Bloomberg News
THE SHORT ANSWER
Greece: Austerity, Relief or Exit?
9:26 AM EST JAN 23, 2015
By
Marcus Walker
[*]Marcus Walker
Greece’s elections on Sunday take place against the background of rising tensions between the small nation and its main creditors, eurozone governments and the IMF, about the country’s strict bailout regimen. Polls point to a win for leftwing opposition party Syriza over the ruling conservatives of New Democracy. Would a Syriza-led government start a game of chicken with Germany and other creditors that could lead to havoc and a Greek exit from the euro? Or can a compromise be found? Here’s our crystal ball.
Who will lead the next Greek government?
Very likely Syriza (whose leader, Alexis Tsipras is pictured above), the leftwing opposition party, unless the conservative incumbent, Premier Antonis Samaras, pulls off the biggest upset victory since Harry Truman in 1948. Syriza might win an absolute majority in Parliament, but polls suggest it will fall just short, requiring support from another party. A pact with centrist To Potami (The River) or center-left Pasok could make the government more pragmatic in talks with Greece’s international creditors. A pact with the nationalist Independent Greeks could make it more hardline.
What agreements with creditors would Syriza need to reach to keep Greece afloat?
Syriza, eurozone governments, and the International Monetary Fund would have to agree on an extension of Greece’s bailout program that does several things:
- Reassures creditors that Greece will continue to improve its budget balance and overhaul its economy;
- Promises fiscal and reform measures quickly that unlock delayed bailout aid worth €7.2 billion ($8.1 billion); and
- Keeps the European Central Bank confident that Greece will stay in the euro, so that the ECB allows Greek banks continued access to central-bank liquidity, even if there are heavy deposit outflows.
How much time is there to avoid a Greek debt default or banking crisis?
The latest deadline for a deal with Europe is July/August, by when Greece needs billions in new financing to repay bonds held by the ECB. But eurozone officials fear Greece could run out of cash as early as March, when repayments of IMF loans fall due. And if talks between Athens and creditors go badly, capital flight—especially deposit outflows—could happen even earlier.
“They don’t have time,” says Gabriel Sterne, head of global research at consultancy Oxford Economics. “Events could become compressed. Someone has to blink quickly.”
Why would Syriza sign up to austerity measures and economic overhauls that it expressly rejects?
To avoid panicky deposit withdrawals and a renewed economic crash. Syriza officials say they could accept a deal on fiscal discipline that would allow Greece to run a primary budget surplus (excluding interest) of 2% of GDP, instead of Greece’s current 4.5% target. That would require European governments to relieve some of Greece’s debt, by reducing the interest rate and extending the maturities on bailout loans.
Why would Europe agree to that kind of soft debt relief?
It has done so before, when recalibrating Greece’s progam after it went badly off track amid similar political uncertainty in 2012. A recalibration of the bailout program—its targets, its timetables, and the financing terms—is almost inevitable now because this winter’s political drama has knocked Greece’s economy and budget off track. But Syriza would still have to perform a major U-turn on its fiscal promises in order to credibly achieve even a 2% primary surplus. It will be hard for Syriza, but it’s been done before. Mr. Samaras did a U-turn on austerity when he won election in 2012.
What about the structural reforms that are part of the bailout terms?
That could be even more difficult for Syriza than a U-turn on fiscal policy. All of Syriza’s ideological tendencies reject the market-oriented overhauls, privatizations, and deregulation measures that Germany and other creditors say are essential for restoring Greece’s economic competitiveness. Syriza wants to reverse some of the reforms already enacted. Creditors say Greece has to take such overhauls further. The gap between the two positions is huge.
If a compromise can be found – enough reforms, enough austerity, enough debt relief – will Greece be saved?
Not necessarily. Since 2010, keeping the bailout program on track has proved even harder than agreeing its terms. The current program relies on optimistic growth and fiscal forecasts. And Syriza has yet to prove it can run a government and implement difficult overhauls. If the program goes off track again, creditors will demand extra austerity and reforms, which could push a Syriza government to breaking point—as happened to the Samaras government this winter. If Syriza cracks under the pressure, another round of uncertainty and early elections will follow, perhaps returning conservative New Democracy to power.
What if no agreement can be reached?
