Constitution Check: Does the federal government have a constitutional duty to stay open?
By Lyle Denniston | National Constitution Center
Lyle Denniston looks at the question of a constitutional obligation to avoid a partial federal government shutdown, and how James Madison would view the situation.
THE STATEMENTS AT ISSUE:
“It’s time to govern. I don’t intend to support a fool’s errand at this point.”
– Representative Charlie Dent, a Pennsylvania Republican, in a comment on September 29 on his unwillingness to prolong the effort to force a shutdown of the federal government.
“When you are trying to get something done in a democratic process, what we have learned over the years is that it responds when there is pressure on it. People just don’t naturally come to the point where they are willing to compromise their position. There has to be pressure on it.”
– Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, a California Republican, in a comment on September 29 on the need for the House of Representatives to stand fast on the legislative agenda of the Republican majority even if it meant a government shutdown.
WE CHECKED THE CONSTITUTION, AND…
When the founding generation was debating how to create a new national government, it was well aware of the hazards—at home and abroad—of having a government that was unable to function. That was the well-remembered legacy of the Articles of Confederation, which the founders were about to discard. It is thus almost a certainty that they never thought that the new national government they were putting together would, one day, find itself unable to govern.
Still, the plain fact is that they did not write into the new Constitution a binding duty to keep the national government open and functioning. There is, for example, no constitutional command to Congress and the president to avoid an impasse over the budget that leads to turning out the lights and closing the doors on many if not most of the federal agencies. That might be an offense to the Constitution’s silent belief in the good faith of those in government to keep it going, but it is not unconstitutional.
In a manner of speaking, the Constitution does seem to expect that government will continue to run in an uninterrupted fashion. Congress is told that it must come in “at least once each year,” and the House and Senate are told that neither of them can adjourn for more than three days unless the other chamber agrees. The House is admonished, at least by implication, that it should pass bills “raising revenue” to pay the government’s operating bills.
The president is charged directly with the duty to “take care that the laws be faithfully executed,” and that presumably means the laws that Congress passes to finance day-to-day government operations.
Did it occur to the founders that, in some years, because of an impasse between the political branches over the budget, there would be no laws passed to pay to keep the government open? Would they have thought that, in that circumstance, Congress and the president had acted unconstitutionally? And, if that notion had occurred to them, what remedy might they have imagined would be necessary?
The president, of course, could face the draconian remedy of impeachment by the House, conviction by the Senate, and removal from office. Such a president might also face the wrath of the voters, if reelection were pursued. Impeachment, of course, does not apply to the House and Senate, so there could be no remedy other than voting the lawmakers out of office the next time an election is held.
It is reasonable to assume that the Constitution provides no other cure for budgetary impasse, with a resulting shutdown of government, because the Constitution did not anticipate a paralyzing polarization in the nation’s political life, and did not expect that short-term partisan preferences could translate into an abject failure to work out modes of keeping the government in motion.
James Madison, the “father” of the Constitution, did warn about the dangers of factionalism in America, but he thought that the competition among those holding differing views would be offsetting, as part of the checks and balances, so that, in the end, the governmental system would work. That is why he favored separation of governmental powers—horizontally at the national level, vertically between national and state levels.
The kind of factionalism that Madison had in mind, however, involved a competition over the best way to run the government—that is, what powers government should have, how those powers should be used, and how those in office could be made always responsive to the will of the sovereign people. It is extremely doubtful that Madison would have expected that one faction might emerge with the belief that no government at all was better than a government that was disappointing to that faction.
What, then, might Madison have thought, had he been around last weekend to hear the comments of Congressmen Dent and Rohrabacher? Would he have agreed with the Pennsylvanian that the time had come “to govern”? Or would he have nodded his head in agreement with the Californian, that “the democratic process” only works in government when pressure points are employed—like threatening shutdown of most agencies for a time—in order to prevail? As Americans assess what has been happening in Washington, they could do well to speculate about “what would Madison do?”
