Home
As the Debt Hits $19 Trillion, Has the US Reached a Tipping Point?
Emily Flake/The Fiscal Times
By Rob Garver and Eric Pianin
April 15, 2016
For several years, the growing federal debt was ignored as the economic recovery chipped away at once massive spending shortfalls of $1 trillion or more. Now, there’s an uneasy feeling among many policy makers and experts that we are beginning to slip back into risky fiscal terrain.
The last time the budget was in balance was in 2001, at the tail end of Democratic President Bill Clinton’s second term. While the government has been awash in red ink ever since, President Obama and congressional GOP leaders have rightfully crowed about a series of bipartisan deals that helped bring down the annual deficit from an astounding $1.4 trillion in 2009 – at the very worst point in the recession – to $438.4 billion just last year.
Related: Big Deficits Loom as Candidates Pile on Spending and Tax Cuts
But times are changing again, and the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has issued several distress calls in recent months that the deficit is headed north again. We will return to another era of big deficits, CBO warns, unless Congress and the White House step in with some meaningful spending reforms. And that, of course, means figuring out how to provide Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security to a growing army of retiring baby boomers without breaking the bank.
Six years ago, The White House and Congress had a real chance of reaching a “grand bargain” of tax and spending reforms that would have put the government on a true, long-term course to another balanced budget. But as is often the case, a lack of political nerve and political foresight prevented that from happening.
Today, we are mostly treated to political doublespeak and hypocrisy about the budget and the need to address a national debt that has reached an historic $19.2 trillion. And that hypocrisy – being played out on Capitol Hill and on the presidential campaign trail – is driving budget and economic experts and average Americans to distraction.
Related: CBO Warns Congressional Spending Is Driving Up the Deficit
It is hard to miss the fact that Congress is once again so politically hamstrung that House and Senate GOP leaders this week threw up their hands and abandoned efforts to pass a budget for the coming fiscal year. There will still be spending bills – have no fear. But the thought of fashioning a comprehensive blue print with a coherent and feasible plan for addressing the long-term debt is out of the question.
Things are no better on the presidential campaign trail where Republicans Donald Trump and Ted Cruz are promoting huge tax cuts that would add trillions of dollars to the national debt. Democrat Bernie Sanders is pushing an $18 trillion “Great Society” style spending agenda that will add many trillions more to the national debt, while Clinton’s adds $1 trillion in additional spending and could reduce tax revenue.
Time Magazine this week published a special issue about the federal debt, turning its cover into a collection notice claiming, “Every American man, woman and child would need to pay” $42,998.12 in order to eliminate the national debt.
The cover story by economist James Grant, of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer, is part diatribe about government spending and the role of the Federal Reserve and part paean to the gold standard. It concludes with a half-hearted endorsement of a flat tax plus a call for the end of employers withholding taxes from employees’ paychecks.
Related: Sanders’ Single-Payer Plan Would Add Up to $14 Trillion to the Debt
Grant makes the indisputable point that the federal debt has exploded in recent years, particularly as the government used monetary stimulus to keep the nation’s economy from sliding into a depression.
But in his telling of the story, the Federal Reserve comes across as the villain -- “the government’s Monopoly-money machine” -- that has enabled a profligate Congress to spend the country into a crisis. “The Fed once fought inflation,” he laments. “Now it actually sets out to cause it–about 2 percent a year is the target. Striving to inflate, it presses down interest rates and rustles up new dollars.”
That’s not a story that most of Grant’s fellow economists are likely to agree with. While virtually all would likely say that the federal debt is higher than it ought to be, substantially fewer would trade current levels of debt for a Fed that passively accepted deflation in the wake of the financial crisis. Fewer still would agree that sticking to a principle that says federal debt must remain low would have been worth risking another Great Depression.
Related: Paul Ryan Faces Fiscal Failure as the House Blows the Budget Deadline
Grant’s article includes a coy discussion of a return to the Gold Standard. Virtually no mainstream economist would endorse returning to a world in which each dollar is tied to a specific amount of gold. And Grant doesn’t either, exactly. He just points out that things sure were better back then.
