Andrew P. Napolitano, a former judge of the Superior Court of New Jersey ANALYSIS/OPINION: re FBI/Clinton
The FBI investigation of former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s failure to protect state secrets contained in her emails has entered its penultimate phase, and it is a dangerous one for her and her aides.
Federal law enforcement sources have let it be known that federal prosecutors and the FBI have completed their examination of raw data in the case. After the FBI acquires raw data — for example, the nature and number of the state secrets in the emails Mrs. Clinton failed to protect or the regular, consistent, systematic nature of that failure — prosecutors and agents proceed to draw rational inferences from that data.
Then they proceed to corroborate those inferences, looking for other sources to support or even to contradict them. With one exception, all of this work has been done with neutral sources of evidence — documents, email metadata, government records and technical experts.
The exception is Bryan Pagliano, the one member of Mrs. Clinton’s inner circle who, with either a written promise of non-prosecution or an order of immunity from a federal judge, began to cooperate with federal prosecutors last fall.
Here is what he told the feds.
Mr. Pagliano has explained to federal prosecutors the who, what, when, how and why he migrated an open State Department email stream and a secret State Department email stream from government computers to Mrs. Clinton’s secret server in her home in Chappaqua, New York. He has told them that Mrs. Clinton paid him $5,000 to commit that likely criminal activity.
He has also told some of the 147 FBI agents assigned to this case thatMrs. Clinton herself was repeatedly told by her own State Department information technology experts and their colleagues at the National Security Agency that her persistent use of her off-the-shelf BlackBerry was neither an effective nor an acceptable means of receiving, transmitting or safeguarding state secrets. Little did they know how reckless she was with government secrets, as none was apparently then aware of her use of her non-secure secret server in Chappaqua for all of her email uses.
We know that the acquisition and corroboration phase of the investigation has been completed because the prosecutors have begun to ask Mrs. Clinton’s top aides during her time as secretary of State to come in for interviews. This is a delicate and dangerous phase for the aides, all of whom have engaged counsel to represent them.
Here are the dangers.
The Department of Justice will not reveal to the aides or their lawyers what it knows about the case or what evidence of criminal wrongdoing, if any, it has acquired on each of them. Hence, if they submit to an FBIinterview, they will go in “blind.” By going in blind, the aides run the risk of getting caught in a “perjury trap.” Though not under oath, they could be trapped into lying by astute prosecutors and aggressive FBI agents, as it is a crime — the equivalent of perjury — to lie to them or materially mislead them.
For this reason, most white-collar criminal defense lawyers will not permit their clients to be interviewed by any prosecutors or FBI agents. Martha Stewart’s lawyers failed to give her that advice, and she went to prison for one lie told in one conversation with one FBI agent.
After interviewing any Clinton aides who choose to be interviewed, the DOJ personnel on the case will move their investigation into its final phase, in which they will ask Mrs. Clinton herself whether she wishes to speak with them. The prosecutors will basically tell her lawyers that they have evidence of the criminal behavior of their client and that before they present it to a grand jury, they want to afford Mrs. Clinton an opportunity blindly to challenge it.
Here is her dilemma.
If she were to talk to federal prosecutors and FBI agents, they would catch her in many inconsistencies, as she has spoken with great deception in public about this case. She has, for example, stated many times that she used the private server so she could have one mobile device for all of her emails. The FBI knows she had four mobile devices. She has also falsely claimed publicly and under oath that she neither sent nor received anything “marked classified.” The FBI knows that nothing is marked classified, and its agents also know that her unprotected secret server transmitted some of the nation’s gravest secrets.
The prosecutors and agents cannot be happy about her public lies and her repeated demeaning attitude about their investigation, and they would have an understandable animus toward her if she were to meet with them.
If she were to decline to be interviewed — a prudent legal but treacherous political decision — the feds would leak her rejection of their invitation, and political turmoil would break loose because one of her most imprudent and often repeated public statements in this case has been that she can’t wait to talk to the FBI. That’s a lie, and the FBI knows it.
