Home
[size=35]World Bank body dismisses Agility's claims against Iraq[/size]
By [size=16]Reuters Staff
4 MIN READ
DUBAI (Reuters) - Kuwaiti logistics company Agility’s claim to recover more than $380 million it said it lost in Iraq has been rejected by an international tribunal, a document seen by Reuters showed.
Agility, one of the largest Gulf logistics companies, was also ordered to pay Iraq more than $5 million for costs related to the case.
The company filed for arbitration in 2017 with the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), which is part of the World Bank Group and handles disputes between international investors.
Agility has said Iraq indirectly confiscated its investment, which was worth over $380 million, and violated a 2015 bilateral protocol between Kuwait and Iraq on encouraging the movement of capital and investment between the two countries.
Agility said Iraq denied the company and its subsidiaries the ability to challenge a 2014 decision by Iraq’s National Communications and Media Commission (CMC) to annul Agility’s investment in Korek Telecom, an Iraqi mobile phone operator.
CMC’s decision was based on Korek’s not meeting conditions related to improving its services and expanding coverage, a source in the Iraqi prime minister’s office said, asking not to be named.
The World Bank body tribunal on Monday dismissed Agility’s claims, and ordered the company to pay Iraq nearly $5.2 million to cover fees related to the case, the document, a copy of the tribunal’s final decision, said.
ADVERTISEMENT
If it does not do so within 30 days, Agility must pay Iraq interest at the six-month U.S. dollar rate of LIBOR plus 2%, as of the time of the decision, on any outstanding amount, compounded semi-annually.
In a statement on Tuesday, Agility called ICSID’s ruling “fundamentally flawed” and said it was considering its options to apply for the decision’s annulment.
Iraq’s government said in a statement it was delighted with the outcome.
In its statement, Agility said it was pursuing claims of more than $700 million directly against Korek, one of its top executives and others through a separate arbitration pursuant to International Chamber of Commerce rules.
CMC’s CEO Ali Khwildi and the Iraqi source said the amount claimed by Agility neared $800 million.
Korek had no immediate comment.
Agility’s position was that Iraq “failed to accord (Agility’s) investment fair and equitable treatment when it prevented the claimant access to the administrative court proceedings in Iraq to challenge the CMC,” the document said.
It also said the World Bank tribunal said it has no jurisdiction on whether the CMC’s order was lawful.
Agility said the tribunal made its decision “without investigating or considering evidence of corruption by key members of Iraq’s Communications and Media Commission (CMC).”
“The ICSID tribunal has sent the message - not only to the Republic of Iraq, but to the international community of civilised nations - that states can expropriate investments without providing compensation to their foreign investors,” Agility said in its statement.
Iraq’s government said Agility’s response was unfair.
“Agility continues to have other business interests in Iraq which are successful. Therefore, a bad commercial investment decision on its part should not be extrapolated to criticise the Iraqi investment climate,” it said in its statement to Reuters.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.][/size]
By [size=16]Reuters Staff
4 MIN READ
DUBAI (Reuters) - Kuwaiti logistics company Agility’s claim to recover more than $380 million it said it lost in Iraq has been rejected by an international tribunal, a document seen by Reuters showed.
Agility, one of the largest Gulf logistics companies, was also ordered to pay Iraq more than $5 million for costs related to the case.
The company filed for arbitration in 2017 with the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), which is part of the World Bank Group and handles disputes between international investors.
Agility has said Iraq indirectly confiscated its investment, which was worth over $380 million, and violated a 2015 bilateral protocol between Kuwait and Iraq on encouraging the movement of capital and investment between the two countries.
Agility said Iraq denied the company and its subsidiaries the ability to challenge a 2014 decision by Iraq’s National Communications and Media Commission (CMC) to annul Agility’s investment in Korek Telecom, an Iraqi mobile phone operator.
CMC’s decision was based on Korek’s not meeting conditions related to improving its services and expanding coverage, a source in the Iraqi prime minister’s office said, asking not to be named.
The World Bank body tribunal on Monday dismissed Agility’s claims, and ordered the company to pay Iraq nearly $5.2 million to cover fees related to the case, the document, a copy of the tribunal’s final decision, said.
ADVERTISEMENT
If it does not do so within 30 days, Agility must pay Iraq interest at the six-month U.S. dollar rate of LIBOR plus 2%, as of the time of the decision, on any outstanding amount, compounded semi-annually.