Lyle Denniston is the National Constitution Center’s adviser on constitutional literacy. He has reported on the Supreme Court for 55 years, currently covering it for SCOTUSblog, an online clearinghouse of information about the Supreme Court’s work.
http://news.yahoo.com/constitution-check-does-federal-government-constitutional-duty-stay-100210250.html
By Lyle Denniston | National Constitution Center
- View Photo
James Madison
Lyle Denniston looks at the question of a constitutional obligation to avoid a partial federal government shutdown, and how James Madison would view the situation.
THE STATEMENTS AT ISSUE:
“It’s time to govern. I don’t intend to support a fool’s errand at this point.”
– Representative Charlie Dent, a Pennsylvania Republican, in a comment on September 29 on his unwillingness to prolong the effort to force a shutdown of the federal government.
“When you are trying to get something done in a democratic process, what we have learned over the years is that it responds when there is pressure on it. People just don’t naturally come to the point where they are willing to compromise their position. There has to be pressure on it.”
– Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, a California Republican, in a comment on September 29 on the need for the House of Representatives to stand fast on the legislative agenda of the Republican majority even if it meant a government shutdown.
WE CHECKED THE CONSTITUTION, AND…
When the founding generation was debating how to create a new national government, it was well aware of the hazards—at home and abroad—of having a government that was unable to function. That was the well-remembered legacy of the Articles of Confederation, which the founders were about to discard. It is thus almost a certainty that they never thought that the new national government they were putting together would, one day, find itself unable to govern.
Still, the plain fact is that they did not write into the new Constitution a binding duty to keep the national government open and functioning. There is, for example, no constitutional command to Congress and the president to avoid an impasse over the budget that leads to turning out the lights and closing the doors on many if not most of the federal agencies. That might be an offense to the Constitution’s silent belief in the good faith of those in government to keep it going, but it is not unconstitutional.
In a manner of speaking, the Constitution does seem to expect that government will continue to run in an uninterrupted fashion. Congress is told that it must come in “at least once each year,” and the House and Senate are told that neither of them can adjourn for more than three days unless the other chamber agrees. The House is admonished, at least by implication, that it should pass bills “raising revenue” to pay the government’s operating bills.
The president is charged directly with the duty to “take care that the laws be faithfully executed,” and that presumably means the laws that Congress passes to finance day-to-day government operations.
Did it occur to the founders that, in some years, because of an impasse between the political branches over the budget, there would be no laws passed to pay to keep the government open? Would they have thought that, in that circumstance, Congress and the president had acted unconstitutionally? And, if that notion had occurred to them, what remedy might they have imagined would be necessary?
The president, of course, could face the draconian remedy of impeachment by the House, conviction by the Senate, and removal from office. Such a president might also face the wrath of the voters, if reelection were pursued. Impeachment, of course, does not apply to the House and Senate, so there could be no remedy other than voting the lawmakers out of office the next time an election is held.
It is reasonable to assume that the Constitution provides no other cure for budgetary impasse, with a resulting shutdown of government, because the Constitution did not anticipate a paralyzing polarization in the nation’s political life, and did not expect that short-term partisan preferences could translate into an abject failure to work out modes of keeping the government in motion.
James Madison, the “father” of the Constitution, did warn about the dangers of factionalism in America, but he thought that the competition among those holding differing views would be offsetting, as part of the checks and balances, so that, in the end, the governmental system would work. That is why he favored separation of governmental powers—horizontally at the national level, vertically between national and state levels.
The kind of factionalism that Madison had in mind, however, involved a competition over the best way to run the government—that is, what powers government should have, how those powers should be used, and how those in office could be made always responsive to the will of the sovereign people. It is extremely doubtful that Madison would have expected that one faction might emerge with the belief that no government at all was better than a government that was disappointing to that faction.