Some Democrats who now understand the gravity of the case againstMrs. Clinton have taken to arguing lately that the feds should establish a different and higher bar — a novel and unknown requirement for a greater quantum of evidence and proof of a heavier degree of harm — before Clinton can be prosecuted. They have suggested this merely because she is the likely Democratic presidential nominee.
The public will never stand for that. America has a bedrock commitment to the rule of law. The rule of law means that no one is beneath the law’s protections or above its requirements. The DOJ is not in the business of rewriting the law, but the Democrats should get in the business of rethinking Mrs. Clinton’s status as their presumptive presidential nominee, lest a summer catastrophe come their way.
• Andrew P. Napolitano, a former judge of the Superior Court of New Jersey, is a contributor to The Washington Times. He is the author of seven books on the U.S. Constitution.
The FBI investigation of former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s failure to protect state secrets contained in her emails has entered its penultimate phase, and it is a dangerous one for her and her aides.
Federal law enforcement sources have let it be known that federal prosecutors and the FBI have completed their examination of raw data in the case. After the FBI acquires raw data — for example, the nature and number of the state secrets in the emails Mrs. Clinton failed to protect or the regular, consistent, systematic nature of that failure — prosecutors and agents proceed to draw rational inferences from that data.
Then they proceed to corroborate those inferences, looking for other sources to support or even to contradict them. With one exception, all of this work has been done with neutral sources of evidence — documents, email metadata, government records and technical experts.
The exception is Bryan Pagliano, the one member of Mrs. Clinton’s inner circle who, with either a written promise of non-prosecution or an order of immunity from a federal judge, began to cooperate with federal prosecutors last fall.
Here is what he told the feds.
Mr. Pagliano has explained to federal prosecutors the who, what, when, how and why he migrated an open State Department email stream and a secret State Department email stream from government computers to Mrs. Clinton’s secret server in her home in Chappaqua, New York. He has told them that Mrs. Clinton paid him $5,000 to commit that likely criminal activity.
He has also told some of the 147 FBI agents assigned to this case thatMrs. Clinton herself was repeatedly told by her own State Department information technology experts and their colleagues at the National Security Agency that her persistent use of her off-the-shelf BlackBerry was neither an effective nor an acceptable means of receiving, transmitting or safeguarding state secrets. Little did they know how reckless she was with government secrets, as none was apparently then aware of her use of her non-secure secret server in Chappaqua for all of her email uses.
We know that the acquisition and corroboration phase of the investigation has been completed because the prosecutors have begun to ask Mrs. Clinton’s top aides during her time as secretary of State to come in for interviews. This is a delicate and dangerous phase for the aides, all of whom have engaged counsel to represent them.
Here are the dangers.
The Department of Justice will not reveal to the aides or their lawyers what it knows about the case or what evidence of criminal wrongdoing, if any, it has acquired on each of them. Hence, if they submit to an FBIinterview, they will go in “blind.” By going in blind, the aides run the risk of getting caught in a “perjury trap.” Though not under oath, they could be trapped into lying by astute prosecutors and aggressive FBI agents, as it is a crime — the equivalent of perjury — to lie to them or materially mislead them.
For this reason, most white-collar criminal defense lawyers will not permit their clients to be interviewed by any prosecutors or FBI agents. Martha Stewart’s lawyers failed to give her that advice, and she went to prison for one lie told in one conversation with one FBI agent.
After interviewing any Clinton aides who choose to be interviewed, the DOJ personnel on the case will move their investigation into its final phase, in which they will ask Mrs. Clinton herself whether she wishes to speak with them. The prosecutors will basically tell her lawyers that they have evidence of the criminal behavior of their client and that before they present it to a grand jury, they want to afford Mrs. Clinton an opportunity blindly to challenge it.
Here is her dilemma.
If she were to talk to federal prosecutors and FBI agents, they would catch her in many inconsistencies, as she has spoken with great deception in public about this case. She has, for example, stated many times that she used the private server so she could have one mobile device for all of her emails. The FBI knows she had four mobile devices. She has also falsely claimed publicly and under oath that she neither sent nor received anything “marked classified.” The FBI knows that nothing is marked classified, and its agents also know that her unprotected secret server transmitted some of the nation’s gravest secrets.