“Sound money coincided with balanced budgets,” he writes.
However, “I don’t ask that we return to some long-lost fiscal and monetary Eden. None has ever existed, even in America. Crises and business cycles are always with us. I merely observe that sound money and a balanced budget were two sides of the coin of American prosperity.”
For reference, back in November, when Republican presidential candidate Ted Cruz advocated a return to the gold standard during a televised debate, David Wessel, director of the Hutchins Center on Fiscal and Monetary Policy at the Brookings Institution, said, “It’s basically seen as nuts, and I think even most conservative economists would say that. We learned the hard way that the gold standard does not bring financial stability. We learned that it’s really bad to have a money supply that’s restricted to the amount of gold you can mine.”
Grant’s article is long on criticism, but relatively short on solutions. After citing statistics about tax avoidance and the amount of effort Americans put into tax preparation, he offers a backhanded endorsement of a flat tax: “Are we quite sure we want no part of the flat-tax idea? An identical low rate on most incomes. No deductions, no H&R Block. Impractical? So is the debt.”
Related: The GOP Budget Is on Life Support, and Paul Ryan Knows It
He also invokes 1950s-era anti-tax activist Vivien Kellems, and urges the country to adopt a program for which she argued. Under Kellems’ plan, employers would no longer withhold taxes. Workers would be given the entirety of their gross pay, and be required to personally hand over the share the government takes.”
Although it would be wildly inefficient, the plan would have the merit of making Americans highly cognizant of the amount of money the government extracts from them in taxes, assessments, and other levies. It also has about as much chance of being implemented as...well...a return to the gold standard.
Americans would be better served if our politicians paid more attention to fiscal responsibility and to the long-term damage excessive debt can do to the country. But these are hard and complex problems that won’t be easily solved.
http://www.thefiscaltimes.com/2016/04/15/Debt-Hits-19-Trillion-Has-US-Reached-Tipping-Point?utm_campaign=548f5168cb03a93709042da0&utm_source=boomtrain&utm_medium=email&bt_alias=eyJ1c2VySWQiOiI5ZDZhYWZiMy00MTE0LTFjMjYtNjA3OC00ZWIzZTc5ZDA3NGMifQ%3D%3D
Emily Flake/The Fiscal Times
By Rob Garver and Eric Pianin
April 15, 2016
For several years, the growing federal debt was ignored as the economic recovery chipped away at once massive spending shortfalls of $1 trillion or more. Now, there’s an uneasy feeling among many policy makers and experts that we are beginning to slip back into risky fiscal terrain.
The last time the budget was in balance was in 2001, at the tail end of Democratic President Bill Clinton’s second term. While the government has been awash in red ink ever since, President Obama and congressional GOP leaders have rightfully crowed about a series of bipartisan deals that helped bring down the annual deficit from an astounding $1.4 trillion in 2009 – at the very worst point in the recession – to $438.4 billion just last year.
Related: Big Deficits Loom as Candidates Pile on Spending and Tax Cuts
But times are changing again, and the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has issued several distress calls in recent months that the deficit is headed north again. We will return to another era of big deficits, CBO warns, unless Congress and the White House step in with some meaningful spending reforms. And that, of course, means figuring out how to provide Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security to a growing army of retiring baby boomers without breaking the bank.
Six years ago, The White House and Congress had a real chance of reaching a “grand bargain” of tax and spending reforms that would have put the government on a true, long-term course to another balanced budget. But as is often the case, a lack of political nerve and political foresight prevented that from happening.
Today, we are mostly treated to political doublespeak and hypocrisy about the budget and the need to address a national debt that has reached an historic $19.2 trillion. And that hypocrisy – being played out on Capitol Hill and on the presidential campaign trail – is driving budget and economic experts and average Americans to distraction.
