Military-Funded Study Predicts When You’ll Protest on Twitter
6:13 PM ET By Patrick Tucker
Who tweets at you, what you tweet back, and why can predict your next protest act on social media.
Ever get angry, go to Twitter, and shoot off a protest tweet tagged #Arabspring, #AppleVsFBI, #syrianconflict or something else in solidarity with a cause? Whether the tweet is part of a violent movement, a peaceful action, or simply a response to a debate, military and national security types have an interest in predicting how big any given protest movement might become. A new study by researchers at Arizona State University, Texas A&M, and Yahoo, funded in part by the Office of Naval Research, can predict with 70 percent accuracy the likelihood that your next tweet will be part of a protest.
It’s no simple problem for the obvious reason that the telltale heart beats but for the guilty. “The ways in which protest-related events affect a person are not observable, resulting in a lack of knowledge of factors operating at that time causing his next post to be a declaration of protest,” the researchers write in their study, published as part of the proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence conference earlier this month.
The researchers collected 2,686 posts related to the Nigerian general election that took place between February and April of last year, an election that was marred by political violence in the form of the Boko Haram insurgency and that was beset by accusations of voting irregularities. So what predicts when someone begins protesting on Twitter? It’s not your personal history so much as your Twitter history of interacting with people who are part of that movement.
“The interaction we study is how users mention each other,” researchers Suhas Ranganath and Fred Morstatter wrote to Defense One in an email. “In the model, the probability of the future post expressing protest increases if: 1) The post mentioning the user is related to the protest. 2) The author of the post mentioning the user is interested in the protest. We dynamically learn [or teach] the model by testing how each of the previous status messages of the given user are affected by the recent posts mentioning him. We then use the model to predict the likelihood of the user expressing protest in his next post.”
Their accuracy threshold of 70 percent is because what might seem completely unpredictable is in fact part of a pattern, albeit one that’s incredibly complex. The researchers employed Brownian motion theory to design the formula, a theory that usually is employed to track the movement of particles, as well as model stock market fluctuations and other highly complicated systems. “Brownian Motion for fluid particles models change in the direction of the particle movement on collision with other particles. We take each ‘particle’ as a social media user. We relate collision with other particles, other users mentioning him, and the change in direction to change of the user’s inclination to express protest in his next post. We then use the models of Brownian motion to relate the two quantities. We mainly employ this to model the dynamic change in user behavior resulting from interactions over time,” Suhas told Defense One.
Could you apply it to ISIS? Yes, so long as you had a good window into how, say, a pro-ISIS Twitter user is interacting with someone else. “This can be applied to scenarios when the complete spreading mechanism is not known. In these scenarios, we go into the history of the user and see who have tried to interact with him and the nature of the interactions. So the individual user’s response to the attempt of organizations like ISIS to interact with him can be modeled using the proposed method,” the researchers told Defense One.
The government has a big interest in stopping the spread of ISIS on social media. Last month, the State Department announced that they would be opening up a new “Global Engagement Center” to combat ISIS online and recruited Michael Lumpkin, then assistant secretary of defense for special operations/low-intensity conflict, to run it. The goal of the new operation goes beyond just winning the Twitter war to destroying the allure of ISIS in the Middle East and beyond.
The researchers caution, however, that predicting a protest tweet is a bit different than predicting the moment of actual radicalization, and one is not just a proxy for the other. “In this paper we attempt to find users expressing protest, which is ultimately the expression of an opinion. Radicalization is the development of an opinion, not necessarily the expression. This makes it a very different problem than what we study,” they told Defense One in an email.
Ranganath and Morstatter’s paper is part of a $750,000 grant from the Office of Naval Research to study how crisis manifests itself in social media. The paper follows years of similar government-funded research into measuring protest dynamics on social media. Perhaps the best known program is the 2011 Open Source Indicators project from the Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Agency, or IARPA, which correctly predicted several protest events in Central and South America in real time.
The most recent effort used only open source data so it doesn’t have any legal or ethical implications for privacy. Nevertheless, some critics, such as writer Nafeez Mosaddeq Ahmed, have argued that such tools are often used to target peaceful protesters and dissidents.