The prosecutors and agents cannot be happy about her public lies and her repeated demeaning attitude about their investigation, and they would have an understandable animus toward her if she were to meet with them.
If she were to decline to be interviewed — a prudent legal but treacherous political decision — the feds would leak her rejection of their invitation, and political turmoil would break loose because one of her most imprudent and often repeated public statements in this case has been that she can’t wait to talk to the FBI. That’s a lie, and the FBI knows it.
Some Democrats who now understand the gravity of the case againstMrs. Clinton have taken to arguing lately that the feds should establish a different and higher bar — a novel and unknown requirement for a greater quantum of evidence and proof of a heavier degree of harm — before Clinton can be prosecuted. They have suggested this merely because she is the likely Democratic presidential nominee.
The public will never stand for that. America has a bedrock commitment to the rule of law. The rule of law means that no one is beneath the law’s protections or above its requirements. The DOJ is not in the business of rewriting the law, but the Democrats should get in the business of rethinking Mrs. Clinton’s status as their presumptive presidential nominee, lest a summer catastrophe come their way.
• Andrew P. Napolitano, a former judge of the Superior Court of New Jersey, is a contributor to The Washington Times. He is the author of seven books on the U.S. Constitution.
Yesterday at 6:45 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance Committee discusses amending the three-year budget
Yesterday at 6:40 am by Rocky
» utube 11/26/24 MM&C MM&C Iraq News-Central Bank Iraq-Monetary Stability Excellent-Budget Law 2023,
Yesterday at 5:19 am by Rocky
» "Rich Iraq" seeks "money" to combat methane emissions: internal and external obstacles
Yesterday at 5:13 am by Rocky
» Increase in foreign remittance sales at the Central Bank of Iraq auction
Yesterday at 5:12 am by Rocky
» Its area is 2.5 million acres, and these are its details.. Work begins on a "large" residential city
Yesterday at 5:09 am by Rocky
» Kurdistan Finance delivers employees' salary schedule to the federal government
Yesterday at 5:08 am by Rocky
» Beggars are sweeping the streets of Iraq.. Their numbers are "large" and 90% of them receive welfare
Yesterday at 5:07 am by Rocky
» Settling tax trust claims
Yesterday at 5:05 am by Rocky
» Launching the National School Health Strategy
Yesterday at 5:04 am by Rocky
» Approval to implement service projects in Babylon
Yesterday at 5:02 am by Rocky
» New container handling berths at ports
Yesterday at 5:02 am by Rocky
» Work: Demand for registration in social security
Yesterday at 5:01 am by Rocky
» Reconstruction: Land Bank to be completed next year
Yesterday at 4:59 am by Rocky
» Aiming to enhance services in schools and prevent diseases, the National School Health Strategy for
Yesterday at 4:58 am by Rocky
» Karmian Festival witnesses the conclusion of commercial and industrial contracts
Yesterday at 4:57 am by Rocky
» Focus on the banking sector
Yesterday at 4:56 am by Rocky
» Minister of Trade: Studies Center is a turning point that serves the Iraqi economy
Yesterday at 4:55 am by Rocky
» Economists: Census is a roadmap for development
Yesterday at 4:54 am by Rocky
» Today's newspapers are interested in Al-Sudani's announcement that the population of Iraq exceeds 45
Yesterday at 4:53 am by Rocky
» International Development Bank: Today's incident was an extortion attempt that did not affect our wo
Yesterday at 4:48 am by Rocky
» thirty-sixth session, chaired by the Minister of Planning
Yesterday at 4:47 am by Rocky
» Closed meeting of the Parliamentary Finance Committee to discuss seven files
Yesterday at 4:46 am by Rocky
» The demographic boom in Iraq: an economic opportunity or a social burden?
