Multiple currency system could be as unsettling as multiple warheads
5-9-16 11:06 AM EDT |
By David Marsh, MarketWatch
Eurozone and China pose biggest risks among the five major currency blocs
LONDON (MarketWatch) -- The world's multicurrency reserve system now shaping up (http://www.marketwatch.com/story/china-aims-to-make-imfs-special-drawing-right-a-real-currency-2016-04-26) is likely to be significantly more volatile than the de facto arrangement linking the dollar and Deutsche mark that existed until 1999, and the dollar-euro system that has existed since then.
This doesn't mean that we are likely to see currency fluctuations as extreme as the near-doubling of the dollar against the D-mark between 1979 (when the U.S. moved to extreme monetary tightening under Fed Chairman Paul Volcker) and the early 1980s. The Volcker squeeze was responsible for the political demise of Jimmy Carter in the U.S., Valery Giscard d'Estaing in France and Helmut Schmidt in Germany.
What we will see is radical multiple uncertainty caused by the oscillations of five major reserve currencies -- the dollar , euro , yen , sterling and renminbi -- each subject to the vagaries of their independent and uncoordinated financial and economic systems.
This need not be vastly unsettling. Indeed, it could be that, after some currency swings, the system will become relatively stable, with offsetting ups and downs of currencies and economic cycles. There may be some resemblance to the MIRV multiple-warhead nuclear missiles deployed by the U.S. and Soviet Union (and to a lesser extent by Britain, France and China) during the hot phase of the Cold War in the 1970s.
Denis Healey, U.K. defense secretary during part of this time, used to say, in the best spirit of nuclear deterrence, that uncertainty associated with the delightfully named multiple independently targetable re-entry vehicles was stabilizing because the adversary would be perpetually on tenterhooks. No one knew exactly which cities were targeted or indeed whether all the warheads were armed.
On the other hand, if communications went awry, signals were misunderstood, or reckless politicians and foolish advisers took control, the accumulation of nuclear tinder could have led to destruction putting the first two world wars in the shade. The same is true of the annihilation that could take place if today's monetary commanders veer too far off course.
Some fundamental fears about the safety of the monetary system focus on China. Beijing has won a battle to bring the renminbi into the International Monetary Fund's special drawing right from Oct. 1. Joining the other four main reserve currencies brings kudos and economic benefits. But it presupposes that the Chinese government can continue liberalization, both internally and in external interactions, without unduly disrupting Communist Party control.
Chinese leaders have pressed ahead with technocratic reforms in areas like foreign-exchange trading and interest rates but have hesitated to interfere with more overtly politicized parts of the economy, such as state-owned enterprises, the disorderly unwinding of which could have currency repercussions.
As Ravi Menon, managing director of the Monetary Authority of Singapore, noted in a lecture (http://www.omfif.org/meetings/city-lectures-and-launches/)sponsored by the Official Monetary and Financial Institutions Forum in London on May 5, China is juggling three balls at the same time: "grappling with the challenge of managing a growth slowdown, addressing vulnerabilities in its financial system, and implementing structural reforms."
The other big imponderable is the euro area.
Mario Draghi, president of the European Central Bank, said correctly in Frankfurt last week that the euro is at the center of a "global excess of savings", reflected in the large current-account surpluses of its principal creditor members, Germany and the Netherlands. Taking into account the sizeable surpluses of other noneuro countries such as Denmark, Sweden and Switzerland whose currencies are part of the wider euro area (and would undoubtedly join if weaker countries left), Europe is home to some of the world's largest current-account surpluses.
This is especially striking now that large Middle East oil exporters have moved into deficit.
The euro is too weak for the German, Dutch and Swiss economies, but too strong for the southern members trying to recover from debts and unemployment -- not a good signal for euro stability in coming years. With euro interest rates expected to remain low indefinitely, the high point for the euro's role in monetary reserves may have occurred in 2009. According to International Monetary Fund figures, its share of official foreign-exchange holdings has slipped since then by more than 8 percentage points, from 28% to 19.9%.
Former Defense Secretary Healey's aphorism on MIRVs may be fitting. The Big Five currencies' strengths and weaknesses may cancel out, just as happened with the five nuclear powers in the Cold War. But, in establishing whether this is true, we may be in for a bumpy ride.
