Home
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
Iraqi Dinar Reset The Redenomination Battle
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
By Joseph Cafariello
Wednesday, July 24th, 2013
There is a growing division among investors over the fate of Iraq?s currency, the dinar. While some expect the IQD?s redenomination to lift the dinar?s value dramatically higher, others say it will have no effect on the money?s value at all.
Iraqi politicians are equally at odds with one another, with some strongly for and others strongly against the plan. But isn?t redenomination supposed to be good for the nation?s currency? Why are they stalling?
Opposing Views in Government
The plan to redenominate the dinar by dropping 3 zeros off its notes has been anticipated since the Iraqi government first announced it back in 2010. The reason for the redenomination is to make transactions and accounting easier for the government, banks, and the general populace. As Shayya, an MP for the State of Law Coalition, explained to the Middle Eastern newspaper Al-Monitor:
?The Iraqi currency is weak, and the money supply has amounted to multi-trillions because of the existence of these useless zeros. The country will witness a significant increase in oil revenues, financial earnings and high budgets. Thus, we need to print new banknotes, as estimated by the Central Bank.?
Indeed, now that the UN has removed Chapter 7 restrictions from the nation, Iraq is fully open for business again and will see ever increasing trade over the coming years. A new currency with fewer zeros will make things so much easier.
Yet some in the Iraqi government are reluctant to move ahead with the change, upsetting a number of redenomination advocates, including MP Nahida Daini, who lamented, ?The Council of Ministers asked to delay the process for fear of money laundering operations.? Daini believes such fears are baseless, reassuring that ?there are regulators in Iraq who can follow up and ensure the integrity of the project.?
Those opposed to redenomination, though, are adamant that the Iraqi government is simply not yet ready for such a monumental task. Mudher Mohammad Saleh, former deputy governor of the Central Bank of Iraq, stessed to Al-Monitor that the deletion of zeros ?does not only involve changing the design of the currency; it implies changing the economic system in the country in general.? He warned that ?the decision to implement the deletion of zeros next year is very dangerous and risky? and ?must be done at the appropriate time.?
In the meantime, ruling officials would rather see the Iraqi government focus on other ways of stabilizing its currency and economy. As Magda al-Tamimi, member of the parliamentary Finance Committee, described it, ?Iraq is not ready to control the possible currency fraud that may result from the deletion of zeros. The Finance Committee is now working toward controlling the Iraqi currency auction, which is witnessing a significant fluctuation in the exchange rate of the Iraqi dinar against the dollar.?
Through these daily currency auctions, the Central Bank of Iraq issues U.S. dollars only to registered banks, importers, and other firms who need USD for conducting international transactions. By thus restricting the amount of USD circulating in Iraq, the CBI manages to control the value of the IQD, holding it at a steady rate.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
By deliberately controlling the IQD:USD exchange rate, the Iraqi central bank ensures the IQD remains weak, as can be evidenced on the chart above. Every time the dinar starts to strengthen (shown by descending plotlines), the CBI manages to bring it right back to its desired exchange rate.
Why? Because maintaining a cheap IQD means that every U.S. dollar of oil revenue the country brings in would be worth more dinars, allowing the country to print more of its own money, which would then allow it to pay for more reconstruction, hire more unemployed, and stimulate its economy. Almost every other nation in the world is trying to keep its currency weak for the same reasons.
Even as Tamimi confirms, ?Development is the gateway to strengthening the currency. Thus, raising the value of the dinar is more important than the deletion of zeros.?
Can Redenomination Include Higher Valuation?
But Tamimi?s comment brings up a very interesting point. While many investors in the Iraqi dinar believe its redenomination (chopping off 3 zeros) will be accompanied by a revaluation (a sudden increase in the value of the new Iraqi money), Tamimi?s statement shows the two events do not happen together. They are two separate concepts that do not coincide.
In stating that ?raising the value of the dinar? (through CBI-controlled daily auctions) is ?more important than the deletion of zeros,? she implies that the deletion of zeros would not strengthen the dinar. Tamimi wants to see a strong dinar, but she sees exchange rate controls as accomplishing that more than the deletion of zeros would.
Think, too, of the implications of Iraq simply declaring its new money as being more valuable overnight. Currently, it takes about 1,164 IQD to buy 1 U.S. dollar. When the Iraqi government deletes 3 zeros, it would take 1.164 of the new money to buy 1 U.S. dollar.
