactions intermediated by a third party are in principle traceable, the exchanges are based in advanced economies. In practice, this makes the information virtually inaccessible to poor-country authorities under most circumstances.Money laundering, tax evasion
But isn’t this just crypto fulfilling its promise of helping citizens bypass corrupt, inefficient, and untrustworthy governments? Maybe, but, just like $100 bills, cryptocurrencies in the developing world are as likely to be used by malign actors as by ordinary citizens.
For example, Venezuela is a major player in crypto markets, partly because expatriates use them to send money back and forth without it being seized by the country’s corrupt regime. But crypto is also surely used by the Venezuelan military in its drug-smuggling operations, not to mention by wealthy, politically connected individuals subject to financial sanctions.
Given that the United States currently maintains financial sanctions on more than a dozen countries, hundreds of entities, and thousands of individuals, crypto is a natural refuge.
One reason why advanced-economy regulators have been slow to act is the view that as long as cryptocurrency-related problems mainly affect the rest of the world, these problems are not their concern. Apparently buying into the idea that cryptocurrencies are essentially assets in which to invest—and that any transaction’s value is unimportant—the regulators are more worried about domestic investor protection and financial stability.
Crypto = conflict diamonds
But economic theory has long demonstrated that the value of any money ultimately depends on its potential underlying uses. The biggest investors in crypto may be in advanced economies, but the uses—and harms—have so far been mainly in emerging markets and developing economies. One might even argue that investing in some advanced-economy crypto vehicles is in a sense no different from investing in conflict diamonds.
Advanced-economy governments will most likely find that the problems with cryptocurrencies eventually come home to roost. When that happens, they will be forced to institute a broad-based ban on digital currencies that do not permit users’ identities to be easily traced (unless, that is, technological advances ultimately strip away all vestiges of anonymity, in which case cryptocurrencies’ prices will collapse on their own). The ban would certainly have to extend to financial institutions and businesses, and would likely also include some restrictions on individuals.
Such a step would sharply undercut today’s cryptocurrency prices by reducing liquidity. Of course, restrictions will be more effective the more countries apply them, but universal implementation is not required for significant local impact.
Stiff lobbying to prevent regulation
Can some version of a ban be implemented? As China has demonstrated, it is relatively easy to shutter the crypto exchanges that the vast majority of people use for trading digital currencies. It is more difficult to prevent “on-chain” transactions, as the underlying individuals are harder to identify. Ironically, an effective ban on 21st-century crypto might also require phasing out (or at least scaling back) the much older device of paper currency, because cash is by far the most convenient way for people to “on-ramp” funds into their digital wallets without being easily detected.
Just to be clear, I am not suggesting that all blockchain applications should be constrained. For example, regulated stablecoins, underpinned by a central-bank balance sheet, can still thrive, but there needs to be a straightforward legal mechanism for tracing a user’s identity if needed.
When, if ever, might stiffer cryptocurrency regulation actually happen? Absent a crisis, it could take many decades, especially with major crypto players pouring huge sums into lobbying, much as the financial sector did in the run-up to the 2008 global financial crisis. But it probably won’t take nearly that long. Unfortunately, the crypto crisis is likely to come sooner rather than later.
This commentary was published with permission of Project Syndicate—What’s the Crypto Regulation Endgame?
Kenneth Rogoff, professor of economics and public policy at Harvard University, was the chief economist of the International Monetary Fund from 2001 to 2003. He is co-author of “This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly” (Princeton University Press, 2011) and author of “The Curse of Cash” (Princeton University Press, 2016).
More on crypto regulation
Bipartisan crypto bill would have CFTC oversee bitcoin, ether and most other digital assets
Consumers report losing $1 billion in crypto to scammers since 2021, FTC study says
From Baron’s: Crypto’s Wild West Days May Be Coming to an End With New Bipartisan Senate Bill
https://www.marketwatch.com/story/when-the-crypto-crisis-hits-and-it-soon-will-the-u-s-will-be-forced-to-strip-away-the-cloak-of-anonymity-that-facilitates-criminal-acts-and-which-gives-crypto-its-allure-11654614986
» MM&C The Iraqi Private Banks Association told NEWS: These are the results of the Prime Minister’s me
» After a break of more than 9 years.. the resumption of a government trade meeting between Iraq and A
» Deputy: The general amnesty law will be passed
» A change in the fuel smuggling map... “control” over the central ports and “laxity” in the north
» Al-Sudani takes three urgent decisions to block the wheat mafias in Iraq
» Electricity embarks on an 11-axis plan to develop the energy sector
» “Thug and smuggler.” A female representative talks about a crocodile in Parliament blackmailing exec
» Al-Sudani told the US State Department: Iraq is keen to strengthen its democratic system
» The Central Bank sells more than $275 million at auction today
» The Minister of Commerce stresses the observance of the Iraqi standard in the supply of goods
» The Iraqi Trade Bank announces its participation in the process of localizing the salaries of Kurdis
» Iraq adopts an advanced system to combat money laundering and terrorist financing
» Increase in Euphrates River levels due to Turkish water releases
» Demands the need to legislate the capital law
» Parliament decided to extend the legislative term by one month
» A bank participating in the process of localizing the salaries of employees in the region
» Parliamentary request to the Ministry of Finance regarding defense mobilization dues/document
» Dollar prices in Baghdad and Kurdistan today
» Al-Rasheed decides to increase the ceiling for granting “construction” loans to 75 million dinars
» A government plan to expand the construction of water harvesting dams
» Frozen or banned? An Iranian official reveals the fate of Tehran’s money in Baghdad
» The Iraqi Trade Bank participates in the process of localizing the salaries of Kurdistan Region empl
» Finance confirms the Iraqi government's desire to benefit from the expertise of French companies
» After targeting its branch in Kurdistan... Dana Gas announces a decrease in its profits to $38 milli
» A parliamentary understanding to extend the legislative term to approve the 2024 budget schedules
» Stopping the Commission’s procedures regarding the region’s elections
» Foreign oil companies violate Iraqi laws
» The position of Speaker of Parliament depends on the political agreement
» The Ministry of Finance decides to send the April salary to the Kurdistan region
» It did not reach the Council.. Parliament determines the mechanisms for dealing with the 2024 budget
» 88 projects awaiting resolution.. What will happen to the stalled laws in Parliament? - Urgent
» Al-Sudani receives the US Undersecretary of State
» It did not reach the Council.. Parliament determines the mechanisms for dealing with the 2024 budget
» Advisor to Al-Sudani: Sanctions on 32 private banks caused financial problems inside Iraq (video)
» An expert comments on the use of the Iraqi currency in commercial transactions with Iran
» Why does Iraq depend on foreign banks for dollar transfers?
