Are Federal Reserve Notes And Treasury Debt The Same Thing?
My respected friend pgl at Angry Bear dumps on Charles Krauthammer for saying this:
<blockquote>2042
is the fictional date for the fictional bankruptcy of a fictional trust
fund. Let's start with basics. The Social Security system has no trust
fund. No lock box. When you pay your payroll tax every year, the money
is not converted into gold bars and shipped to some desert island, ready
for retrieval when you turn 65... These pieces of paper might be useful
for rolling cigars. They will not fund your retirement. Your Leisure
World greens fees will be coming from the payroll taxes of young people
during the years you grow old. That is why 2042 is a fiction. The really
important date is 2018.
</blockquote>pgl trots out a pretty clever argument.
<blockquote>If there are Federal Reserve notes in your wallet, I’ll gladly buy you a cup of coffee if you give them to me.
If you really believe piece of paper called financial assets are
worth nothing, I’ll gladly take all of your cash, funds in your bank
accounts, and other financial assets. In turn, I’ll even buy a week’s
worth of groceries.
</blockquote>Clever, but not apt, I think,
because modern institutions really do imply different expectations about
the liability represented by a Federal Reserve note compared to that
represented by a Treasury security.
Here's what I mean. I think it useful (and appropriate) to think of
my economic relationship with the government in terms of the totality of
our financial interactions. In other words, my net tax burden does not
just consist of my social security taxes, or my income-tax payments, or
what I remit in Medicare "premiums", etc., etc., etc, but the present
value of all my payments to the government less all the payments they
make to me. (This is the fundamental idea behind the concept of generational accounting, of which I am a very big fan.)
Suppose I hold a Treasury security. That, of course, is a payment the
government owes to me, and I have every expectation that it will be
made. But if, for some reason, there has been a miscalculation, a
change in economic circumstances, a change in policy, the government may
find that it has to raise my taxes to obtain the revenues to honor
those payments. In doing so, it has effectively reduced the return on
that security. Distortionary price effects aside -- granted, a major
qualification -- why should it matter to me how it happens? Lower my
social security benefits, raise my income taxes, whatever. It all
amounts to a haircut on that Treasury payment to me.
Because the distributional aspects of these things can matter,
blanket haircuts are probably a pretty bad idea -- foreigners, for
example, finance a good chunk of our collective borrowing, and they
aren't likely to appreciate the opportunity to finance our fiscal
imbalances on an ongoing basis. Changes in tax and transfer policies
are the way we go because they can be targeted (which gets us to
positive versus normative questions, which I'll address below.) But the
basic economic distinction is one without a difference.
Why are Federal Reserve notes different? At some level, they aren't,
as pgl has reminded me on numerous occasions. One way to truly
implement a haircut on government debt is to reduce the purchasing power
of the currency in which the debt is paid -- by employing, in other
words, the so-called inflation tax. But the United States, and almost
all developed countries, have worked hard to ensure people that this
won't happen. This is why the Fed is largely independent of the
Treasury. In essence, we have guaranteed that fiscal imbalances won't
be addressed by reducing the value of Federal Reserve notes. Despite
protests to the contrary, no such promise is made for the return to
Treasury notes, as the ever-changing tax rate on interest income makes
abundantly clear.
Now to Krauthammer's point. Here we, again, we have the unfortunate
confluence of positive and normative assertions. I think Krauthammer is
making the positive point that private debt and equity supports investment. In many cases, public debt supports consumption,
and there is a big difference between these two situations. Of course,
you may want to argue that, at the margin, the bulk of public
expenditure is actually investment (and more productive than private
investment). That is an assertion that can be adjudicated by evidence,
and I'll listen But there is no fallacy in Krauthammer's assertion.
Then there is the normative question -- whether is right to
renege on the government payments promised (and planned for) by retirees
and near-retirees. On this, pgl and I (and President Bush) agree that
the answer is "no."
http://macroblog.typepad.com/macroblog/2005/02/are_federal_res.html
My respected friend pgl at Angry Bear dumps on Charles Krauthammer for saying this:
<blockquote>2042
is the fictional date for the fictional bankruptcy of a fictional trust
fund. Let's start with basics. The Social Security system has no trust
fund. No lock box. When you pay your payroll tax every year, the money
is not converted into gold bars and shipped to some desert island, ready
for retrieval when you turn 65... These pieces of paper might be useful
for rolling cigars. They will not fund your retirement. Your Leisure
World greens fees will be coming from the payroll taxes of young people
during the years you grow old. That is why 2042 is a fiction. The really
important date is 2018.
</blockquote>pgl trots out a pretty clever argument.
<blockquote>If there are Federal Reserve notes in your wallet, I’ll gladly buy you a cup of coffee if you give them to me.
