Home
Iraqi Panel Promotes 'Biden Plan' For Federal Iraq
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
US Vice President Joe Biden talks with soldiers at Camp Victory on the outskirts of Baghdad
An Iraqi parliamentary committee, in a recent visit to Washington, has reiterated its demands to divide Iraq into three regions in a bid to solve the current problems plaguing the country. These demands have been made several times in the past, and they consist of creating three major regions that enjoy demographic and political unity ? Shiite in the south, Sunni in the west and center, and Kurdish in the north.
In both popular and media memory, this idea has been associated with the name of US Vice President Joe Biden, as he was the one to suggest it when he was a senator in 2007. At the time, the idea was opposed by the Baker-Hamilton Co mmission, which was set up by former US President George W. Bush to study the situation in Iraq after the outbreak of civil war in 2006.
This association, however, seems largely misleading, and it has been used to either defend the idea by giving it objective and international dimensions, or to demonize it by saying that the goal of the US war on Iraq in 2003 was to divide the country, in the framework of an ongoing conspiracy theory.
The idea of regions was raised in different ways prior to the US occupation of Iraq. It was adopted by the Kurds decades ago, and translated into the autonomy project of the Kurdish areas, which was announced by the authorities in the mid-1970s. The idea was then put on the agenda of the Salahuddin Conference for the Iraqi opposition forces in 1992, and then discussed in the conference of the same forces in London in 2002.
After 2003, the issue of regions was raised in a clearer way. In exchange for making the Iraqi Kurdistan region a reality, prominent Shiite forces headed by the Supreme Islamic Council openly adopted the Shiite regional project under the name of "the region of the center and the south." In contrast, the Sunni regional project was explicitly raised for the first time by former governor of Anbar Faisal al-Qaoud in 2003. He gave his life defending this idea.
Meanwhile, discussions about the project were ongoing in Iraq before Biden reintroduced it in 2007, and they did not stop afterward. But there have been changes in the views of these communities over the past 10 years. Shiites found it absurd to cling to this project at a time during which they fully controlled the central government. Thus, supporters of the Shiite region challenged this project and defended the idea of a strong central state. Meanwhile, Sunnis who had attacked the project gradually adopted and defended it. For their part, Kurds continued to cling to it and deem it the solution for Iraq and a safeguard against the emergence of an authoritarian central authority.
Apart from the historical basis of forming federal regions in Iraq, the visit made by the Iraqi parliamentary delegation to the US was an occasion to relaunch the project as a solution to the political crisis plaguing Iraq. Head of the parliamentary legal committee, Khalid Shwani, confirmed in a statement that "a delegation of the committee met during its visit to the US at the State Department with the assistant secretary of state for Near Eastern affairs and the people in charge of the Iraq dossier at the ministry in order to discuss views on the future of relations between the two countries within the framework of the strategic agreement, as well as the political crisis in the country.?
Shwani pointed out that ?the committee believes that the establishment of three federations in Iraq will be a guarantee for the construction of a unified federal state as per the project of US Vice President Joe Biden.?
?The delegation of the committee and US officials emphasized the need to address the problems in accordance with the constitution in order to ensure the participation of all in the decision-making process and complete the building of the federal state institution,? he added.
Remarkably, the statement also attempted to link the project to establish three regions to Biden, and ignored all the aforementioned history. Yet, that is not the core issue, which is that solutions are totally absent in Iraq, except for a federal system based on national and sectarian factors.
The assumption that the three federations will succeed in resolving the Iraqi crisis seems to be a prejudice. These are the same assumptions that have confounded the situation in Iraq since 2003, and prevented a stable identity of the state from being established.
Assuming that sectarian or national homogeneity in each region could dissolve the regional, tribal, political and economic conflicts that are expected to erupt between and within the cities seems to be general and uncertain, just as Sunni and Shiite overlapping ? in the cities of Basra in the far south, Mosul in the far north and the cities of Diyala, Salahuddin, Babil, Wasit and Karbala ? is also uncertain.