The real value, according to the researchers, lies in predicting how big a political storm could be before it hits. “Social media provides a platform for people to declare protest on various sociopolitical issues. In scenarios where the spread of protest is not available, predicting if the next post of a given user will be a declaration of protest will help in estimating the number of protest participants,” they write.
http://www.defenseone.com/technology/2016/02/military-funded-study-predicts-when-youll-protest-twitter/126156/
6:13 PM ET By Patrick Tucker
Who tweets at you, what you tweet back, and why can predict your next protest act on social media.
- Technology
Ever get angry, go to Twitter, and shoot off a protest tweet tagged #Arabspring, #AppleVsFBI, #syrianconflict or something else in solidarity with a cause? Whether the tweet is part of a violent movement, a peaceful action, or simply a response to a debate, military and national security types have an interest in predicting how big any given protest movement might become. A new study by researchers at Arizona State University, Texas A&M, and Yahoo, funded in part by the Office of Naval Research, can predict with 70 percent accuracy the likelihood that your next tweet will be part of a protest.
It’s no simple problem for the obvious reason that the telltale heart beats but for the guilty. “The ways in which protest-related events affect a person are not observable, resulting in a lack of knowledge of factors operating at that time causing his next post to be a declaration of protest,” the researchers write in their study, published as part of the proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence conference earlier this month.
The researchers collected 2,686 posts related to the Nigerian general election that took place between February and April of last year, an election that was marred by political violence in the form of the Boko Haram insurgency and that was beset by accusations of voting irregularities. So what predicts when someone begins protesting on Twitter? It’s not your personal history so much as your Twitter history of interacting with people who are part of that movement.
“The interaction we study is how users mention each other,” researchers Suhas Ranganath and Fred Morstatter wrote to Defense One in an email. “In the model, the probability of the future post expressing protest increases if: 1) The post mentioning the user is related to the protest. 2) The author of the post mentioning the user is interested in the protest. We dynamically learn [or teach] the model by testing how each of the previous status messages of the given user are affected by the recent posts mentioning him. We then use the model to predict the likelihood of the user expressing protest in his next post.”
Their accuracy threshold of 70 percent is because what might seem completely unpredictable is in fact part of a pattern, albeit one that’s incredibly complex. The researchers employed Brownian motion theory to design the formula, a theory that usually is employed to track the movement of particles, as well as model stock market fluctuations and other highly complicated systems. “Brownian Motion for fluid particles models change in the direction of the particle movement on collision with other particles. We take each ‘particle’ as a social media user. We relate collision with other particles, other users mentioning him, and the change in direction to change of the user’s inclination to express protest in his next post. We then use the models of Brownian motion to relate the two quantities. We mainly employ this to model the dynamic change in user behavior resulting from interactions over time,” Suhas told Defense One.
Could you apply it to ISIS? Yes, so long as you had a good window into how, say, a pro-ISIS Twitter user is interacting with someone else. “This can be applied to scenarios when the complete spreading mechanism is not known. In these scenarios, we go into the history of the user and see who have tried to interact with him and the nature of the interactions. So the individual user’s response to the attempt of organizations like ISIS to interact with him can be modeled using the proposed method,” the researchers told Defense One.
The government has a big interest in stopping the spread of ISIS on social media. Last month, the State Department announced that they would be opening up a new “Global Engagement Center” to combat ISIS online and recruited Michael Lumpkin, then assistant secretary of defense for special operations/low-intensity conflict, to run it. The goal of the new operation goes beyond just winning the Twitter war to destroying the allure of ISIS in the Middle East and beyond.
The researchers caution, however, that predicting a protest tweet is a bit different than predicting the moment of actual radicalization, and one is not just a proxy for the other. “In this paper we attempt to find users expressing protest, which is ultimately the expression of an opinion. Radicalization is the development of an opinion, not necessarily the expression. This makes it a very different problem than what we study,” they told Defense One in an email.
Ranganath and Morstatter’s paper is part of a $750,000 grant from the Office of Naval Research to study how crisis manifests itself in social media. The paper follows years of similar government-funded research into measuring protest dynamics on social media. Perhaps the best known program is the 2011 Open Source Indicators project from the Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Agency, or IARPA, which correctly predicted several protest events in Central and South America in real time.