If you really believe piece of paper called financial assets are
worth nothing, I’ll gladly take all of your cash, funds in your bank
accounts, and other financial assets. In turn, I’ll even buy a week’s
worth of groceries.
</blockquote>Clever, but not apt, I think,
because modern institutions really do imply different expectations about
the liability represented by a Federal Reserve note compared to that
represented by a Treasury security.
Here's what I mean. I think it useful (and appropriate) to think of
my economic relationship with the government in terms of the totality of
our financial interactions. In other words, my net tax burden does not
just consist of my social security taxes, or my income-tax payments, or
what I remit in Medicare "premiums", etc., etc., etc, but the present
value of all my payments to the government less all the payments they
make to me. (This is the fundamental idea behind the concept of generational accounting, of which I am a very big fan.)
Suppose I hold a Treasury security. That, of course, is a payment the
government owes to me, and I have every expectation that it will be
made. But if, for some reason, there has been a miscalculation, a
change in economic circumstances, a change in policy, the government may
find that it has to raise my taxes to obtain the revenues to honor
those payments. In doing so, it has effectively reduced the return on
that security. Distortionary price effects aside -- granted, a major
qualification -- why should it matter to me how it happens? Lower my
social security benefits, raise my income taxes, whatever. It all
amounts to a haircut on that Treasury payment to me.
Because the distributional aspects of these things can matter,
blanket haircuts are probably a pretty bad idea -- foreigners, for
example, finance a good chunk of our collective borrowing, and they
aren't likely to appreciate the opportunity to finance our fiscal
imbalances on an ongoing basis. Changes in tax and transfer policies
are the way we go because they can be targeted (which gets us to
positive versus normative questions, which I'll address below.) But the
basic economic distinction is one without a difference.
Why are Federal Reserve notes different? At some level, they aren't,
as pgl has reminded me on numerous occasions. One way to truly
implement a haircut on government debt is to reduce the purchasing power
of the currency in which the debt is paid -- by employing, in other
words, the so-called inflation tax. But the United States, and almost
all developed countries, have worked hard to ensure people that this
won't happen. This is why the Fed is largely independent of the
Treasury. In essence, we have guaranteed that fiscal imbalances won't
be addressed by reducing the value of Federal Reserve notes. Despite
protests to the contrary, no such promise is made for the return to
Treasury notes, as the ever-changing tax rate on interest income makes
abundantly clear.
Now to Krauthammer's point. Here we, again, we have the unfortunate
confluence of positive and normative assertions. I think Krauthammer is
making the positive point that private debt and equity supports investment. In many cases, public debt supports consumption,
and there is a big difference between these two situations. Of course,
you may want to argue that, at the margin, the bulk of public
expenditure is actually investment (and more productive than private
investment). That is an assertion that can be adjudicated by evidence,
and I'll listen But there is no fallacy in Krauthammer's assertion.
Then there is the normative question -- whether is right to
renege on the government payments promised (and planned for) by retirees
and near-retirees. On this, pgl and I (and President Bush) agree that
the answer is "no."
http://macroblog.typepad.com/macroblog/2005/02/are_federal_res.html
Today at 7:00 am by Rocky
» utube 5/9/24 MM&C 0:02 / 46:46 PM - Al-Sudani - Golden Opportunity - Private Sector - Contra
Today at 6:57 am by Rocky
» utube MM&C 5/11/24 Iraqi Dinar - IQD Update - International - IraqTiming - 2024 Budget Schedule - Sp
Today at 6:55 am by Rocky
» Bahr Al-Ulum calls for legislating the renewable energy law and localizing the solar panel industry
Today at 6:49 am by Rocky
» In numbers: the rise in internal debt in Iraq
Today at 6:49 am by Rocky
» Jordan demands that Iraq continue to export oil for another three months
Today at 6:46 am by Rocky
» Iraq is the largest producer.. OPEC+ is pumping higher than scheduled and in anticipation of the Jun
Today at 6:44 am by Rocky
» Close to the coordination framework: There is no intention to change the internal regulations of Par
Today at 6:43 am by Rocky
» Central Bank sales exceed $274 million today
Today at 6:41 am by Rocky
» But the representative of the exchange companies is pessimistic... Why did the dollar fall?... The C
Today at 6:38 am by Rocky
» Jordan addresses Iraq to extend a memorandum of understanding to purchase oil
Today at 6:36 am by Rocky
» Bribes increased from 3,000 to 50,000 dollars.. What is the condition of alcohol in Iraq after the p
Today at 6:34 am by Rocky
» Presence movement: Sunnis and Kurds while the Americans remain in Iraq
Today at 5:31 am by Rocky
» A deputy reveals the contents of the first water strategy in Iraq
Today at 5:29 am by Rocky
» Soon...the second reading of the proposed red card law