» Deputy: The fuel smuggling map in Iraq has “radically changed” from what it was years ago
» Petroleum Products announces a decrease in gasoline imports by about 8 million liters
» Government advisor: Collections will shift almost completely to electronic payment in the middle of
» Complete decisions of the Council of Ministers session
» Al-Sudani chairs the first meeting to restructure the government apparatus
» The National University holds its second international scientific conference with the participation
» Parliamentary proposals to extend the legislative term of the House of Representatives to resolve th
» Hanoun: We are working on preparing a six-year strategy to combat corruption based on technology
» The Ministerial Council for the Economy decides to stop the import of 6 crops due to their abundance
» Minister of Industry: He turned to Chinese companies to supply Iraq with spongy iron ores
» A foreign report reveals the existence of an undeclared Iraqi-British agreement regarding asylum see
» “Fares Issa” visits the Ministry of Finance and Economy in the Kurdistan Region
» Nechirvan Barzani: We want to address all problems with Iran and begin a new phase of relations
» The position of Speaker of Parliament.. Representatives confirm: “There is no amendment to the bylaw
» Demands to put an end to foreign workers
» Iranian official: We do not have frozen funds in Iraq
» Entering 31 countries in the world without a visa.. A look at the Iraqi passport during 2024
» An Iranian plan to export goods to Iraq worth $3 billion
» The Board of Commissioners decides to suspend the technical and financial procedures for the Kurdist
» Baghdad Governorate approves the two paths of the development road
» Mawazine publishes the full decisions of the Council of Ministers at its session today
» Asaib: The Sunnis are accustomed to having an external actor leading them
» The Iranian ambassador in Baghdad: The Sudanese government enjoys the support of the Shiite and Sunn
» Politician: Representatives of Taqadum “hurt” Al-Halbousi and their party
» “Deficit” is the password.. Parliamentary Finance decodes the budget delay
» Al-Sudani: The tourism sector will be a substitute resource for oil in the coming years
» Finance confirms the Iraqi government's desire to benefit from the expertise of French companies
» utube 5/4/24 MM&C Iraq Dinar- IQD Update - No Float of Exchange Rate - Budget -2024 - Schedules -
» After a break of more than 9 years.. the resumption of a government trade meeting between Iraq and A
» A deputy in finance expects the Council of Ministers to approve the budget schedules in today’s sess
» A deputy resolves the controversy over the “transfer supplement” in two ministries
» Al-Halbousi’s “vacant” seat.. Will the coordination framework end the “Taqaddum” dream of an allianc
» The Federal Government issues a state order to stop the Commission’s work procedures regarding the K
» Including the freedom to choose the bank and withdraw the salary for “free”... “My Account” features
» The Central Bank sells more than $250 million during its daily auction
» Al-Sudani receives a delegation from the Union of Arab Banks
» Iraq and the United States of America hold trade meetings in Washington
» In pictures... The activities of the Union of Arab Banks conference in Baghdad, “Day Two”
» The Director General of Ports announces the completion of berths (3) and (4) in Al-Faw Grand Port
» The Council of Ministers holds its regular session headed by Al-Sudani
» Parliament publishes the agenda of its session for next Thursday
» A government measure to reduce "money laundering" using the buying and selling of real estate in Ira
» Iraq proposes establishing a specialized council to combat corruption in Arab countries
» Al-Mawarid intends to establish infrastructure and investment projects for the water sector in Iraq
» The Federal Court issues a decision regarding postponing the election of the Speaker of the House of
» A government meeting to discuss financing and implementation mechanisms for the Development Road Pro
» Al-Sudani: Iraqi banks are on the right track with financial transfers
» Al-Khazali: The Turkish side is still imposing its conditions on Iraq
» Rights: We refuse to amend the bylaws of Parliament under political influence and desires
» Nechirvan Barzani: We want to address all problems with Iran and begin a new phase of relations
» Today, Iraq and Iran signed the minutes of a joint meeting related to trade
» KPMG International begins auditing the revenues of telephone companies operating in Iraq
» Oil: The seventh batch of equipment for the gas manufacturing project in the Nasiriyah and Gharraf f
» Al-Sudani assures the French ambassador of Iraq’s openness to “fruitful” partnerships
» Government move to install gold screening devices at 4 airports
» Sudanese Advisor: The oil sector is witnessing a rapid renaissance
» Opening offices specialized in employing people with disabilities
» Infrastructure and investment projects for the water sector in Iraq
» Adopting the electronic system in the next census
» Al-Sudani chairs the first meeting to restructure the government apparatus
» Business Council: Efforts to open a branch of the Chinese Bank in Iraq
» Iraqi diplomacy is balanced openness