The most recent effort used only open source data so it doesn’t have any legal or ethical implications for privacy. Nevertheless, some critics, such as writer Nafeez Mosaddeq Ahmed, have argued that such tools are often used to target peaceful protesters and dissidents.
The real value, according to the researchers, lies in predicting how big a political storm could be before it hits. “Social media provides a platform for people to declare protest on various sociopolitical issues. In scenarios where the spread of protest is not available, predicting if the next post of a given user will be a declaration of protest will help in estimating the number of protest participants,” they write.

http://www.defenseone.com/technology/2016/02/military-funded-study-predicts-when-youll-protest-twitter/126156/
» 1350 or 1640? Parliamentary Finance talks about news of changing the exchange rate in the budget
» Minister of Oil: We will invite international companies to rebuild the North Refinery
» Iraq.. 100 days since the Sudanese government assumed power
» Dollar prices ignore government decisions and continue to rise in Iraq
» The Governor of Diwaniyah announces the approval of the Minister of Labor to increase the number of
» Talabani On The Crisis In Baghdad And The Region: It Is No Longer In The Interest Of Any Party To De
» The House of Representatives completes the election of heads and deputies of parliamentary committee
» A leader in Al-Fateh: Internal hands want to thwart the Sudanese and the dollar crisis to "bring the
» Next Thursday.. 3 files related to Iraq will be presented to the UN Security Councilproposals from
» The Minister of Finance addresses Al-Sudani regarding the launch of real estate loans for citizens (
» The judiciary summons the Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives for bypassing the Federal S
» Basem Khashan: The number of Sudanese advisors will reach 100 times soon..!
» Mazhar Muhammad Salih denies accusing a Kurdish politician of smuggling dollars
» A close associate of the coordination framework reveals a financial loan to Kurdistan instead of the
» Mandalawi and Alaq put the dollar on the table in Parliamen
» Parliamentary Finance resolves the controversy: The Sudanese government has no intention of reducing
» Tomorrow, Tuesday: an important meeting of the Central Bank of Iraq and expected decisions regarding
» Governor of Baghdad: He directed to establish new industrial cities in the capital
» Integrity: the overthrow of the former director of the Tax Authority, his wife, and two accused of c
» Election of Ahmed Al-Kinani and Ali Al-Hamidawi as chairpersons of the Economics and Services Commit
» The World Economic Forum appreciates the participation of the President of the Republic
» Iraq and Egypt are discussing expanding the scope of the Memorandum of Understanding signed between
» Deputy: The distribution of committees is according to the political agreement
» Deputy on the budget: its subject needs a lot of details
» Integrity reveals a “qualitative process”: it toppled heads and seized large sums of money
» Parliamentary source: Today...the presidencies of the committees in the House of Representatives are
» A deputy talks about the possibility of repeating the scenario of the Lebanese economic crisis in Ir
» Al-Karbouli calls on Japan to enhance its role in developing the infrastructure of the liberated cit
» Planning discusses with a UN program the results of a survey of institutions in Iraq
» Creating an integrated electronic service to change the names of beneficiaries of water and electric
» At the inauguration of the Judicial Complex in Ghamas... .. Minister of Justice: We will open more c
» Will you succeed in dealing with the rise of the dollar? An economist suggests adding a cash currenc
» Infographic: Learn the security signs to discover counterfeit Iraqi currency
» Expert: Solving the dollar problem requires breaking the link between it and commodity prices in the
» Al-Mandalawi to Al-Alaq: Financial stability must return to the markets soon
» Health: The 2023 budget will include standard allocations for the health sector
» Parliamentary Finance calls for expediting sending the budget law
» Finance: creating 24,933 job degrees to confirm contracts in 3 places
» With a capacity of 100,000 tons.. Announcing the construction of a new silo in Wasit
» corruption
» The new generation holds the Kurdistan government responsible for 4 crises in the region
» The Iraqi Central Bank's sales increased to more than 91 million dollarsproposals from
» Alekti: The Association of Banks has not done its part to solve the dollar crisis..and the governmen