Today at 5:28 am by Rocky
» The discovery of 10 new oil and gas fields in the Anbar desert
Today at 5:27 am by Rocky
» A bloc announces to “Al-Ma’louma” the date of the parliamentary speaker’s election session
Today at 5:26 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance explains the mechanism for amending the retirement law
Today at 5:24 am by Rocky
» Sovereignty accuses Al-Halbousi of obstructing the election of a Speaker of Parliament
Today at 5:23 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Agriculture accuses Kurdistan of harming the farmers of the center and south
Today at 5:22 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani confirms Iraq's readiness to host the Arab Network conference
Today at 5:21 am by Rocky
» Nechirvan Barzani calls on the Iraqi government to allocate a budget to confront climate change
Today at 5:20 am by Rocky
» “Iraq is in danger.” Political warnings against ending the work of the UN mission
Today at 5:19 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi Interior Minister announces the signing of a security cooperation memorandum with Syria
Today at 5:17 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Oil told “Al-Iqtisad News”: The 5th and 6th rounds will add 3 Mqmq of gas to Iraq’s
Today at 5:16 am by Rocky
» Economist: Tax revenues from the private sector should be 4 trillion dinars annually
Today at 5:14 am by Rocky
» The Real Estate Bank calls on the Iraqi Central Bank to determine a plan to allocate a new initiativ
Today at 5:13 am by Rocky
» More than one billion and 400 million dollars...CBI sales within a week
Today at 5:12 am by Rocky
» Oil: Iraq achieved self-sufficiency in liquid gas and began exporting the surplus
Today at 5:10 am by Rocky
» Iraq begins exporting liquid gas
Today at 5:09 am by Rocky
» The Cabinet Secretariat sets to Al-Iqtisad News the completion date for the Chinese agreement school
Today at 5:09 am by Rocky
» Securities: The most recent law of the Authority in the Arab and regional countries
Today at 5:07 am by Rocky
» A European desire to strengthen security and economic cooperation with Baghdad
Today at 5:06 am by Rocky
» The close selection of a person for the position of Speaker of Parliament
Today at 5:05 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary law excludes the exchange of penalties for cash amounts
Today at 5:04 am by Rocky
» An agreement with Italy to finance industrial projects
Today at 5:02 am by Rocky
» The Najaf Chamber of Commerce signs a “memorandum of understanding” with its Thai counterpart
Today at 5:01 am by Rocky
» Baghdad, Arab Forum
Today at 5:00 am by Rocky
» Specialists: Economic integration and job opportunities await development
Today at 4:59 am by Rocky
» The President of the Republic, Nechirvan and Barzani stress the necessity of coordinating efforts be
Today at 4:57 am by Rocky
» The Judicial Institute announces the names of those accepted for the 48th and 49th sessions
Today at 4:56 am by Rocky
» Today's newspapers are interested in launching the fifth licensing supplement rounds and the sixth l
Today at 4:55 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani receives the Secretary-General of the Arab Network for National Human Rights Institutions
Today at 4:53 am by Rocky
» Trade participates in the meetings of the Economic and Social Council at the level of senior officia
Today at 4:52 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Transport discusses with the Tunisian Minister of Foreign Affairs and Immigration wa
Today at 4:50 am by Rocky
» Iraq recorded an increase in its oil exports to the United States last week
Today at 4:49 am by Rocky
» It is governed by three dimensions.. Parliament talks about a strategic priority for Iraqi national
Today at 4:48 am by Rocky
» To what extent do Arab countries influence politically Iraq? It has become more independent
Today at 4:46 am by Rocky
» The Iranian ambassador in Baghdad: Iraq has paid its debts, and the security agreement includes thre
Today at 4:45 am by Rocky
» Dollar exchange rates decline slightly on the Baghdad Stock Exchange
Today at 4:44 am by Rocky
» China has 18% of the fields in the two new rounds, and 11 countries share the remainder
Today at 4:43 am by Rocky
» On the table...a proposal for the Kurdistan oil crisis and an effort to conclude a similar agreement
Today at 4:42 am by Rocky
» Al-Awadi: A government decision to provide sovereign guarantees and guarantees to encourage the inve
Today at 4:40 am by Rocky
» 6 Chinese companies are among the winners of developing Iraqi oil and gas fields
Today at 4:38 am by Rocky
» Baghdad gives UNAMI the end of 2025 to leave the country after fiery briefings
Today at 4:37 am by Rocky
» Dhi Qar clarifies: The quarry burying radioactive materials is regular and does not pose a danger
Today at 4:36 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: There are 64 lagging projects in Babylon
Today at 4:34 am by Rocky
» The housing crisis is expanding and planning confirms: Iraq needs 3 million housing units to solve i
Today at 4:34 am by Rocky
» 90 billion dinars were recovered from social protection violators
Today at 4:32 am by Rocky
» Iraq seeks to increase its oil reserves to more than 160 billion barrels
Today at 4:31 am by Rocky
» After keeping the numbers secret... Did the rain increase Iraq's water reserves by 120%?