-David Marsh; 415-439-6400; AskNewswires@dowjones.com
http://news.morningstar.com/all/market-watch/TDJNMW20160509254/multiple-currency-system-could-be-as-unsettling-as-multiple-warheads.aspx#.VzGxXCiK5rY.twitter?platform=hootsuite
5-9-16 11:06 AM EDT |
By David Marsh, MarketWatch
Eurozone and China pose biggest risks among the five major currency blocs
LONDON (MarketWatch) -- The world's multicurrency reserve system now shaping up (http://www.marketwatch.com/story/china-aims-to-make-imfs-special-drawing-right-a-real-currency-2016-04-26) is likely to be significantly more volatile than the de facto arrangement linking the dollar and Deutsche mark that existed until 1999, and the dollar-euro system that has existed since then.
This doesn't mean that we are likely to see currency fluctuations as extreme as the near-doubling of the dollar against the D-mark between 1979 (when the U.S. moved to extreme monetary tightening under Fed Chairman Paul Volcker) and the early 1980s. The Volcker squeeze was responsible for the political demise of Jimmy Carter in the U.S., Valery Giscard d'Estaing in France and Helmut Schmidt in Germany.
What we will see is radical multiple uncertainty caused by the oscillations of five major reserve currencies -- the dollar , euro , yen , sterling and renminbi -- each subject to the vagaries of their independent and uncoordinated financial and economic systems.
This need not be vastly unsettling. Indeed, it could be that, after some currency swings, the system will become relatively stable, with offsetting ups and downs of currencies and economic cycles. There may be some resemblance to the MIRV multiple-warhead nuclear missiles deployed by the U.S. and Soviet Union (and to a lesser extent by Britain, France and China) during the hot phase of the Cold War in the 1970s.
Denis Healey, U.K. defense secretary during part of this time, used to say, in the best spirit of nuclear deterrence, that uncertainty associated with the delightfully named multiple independently targetable re-entry vehicles was stabilizing because the adversary would be perpetually on tenterhooks. No one knew exactly which cities were targeted or indeed whether all the warheads were armed.
On the other hand, if communications went awry, signals were misunderstood, or reckless politicians and foolish advisers took control, the accumulation of nuclear tinder could have led to destruction putting the first two world wars in the shade. The same is true of the annihilation that could take place if today's monetary commanders veer too far off course.
Some fundamental fears about the safety of the monetary system focus on China. Beijing has won a battle to bring the renminbi into the International Monetary Fund's special drawing right from Oct. 1. Joining the other four main reserve currencies brings kudos and economic benefits. But it presupposes that the Chinese government can continue liberalization, both internally and in external interactions, without unduly disrupting Communist Party control.
Chinese leaders have pressed ahead with technocratic reforms in areas like foreign-exchange trading and interest rates but have hesitated to interfere with more overtly politicized parts of the economy, such as state-owned enterprises, the disorderly unwinding of which could have currency repercussions.
As Ravi Menon, managing director of the Monetary Authority of Singapore, noted in a lecture (http://www.omfif.org/meetings/city-lectures-and-launches/)sponsored by the Official Monetary and Financial Institutions Forum in London on May 5, China is juggling three balls at the same time: "grappling with the challenge of managing a growth slowdown, addressing vulnerabilities in its financial system, and implementing structural reforms."
The other big imponderable is the euro area.
Mario Draghi, president of the European Central Bank, said correctly in Frankfurt last week that the euro is at the center of a "global excess of savings", reflected in the large current-account surpluses of its principal creditor members, Germany and the Netherlands. Taking into account the sizeable surpluses of other noneuro countries such as Denmark, Sweden and Switzerland whose currencies are part of the wider euro area (and would undoubtedly join if weaker countries left), Europe is home to some of the world's largest current-account surpluses.
This is especially striking now that large Middle East oil exporters have moved into deficit.
The euro is too weak for the German, Dutch and Swiss economies, but too strong for the southern members trying to recover from debts and unemployment -- not a good signal for euro stability in coming years. With euro interest rates expected to remain low indefinitely, the high point for the euro's role in monetary reserves may have occurred in 2009. According to International Monetary Fund figures, its share of official foreign-exchange holdings has slipped since then by more than 8 percentage points, from 28% to 19.9%.