» A new rise in the exchange rates of the dollar in Baghdad..and a raid on the Al-Kifah and Al-Harithi
» Parliamentary Finance invites the government regarding the 2023 budget
» Iraq and UNESCO are discussing the development of the education, culture and science sectors
» High prices of “foreign and Iraqi” gold in the local markets in the capital, Baghdad, and in the mar
» Iyad Allawi receives the President of the Republic, Abdul Latif Rashid, to discuss the situation in
» Iraq and the Netherlands are discussing the human rights file within the jurisdiction
» The central bank governor presents plans to control the dollar's rise
» Rashid and Allawi stress the necessity of holding a Kurdish dialogue under the supervision of Masoud
» It was preceded by American negotiation.. An Iraqi tendency to adopt the price of the dollar at 1,64
» KDP: The parties did not abide by the document that contributed to the formation of the government
» Al-Alaq briefs the Iraqi parliament on a "financial plan" to control the exchange rate and prevent s
» The bank’s dollar sales increased by 44% in the currency auction
» It imports 16 million liters per day.. Iraq is among the cheapest in the world with gasoline prices
» The crisis of the rise in the dollar exchange rate between the weak establishment of a fixed exchang
» Hamza El-Gawahry: The agreements with Siemens are a good step for investing in gas
» It costs 9 billion dollars.. Oil expert: The oil pipeline between Iraq and Jordan is useless
» Transport The project to link the port of Faw with Turkey is included in the 2023 budget
» Iraqis have spent more than 700 million dollars on treatment in India over the past 3 years
» Central Bank sales jump 40% and exceed $90 million
» The Governor of the Central Bank briefs the Presidency of Parliament on a “financial plan” to contro
» Labor is considering including the economic inclusion project in the 2023 budget
» Oil ignores the Iran bombings...waiting for OPEC's word
» Politicians: Investment laws deprive the state of huge sums
» Adding 1,000 megawatts to the national grid by 2023
» Preventing the transfer of funds to the region confuses the papers of the Party and the administrati
» Investigative committees of breaches of foreign investors
» Integrity reveals manipulation of 9 real estate and tax evasion in Fallujah
» Parliamentary Finance urges accelerating the approval of the 2023 draft budget
» Federal decision on the territory restores political tension
» Good news from the Central Bank, the Iraqi dinar has become equivalent to a dinar and a half. Video
» Kurdistan Regional Government: There is no compromise on our constitutional rights... There is no al
» After the complaint of the Federal Court.. issuance of a summons order against the second deputy spe
» Al-Zamili and Al-Janabi are the heads of the Parliamentary Security and Integrity Committees
» Election of Alia Nassif as First Vice-Chairman of the Integrity Committee and Karim Shakour as Secon
» Praising the efforts of the Minister of Construction.. Representative Kazem Al-Shammari expresses hi
» An American-British welcome to the Sulaymaniyah meeting: By working together, a more developed Kurdi
» Parliament elects the heads of parliamentary committees, three of which are for the Kurdistan Democr
» President Barzani receives the Kuwaiti Consul in Erbil
» Pumping food items at reduced prices next week
» State administration takes over the important parliamentary committee chairmen
» A leader in Al-Asa'ib sparks a dispute between Al-Sudani and Al-Maliki
» Formation of a committee to discuss constitutional amendments in Iraq
» "Money transfer" ignites disputes between Baghdad and Erbil
» Iraq renews its refusal to use its lands to encroach on neighboring countries
» Morocco reopens its embassy in the Iraqi capital
» Expectations of a delay in approving the budget until May: its amounts reach 220 trillion dinars
» The “frame” traces Al-Kazemi’s steps in the Basra-Aqaba pipeline, and a faction in the crowd threate
» Inclusion of the project to link the port of Fao with Turkey in the 2023 budget
» Economic center: Iraqis spent 700 million dollars on treatment in India in 3 years
» Parliament issues a clarification regarding the elections for parliamentary committee chairs
» Exchange rates in the Iraqi markets.. 166 thousand per 100 dollars
» The Presidents of the Republic and the National Coalition are discussing the Kurdish differences
» Iraq and the Netherlands are discussing the human rights file within the jurisdiction
» Approval of extinguishing the debts of the wounded and martyrs of the Popular Mobilization Forces in
» New administrative changes in the Ministry of Interior