Yesterday at 4:44 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani confirms to Russian delegation Iraq's desire to establish a mechanism that brings mutual b
Yesterday at 4:42 am by Rocky
» Parliament holds its session headed by Al-Mashhadani and attended by 168 MPs
Yesterday at 4:41 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi government deducts 1% of the salaries of employees and retirees to donate to Gaza and Leba
Yesterday at 4:38 am by Rocky
» Iran announces its commitment to continuing gas exports to Iraq
Yesterday at 4:37 am by Rocky
» Iraq, Russia discuss energy cooperation
Yesterday at 4:36 am by Rocky
» British Home Secretary to visit Iraq tomorrow
Yesterday at 4:35 am by Rocky
» The next parliament will have 450 members.. Officially, Al-Sudani announces that the population of I
Yesterday at 4:33 am by Rocky
» US Ambassador Warns of 'Frightening Actions': Iraq Does Not Want to Be Drawn into Regional Conflict
Yesterday at 4:32 am by Rocky
» Planning: The announced census results are not preliminary and the number will increase
Yesterday at 4:30 am by Rocky
» Election “hype” begins early.. Al-Maliki insists on holding it and Al-Sudani prepares
Yesterday at 4:29 am by Rocky
» “No more delays”.. Parliament changes the mechanism of holding sessions: “Controversial” laws are re
Yesterday at 4:28 am by Rocky
» Al-Mashhadani to the heads of the blocs: I prefer to vote on the general amnesty law before anything
Yesterday at 4:27 am by Rocky
» Iraq ranks 8th in the Arab world in achieving work-life balance in 2025
Yesterday at 4:26 am by Rocky
» Labor announces issuance of more than a quarter of a million national cards for social protection be
Yesterday at 4:24 am by Rocky
» Iraqi-Chinese research on accelerating combined cycle power projects
Yesterday at 4:23 am by Rocky
» Al-Maliki praises the decision of the International Criminal Court and demands the resolution of the
Yesterday at 4:22 am by Rocky
» Al-Mashhadani calls for voting on the general amnesty law for the “oppressed” before other laws
Yesterday at 4:21 am by Rocky
» Yazan Mishaan Al-Habouri revolts against his "leak": There are those who obstruct the government's e
Yesterday at 4:19 am by Rocky
» US Ambassador: Ending the presence of the international coalition in Iraq is being implemented and w
Yesterday at 4:18 am by Rocky
» Al-Mashhadani directs to raise the suspended laws to the Presidency of the House of Representatives
Yesterday at 4:17 am by Rocky
» "His general situation is unbearable" .. Parliamentarian: Political consensus to keep Iraq away from
Yesterday at 4:16 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani agrees to launch the “For Her” initiative to support Iraqi women
Yesterday at 4:15 am by Rocky
» Development Bank condemns extortion attempts: It will not affect our workflow
Yesterday at 4:13 am by Rocky
» Iraq-China oil-for-reconstruction deal faltering: A geopolitical shift in the Middle East
Yesterday at 4:12 am by Rocky
» Planning reveals the next step of the census: We will visit these families
Yesterday at 4:10 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance Committee calls on the government to expedite sending the budget tables
Yesterday at 4:09 am by Rocky
» OPEC+ may extend oil cuts at its meeting next Sunday
Yesterday at 4:06 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Integrity Committee discusses with the Director of Central Oil the file of contracts a
Yesterday at 4:04 am by Rocky
» Government notice regarding the legal status of foreign workers
Yesterday at 4:02 am by Rocky
» House of Representatives holds "important" session today.. Expectations of extending the legislative
Yesterday at 4:00 am by Rocky
» Slight rise in dollar prices against the dinar in Iraqi stock exchanges
Yesterday at 3:59 am by Rocky
» Baghdad "softens" and Kurdistan oil prepares to continue its global journey
Yesterday at 3:58 am by Rocky
» "For 5 million dinars or in installments" .. Iraqi electric cars soon on the streets
Yesterday at 3:57 am by Rocky
» Where did the Intelligence Bill get to in the House of Representatives?
