Bloomberg News
THE SHORT ANSWER
Greece: Austerity, Relief or Exit?
9:26 AM EST JAN 23, 2015
By
Marcus Walker
[*]Marcus Walker
Greece’s elections on Sunday take place against the background of rising tensions between the small nation and its main creditors, eurozone governments and the IMF, about the country’s strict bailout regimen. Polls point to a win for leftwing opposition party Syriza over the ruling conservatives of New Democracy. Would a Syriza-led government start a game of chicken with Germany and other creditors that could lead to havoc and a Greek exit from the euro? Or can a compromise be found? Here’s our crystal ball.
Who will lead the next Greek government?
Very likely Syriza (whose leader, Alexis Tsipras is pictured above), the leftwing opposition party, unless the conservative incumbent, Premier Antonis Samaras, pulls off the biggest upset victory since Harry Truman in 1948. Syriza might win an absolute majority in Parliament, but polls suggest it will fall just short, requiring support from another party. A pact with centrist To Potami (The River) or center-left Pasok could make the government more pragmatic in talks with Greece’s international creditors. A pact with the nationalist Independent Greeks could make it more hardline.
What agreements with creditors would Syriza need to reach to keep Greece afloat?
Syriza, eurozone governments, and the International Monetary Fund would have to agree on an extension of Greece’s bailout program that does several things:
- Reassures creditors that Greece will continue to improve its budget balance and overhaul its economy;
- Promises fiscal and reform measures quickly that unlock delayed bailout aid worth €7.2 billion ($8.1 billion); and
- Keeps the European Central Bank confident that Greece will stay in the euro, so that the ECB allows Greek banks continued access to central-bank liquidity, even if there are heavy deposit outflows.
How much time is there to avoid a Greek debt default or banking crisis?
The latest deadline for a deal with Europe is July/August, by when Greece needs billions in new financing to repay bonds held by the ECB. But eurozone officials fear Greece could run out of cash as early as March, when repayments of IMF loans fall due. And if talks between Athens and creditors go badly, capital flight—especially deposit outflows—could happen even earlier.
“They don’t have time,” says Gabriel Sterne, head of global research at consultancy Oxford Economics. “Events could become compressed. Someone has to blink quickly.”
Why would Syriza sign up to austerity measures and economic overhauls that it expressly rejects?
To avoid panicky deposit withdrawals and a renewed economic crash. Syriza officials say they could accept a deal on fiscal discipline that would allow Greece to run a primary budget surplus (excluding interest) of 2% of GDP, instead of Greece’s current 4.5% target. That would require European governments to relieve some of Greece’s debt, by reducing the interest rate and extending the maturities on bailout loans.
Why would Europe agree to that kind of soft debt relief?
It has done so before, when recalibrating Greece’s progam after it went badly off track amid similar political uncertainty in 2012. A recalibration of the bailout program—its targets, its timetables, and the financing terms—is almost inevitable now because this winter’s political drama has knocked Greece’s economy and budget off track. But Syriza would still have to perform a major U-turn on its fiscal promises in order to credibly achieve even a 2% primary surplus. It will be hard for Syriza, but it’s been done before. Mr. Samaras did a U-turn on austerity when he won election in 2012.
What about the structural reforms that are part of the bailout terms?
That could be even more difficult for Syriza than a U-turn on fiscal policy. All of Syriza’s ideological tendencies reject the market-oriented overhauls, privatizations, and deregulation measures that Germany and other creditors say are essential for restoring Greece’s economic competitiveness. Syriza wants to reverse some of the reforms already enacted. Creditors say Greece has to take such overhauls further. The gap between the two positions is huge.
If a compromise can be found – enough reforms, enough austerity, enough debt relief – will Greece be saved?
Not necessarily. Since 2010, keeping the bailout program on track has proved even harder than agreeing its terms. The current program relies on optimistic growth and fiscal forecasts. And Syriza has yet to prove it can run a government and implement difficult overhauls. If the program goes off track again, creditors will demand extra austerity and reforms, which could push a Syriza government to breaking point—as happened to the Samaras government this winter. If Syriza cracks under the pressure, another round of uncertainty and early elections will follow, perhaps returning conservative New Democracy to power.
What if no agreement can be reached?
That’s a serious risk, given the chasm between Syriza and creditors, especially Berlin. Even rising doubts about whether a compromise can be found could lead to heavy deposit withdrawals from Greek banksand capital flight from the country. At that point, the ECB would have to decide whether to keep liquidity open for Greek banks or to cut them off, because of the lack of a prospective agreement and Europe’s rising financial exposure in case Greece leaves the euro. Greece and the eurozone would very likely have to impose capital controls, like in Cyprus, to stop the capital flight. But that would probably be an interim step. Either Syriza would have to give in and sign a bailout program, or Greece would have to print drachmas to keep the economy, government and financial system from collapse.