In a statement on Tuesday, Agility called ICSID’s ruling “fundamentally flawed” and said it was considering its options to apply for the decision’s annulment.
Iraq’s government said in a statement it was delighted with the outcome.
IRAQI AVENUES
The tribunal’s decision hinged on the fact that the dispute predated the Kuwait-Iraq protocol and that Agility did not use all the legal avenues available in Iraq to challenge the CMC’s decision, the Iraqi source said.In its statement, Agility said it was pursuing claims of more than $700 million directly against Korek, one of its top executives and others through a separate arbitration pursuant to International Chamber of Commerce rules.
CMC’s CEO Ali Khwildi and the Iraqi source said the amount claimed by Agility neared $800 million.
Korek had no immediate comment.
Agility’s position was that Iraq “failed to accord (Agility’s) investment fair and equitable treatment when it prevented the claimant access to the administrative court proceedings in Iraq to challenge the CMC,” the document said.
It also said the World Bank tribunal said it has no jurisdiction on whether the CMC’s order was lawful.
Agility said the tribunal made its decision “without investigating or considering evidence of corruption by key members of Iraq’s Communications and Media Commission (CMC).”
“The ICSID tribunal has sent the message - not only to the Republic of Iraq, but to the international community of civilised nations - that states can expropriate investments without providing compensation to their foreign investors,” Agility said in its statement.
Iraq’s government said Agility’s response was unfair.
“Agility continues to have other business interests in Iraq which are successful. Therefore, a bad commercial investment decision on its part should not be extrapolated to criticise the Iraqi investment climate,” it said in its statement to Reuters.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.][/size]
» Parliamentary Finance: Amending the Federal Budget Opens the Way to Change Ineffective Paragraphs
» utube 11/23/24 MM&C Reporting-Expectations are High-IMF-Flexible Exchange Rate Regime-Pr
» utube 11/26/24 MM&C MM&C Iraq News-Central Bank Iraq-Monetary Stability Excellent-Budget Law 2023,
» utube 11/27/24 MM&C The National Union explains the reasons for not legislating the oil and gas
» Mr. Al-Hakim: Oil dependence is an economic problem for Iraq, and decentralization is a guarantee of
» Al-Ziyadi: Amending the Investment Law and the Central Bank’s Interaction Guarantee the Success of t
» Iraq signs Mecca agreement to enhance cooperation in combating corruption and recovering its proceed
» Rights Center: 2024 Census Will Not Change Number of House of Representatives Seats.. Explains Why
» Parliamentary Oil: Amending a paragraph in the budget enhances oil exports and understanding with Ku
» Will Iraq take the adventure of joining BRICS despite American risks?
» MP: Former Oil Minister Blackmailed Main Suspect in Stealing the Century
» Negative impact on the legislation of laws.. Popular movement criticizes the weak performance of the
» Al-Maliki Coalition: Most blocs support amending the electoral law
» The National Union explains the reasons for not legislating the oil and gas law
» Iraq signs two memoranda of understanding with the Arab Tourism Organization
» Parliamentary Committee: Granting investment licenses reduces housing unit prices
» Parliamentary Finance: Amending the budget law will allow for changing useless paragraphs and items
» MP reveals latest developments in Personal Status Law
» Salary scale pushes towards hosting Al-Sudani inside the parliament dome
» Intensive meetings with British BP to develop Kirkuk fields
» "Al-Eqtisad News" publishes the full decisions of the Cabinet session
» Parliamentary Energy: Iraq continues its efforts to diversify gas supply sources
» What is Iraq's connection? Goldman Sachs: OPEC+ cuts may support oil in the short term
» New understandings between Baghdad and Erbil to export oil via Turkish Ceyhan
» Minister of Communications: We will deal with the global parent company Vodafone, not its branch in
» "Pessimism" about Trump's arrival to the US presidency.. Will it affect the Iraqi economy?