Yet if the Iraqi government takes the additional step of increasing the value of the new money ? let?s say by doubling it ? then that same 1.164 of new money would buy 2 U.S. dollars. This would mean that with one stroke of the pen, the nation of Iraq would be worth twice as much in USD as before, overnight.
However, the amount of assets the country owns would still be the same the day after the revaluation as it was the day before. So where would that additional value come from? Is there suddenly twice as much oil in Iraq?s stockpile? No. Is there suddenly twice as much gold in Iraq?s vaults? No.
Other nations would protest. In order for the government to declare its money to be suddenly worth twice as much in USD as before, it would have to provide assets to account for that extra wealth in USD ? not underground reserves, but actual exchangeable assets.
A nation?s currency is not a representation of its wealth. A nation?s currency is simply a representation of its assets. Its assets are the true indication of a nation?s wealth. If a nation?s assets have not changed, its wealth will not change either, regardless of any changes it makes to its money.
Even as 1,000 old money is worth 1 new money, they will still be worth the same in USD because the entire country of Iraq will still be worth the same in USD on the day of the conversion as it was the day before.
Investing in Iraq?s Future
Iraq will some day ? and not far into the future either ? mount one of the greatest comebacks since Japan and Germany after the second world war. Iraq is destined to become the world?s second largest oil exporter, and it will be rich.
It makes sense, then, to invest in the country early on, while it is still under development. But there are better ways of doing it than buying a fixed IQD that does not trade freely.
Iraq has an active stock market, the Iraqi Stock Exchange (ISX), which currently lists more than 100 companies including industrials, banks, insurers, hotels, and telecoms ? all sectors which will undoubtedly flourish as the nation develops.
It may be complicated for a foreigner to invest in the ISX. However, many companies listed in Iraq are listed in other countries as well where it may be easier for you to trade.
The IQD, however, is a different story. The Iraqi government simply cannot afford to let its currency trade freely on an open market at the whim of supply and demand forces. If it were allowed to trade freely, it would probably strengthen to a certain extent, as graphs show. But this would lead to deflation, make money too expensive for businesses to get their hands on, and it would ultimately stop the economy?s gears from turning.
A strong IQD would shut Iraq down like the 2008 credit crisis nearly shut American down. And just as the U.S. central bank has been doing all it can to keep interest rates down and prevent the USD from strengthening too much, so too will the CBI continue to do what it can to keep the IQD down.
Since redenomination is not the same as revaluation, investors would do best to find other ways of benefiting from Iraq?s future rise, since they won?t find it in the dinar ? no matter how many or how few zeros it has.
Joseph Cafariello
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
Iraqi Dinar Reset The Redenomination Battle
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
By Joseph Cafariello
Wednesday, July 24th, 2013
There is a growing division among investors over the fate of Iraq?s currency, the dinar. While some expect the IQD?s redenomination to lift the dinar?s value dramatically higher, others say it will have no effect on the money?s value at all.
Iraqi politicians are equally at odds with one another, with some strongly for and others strongly against the plan. But isn?t redenomination supposed to be good for the nation?s currency? Why are they stalling?
Opposing Views in Government
The plan to redenominate the dinar by dropping 3 zeros off its notes has been anticipated since the Iraqi government first announced it back in 2010. The reason for the redenomination is to make transactions and accounting easier for the government, banks, and the general populace. As Shayya, an MP for the State of Law Coalition, explained to the Middle Eastern newspaper Al-Monitor:
?The Iraqi currency is weak, and the money supply has amounted to multi-trillions because of the existence of these useless zeros. The country will witness a significant increase in oil revenues, financial earnings and high budgets. Thus, we need to print new banknotes, as estimated by the Central Bank.?
Indeed, now that the UN has removed Chapter 7 restrictions from the nation, Iraq is fully open for business again and will see ever increasing trade over the coming years. A new currency with fewer zeros will make things so much easier.
Yet some in the Iraqi government are reluctant to move ahead with the change, upsetting a number of redenomination advocates, including MP Nahida Daini, who lamented, ?The Council of Ministers asked to delay the process for fear of money laundering operations.? Daini believes such fears are baseless, reassuring that ?there are regulators in Iraq who can follow up and ensure the integrity of the project.?