That’s a serious risk, given the chasm between Syriza and creditors, especially Berlin. Even rising doubts about whether a compromise can be found could lead to heavy deposit withdrawals from Greek banks and capital flight from the country. At that point, the ECB would have to decide whether to keep liquidity open for Greek banks or to cut them off, because of the lack of a prospective agreement and Europe’s rising financial exposure in case Greece leaves the euro. Greece and the eurozone would very likely have to impose capital controls, like in Cyprus, to stop the capital flight. But that would probably be an interim step. Either Syriza would have to give in and sign a bailout program, or Greece would have to print drachmas to keep the economy, government and financial system from collapse.
Is Germany prepared to countenance Greek exit from the euro?
Chancellor Angel Merkel would certainly like to avoid a Grexit. The media coverage of a financial meltdown and economic devastation in Greece that would follow Grexit would likely be deeply damaging for Germany’s standing in Europe. Moreover, Germany, like other eurozone countries, would face heavy losses on bailout loans and central-bank exposure to Greece.
But Germany can only continue to finance Greece if there’s a counterparty: a government in Athens that is prepared to run a significant primary budget surplus, and to overhaul the Greek economy to make it more viable inside the euro.
And if Syriza refuses to meet those terms: Will Merkel blink?
No. German leaders fear that funding a Greece that refuses to reform would be the death knell of the eurozone. Other debtor countries could conclude that they could blackmail Berlin, refuse to cut their deficits or overhaul their economies, and still get German taxpayers’ money. The cost of lending to a recalcitrant Greece would eventually reach far higher than the cost of Grexit, German politicians are convinced. If Syriza doesn’t blink, then Ms. Merkel could reluctantly say auf Wiedersehen, Griechenland.
Will Syriza blink?
Possibly, if failure to come to terms quickly with Europe leads to deposit flight and Grexit panic, battering Greece’s economy. Syriza might also split and fall from power in such a situation, triggering another election. The big question is whether Syriza will overplay its hand, realizing the weakness of Greece’s position only too late, when bank deposits are already fleeing the country.
http://blogs.wsj.com/briefly/2015/01/23/greece-austerity-relief-or-exit-the-short-answer/#twitter
» Finance: The sudden loan requested by the government is illegal and we do not know about it
» Parliamentary Finance sets the date for completing its discussion with the ministers and governors o
» Finance reveals the results of its meeting with the region’s delegation: We will not vote on such te
» Iraq and Kuwait are discussing the file of remaining debt payments and the possibility of postponing
» The International Development Bank announces its joining the "Bani" platform
» Oil Minister: Iraq is keen to develop its oil and gas fields
» Tuesday's session ... the insurance law and the retirement of private sector workers at the Parliame
» Source: The IMF knows very well that the Minister of Finance has lost the confidence of the people a
» International Monetary: Iraq requested emergency assistance
» After changing the exchange rate, the inflation rate rose by 3.3%
» Iraqi president approves more than 340 death sentences: official
» A storm of changes strikes the 2021 budget days before its approval: What happened to the dollar exc
» An economist predicts a new dollar exchange rate and identifies the reason
» After more than a month of the parliamentary movement .. Setting an official date for the questionin
» International report: The Iraqi economy experienced its worst downturn since 2003
» The constitutional case related to the export of oil and gas as a model
» Two Kurdish delegations to Baghdad to persuade the parliament and the blocs to pass the budget
» A major change in the budget, including the price of oil, and these points of contention
» In the aftermath of the Baghdad bombings, Al-Kazemi ousted five prominent security chiefs
» Majida Al-Tamimi: The discount is imminent … The budget is presented within days
» Oil Parliament reveals the completion of the legal drafting of the oil and gas law
» A decrease in sales .. The Central Bank of Iraq sells only 3 million and 225 thousand dollars
» A monthly salary for every Iraqi..within the promises of previous governments and the possibility of
» Al-Maliki launches his election campaign early: We are coming to restore the prestige of the state
» Finance announces the launch of employee payroll financing for the month of January
» Iraq tops the first place in the Arab world in terms of activity and trading
» Credit rating .. Iraq is among the countries with the highest risk
» The Central Bank cancels two previous decisions pertaining to the Sharia Committee in Islamic Banks
» Iraqi port revenue surges as anti-corruption move bears fruit
» Iran's Rouhani hails departure of 'tyrant' Trump
» House of Representatives set, on Wednesday, the date for the employees’ salaries to be disbursed for
» Rafidain Bank announces the launch of loans of all kinds