Yesterday at 3:55 am by Rocky
» "Contract Suspicions Series"... What are the loopholes in the Korean air defense system contract in
Yesterday at 3:54 am by Rocky
» MP reveals latest developments in the formation of the new Kurdistan government
Yesterday at 3:51 am by Rocky
» Personal status: imposing a vision or turning Iraq into a copy similar to the Iranian religious regi
Yesterday at 3:50 am by Rocky
» Oral question to the governor.. Parliamentary movement regarding the “Basra, the Economic Capital of
Yesterday at 3:48 am by Rocky
» MM&C 11/25/24 Parliamentarian: We need to extend the legislative chapter to 8 sessions and the bud
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 10:04 am by Rocky
» Al-Alaq: The monetary situation in Iraq is excellent and our reserves support the stability of the e
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 8:29 am by Rocky
» utube 11/25/24 MM&C MM&C Iraq News-CBI Building Final Touches-Oil Exports-Development Road-Turkey-B
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 6:33 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary movement to include the salary scale in the next session
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 5:11 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Finance Committee reveals the budget paragraphs included in the amendment
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 5:10 am by Rocky
» Al-Maliki calls on the Bar Association to hold accountable members who violate professional conduct
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 5:08 am by Rocky
» Politician: The security agreement with America has many aspects
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 5:07 am by Rocky
» Kurdistan Planning: More than 6 million people live in the region, the oldest of them is 126 years o
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 5:05 am by Rocky
» Al-Alaq: Arab consensus on the role of central bank programs in addressing challenges
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 5:03 am by Rocky
» Economics saves from political drowning
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 5:02 am by Rocky
» Agriculture calls for strict ban on import of "industrial fats" and warns of health risks
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 5:01 am by Rocky
» Iraq is the fourth largest oil exporter to China
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 5:00 am by Rocky
» Railways continue to maintain a number of its lines to ensure the smooth running of trains
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:59 am by Rocky
» Parliament resumes its sessions tomorrow.. and these are the most important amendments in the budget
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:58 am by Rocky
» Bitcoin Fails to Continue Rising as It Approaches $100,000
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:57 am by Rocky
» Minister of Planning: There will be accurate figures for the population of each governorate
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:56 am by Rocky
» Popular Mobilization Law is ready for voting
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:54 am by Rocky
» Mechanisms for accepting people with disabilities into postgraduate studies
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:52 am by Rocky
» Government coordination to create five thousand jobs
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:51 am by Rocky
» Transport: Next month, a meeting with the international organization to resolve the European ban
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:50 am by Rocky
» Census is a path to digital government
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:49 am by Rocky
» Calls to facilitate loans and reduce interest rates for the private sector
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:47 am by Rocky
» The launch of the third and final phase of the "population census"
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:46 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: We have accomplished a step that is the most prominent in the framework of planning, deve
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:44 am by Rocky
» Justice discusses modern mechanisms to develop investment in real estate and minors’ money
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:43 am by Rocky
» Dubai to host Arabplast exhibition next month
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:41 am by Rocky
» Al-Tamimi: Integrity plays a major role in establishing the foundations of laws that will uphold jus
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:39 am by Rocky
» Reaching the most important people involved in the "theft of the century" in Diyala
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:38 am by Rocky
» Transportation: Completion of excavation works and connection of the immersed tunnel manufacturing b
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:36 am by Rocky
» Between internal and regional challenges... Formation of the Kurdistan government on a "slow fire" a
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:35 am by Rocky
» Kurdistan Region Presidency: We will issue a regional order to determine the first session of parlia
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:34 am by Rocky
» The Minister of Foreign Affairs announces the convening of the Ambassadors Conference tomorrow, Mond
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:33 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: Iraq must always be at the forefront
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:32 am by Rocky
» Al-Mashhadani: We support the Foreign Ministry in confronting any external interference that affects
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:31 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani chairs meeting with Oliver Wyman delegation
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:29 am by Rocky
» Half a million beggars in Iraq.. 90% of them receive welfare salaries
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:27 am by Rocky
» Sudanese announces preliminary results of the general population and housing census in detail
Mon 25 Nov 2024, 4:26 am by Rocky