Those opposed to redenomination, though, are adamant that the Iraqi government is simply not yet ready for such a monumental task. Mudher Mohammad Saleh, former deputy governor of the Central Bank of Iraq, stessed to Al-Monitor that the deletion of zeros ?does not only involve changing the design of the currency; it implies changing the economic system in the country in general.? He warned that ?the decision to implement the deletion of zeros next year is very dangerous and risky? and ?must be done at the appropriate time.?
In the meantime, ruling officials would rather see the Iraqi government focus on other ways of stabilizing its currency and economy. As Magda al-Tamimi, member of the parliamentary Finance Committee, described it, ?Iraq is not ready to control the possible currency fraud that may result from the deletion of zeros. The Finance Committee is now working toward controlling the Iraqi currency auction, which is witnessing a significant fluctuation in the exchange rate of the Iraqi dinar against the dollar.?
Through these daily currency auctions, the Central Bank of Iraq issues U.S. dollars only to registered banks, importers, and other firms who need USD for conducting international transactions. By thus restricting the amount of USD circulating in Iraq, the CBI manages to control the value of the IQD, holding it at a steady rate.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
By deliberately controlling the IQD:USD exchange rate, the Iraqi central bank ensures the IQD remains weak, as can be evidenced on the chart above. Every time the dinar starts to strengthen (shown by descending plotlines), the CBI manages to bring it right back to its desired exchange rate.
Why? Because maintaining a cheap IQD means that every U.S. dollar of oil revenue the country brings in would be worth more dinars, allowing the country to print more of its own money, which would then allow it to pay for more reconstruction, hire more unemployed, and stimulate its economy. Almost every other nation in the world is trying to keep its currency weak for the same reasons.
Even as Tamimi confirms, ?Development is the gateway to strengthening the currency. Thus, raising the value of the dinar is more important than the deletion of zeros.?
Can Redenomination Include Higher Valuation?
But Tamimi?s comment brings up a very interesting point. While many investors in the Iraqi dinar believe its redenomination (chopping off 3 zeros) will be accompanied by a revaluation (a sudden increase in the value of the new Iraqi money), Tamimi?s statement shows the two events do not happen together. They are two separate concepts that do not coincide.
In stating that ?raising the value of the dinar? (through CBI-controlled daily auctions) is ?more important than the deletion of zeros,? she implies that the deletion of zeros would not strengthen the dinar. Tamimi wants to see a strong dinar, but she sees exchange rate controls as accomplishing that more than the deletion of zeros would.
Think, too, of the implications of Iraq simply declaring its new money as being more valuable overnight. Currently, it takes about 1,164 IQD to buy 1 U.S. dollar. When the Iraqi government deletes 3 zeros, it would take 1.164 of the new money to buy 1 U.S. dollar.
Yet if the Iraqi government takes the additional step of increasing the value of the new money ? let?s say by doubling it ? then that same 1.164 of new money would buy 2 U.S. dollars. This would mean that with one stroke of the pen, the nation of Iraq would be worth twice as much in USD as before, overnight.
However, the amount of assets the country owns would still be the same the day after the revaluation as it was the day before. So where would that additional value come from? Is there suddenly twice as much oil in Iraq?s stockpile? No. Is there suddenly twice as much gold in Iraq?s vaults? No.
Other nations would protest. In order for the government to declare its money to be suddenly worth twice as much in USD as before, it would have to provide assets to account for that extra wealth in USD ? not underground reserves, but actual exchangeable assets.
A nation?s currency is not a representation of its wealth. A nation?s currency is simply a representation of its assets. Its assets are the true indication of a nation?s wealth. If a nation?s assets have not changed, its wealth will not change either, regardless of any changes it makes to its money.
Even as 1,000 old money is worth 1 new money, they will still be worth the same in USD because the entire country of Iraq will still be worth the same in USD on the day of the conversion as it was the day before.
Investing in Iraq?s Future
Iraq will some day ? and not far into the future either ? mount one of the greatest comebacks since Japan and Germany after the second world war. Iraq is destined to become the world?s second largest oil exporter, and it will be rich.
It makes sense, then, to invest in the country early on, while it is still under development. But there are better ways of doing it than buying a fixed IQD that does not trade freely.
Iraq has an active stock market, the Iraqi Stock Exchange (ISX), which currently lists more than 100 companies including industrials, banks, insurers, hotels, and telecoms ? all sectors which will undoubtedly flourish as the nation develops.
It may be complicated for a foreigner to invest in the ISX. However, many companies listed in Iraq are listed in other countries as well where it may be easier for you to trade.