Related: CBO Warns Congressional Spending Is Driving Up the Deficit
It is hard to miss the fact that Congress is once again so politically hamstrung that House and Senate GOP leaders this week threw up their hands and abandoned efforts to pass a budget for the coming fiscal year. There will still be spending bills – have no fear. But the thought of fashioning a comprehensive blue print with a coherent and feasible plan for addressing the long-term debt is out of the question.
Things are no better on the presidential campaign trail where Republicans Donald Trump and Ted Cruz are promoting huge tax cuts that would add trillions of dollars to the national debt. Democrat Bernie Sanders is pushing an $18 trillion “Great Society” style spending agenda that will add many trillions more to the national debt, while Clinton’s adds $1 trillion in additional spending and could reduce tax revenue.
Time Magazine this week published a special issue about the federal debt, turning its cover into a collection notice claiming, “Every American man, woman and child would need to pay” $42,998.12 in order to eliminate the national debt.
The cover story by economist James Grant, of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer, is part diatribe about government spending and the role of the Federal Reserve and part paean to the gold standard. It concludes with a half-hearted endorsement of a flat tax plus a call for the end of employers withholding taxes from employees’ paychecks.
Related: Sanders’ Single-Payer Plan Would Add Up to $14 Trillion to the Debt
Grant makes the indisputable point that the federal debt has exploded in recent years, particularly as the government used monetary stimulus to keep the nation’s economy from sliding into a depression.
But in his telling of the story, the Federal Reserve comes across as the villain -- “the government’s Monopoly-money machine” -- that has enabled a profligate Congress to spend the country into a crisis. “The Fed once fought inflation,” he laments. “Now it actually sets out to cause it–about 2 percent a year is the target. Striving to inflate, it presses down interest rates and rustles up new dollars.”
That’s not a story that most of Grant’s fellow economists are likely to agree with. While virtually all would likely say that the federal debt is higher than it ought to be, substantially fewer would trade current levels of debt for a Fed that passively accepted deflation in the wake of the financial crisis. Fewer still would agree that sticking to a principle that says federal debt must remain low would have been worth risking another Great Depression.
Related: Paul Ryan Faces Fiscal Failure as the House Blows the Budget Deadline
Grant’s article includes a coy discussion of a return to the Gold Standard. Virtually no mainstream economist would endorse returning to a world in which each dollar is tied to a specific amount of gold. And Grant doesn’t either, exactly. He just points out that things sure were better back then.
“Sound money coincided with balanced budgets,” he writes.
However, “I don’t ask that we return to some long-lost fiscal and monetary Eden. None has ever existed, even in America. Crises and business cycles are always with us. I merely observe that sound money and a balanced budget were two sides of the coin of American prosperity.”
For reference, back in November, when Republican presidential candidate Ted Cruz advocated a return to the gold standard during a televised debate, David Wessel, director of the Hutchins Center on Fiscal and Monetary Policy at the Brookings Institution, said, “It’s basically seen as nuts, and I think even most conservative economists would say that. We learned the hard way that the gold standard does not bring financial stability. We learned that it’s really bad to have a money supply that’s restricted to the amount of gold you can mine.”
Grant’s article is long on criticism, but relatively short on solutions. After citing statistics about tax avoidance and the amount of effort Americans put into tax preparation, he offers a backhanded endorsement of a flat tax: “Are we quite sure we want no part of the flat-tax idea? An identical low rate on most incomes. No deductions, no H&R Block. Impractical? So is the debt.”
Related: The GOP Budget Is on Life Support, and Paul Ryan Knows It
He also invokes 1950s-era anti-tax activist Vivien Kellems, and urges the country to adopt a program for which she argued. Under Kellems’ plan, employers would no longer withhold taxes. Workers would be given the entirety of their gross pay, and be required to personally hand over the share the government takes.”
Although it would be wildly inefficient, the plan would have the merit of making Americans highly cognizant of the amount of money the government extracts from them in taxes, assessments, and other levies. It also has about as much chance of being implemented as...well...a return to the gold standard.