What, then, might Madison have thought, had he been around last weekend to hear the comments of Congressmen Dent and Rohrabacher? Would he have agreed with the Pennsylvanian that the time had come “to govern”? Or would he have nodded his head in agreement with the Californian, that “the democratic process” only works in government when pressure points are employed—like threatening shutdown of most agencies for a time—in order to prevail? As Americans assess what has been happening in Washington, they could do well to speculate about “what would Madison do?”
Lyle Denniston is the National Constitution Center’s adviser on constitutional literacy. He has reported on the Supreme Court for 55 years, currently covering it for SCOTUSblog, an online clearinghouse of information about the Supreme Court’s work.
http://news.yahoo.com/constitution-check-does-federal-government-constitutional-duty-stay-100210250.html
Today at 5:32 am by Rocky
» Minister of Resources: Iraq is one of the countries most affected by climate change
Today at 5:29 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani arrives in Riyadh to participate in the World Economic Forum
Today at 5:27 am by Rocky
» An Arab call to the countries neighboring Iraq regarding the share of water
Today at 5:26 am by Rocky
» IMF: Poor productivity is responsible for 50% of the decline in economic growth
Today at 5:20 am by Rocky
» The President of the Republic stresses to Barzani the importance of focusing on construction, recons
Today at 5:19 am by Rocky
» Will Iran lose the Iraqi market? 20 million dollars is threatened with loss
Today at 5:18 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Economy: Parliament will extend the legislative term to approve the budget
Today at 5:13 am by Rocky
» The price of the dollar is close to 145 thousand dinars؛ how much is $100 worth of transactions؟
Today at 5:13 am by wciappetta
» A factory for producing electric cars
Today at 5:12 am by Rocky
» Prime Minister: We have launched strategies to improve the conditions of workers
Today at 5:10 am by Rocky
» Economic prospects from America to Türkiye
Today at 5:09 am by Rocky
» Al-Rayes: The path of development is the first gateway to sustainable economic advancement
Today at 5:08 am by Rocky
» Days after announcing the connection with Jordan, an almost complete absence of electricity in Ramad
Today at 5:06 am by Rocky
» A Kurdistan delegation meets with the Ministry of Finance in Baghdad to discuss “revenues and implem
Today at 5:05 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Economy reviews files and the importance of Sudanese’s upcoming visit to Saudi Arabia
Today at 4:59 am by Rocky
» Al-Maliki talks about postponing the Kurdistan Parliament elections and says that salary transfers w
Today at 4:54 am by Rocky
» The President of the Republic and Barzani discuss the results of Sudanese’s visit to the United Stat
Today at 4:53 am by Rocky
» The Ministry of Finance is "dizzy"... An expert points out a "lapse" in the budget schedules: Februa
Today at 4:49 am by Rocky
» Sudanese Advisor: The 2024 budget has entered into force... and there is no need to send its schedul
Today at 4:43 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi dinar is recovering against the US dollar in local markets
Today at 4:42 am by Rocky
» Iraq.. The claim that OPEC’s decisions affect oil derivatives only and not crude is “inaccurate”
Today at 4:39 am by Rocky
» Al-Bawi: Erdogan failed in his promises to his people and seeks to plunge Iraq into its conflict wit
Today at 4:37 am by Rocky
» The Sudanese and his battle against corruption.. Where is the fault with the government or with the
Today at 4:36 am by Rocky
» Amnesty International criticizes Iraq's implementation of 13 death sentences
Today at 4:34 am by Rocky
» The ambassador is very angry with Parliament: The homosexuality law obstructs the government and har
Today at 4:33 am by Rocky
» Al-Mandalawi: There is no place for homosexuality in the Iraq of the prophets and saints, and that i
Today at 4:32 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani receives the President of the University: Towards the strength and status of the Arab syst
Today at 4:31 am by Rocky
» Ayed Al-Hilali: All leaders are discussing “the finer details of Sudanese” tonight, and Barzani join
Today at 4:30 am by Rocky
» He announced the reception of offers from three alliances from international companies for the Baghd