The IQD, however, is a different story. The Iraqi government simply cannot afford to let its currency trade freely on an open market at the whim of supply and demand forces. If it were allowed to trade freely, it would probably strengthen to a certain extent, as graphs show. But this would lead to deflation, make money too expensive for businesses to get their hands on, and it would ultimately stop the economy?s gears from turning.
A strong IQD would shut Iraq down like the 2008 credit crisis nearly shut American down. And just as the U.S. central bank has been doing all it can to keep interest rates down and prevent the USD from strengthening too much, so too will the CBI continue to do what it can to keep the IQD down.
Since redenomination is not the same as revaluation, investors would do best to find other ways of benefiting from Iraq?s future rise, since they won?t find it in the dinar ? no matter how many or how few zeros it has.
Joseph Cafariello
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
» Al-Sudani chairs the fifth session of the Supreme Coordination Committee between the governorates
» A fruitful international-Japanese partnership produces its eighth batch... Celebrating the success o
» The President of the Republic stresses the need to develop a future strategy for financial policy ac
» Tomorrow.. Turkish Trade Minister visits Baghdad to discuss several files
» Rashid and Al-Alaq discuss the future of the Iraqi banking sector
» US Ambassador assures Maliki of her country's support for Iraq's stability
» Parliamentarian addressing the Judicial Council: When will corruption files be resolved?
» Economist: Re-exporting Kurdistan oil will cause Iraq to lose $5 billion and a budget deficit
» Financial Advisor: Good performance of fiscal space reflects government’s ability to increase spendi
» The President of the Republic stresses the need to develop a future strategy for financial policy
» Parliament determines the most important laws it will work on before its legislative break in a few
» Dollar exchange rates against the dinar in Iraqi stock exchanges
» Government correspondence to install 8 thousand electricity meter readers
» utube 11/16/24 MM&C-News Report-Iraq Dinar-Oil-Flow-Global Maritime Trade-Cross Border Transfer-Ex
» utube 11/13/24 MM&C MM&C News-Private Sector- Electronic Payments-Reconstruction-Development-Digit
» utube MM&C 11/15/24 Update-Budget-Non Oil Resources-CBI-USFED-Cross Border Transfers-Oil
» Al-Sudani is besieged by lawsuits over the “wiretapping network”... and Al-Maliki heard “inappropria
» Tens of thousands of foreigners work illegally in Basra... and the departments will bear the respons
» 4 reasons for the Sudanese government’s silence in the face of the factions’ attacks.. Will Baghdad
» PM's advisor: Government able to increase spending without inflation or fiscal deficit
» Prime Minister stresses the need to complete 2024 projects before the end
» Minister of Labor sets date for launching second batch of social protection beneficiaries in the pol
» Al-Sudani approves 35 new service projects, stresses the need to complete 2024 projects
» Minister of Labor: The population census will provide accurate calculations of poor families covered
» Electricity announces its readiness for the winter peak
» Economist: Parallel market remains pivotal to financing Iraq’s trade with Iran, Syria
» Trump: Iraq: A subsidiary or the focus of major deals?
» Counselor Mazhar Saleh: The government is able to increase spending without causing inflation or a f
» Al-Sudani's advisor to "Al-Maalouma": We do not need to bring in foreign workers
» Parliamentary Rejection.. Parliamentarian Talks About Jordanian Agreement That Harms Iraq’s Economy
» Al-Sudani chairs the periodic meeting of the service and engineering effort team
» Al-Sahaf: Washington continues to support terrorist organizations in Iraq
» Al-Maliki Coalition: America is trying to make Iraq hostile to its neighbors by violating its airspa
» Close source: Al-Sudani failed to convince Al-Hakim and Al-Amiri to carry out the ministerial reshuf
» Al-Sayhoud on Postponing Parliament Sessions: Bad Start for Al-Mashhadani
» Peshmerga Minister: The survival of the Kurdistan Region depends on the presence of a strong Peshmer
» Al-Maliki Coalition: US pressures prevent Israel from striking Iraq
» Nechirvan Barzani calls for keeping Peshmerga out of partisan conflicts, urges formation of 'strong
» US Institute: Trump administration may prevent Iraq from importing Iranian gas as part of pressure o
» The meter will visit families again.. Planning details the steps for conducting the population censu
» Government clarification: Is Iraq able to increase spending?