Former Defense Secretary Healey's aphorism on MIRVs may be fitting. The Big Five currencies' strengths and weaknesses may cancel out, just as happened with the five nuclear powers in the Cold War. But, in establishing whether this is true, we may be in for a bumpy ride.
-David Marsh; 415-439-6400; AskNewswires@dowjones.com
http://news.morningstar.com/all/market-watch/TDJNMW20160509254/multiple-currency-system-could-be-as-unsettling-as-multiple-warheads.aspx#.VzGxXCiK5rY.twitter?platform=hootsuite
» The Prime Minister is discussing in Paris providing Iraq with specialized radars and combat aircraft
» The Prime Minister is discussing with the delegation of Alstom Transport Company the suspended Baghd
» Prime Minister: We need a new style of relationship with the international coalition, and our financ
» An expert hints at the stability of the dollar at a certain number: two options before the dinar det
» It provides thousands of job opportunities and millions of dollars.. Can Iraq implement the "transit
» Pompeo's memoirs.. Al-Abadi told me: You take my money and Soleimani will take my life
» Iraq gets about $100 million annually from aircraft crossing its airspaceproposals from
» Iraq.. 12 million citizens do not receive 200,000 dinars per month
» 100 dollars for the “hardship” .. This is how the dollar is smuggled after the application of the el
» Iraq wants to buy French Rafale aircraft
» In detail... Iraq and France sign a memorandum of understanding in the field of combating corruption
» Transport reviews the details of a "giant project" linking Iraq with Europe
» Sheikh Jamal Al-Dari: Iraq's signing of the strategic partnership agreement with France is an import
» Legal experts: The Federal Court is unconstitutional and “political tensions” are behind the decisio
» Fouad Hussein: Al-Sudani and Macron did not address the recent Federal Court decision
» “Sales diplomacy.” South Korea strengthens its presence in Iraq and the region’s markets
» Foreign Ministry: Iraq seeks to recover smuggled funds by signing memorandums of understanding
» Parliamentary Finance: The dollar is available in the Central Bank, and banks refrain from buying it
» Al-Samarrai on the Paris Agreement: It represents a transition that the Iraqis have been waiting for
» "Exceptional circumstances" suspend the work of the Iraqi embassy in a European country
» This Is How The Dollar Crisis Was Made.. And This Is How The Sudanese Became! C 2
» 4 parliamentary questions looking for the "secret" of depositing Iraq's money in the US Federal Rese
» Ministry of Commerce: The prices of building materials in our warehouses are fixed and have not been
» Iraqi Kurdistan warns of the "illegal" suspension of funding
» Integrity announces the return of more than a trillion dinars in the investigations of the investmen
» Counselor Mazhar Saleh presents proposals to ensure market stability
» Obelisk Hour: The decision of the Federal Court is implemented retroactively and the money is return
» The Constitution Amendment Committee is fading away amid calls to reduce Parliament to 250 deputies
» The oil and gas law has been faltering since 2008, and the Federal Council is at the center of a dis
» Iraq is outside the group.. Arab countries are classified as a "cultural influence index"
» A leader in the framework: The theft of the century revealed 3 surprises... and 70% of the cases hav
» A leader in the framework: Russia will intervene in resolving the urgent dollar crisis in Iraq
» “The washing continues.” Parliamentary Finance: Exempting the governor of the Central Bank does not
» Kurdish deputy: One goal behind Baghdad's pressure on the oil companies in the region
» After cutting off funds from the region, its president announces: The Kurds are Iraqi citizens
» Al-Sudani in Paris.. Details about armament deals, gas and electricity investments
» Washington surprised Baghdad with the restrictions of the dollar.. A Dutch network talks about "deli
» There is no power over the judiciary other than the law.