Today at 4:28 am by Rocky
» During his meeting with the head of the Iraqi Journalists Syndicate... Al-Amiri stresses the importa
Today at 4:26 am by Rocky
» To address the dollar exchange rate... Mazhar Muhammad explains the risks of floating the Iraqi dina
Today at 4:25 am by Rocky
» During the launch of the Arab Labor Conference in its 50th session in Baghdad... Al-Sudani: We launc
Today at 4:24 am by Rocky
» Saudi Arabia announces an increase in direct flights with Iraq
Today at 4:23 am by Rocky
» Resources: Government measures have contributed to improving the water situation in Iraq
Today at 4:22 am by Rocky
» Al-Sadr: The voice of American universities calling for an end to Zionist terrorism is our voice
Today at 4:21 am by Rocky
» International organization: 50% of displaced Iraqis lack official documents
Today at 4:20 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The path of development will provide many job opportunities
Today at 4:19 am by Rocky
» Parliament Finance: The necessity of converting tax and customs revenues to digital processing
Today at 4:18 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani announces that clues have been found to uncover those involved in the Kormor bombing
Today at 4:16 am by Rocky
» The start of the work of the Fourth Baghdad International Water Conference
Today at 4:09 am by Rocky
» The Council of Ministers will suspend official working hours next Wednesday
Today at 4:07 am by Rocky
» An almost complete outage of water and electricity in western Anbar
Today at 4:06 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary expectations of extending the legislative term to approve the budget
Today at 4:00 am by Rocky
» Education: The cost of participating in the electronic school will amount to 200 thousand dinars
Today at 3:59 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani arrives in Riyadh to participate in the World Economic Forum
Today at 3:58 am by Rocky
» A newspaper reveals a dark world that brings together bloggers and politicians
Today at 3:57 am by Rocky
» Al-Marsoumi: The bombing of the Kormor field undermined efforts to achieve self-sufficiency in gas
Today at 3:55 am by Rocky
» utube MM&C 4/24/24 Support - USA- Turkey - Timing- Currency Value - Tabled
Yesterday at 2:18 pm by Rocky
» utube MM&C 4/26/24 Iraqi Dinar - US Treasury Exchange Rates- Focus - Banking Partnerships - Rate C
Yesterday at 2:17 pm by Rocky
» Parliamentary efforts to transform Iraq into a global market for transferring Internet capacities
Yesterday at 2:07 pm by Rocky
» A parliamentary committee that enriches the political forces: Stop plundering Iraq’s wealth and work
Yesterday at 1:56 pm by Rocky
» Politician: Salem Al-Issawi is the most likely to assume the presidency of Parliament
Yesterday at 1:55 pm by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The world today is witnessing crises whose impact has been reflected in the global econo
Yesterday at 9:50 am by Rocky
» The Federal Court responds to an inquiry by Al-Sudani regarding the powers of the provincial council
Yesterday at 9:40 am by Rocky
» Among them are the Iraqis... a list of the most sought-after immigrants to America
Yesterday at 9:38 am by Rocky
» An expert talks about the "biggest barrier" and the positives of merging Iraqi and Arab banks
Yesterday at 9:29 am by Rocky
» The House of Representatives adjourns its session
Yesterday at 9:24 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary demands to expedite the legislation of the Eid al-Ghadir holiday law (documents)
Yesterday at 9:23 am by Rocky
» Parliament adds the paragraph “Electing the Speaker of the House of Representatives” to its agenda
Yesterday at 9:21 am by Rocky
» Alsumaria publishes the text of the law against prostitution and homosexuality
Yesterday at 9:20 am by Rocky
» A parliamentarian reveals the reason for the failure of the Speaker of Parliament to pass during tod
Yesterday at 9:19 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The government has launched many strategies and initiatives that will improve the reality
Yesterday at 8:42 am by Rocky
» International Business: Iraq has made progress in supporting businesses through investment and priva
Yesterday at 8:33 am by Rocky
» Association of Banks: Iraq is witnessing great development in the transition to electronic governmen