» Iraq is the fourth largest Arab country and the 51st largest in the world in the list of the world's
» Parliamentary criticism follows granting Vodafone the national mobile phone license
» Oil Markets: OPEC+ Plans to Increase Production, Trump's Promises Spark Controversy
» Natural barriers to stop desertification in the country
» Parliament Legality to Al-Sabah: Extending the Legislative Session Aims to Pass Important Laws
» The Council of Ministers takes 19 important decisions
» Al-Sudani: We succeeded in sparing Iraq the consequences of conflicts
» 20 schools with international standards in Babylon
» Transport to {Sabah}: One million passengers on board the Green Bird in 4 months
» Agriculture to {Sabah}: Strategic work programs to stop desertification in the country
» Food Basket: Improved Quality, Delayed Distribution
» Parliament extends its term and ends reading of three laws
» Great government achievements.. Model school buildings project
» Parliamentary meeting to discuss four important oil files
» Parliamentary Committee: We support amending the budget law and we submitted a request to add a new
» Al-Sudani stresses the importance of relations between Iraq and Kuwait and the government's efforts
» Al-Sudani leaves Baghdad for Spain on an official visit
» Economist: Non-oil revenues to achieve significant growth in 2024
» Transport signs a consulting contract with an Italian company regarding the first phase of the devel
» Iraqi Exhibitions Announce New Exhibitions Next Month
» Integrity: Iraq signs Mecca Agreement to enhance cooperation in combating corruption
» Despite setting the first session... the talks to form the regional government are at a standstill a
» Speaker of the House of Representatives discusses a number of important national issues with the Pre
» Iraqi oil falls again on third day of trading
» Economist: Iraq has a reliable database and the census does not create development but rather facili
» Decisive moves to propose salary scale amendment under the parliament dome
» To solve the overcrowding crisis, Iraq needs to build 10,000 schools
» 64% of Anbar power plant in Hit completed: A qualitative step to enhance energy
» Minister of Interior: We discussed with the United Kingdom ways of security and intelligence coopera
» The possibility of an Israeli strike on Iraq is increasing.. Will the factions stop the attacks if a
» Halt of Iranian gas supplies threatens operation of power plants in Iraq
» The Presidency of the Region announces: The new parliament will hold its first session on the second
» America: Factions in Iraq expose the country to the risk of instability
» Planning reveals the next step of the census: We will visit these families
» Health: Opening of three new factories to produce various medicines
» Health: Ongoing work to develop and create new specialized centers throughout Iraq
» The House of Representatives completes the first reading of the draft law amending the first three-y
» President of the Republic: The necessity of unifying efforts to establish peace and stability in the
» Al-Mandlawi to Kuwaiti Ambassador: The security of the region is indivisible
» Indian Oil Corporation maintains deal to import Iraqi oil
» Iraq's oil exports exceed 103 million barrels last month
» MP angry over obstruction of defense minister’s interrogation: Files threaten Iraq’s security collap
» Cabinet decisions include those related to “voluntary deduction” and Iraqi airports
» For the first time since 2003, non-oil revenues achieve significant growth during 2024 (tables)
» Find out the dollar prices in the Iraqi markets
» A new suspicion in the railways, its heroes are the “22 billion contract team”.. Signing a contract
» Prime Minister sponsors signing of two memoranda of understanding in the field of tourism
» Parliamentary Finance Committee discusses amending the three-year budget
» "Rich Iraq" seeks "money" to combat methane emissions: internal and external obstacles
» Increase in foreign remittance sales at the Central Bank of Iraq auction
» Its area is 2.5 million acres, and these are its details.. Work begins on a "large" residential city
» Kurdistan Finance delivers employees' salary schedule to the federal government
» Beggars are sweeping the streets of Iraq.. Their numbers are "large" and 90% of them receive welfare
» Settling tax trust claims
» Launching the National School Health Strategy
» Approval to implement service projects in Babylon
» New container handling berths at ports
» Work: Demand for registration in social security
» Reconstruction: Land Bank to be completed next year
» Aiming to enhance services in schools and prevent diseases, the National School Health Strategy for
» Karmian Festival witnesses the conclusion of commercial and industrial contracts
» Focus on the banking sector
» Minister of Trade: Studies Center is a turning point that serves the Iraqi economy
» Economists: Census is a roadmap for development
» Today's newspapers are interested in Al-Sudani's announcement that the population of Iraq exceeds 45
» International Development Bank: Today's incident was an extortion attempt that did not affect our wo
» thirty-sixth session, chaired by the Minister of Planning
» Closed meeting of the Parliamentary Finance Committee to discuss seven files
» The demographic boom in Iraq: an economic opportunity or a social burden?
» Al-Sudani confirms to Russian delegation Iraq's desire to establish a mechanism that brings mutual b
» Parliament holds its session headed by Al-Mashhadani and attended by 168 MPs
» The Iraqi government deducts 1% of the salaries of employees and retirees to donate to Gaza and Leba