In addition, easing the political struggle over power in Baghdad through [the establishment of] regions will not prevent other kinds of conflict over the borders of these regions from erupting, particularly with the significant border conflict between Iraqi cities, not to mention the problems concerning the distribution and management of wealth.
With all this, the essence of the federal concept is still a significant point of contention in Iraq, where those opposing it believe that the Kurdistan region of Iraq?s complex and specific situation does not realistically represent a federation and is closer to a confederation.
All these assumptions lead to an objective question: Have the Iraqis exhausted all alternative solutions, most notably the implementation of a real decentralized system that gives a specific status to the Kurdistan region and broad powers to the other administrative units (the provinces)?
Of course, the answer is, "No." The law, which clarifies the relationship between the central government in Baghdad and provincial authorities, was not serious in guaranteeing a decentralized system, and did not give the provinces the powers that they are entitled to have. Yet, it has contributed to consolidating the central authority?s powers, and allowed the political, security and economic turmoil in Iraq today to be produced.
The key to Iraq lies in turning the provinces into administrative units with wide powers that may be similar to the federal powers, in the fields of internal security, investment, construction, services, education, religious and sectarian specificity in exchange for annulling many central service ministries and bureaucratic systems inherited from the former socialist regime.
Empowering the provinces cannot take place without a fair distribution of wealth, ensuring that foreign policy, the military and national security are in the hands of the central authority, and passing a series of laws, most notably the establishment of the Federation Council, as provided in the Iraqi constitution. This Council would be parallel to the Iraqi Parliament and control the ties between the provinces, the regions and authority in Baghdad.
Iraq did not go through a phase of a decentralized system to prescribe its failure and move toward its partition into three regions. Security failures, economic regression and the spread of corruption probably reside in not taking openly, legally and clearly the option of a decentralized state, and the non-emergence of political parties and leaders who seek to be strongly committed to a comprehensive centralized system.
Mushreq Abbas is a contributing writer for Al-Monitor?s Iraq Pulse. An author and journalist who has worked in the media for 15 years, he holds a degree in political science from Baghdad University.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
US Vice President Joe Biden talks with soldiers at Camp Victory on the outskirts of Baghdad
An Iraqi parliamentary committee, in a recent visit to Washington, has reiterated its demands to divide Iraq into three regions in a bid to solve the current problems plaguing the country. These demands have been made several times in the past, and they consist of creating three major regions that enjoy demographic and political unity ? Shiite in the south, Sunni in the west and center, and Kurdish in the north.
In both popular and media memory, this idea has been associated with the name of US Vice President Joe Biden, as he was the one to suggest it when he was a senator in 2007. At the time, the idea was opposed by the Baker-Hamilton Co mmission, which was set up by former US President George W. Bush to study the situation in Iraq after the outbreak of civil war in 2006.
This association, however, seems largely misleading, and it has been used to either defend the idea by giving it objective and international dimensions, or to demonize it by saying that the goal of the US war on Iraq in 2003 was to divide the country, in the framework of an ongoing conspiracy theory.
The idea of regions was raised in different ways prior to the US occupation of Iraq. It was adopted by the Kurds decades ago, and translated into the autonomy project of the Kurdish areas, which was announced by the authorities in the mid-1970s. The idea was then put on the agenda of the Salahuddin Conference for the Iraqi opposition forces in 1992, and then discussed in the conference of the same forces in London in 2002.
After 2003, the issue of regions was raised in a clearer way. In exchange for making the Iraqi Kurdistan region a reality, prominent Shiite forces headed by the Supreme Islamic Council openly adopted the Shiite regional project under the name of "the region of the center and the south." In contrast, the Sunni regional project was explicitly raised for the first time by former governor of Anbar Faisal al-Qaoud in 2003. He gave his life defending this idea.