Americans would be better served if our politicians paid more attention to fiscal responsibility and to the long-term damage excessive debt can do to the country. But these are hard and complex problems that won’t be easily solved.
http://www.thefiscaltimes.com/2016/04/15/Debt-Hits-19-Trillion-Has-US-Reached-Tipping-Point?utm_campaign=548f5168cb03a93709042da0&utm_source=boomtrain&utm_medium=email&bt_alias=eyJ1c2VySWQiOiI5ZDZhYWZiMy00MTE0LTFjMjYtNjA3OC00ZWIzZTc5ZDA3NGMifQ%3D%3D
» utube 11/19/24 MM&C MM&C-News-Report-Census-Global Transparency-Budget-Trade-Banking-Delete the Ze
» utube 11/18/24 MM&C IQD News Report - Contracts - Projects - Non Oil Revenue Streams - Activating
» North Gas announces resumption of production line (1000) after maintenance is completed
» Economist: The government is relying on weak reasons to diversify non-oil sources
» Parliamentarian reveals secrets of railway investment
» Iraqi Prime Minister: Tomorrow we will take an important step that has been delayed for years
» Federal decisions threaten to shut down two thousand factories and disrupt a quarter of a million jo
» First government comment on Israel's complaint against Iraq before the UN Security Council
» Turkish Trade Minister: Development Path is the Best Corridor in the World
» The future of international trade transactions in US dollars in Iraq
» The first project to index Iraqi manuscripts digitally
» Parliamentary Security: Army Aviation College Law Ready for Voting
» Population Census.. The Path to Development
» Population census: an important tool for achieving sustainable economic development
» Knowledge Summit 2024 kicks off, sharing visions and expertise on the future of knowledge and innova
» The Minister of Interior discusses with the representative of the Secretary-General of the United Na
» Minister of Transport confirms that the development road project will pave the way for important str
» Türkiye's exports to Arab countries amounted to $40 billion in the first ten months of this year, an
» Resumption of production line (1000) in the North Gas Company
» Al-Hakim calls for enacting a law that legally protects paramedics from tribal prosecutions
» The President of the Supreme Judicial Council discusses with the Spanish Ambassador cooperation betw
» Al-Sudani: The census is the dividing line between guesses and facts to distribute wealth according
» The Speaker of the House of Representatives discusses with the Chinese Ambassador bilateral relation
» Kurdish parties set impossible conditions for participation in the new government and formation in A
» Can America limit China's influence in Iraq?
» It will be passed soon.. Revealing the most important amendments to the Anti-Narcotics Law in Iraq
» Al-Mashhadani: The general amnesty law is at the top of our priorities for the next stage
» Al-Sudani confirms the government's desire to develop the trade balance with Türkiye
» MP: No understanding on "controversial" laws, disputes continue - Urgent
» "An important achievement" .. The government reviews the most prominent advantages provided by the p
» Al-Mashhadani confirms Parliament's support for legal agreements between Baghdad and Erbil
» There is no point in changing them.. Politician: The new ministers will be nominated by the same par
» Al-Hakim calls for enacting a law that legally protects paramedics from tribal prosecutions
» Al-Sudani: The census is the dividing line between guesses and facts to distribute wealth according
» The Speaker of the House of Representatives discusses with the Chinese Ambassador bilateral relation
» The third scenario for the chaos of the Middle East.. An Iraqi movement talks about the "Al-Hawl exp
» Al-Sudani: Tomorrow we will take an important step that has been delayed for years (video)
» Al-Sadr warns the government and parliament of two "important" matters
» Iraqi-Iranian talks to implement Basra-Shalamcheh railway
» Until the end of the month.. UAE announces cancellation of flights to Baghdad
» Foreign Minister: Iraq's policy is based on establishing balanced relations
» Al-Sudani: Election of Parliament Speaker helps the Council to continue performing its duties
» Revealing the details of the meeting between the President of the Republic and the Judicial Council