Yesterday at 8:25 am by Rocky
» The House of Representatives votes to add an item to its agenda (election of the Speaker of the Hous
Yesterday at 8:22 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary integrity: Combating corruption requires parliamentary legislation
Yesterday at 8:15 am by Rocky
» Al-Karaawi: America is trying to restrict Iraq
Yesterday at 8:13 am by Rocky
» The State of Law coalition moves to form the local government in Diyala
Yesterday at 8:12 am by Rocky
» The Sudanese and his battle against corruption.. Where is the fault with the government or with the
Yesterday at 8:11 am by Rocky
» Prime Minister's Advisor: We will see the dollar fall on the black market soon
Yesterday at 8:09 am by Rocky
» The Sunni blocs are resolute. The presidency of the Council is ours, away from Al-Halbousi
Yesterday at 8:08 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani discusses with a workers’ organization his government’s steps in this field
Yesterday at 7:58 am by Rocky
» Parliament holds its session in the presence of 170 deputies
Yesterday at 7:57 am by Rocky
» In the presence of Nechirvan Barzani and Al-Sudani... the State Administration Coalition holds an “i
Yesterday at 7:55 am by Rocky
» The UAE company ADNOC resorts to Iraqi oil. Find out the reasons
Yesterday at 7:53 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi Parliament votes to add an item to elect a president to its agenda
Yesterday at 7:52 am by Rocky
» The Federal Court responds to an inquiry by Al-Sudani regarding the powers of the provincial council
Yesterday at 7:51 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: It is necessary to attract women to work as a productive energy that cannot be disrupted
Yesterday at 7:47 am by Rocky
» Zebari regarding targeting the Kormor field: a systematic attack on the economy of Kurdistan
Yesterday at 7:46 am by Rocky
» Saudi Arabia tops, and this is Iraq's rank... a list of major suppliers of crude oil to South Korea
Yesterday at 7:45 am by Rocky
» With a value of 125 million dollars.. Iraq is at the forefront of countries importing Iranian textil
Yesterday at 7:44 am by Rocky
» More than a billion dollars in sales from the Iraqi Central Bank within a week
Yesterday at 7:43 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani stresses the need for the expertise of the International Labor Organization to legislate a
Yesterday at 7:29 am by Rocky
» Including the return of 21 wanted persons.. The Iraq Money Recovery Fund counts its achievements in
Yesterday at 7:27 am by Rocky
» The path to development is the criterion between true patriotism and political clowning.
Yesterday at 7:25 am by Rocky
» The file of the Presidency of Parliament is on the state administration table... this evening
Yesterday at 7:22 am by Rocky
» Director General of the International Labor Organization: Many challenges in the world of work and t
Yesterday at 7:20 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The world is witnessing crises that reflect negatively on the Arab and international peop
Yesterday at 7:11 am by Rocky
» Prime Minister: Our government has provided great support for the success of the activities, program
Yesterday at 7:08 am by Rocky
» Al-Asadi: Iraq places the social protection file among its priorities
Yesterday at 7:07 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: Iraq is one of the first countries in the region to join the International Labor Organiza
Yesterday at 7:05 am by Rocky
» In the presence of Al-Sudani and Barzani, the State Administration Coalition holds an “important” me
Yesterday at 7:03 am by Rocky
» Appreciating the presence of Al-Sudani... Director General of the Arab Labor Organization: Here from
Yesterday at 5:29 am by Rocky
» Prime Minister: Our government has provided great support for the success of the activities, program
Yesterday at 5:28 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The world is witnessing crises that reflect negatively on the Arab and international peop
Yesterday at 5:24 am by Rocky
» The Parliamentary Development Institute organizes a workshop on the political role of the representa
Yesterday at 5:22 am by Rocky
» With Arab and international participation. Tomorrow will be the start of the Fourth Baghdad Internat
Yesterday at 5:21 am by Rocky
» OPEC Secretary General: The end of oil is not on the horizon
Yesterday at 5:19 am by Rocky