Is Germany prepared to countenance Greek exit from the euro?
Chancellor Angel Merkel would certainly like to avoid a Grexit. The media coverage of a financial meltdown and economic devastation in Greece that would follow Grexit would likely be deeply damaging for Germany’s standing in Europe. Moreover, Germany, like other eurozone countries, would face heavy losses on bailout loans and central-bank exposure to Greece.
But Germany can only continue to finance Greece if there’s a counterparty: a government in Athens that is prepared to run a significant primary budget surplus, and to overhaul the Greek economy to make it more viable inside the euro.
And if Syriza refuses to meet those terms: Will Merkel blink?
No. German leaders fear that funding a Greece that refuses to reform would be the death knell of the eurozone. Other debtor countries could conclude that they could blackmail Berlin, refuse to cut their deficits or overhaul their economies, and still get German taxpayers’ money. The cost of lending to a recalcitrant Greece would eventually reach far higher than the cost of Grexit, German politicians are convinced. If Syriza doesn’t blink, then Ms. Merkel could reluctantly say auf Wiedersehen, Griechenland.
Will Syriza blink?
Possibly, if failure to come to terms quickly with Europe leads to deposit flight and Grexit panic, battering Greece’s economy. Syriza might also split and fall from power in such a situation, triggering another election. The big question is whether Syriza will overplay its hand, realizing the weakness of Greece’s position only too late, when bank deposits are already fleeing the country.
http://blogs.wsj.com/briefly/2015/01/23/greece-austerity-relief-or-exit-the-short-answer/#twitter
» Oil: government interest in investing in "free" gas in the Akkas and Mansouriya fields
» Al-Fateh: The dollar rose as a result of “hidden” agreements that Al-Kazemi concluded with Washingto
» Al-Bandawi is likely to reach the budget to the Council of Ministers in the next seven days
» Al-Bawi: Al-Halbousi transgressed the interest of the people by obstructing the holding of the "doll
» Economist: All oil revenues reach the Federal Bank before they are sent to Iraq
» Al-Nasr: Reviewing the coordination framework agreement will be a priority for Al-Sudani's visit to
» An expected problem with the salaries of employees.. The state does not own the dinar, and the bet i
» As part of the "battle" being waged by Al-Sudanese... the secrets of an ambush that overthrew a mill
» Victory: One reason behind the dollar's rise... and Iraq is still in the seventh item
» An American monitoring alerts Al-Sudanese: The dollar crisis predicts bankruptcy and protests
» Demonstrations begin in central Baghdad to protest against the rise of the dollar
» Environment is in the process of circulating an international report on climate change to all govern
» The Judicial Council enters the crisis line of market turmoil
» Multiple efforts to end the dollar's domination of the global market.. You know it
» Direction to the Iraqi courts regarding the dollar
» The conclusion of a commercial memorandum between Iraq and Jordan
» "Beware of the Revolution of the Hungry"... Demonstrations in Karbala and Najaf against the rise of
» Zidane directs to take legal measures against those causing damage to the national economy
» National Security overthrows merchants and owners of companies who smuggle currency
» The arrest of a currency smuggler in possession of a large sum in Salah al-Din
» The counterfeit Iraqi dinar.. Organized gangs penetrate the markets and exacerbate the wounds of the
» The most prominent of which is the "tax holiday".. 5 positive outcomes of the Sudanese meeting with
» An expert talks about fears of printing a cash block of more than 80 trillion dinars without cover
» The dollar crisis in Iraq.. daily exacerbation and warnings of its long continuation
» Federation of Chambers of Commerce: We are committed to the official exchange rate, and there is no
» A demonstration in central Baghdad to demand a reduction in the price of the dollar against the dina
» The conclusion of a commercial memorandum between Iraq and Jordan
» Deputy: Forming a specialized committee to control exchange rates and restore them to their previous
» Its employees from Iraq after a dispute over energy projects
» Sudanese issues strict directives to deal with currency smuggling
» The most prominent of what came in the meeting of the Kurdistan Democratic Party with the Change Mov
» Petroleum Products Distribution Company: The fuel card will be applied in all governorates except Ku
» Jenin Blaskhart: The federal government confirmed its commitment to settling outstanding issues with
» Environment discloses the outcomes of its meetings with the World Bank on climate change
» Sudanese advisor: Iraq's economy will not be determined by shop brokers
» The start of the second meeting between the Iraqi delegation and the US federal government regarding
» Deputy: The budget is still in the corridors of the Ministry of Finance and has not been discussed i
» Iraq .. Disclosure of the ratio of government spending to GDP within 10 years
» KTFA Members "News and Views" Thursday 2-2-2023
» Parliamentary services: Traders stopped exchanging dollars exacerbated the crisis even more