» Parliament asks Foreign Minister Fuad Hussein about the reason for depositing Iraq's money in the US
» America calls on Iraq to abide by its sanctions against Iran and to prevent the transfer of the doll
» Sudanese financial advisor offers new solutions to reduce the dollar crisis
» Headed by Al-Halbousi.. Starting a consultative meeting for the Arab Inter-Parliamentary Union
» Prime Minister: We will continue to work for serious partnerships that guarantee Iraq achieving econ
» Adviser to the Prime Minister presents two proposals to ensure the stability of the national market
» Al-Sudani expresses his government's desire to cooperate with UNESCO to implement small and medium p
» Trade: Government movement led by Al-Sudani to control food prices
» Minister of Labor: The Social Research Campaign is the largest in the region
» Saleh: The proceeds of small trades constitute 70% of the total import units
» Resources: Upcoming meetings with the Turkish side and dialogues with Iran on water shares
» The Minister of Electricity explains the reason for the recent decline in supply hours
» Nechirvan Barzani discusses with Erdogan the situation in Kurdistan and Iraq and ways to enhance coo
» Nechirvan Barzani on the anniversary of the liberation of Kobani: The people of Kurdistan will never
» Education determines the number of college schools Iraq needs
» From behind the scenes of the stock exchanges...a specialist reveals 3 types of dollar dealers there
» A great success for the forum of commercial meetings between Iraqi and Qatari companies.
» Within the framework of aid distribution … the Minister of Immigration instructed to provide aid to
» Legal experts: The Federal Court is unconstitutional and “political tensions” are behind the decisio
» The Prime Minister announces the signing of the strategic partnership agreement with Macron
» Al-Sudani appoints Laith Al-Athari as a member of the Board of Trustees of the Media and Communicati
» Judge Jaafar reveals the secrets of theft of the century: Politicians and parties in the previous go
» Al-Halbousi concludes his visit to Algeria
» The industry announces the production of 24 thousand tons of asphalt derivatives and an increase in
» Terrifying.. revealing the toll of mine victims in the Kurdistan region
» Education announces the availability of scholarships for foreign students and seats for non-Iraqis
» Reveal the details of the Iraqi-French agreement
» The stability of the dollar exchange rate in Iraq
» The Ministry of Industry announces the formation of special committees to implement the government p
» Al-Sudani and Macron discuss joint cooperation in a number of vital sectors
» Under the auspices of its Minister, Nizar Amidi, the environment organizes an event to launch the Vi
» Iraq.. Overthrowing more than 1,100 dealers and seizing 22,159 kg of drugs during the current month
» The House of Representatives announces the agenda for the next Saturday session
» An official statement reveals the details of the Sudanese and Macron meeting
» Presidency of the Council hinder the discussion of the exchange rate
» Dollar exchange rates in the Iraqi market
» The most prominent contents of the partnership agreement between Iraq and France
» Analysis: 4 reasons prompted Al-Sudani to demand the survival of US forces in Iraq
» The Iraqi judiciary: the main suspect in the tax secretariat case paid about two-thirds of the money
» After the message of the US Federal Reserve to the Iraqi Central Bank... a new strategy to combat "m
» The Kurdistan region is negotiating with the Iranian opposition parties to stop their activities in
» Economist: 14% for Kurdistan in the 2023 budget, in exchange for the delivery of 150,000 barrels of
» Minister of Labor: We are keen to provide the best services and we do not want to pass poverty on to
» Trade: Government movement led by Al-Sudani to control food prices
» Iraq second.. a list of the countries that import the most from Iran
» Kurdistan Parliament: The decision of the Federal Court will negatively affect the rapprochement bet
» KTFA Wednesday Night CC with Frank26 "Numbers" 1-25-2023
» Al-Halbousi is heading a parliamentary delegation to participate in the meeting of the Organization
» Disclosure of the details of the framework agreement with the Sudanese to dismiss the central govern
» American report: The Kurdistan government allowed the Turkish bombing of its lands as a metaphor for
» Reuters: A close victory for Al-Sudani through a French-Qatari deal worth $27 billionproposals from
» Ina / Al-Jubouri: America considers leaving Iraq as its loss to the Middle East
» Aware / Al-Shammari: Fruitful cooperation between Iraq and Jordan in controlling borders and combati
» State of law: Finance Minister Taif Sami prevented the sending of money to Kurdistan a month ago
» After a day of protests in front of the Iraqi Central Bank.. the dollar prices stabilized at 161 tho
» Integrity opens the file (investment portfolio) between retirement and Qi Card and returns more than
» Al-Dari: We trust Al-Sudanese ability to find "constitutional alternatives" that respect the decisio
» The deputy speaker of the Iraqi parliament calls on the political forces to take a stand on the deci
» A travel ban was issued against the former agent of the Iraqi Intelligence Agency, Ahmed "Abu Raghee
» An analysis detailing the significance of the Sudanese visit to France