Today at 4:30 am by Rocky
» In the first quarter of 2024.. Iran will displace Iraq and become the second largest producer in OPE
Today at 4:28 am by Rocky
» Iraqi oil exports to Jordan stopped 20 days ago
Today at 4:27 am by Rocky
» Iraq and Syria sign a memorandum of security cooperation in several fields
Today at 4:25 am by Rocky
» Parliament recommends stopping electronic schools in Iraq
Today at 4:24 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary law rules out passing a law replacing penalties with sums of money
Today at 4:22 am by Rocky
» After a rare meeting... sources talk about Al-Sadr's future in political life in Iraq
Today at 4:21 am by Rocky
» The President of the Republic warns of climate change and its threat to food security and future gen
Today at 4:20 am by Rocky
» The Iranian ambassador to Iraq talks about negotiations for the withdrawal of American forces and Tu
Today at 4:19 am by Rocky
» Deputy: Iraq represents an important factor in the stability of the global oil market
Today at 4:16 am by Rocky
» Transportation: The Iraqi-Turkish technical committees continue to fulfill the requirements for impl
Today at 4:15 am by Rocky
» Economic: Raising the interest rate will reduce real estate prices
Yesterday at 7:20 am by Rocky
» Did Barzani agree in Tehran to end the presence of Iranian groups in Kurdistan? - urgent
Yesterday at 7:16 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: We are establishing a new situation for the global energy market through the Development
Yesterday at 7:14 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The government program devoted a wide scope to the government’s vision for oil and gas in
Yesterday at 7:11 am by Rocky
» Al-Awadi: Ending the work of the UNAMI mission is consistent with the government’s vision in this fi
Yesterday at 7:10 am by Rocky
» MM&C Floating the dinar" returns to the forefront.. Will the Central Bank of Iraq resort to it and w
Yesterday at 5:24 am by Rocky
» The Secretary of the Ministry of Defense meets with the Commander of the NATO mission
Yesterday at 5:17 am by Rocky
» Expert: The stability of the economy is linked to the political situation
Yesterday at 5:13 am by Rocky
» A parliamentary request to lift the injustice against 20,000 Iraqi employees
Yesterday at 5:09 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance criticizes the government's failure to send the budget schedules
Yesterday at 5:08 am by Rocky
» Minister of Oil: The 5th and 6th licensing rounds will take place within the framework of exploratio
Yesterday at 5:07 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: Iraq is a difficult number in the global market in the field of energy
Yesterday at 5:06 am by Rocky
» Al-Khanjar rejects Al-Halbousi’s request to head Parliament
Yesterday at 5:05 am by Rocky
» Revealing the date of the arrival of the 2024 budget schedules
Yesterday at 5:04 am by Rocky
» Al-Halbousi nominates Talal Al-Zubaie for presidency of the House of Representatives
Yesterday at 5:03 am by Rocky
» "A coup in Iraqi universities"... Replacement of presidents and deans under the new education law
Yesterday at 5:01 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: Iraq is a difficult number in the equation of energy and oil wealth in the region and the
Yesterday at 5:00 am by Rocky
» Minister of Oil: We hope to announce an increase in Iraq’s oil reserves to 160 billion barrels
Yesterday at 4:58 am by Rocky
» Iraq's mass graves...stories that did not end with the burial of their owners, and the "legacy of IS
Yesterday at 4:57 am by Rocky
» Pictures: New licenses in Iraq to extract “huge” quantities of oil and gas
Yesterday at 4:56 am by Rocky
» Transport reopens the Baghdad - Samarra railway line
Yesterday at 4:55 am by Rocky
» Al-Awadi: A government decision to provide sovereign guarantees and guarantees to encourage the inve
Yesterday at 4:54 am by Rocky
» Oil clarifies the mechanism for investing grant funds and licensing contracts
Yesterday at 4:51 am by Rocky
» A $700 million agreement is signed between Iraq and Italy to finance these projects
Yesterday at 4:50 am by Rocky
» Iraq recovers 90 billion dinars from social protection violators
Yesterday at 4:49 am by Rocky
» Sudanese officially launches the two licensing rounds and sets the date for stopping gas burning
Yesterday at 4:48 am by Rocky
» An economic vision for the standard of competition for exploratory plots in Iraq
Yesterday at 4:47 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi Islamic Bank announces an increase in its capital to 300 billion dinars
Yesterday at 4:46 am by Rocky