Meanwhile, discussions about the project were ongoing in Iraq before Biden reintroduced it in 2007, and they did not stop afterward. But there have been changes in the views of these communities over the past 10 years. Shiites found it absurd to cling to this project at a time during which they fully controlled the central government. Thus, supporters of the Shiite region challenged this project and defended the idea of a strong central state. Meanwhile, Sunnis who had attacked the project gradually adopted and defended it. For their part, Kurds continued to cling to it and deem it the solution for Iraq and a safeguard against the emergence of an authoritarian central authority.
Apart from the historical basis of forming federal regions in Iraq, the visit made by the Iraqi parliamentary delegation to the US was an occasion to relaunch the project as a solution to the political crisis plaguing Iraq. Head of the parliamentary legal committee, Khalid Shwani, confirmed in a statement that "a delegation of the committee met during its visit to the US at the State Department with the assistant secretary of state for Near Eastern affairs and the people in charge of the Iraq dossier at the ministry in order to discuss views on the future of relations between the two countries within the framework of the strategic agreement, as well as the political crisis in the country.?
Shwani pointed out that ?the committee believes that the establishment of three federations in Iraq will be a guarantee for the construction of a unified federal state as per the project of US Vice President Joe Biden.?
?The delegation of the committee and US officials emphasized the need to address the problems in accordance with the constitution in order to ensure the participation of all in the decision-making process and complete the building of the federal state institution,? he added.
Remarkably, the statement also attempted to link the project to establish three regions to Biden, and ignored all the aforementioned history. Yet, that is not the core issue, which is that solutions are totally absent in Iraq, except for a federal system based on national and sectarian factors.
The assumption that the three federations will succeed in resolving the Iraqi crisis seems to be a prejudice. These are the same assumptions that have confounded the situation in Iraq since 2003, and prevented a stable identity of the state from being established.
Assuming that sectarian or national homogeneity in each region could dissolve the regional, tribal, political and economic conflicts that are expected to erupt between and within the cities seems to be general and uncertain, just as Sunni and Shiite overlapping ? in the cities of Basra in the far south, Mosul in the far north and the cities of Diyala, Salahuddin, Babil, Wasit and Karbala ? is also uncertain.
In addition, easing the political struggle over power in Baghdad through [the establishment of] regions will not prevent other kinds of conflict over the borders of these regions from erupting, particularly with the significant border conflict between Iraqi cities, not to mention the problems concerning the distribution and management of wealth.
With all this, the essence of the federal concept is still a significant point of contention in Iraq, where those opposing it believe that the Kurdistan region of Iraq?s complex and specific situation does not realistically represent a federation and is closer to a confederation.
All these assumptions lead to an objective question: Have the Iraqis exhausted all alternative solutions, most notably the implementation of a real decentralized system that gives a specific status to the Kurdistan region and broad powers to the other administrative units (the provinces)?
Of course, the answer is, "No." The law, which clarifies the relationship between the central government in Baghdad and provincial authorities, was not serious in guaranteeing a decentralized system, and did not give the provinces the powers that they are entitled to have. Yet, it has contributed to consolidating the central authority?s powers, and allowed the political, security and economic turmoil in Iraq today to be produced.
The key to Iraq lies in turning the provinces into administrative units with wide powers that may be similar to the federal powers, in the fields of internal security, investment, construction, services, education, religious and sectarian specificity in exchange for annulling many central service ministries and bureaucratic systems inherited from the former socialist regime.
Empowering the provinces cannot take place without a fair distribution of wealth, ensuring that foreign policy, the military and national security are in the hands of the central authority, and passing a series of laws, most notably the establishment of the Federation Council, as provided in the Iraqi constitution. This Council would be parallel to the Iraqi Parliament and control the ties between the provinces, the regions and authority in Baghdad.
Iraq did not go through a phase of a decentralized system to prescribe its failure and move toward its partition into three regions. Security failures, economic regression and the spread of corruption probably reside in not taking openly, legally and clearly the option of a decentralized state, and the non-emergence of political parties and leaders who seek to be strongly committed to a comprehensive centralized system.