» Türkiye: Our relationship with Iraq included the economy in a comprehensive and broad manner
» Ministry of Commerce denies intentions to withhold food ration cards linked to population census
» Baghdad and Washington discuss the tense situation in the regional environment
» The dollar continues to rise
» Al-Sudani directs an urgent appeal to the Iraqis
» MM&C 11/17/24 For the first time in Iraq.. Efforts to establish an "Investment Association" to attr
» utube 11/16/24 MM&C-News Report-Iraq Dinar-Oil-Flow-Global Maritime Trade-Cross Border Transfer-Ex
» Global conflicts move to Iraq.. America and China fight economically in Baghdad
» Al-Sudani: Iraqi openness to comprehensive partnership with Türkiye and developing trade balance
» Accused of negligence, the Parliamentary Energy Committee calls on Al-Sudani to hold the “Baghdad El
» Al-Maliki's coalition notes Al-Sudani's performance in three files
» On charges of forgery... Al-Dulaimi complains about Al-Halbousi before the Integrity Commission
» Al-Karawi: The government mortgaged the port of Faw to companies affiliated with the Zionist entity
» Parliamentary Integrity: We will proceed with the ministerial amendment even if the government delay
» Reopening of applications to the morning private government education channel
» Bitcoin rises after weekly losses
» Al-Maliki Coalition: The government amendment does not exceed three ministerial portfolios
» Parliamentarian: Amending the Election Law is out of the question
» Israel threatens to target infrastructure in Iraq and assassinate "prominent figures"
» Parliamentary regions: Article 140 road is closed
» The Central Bank of Iraq's dollar sales increased
» Al-Alaq reviews to the President of the Republic the Central Bank’s plans to develop the banking sec
» Al-Atwani to the French Embassy delegation: Halting external borrowing indicates an improvement in I
» Parliamentary move against Kar Oil Company: Suspicions of "fake" electricity supply
» Parliamentary Health: Iraq suffers from a large surplus in the number of doctors and pharmacists by
» It causes a loss of one billion dollars per month.. A date has been set for the resumption of Kurdis
» Türkiye blames Iraq: You waste water and do not have good management in rationalizing it
» Iraq rejects “COP29” proposal: We will not get rid of fossil fuels, as they are the basis of our eco
» Bitcoin nears $90,000 after biggest drop since election
» For the first time, Iraq issues the commodity structure of exports and imports
» Procedures for (automating) the work of Baghdad International Airport
» Planning: No cuts to benefits or taxes due to census
» International organizations praise the government's national initiatives
» {Official platform} to combat rumors
» Al-Sudani: The census will be used exclusively to develop development plans
» Justice audits financial movements in its departments
» Al-Imar to {Sabah}: 3 residential cities in Baghdad to be referred soon
» Kurdistan Region of Iraq plans to receive 10 million tourists annually
» Discussion of mineral investment and export mechanisms
» Consensus on the importance of planning in achieving sustainable development
» Corporate Restructuring: Stimulating Economic Growth
» Iraq's commitment to OPEC decisions controls oil prices
» Delete zeros and evaluate the dinar
» Economists: Empowering the private sector requires a legislative system
» Preparations for holding meetings of the Iraqi-Egyptian Committee
» Parliamentary Legal Committee to Nina: Controversial and important laws will be passed in one go in
» Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics to Nina: The census activities are completely
» Turkish Trade Minister to visit Iraq tomorrow, Monday, heading a delegation of businessmen
» Slight decrease in dollar exchange rates in local markets
» Basra Gas Company launches the “Safe Step” program to raise awareness of the dangers of mines and wa
» With high-level governmental and international presence... the activities of the Iraqi Digital Space
» Ministry of Oil: FCC project to produce derivatives to be completed in the middle of next year
» Does America influence the decisions to form the regional government?.. 5 critical months
» Search for remains of the eight-year war postponed until 2025.. Diggers await spring
» US forces reposition in the "Desert Triangle" in western Iraq