» The Chamber of Commerce submits a request to solve the dollar crisis in internal transactions
» THE PRIME MINISTER CHAIRS A MEETING ON THE EXCHANGE RATE: “SOME BANKS DO NOT MAKE THE DESIRED CONTRI
» Al-Sudani issues directives to tackle currency smuggling and arrest smugglers and speculators
» Video: The head of the Karbala Chamber of Industry criticizes the industrial reality in Iraq and rev
» Religious authority and drugs: a prohibition of their trade, money, and abuse...and a mandate to com
» Baghdad and Washington "agree on, among other things" on the status of the dollar in Iraq
» Biden assures Al-Sudani of his welcome to the Iraqi delegation's visit to Washington next weekpropos
» Solutions are exhausted.. A specialist identifies the last option to solve the dollar crisis in Iraq
» Despite Al-Sudani's visit... Parliamentary assurances that there are "problems" with the French Tota
» International report: The solution to the dollar crisis in Iraq is imminent and its signs will appea
» The most prominent of which is the "tax holiday".. 5 positive outcomes of the Sudanese meeting with
» Amidst the apparent 'chaos'.. New directives from Al-Sudani to control the dollar
» French 'Total' withdraws its employees from Iraq in light of disagreements with Baghdad
» America's envoy to the Security Council: We urge the Sudanese to fulfill his obligations to "confine
» The White House: Telephone discussions between Biden and the Sudanese dealt with several files
» Instead of Iranian... Parliamentary oil: Iraq will suffice with domestic gas to operate electric sta
» Iraq's share in the projects impede the agreement with the French oil giant
» Al-Sudani directs banking facilities and indicates reluctance
» The dollar is facing a difficult test.. What is the expected scenario?
» Foreign Ministry: An Iraqi delegation to Washington to discuss basic issues related to financial and
» National Security announces the arrest of company owners on charges of smuggling currency abroad
» Exchange rates of the dollar against the dinar
» What is the rank of Iraq in the Arab economies competitiveness index?
» Associated Press on the dollar crisis and federal restrictions: The Iraqi regime is threatened
» “They have 72 hours.” Al-Sudani asks for clarification about the video “The Lady of Gold”
» After warning her of the “division in Kurdistan.” Talabani meets Blaskhart
» Baghdad and Washington “agree on, among other things” about the status of the dollar in Iraq
» Politics, economy and security are at the heart of bin Farhan's visit to Baghdad
» Deputy: Unknown reasons behind the failure to hold an emergency parliamentary session regarding the
» The Prime Minister, Mr. Muhammad Shia'a Al-Sudani, meets with the former Prime Minister, Mr. Adel Ab
» Iraq ranks 15th in the Arab economies competitiveness index
» Al Janoob Islamic Bank provides good news to merchants and business owners regarding saving the doll
» A huge deficit.. Parliamentary finance reveals the details of the budget
» The Minister of Justice directs to overcome the obstacles facing the work of the Investment Authorit
» Deputy: Everyone is pushing for a population census in Iraq
» Al-Sudani directs to simplify the procedures for dealings with merchants in state departments
» Government directives to deal with currency smuggling
» They renewed their commitment to Iraq's security and stability.. Al-Sudani and Biden discuss regiona
» Dollar exchange rates in the Iraqi market
» Minister of Health: We are determined to develop and improve the health system in Iraq
» The Prime Minister chairs a meeting on the exchange rate: "Some banks do not make the desired contri
» Expert: Fears that the government will resort to printing a monetary block at an amount of 82-87 tri
» Al-Sudanese directs to simplify the procedures for merchants' dealings in the concerned / expanded s
» Pavel Talabani is discussing with the German ambassador ways to overcome the differences between the
» with the video. . The National Security Agency announces the arrest of a group of owners of large co
» A call for major demonstrations tomorrow in Tahrir Square to reduce the exchange rate of the dollar
» The Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces issues directives to tackle currency smuggling and arrest
» Sanad ... a meeting in Turkey between the Iraqi delegation and a delegation representing the US Fede
» The dollar crisis will not be resolved soon... a "disappointed" statement from the parliamentary fin
» A good opportunity before prices rise.. Iraq is racing against time to buy wheat immediatelyproposal
» A bank releases good news for merchants: dollars at the official rate and “no commission” transfersp
» Iraq's chambers of commerce and economic elites in the Sudanese office: 10 urgent points to reduce t
» The Ministry of Education denies that "the illiteracy rate in Iraq has reached 47 percent."proposals
» Iraq market: trading of shares worth 5 billion dinars within a week
» Blaskhart calls for expediting the approval of the budget and giving priority to diversifying the ec
» Petroleum products: The fuel card will be applied in all governorates
» Foreign Ministry: The Iraqi delegation will discuss in Washington the rise of the dollar and financi
» Al-Halbousi: Parliament supports the Iraqi government and the bilateral cooperation agreement with S