Mushreq Abbas is a contributing writer for Al-Monitor?s Iraq Pulse. An author and journalist who has worked in the media for 15 years, he holds a degree in political science from Baghdad University.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Thanks for the AM chuckle Neno...totally agree!!!
» utube 11/18/24 MM&C IQD News Report - Contracts - Projects - Non Oil Revenue Streams - Activating
» MM&C 11/17/24 For the first time in Iraq.. Efforts to establish an "Investment Association" to attr
» utube 11/16/24 MM&C-News Report-Iraq Dinar-Oil-Flow-Global Maritime Trade-Cross Border Transfer-Ex
» Global conflicts move to Iraq.. America and China fight economically in Baghdad
» Al-Sudani: Iraqi openness to comprehensive partnership with Türkiye and developing trade balance
» Accused of negligence, the Parliamentary Energy Committee calls on Al-Sudani to hold the “Baghdad El
» Al-Maliki's coalition notes Al-Sudani's performance in three files
» On charges of forgery... Al-Dulaimi complains about Al-Halbousi before the Integrity Commission
» Al-Karawi: The government mortgaged the port of Faw to companies affiliated with the Zionist entity
» Parliamentary Integrity: We will proceed with the ministerial amendment even if the government delay
» Reopening of applications to the morning private government education channel
» Bitcoin rises after weekly losses
» Al-Maliki Coalition: The government amendment does not exceed three ministerial portfolios
» Parliamentarian: Amending the Election Law is out of the question
» Israel threatens to target infrastructure in Iraq and assassinate "prominent figures"
» Parliamentary regions: Article 140 road is closed
» The Central Bank of Iraq's dollar sales increased
» Al-Alaq reviews to the President of the Republic the Central Bank’s plans to develop the banking sec
» Al-Atwani to the French Embassy delegation: Halting external borrowing indicates an improvement in I
» Parliamentary move against Kar Oil Company: Suspicions of "fake" electricity supply
» Parliamentary Health: Iraq suffers from a large surplus in the number of doctors and pharmacists by
» It causes a loss of one billion dollars per month.. A date has been set for the resumption of Kurdis
» Türkiye blames Iraq: You waste water and do not have good management in rationalizing it
» Iraq rejects “COP29” proposal: We will not get rid of fossil fuels, as they are the basis of our eco
» Bitcoin nears $90,000 after biggest drop since election
» For the first time, Iraq issues the commodity structure of exports and imports
» Procedures for (automating) the work of Baghdad International Airport
» Planning: No cuts to benefits or taxes due to census
» International organizations praise the government's national initiatives
» {Official platform} to combat rumors
» Al-Sudani: The census will be used exclusively to develop development plans
» Justice audits financial movements in its departments
» Al-Imar to {Sabah}: 3 residential cities in Baghdad to be referred soon
» Kurdistan Region of Iraq plans to receive 10 million tourists annually
» Discussion of mineral investment and export mechanisms
» Consensus on the importance of planning in achieving sustainable development
» Corporate Restructuring: Stimulating Economic Growth
» Iraq's commitment to OPEC decisions controls oil prices
» Delete zeros and evaluate the dinar
» Economists: Empowering the private sector requires a legislative system
» Preparations for holding meetings of the Iraqi-Egyptian Committee
» Parliamentary Legal Committee to Nina: Controversial and important laws will be passed in one go in
» Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics to Nina: The census activities are completely
» Turkish Trade Minister to visit Iraq tomorrow, Monday, heading a delegation of businessmen
» Slight decrease in dollar exchange rates in local markets
» Basra Gas Company launches the “Safe Step” program to raise awareness of the dangers of mines and wa
» With high-level governmental and international presence... the activities of the Iraqi Digital Space
» Ministry of Oil: FCC project to produce derivatives to be completed in the middle of next year
» Does America influence the decisions to form the regional government?.. 5 critical months
» Search for remains of the eight-year war postponed until 2025.. Diggers await spring
» US forces reposition in the "Desert Triangle" in western Iraq
» Al-Dahlaki: The general amnesty law is not just an election slogan as the "forgers" want it to be
» Date set for resuming oil exports from Kurdistan via Turkish port of Ceyhan
» 2025 budget between the government and parliament corridors
» Parliamentary Finance: Population census is a criterion for distributing resources and financial all
» Dollar prices in Iraqi markets
» A source reviews the factors that "undermine" the goals.. What is behind the efforts to form the "Ce
» What are the most controversial paragraphs in the general amnesty law? Al-Saadi reveals to Sumaria
» Al-Sudani chairs the fifth session of the Supreme Coordination Committee between the governorates
» A fruitful international-Japanese partnership produces its eighth batch... Celebrating the success o
» The President of the Republic stresses the need to develop a future strategy for financial policy ac
» Tomorrow.. Turkish Trade Minister visits Baghdad to discuss several files
» Rashid and Al-Alaq discuss the future of the Iraqi banking sector
» US Ambassador assures Maliki of her country's support for Iraq's stability
» Parliamentarian addressing the Judicial Council: When will corruption files be resolved?