» Parliamentary Finance: The budget will be ready next week
» The Iraqi government announces the imminent launch of small income-generating projects
» Government is talking about the Baghdad Renaissance project: Basmaya loans without interest over 20
» The Council of Ministers votes on setting October 10 as the date for early elections
» The director of Al-Rafidain Bank announces good news about the loan interest
» International Monetary Fund: Great ambiguity surrounds the outlook for the global economy
» The decision to devalue the currency is on the table of experts
» Iraq has sufficient gas to fuel all electricity stations: MP
» Rumors of an airstrike in Iraq come amid Iran tensions. Claims that the US struck Iranian-backed mil
» Time for Iraq’s militias to lay down arms. Many Iraqis are heartily sick of the pro-Iran troublemak
» “Made in Iraq” activities kicked off at Baghdad International Fair … encouraging investment and sup
» AM Best Releases Country Risk Assessment Report on Iraq
» Banks Are Reluctant To Buy Dollars In Cash From The Central Bank
» Determine when to pass the budget law
» Zain Cash offers an exclusive offer for its permanent wallet customers
» Decision of the Parliamentary Finance Committee: The amendments will include most of the items in th
» Parliamentary warnings .. Delay in approving the budget will affect the payment of salaries of emplo
» Al-Rafidain Bank raises the interest for savings accounts to 5 percent and fixed deposits to 7
» “Made in Iraq” activities kicked off at Baghdad International Fair … encouraging investment and supp
» The head of the Iraqi Supreme Judicial Council discusses with the US ambassador extraditing Trump
» Iraq loses more than $61m monthly in uncollected electricity fees in Baghdad: MP
» IHEC proposes to delay early election until October 16
» Mid-January .. Iraq Applies The Electronic Payment System, Exporters And Importers
» US drawdown of troops in Iraq is complete, says Pentagon
» How Erbil and Baghdad could fuel Iraq’s recovery
» The Council of Ministers decides to adopt the biometric card as proof
» Parliament ends discussion of the 2021 draft budget
» Parliamentary Finance: To vote on the budget next week .. This is the fate of the salary deduction
» Postponing Iraqi elections seen as an opportunity for Kadhimi to boost political fortunes
» Iraqi protest leaders launch political bloc ahead of elections
» Iran test-fires ballistic missiles on targets at sea
» American diplomat James Jeffrey: Trump’s model will continue in Iraq and Syria
» Foreign Ministry talks about its measures to remove Iraq from the list of money laundering
» Washington and Baghdad agree on Iraqi independence in the energy field
» The presidencies of Iraq recommend dissolving parliament
» Iraq to Participate in Buna Payment Platform
» Finance Minister: We will take a package of measures to reduce the effects of devaluation
» US piles pressure on Iran-backed militia commanders in Iraq with new sanctions
» The Iraqi parliament moves to change the price of oil in the budget
» Parliament keeps the debate on the draft budget open and sets a date for its holding
» Al-Halbousi stresses to Allawi the importance of limiting the repercussions of the financial situati
» Finance resolves the controversy and reveals the fate of the dollar exchange rate in the budget
» Parliament ends the second reading of the draft law on Iraq’s accession to an international protocol
» Saleh officially ratifies Iraq’s accession to the Paris climate agreement
» Article 140 postpones the resolution of constitutional amendments
» More than three-quarters. "Big" decline in central bank sales
» Finance Minister: We will take a package of measures to mitigate the effects of the devaluation in t
» Gorran MP alleges $78bn removed from Iraq since 2016, including $12bn from Kurdistan Region
» “Strict” measures and “serious” international monitoring awaiting early elections
» Al-Kazemi government takes 5 new decisions
» The presidencies, the Commission and UNAMI stress on increasing the biometric registration rate and
» The Three Presidencies: Reaching Radical Solutions Between the Federal Government and the Kurdistan
» The Parliamentary Finance committee to convene at the Prime Ministry's headquarters
» Al-Halbousi discusses with the Kurdistan Democratic delegation the budget and early elections
» The House of Representatives keeps its session going until tomorrow to complete the budget
» The high price of the dollar in Baghdad and its st
» An Iraqi forum discusses the impact of changing the exchange rate on the poor, destitute and low-inc
» Council of Representatives should vote on early election date: MP
» There will be no salary issues in Region, if Erbil, Baghdad abide by draft 2021 Iraqi Budget Law: MP
» Al-Kazemi and Al-Halbousi are discussing the budget and amending the Federal Court law
» Finance determines the changes it will make in the 2021 budget: changing the price of a barrel of oi
» Iraq maintains its ranking globally in gold reserves
» Foreign Ministry Spokesman: US sanctions against Hashd al-Sha'bi chief ‘insult to Iraq’
» Parliament’s agenda for next Monday’s session
» In details … Cabinet decisions for Saturday
» The Iraqi Parliament ends the first reading of the 2021 budget