» Iraq advances over China.. Iran's trade exchange witnesses growth during October
» Al-Sudani approves 35 new service projects and begins implementing them within 10 days
» Al-Sudani and Al-Hakim discuss developments in the political scene and the results of the visit to K
» Minister of Labor: Government measures contributed to reducing the poverty rate from 22% to 16.5%
» Al-Maliki calls for strengthening national dialogue and unity to overcome the current stage
» Al-Sudani stresses the importance of accuracy and specifications in service and engineering projects
» Baghdad Governor: 169 projects are listed for referral and contracting
» Industry confirms success by signing 4 investment contracts for strategic industries
» Parliament confirms its support for conducting the general population census and decides to resume s
» Parliament gains a "holiday and a half"... Half of the "extended" legislative term passes without se
» Find out the exchange rates of the dollar against the dinar in the Iraqi stock exchanges
» Al-Maliki describes tribes as a "pillar" for confronting challenges in Iraq
» The plan in the "distribution method".. A representative describes the "investment achievement" as n
» Iraq is ahead of China in trade exchange with Iran.. These are the numbers
» MM&C 11/14/24 Central Bank Governor Urges Türkiye to Open Accounts for Iraqi Banks
» MM&C 11/14/24 Trump and the Iraqi Banks Puzzle
» New decline in gold in Iraq.. and globally records the worst week in 3 years
» Monitoring body approves 2023 imports annual report
» Development Road: Faw Port Ignites Regional Corridor Race
» First in Iraq... Diyala sets a plan for "rural reconstruction"
» Al-Saadi: Influential parties are working to erase the theft of the century file
» MP: Baghdad supports the "Diyala Artery" project with 40 billion dinars
» Source: General amnesty law will pave the way for the return of terrorist groups
» The Prime Minister stresses the need to expedite the completion of the requirements for restructurin
» Minister of Resources: The project to develop the left side of the Tigris River has reached its fina
» Foreign Minister: We are proceeding with implementing the associated gas exploitation program
» Swiss Ambassador Expresses His Country's Desire to Invest in Iraq
» "We left the camel and its load" .. Moroccan farmers await "imminent compensation" from Iraq
» OPEC sues Iraqi minister over oil violations.. What is Kurdistan's involvement?
» Iraq warns of 'dire consequences' of imposing barriers to plastic products
» Iranian newspaper: Iraq's development path is a step towards regional economic integration
» Al-Mandlawi discusses with the Russian ambassador developing relations in the fields of economy, inv
» Oil Minister discusses with Dutch Ambassador strengthening bilateral relations
» The Minister of Oil discusses with the companies "+dss" and "Xergy", joint cooperation to develop th
» Rafidain Bank announces a plan to include other branches in the implementation of the comprehensive
» With the presence of the opposition... Baghdad supports the partnership government in Kurdistan
» Parliamentary move to raise retirement age in state institutions to 63 years
» Through leaks.. Warnings against creating political crises as parliamentary elections approach
» Iraqi oil returns to decline in global markets
» Parliamentary Committee: Iraq uses its international relations to avert the dangers of war from its
» The value of non-oil imports for Sulaymaniyah and Halabja governorates during a week
» Rafidain: Continuous expansion in implementing the comprehensive banking system
» Planning: The population census includes residents of Iraq according to a special mechanism
» Transparency website reveals non-oil imports to Sulaymaniyah and Halabja during a week
» Al-Sudani directs the adoption of specialized international companies to prepare a unified structure
» MP warns of a move that will worsen the housing crisis and calls on the government
» Disagreements strike the Kurdish house... hindering the formation of the regional parliament and gov
» Hundreds of Moroccan farmers are waiting for “imminent compensation” from Iraq.. What’s the story?
» Iraq 10-Year Review: Spending, Imports, Unemployment in 2024 at ‘Highest Level’ in a Decade
» Call to all smokers in Iraq: Prepare for the law
» utube 11/11/24 MM&C News Reporting-IRAQ-USA-Financial Inclusion up 48%-Money Inside & Out of Iraq
» Al-Mandlawi to the UN envoy: The supreme authority diagnosed the problems and provided solutions for
» Saleh: Government strategy to boost gold reserves as part of asset diversification
» Prime Minister's advisor rules out oil price collapse: Trump's policy will not sacrifice petrodollar
» Tripartite alliance between Iraq, Egypt and Jordan to boost maritime trade
» Parliamentary Committee reveals date of entry into force of Personal Status Law
» Al-Fatah warns against US blackmail and Trump's intentions for the next stage