» Economist: Re-exporting Kurdistan oil will cause Iraq to lose $5 billion and a budget deficit
» Financial Advisor: Good performance of fiscal space reflects government’s ability to increase spendi
» The President of the Republic stresses the need to develop a future strategy for financial policy
» Parliament determines the most important laws it will work on before its legislative break in a few
» Dollar exchange rates against the dinar in Iraqi stock exchanges
» Government correspondence to install 8 thousand electricity meter readers
» utube 11/13/24 MM&C MM&C News-Private Sector- Electronic Payments-Reconstruction-Development-Digit
» utube MM&C 11/15/24 Update-Budget-Non Oil Resources-CBI-USFED-Cross Border Transfers-Oil
» Al-Sudani is besieged by lawsuits over the “wiretapping network”... and Al-Maliki heard “inappropria
» Tens of thousands of foreigners work illegally in Basra... and the departments will bear the respons
» 4 reasons for the Sudanese government’s silence in the face of the factions’ attacks.. Will Baghdad
» PM's advisor: Government able to increase spending without inflation or fiscal deficit
» Prime Minister stresses the need to complete 2024 projects before the end
» Minister of Labor sets date for launching second batch of social protection beneficiaries in the pol
» Al-Sudani approves 35 new service projects, stresses the need to complete 2024 projects
» Minister of Labor: The population census will provide accurate calculations of poor families covered
» Electricity announces its readiness for the winter peak
» Economist: Parallel market remains pivotal to financing Iraq’s trade with Iran, Syria
» Trump: Iraq: A subsidiary or the focus of major deals?
» Counselor Mazhar Saleh: The government is able to increase spending without causing inflation or a f
» Al-Sudani's advisor to "Al-Maalouma": We do not need to bring in foreign workers
» Parliamentary Rejection.. Parliamentarian Talks About Jordanian Agreement That Harms Iraq’s Economy
» Al-Sudani chairs the periodic meeting of the service and engineering effort team
» Al-Sahaf: Washington continues to support terrorist organizations in Iraq
» Al-Maliki Coalition: America is trying to make Iraq hostile to its neighbors by violating its airspa
» Close source: Al-Sudani failed to convince Al-Hakim and Al-Amiri to carry out the ministerial reshuf
» Al-Sayhoud on Postponing Parliament Sessions: Bad Start for Al-Mashhadani
» Peshmerga Minister: The survival of the Kurdistan Region depends on the presence of a strong Peshmer
» Al-Maliki Coalition: US pressures prevent Israel from striking Iraq
» Nechirvan Barzani calls for keeping Peshmerga out of partisan conflicts, urges formation of 'strong
» US Institute: Trump administration may prevent Iraq from importing Iranian gas as part of pressure o
» The meter will visit families again.. Planning details the steps for conducting the population censu
» Government clarification: Is Iraq able to increase spending?