Papers, Please!
Challenging ID Demands
The Identity Project explores and defends the fundamental American right to move freely around our country and to live without constantly having to prove who we are or why we are here.
Home The Issue Who We Are What We Do Secure Flight Featured Cases Policy Analysis Lawyer's Corner Take Action Press Room Contact Us Friends

« The human rights of migrants in transit
Since a change in Federal regulations in 2009 eliminated the last exception for crossing land borders to or from Canada and Mexico, it is a violation of Federal law “for any citizen of the United States to depart from or enter, or attempt to depart from or enter, the United States unless he bears a valid United States passport.”
This requirement for a passport can be “waived” at the “discretion” of the Department of State. But there is no right to a waiver, no formal procedures or standards for requesting such a waiver, and no apparent mechanism for judicial review of denial of a waiver.
So denying or revoking a US passport amounts to closing the US borders to that US citizen.
It’s not clear at whom, or at what conduct, this new provision in US law is directed.
Are Congress and the President concerned that suspected criminal violators of the tax laws might flee the country before they can be charged or arrested? So much for the presumption of innocence, the distinction between tax debts and crimes, and the Constitutional prohibition on imprisonment for debt.
Is the intent to prevent tax debtors from spiriting their untaxed assets out of the country before they can be seized? If so, restrictions on personal movement are both overbroad and likely to be ineffectual. Most international transfers of wealth occur electronically, and most cross-border shipments of tangible goods are in the form of unaccompanied freight, not accompanied luggage.
Is the goal to exile tax debtors from US territory? Under international human rights treaty law, the right to enter the country of one’s citizenship is [url=http://www.equalrightstrust.org/ertdocumentbank//general comment 27.pdf]the most absolute[/url] of the rights of freedom of movement: “There are few, if any, circumstances in which deprivation of the right to enter one’s own country could be reasonable.”
Denial or revocation of a US passport under this new law is an elaborate five-step process, although most of the steps are purely clerical:
There are some options, but they are entirely at the discretion of the Secretary of State:
There’s an impunity clause in the law, although it’s unclear to what if any extent it is Constitutional, that attempts to protect government agents from liability for violating US citizens’ right to travel:
A citizen could bring an action for a writ of mandamus ordering the State Department to issue a passport, which in some other cases has prompted the State Department to issue a passport before the case could be decided.
Or a citizen could bring an action for an injunction prohibiting the DHS from interfering with their entry or exit to or from the US.
In either case, we look forward to a declaratory judgement that this law is unconstitutional, and violates US obligations as a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
This entry was posted on Wednesday, December 9th, 2015 at 11:36 am and is filed under Freedom To Travel, Papers, Please. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
[list defaultattr=]
[*] John Says:
December 9th, 2015 at 9:24 pm
Any thoughts on whether a bankruptcy discharge of the subject tax liability would entitle one to be decertified, and eligible for a passport?
[*]New Collection Challenges | War Tax Talk Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 6:39 am
[...] Another good blog on the passport topic on the website Papers, Please! from The Identity Project. [...]
[*]Marsha Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 7:50 am
Does this mean Al Sharpton?
[*]Edward Hasbrouck Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 7:59 am
@John - Yes, there is a provision in the law for reversal of a certification of tax debt (and for judicial review of the decision on whether to reverse a certification) in several circumstances including if the debt “has been fully satisfied or has become legally unenforceable.”
[*]Aileen Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 8:18 am
So, is this effectively a “no fly” list? Because if so, then if Obama’s wishes go forward, they won’t be able to own guns either. And after the IRS’s persecution of Tea Party members through tax audits etc… I’d say we can look forward to anyone who disagrees with the current government being found guilty of tax fraud, owing that debt and then not only being not allowed to travel/leave the country but being disarmed as well.
[*]Mae Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 11:46 am
You would think if their a deadbeat on their finances the government would be happy to get rid of them. The way to get your money is to let them out but not allow them back IN until they have the money they owe you.
[/list]
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website
Copyright © 2015 The Identity Project • [url=feed:http://papersplease.org/wp/feed/]Entries (RSS)[/url] / [url=feed:http://papersplease.org/wp/comments/feed/]Comments (RSS)[/url]
Top / Home / Contact Us / Donate Now
http://papersplease.org/wp/2015/12/09/no-passports-for-us-citizens-who-havent-paid-taxes-or-dont-have-a-social-security-number/
Challenging ID Demands
The Identity Project explores and defends the fundamental American right to move freely around our country and to live without constantly having to prove who we are or why we are here.
Home The Issue Who We Are What We Do Secure Flight Featured Cases Policy Analysis Lawyer's Corner Take Action Press Room Contact Us Friends

« The human rights of migrants in transit
No passports for US citizens who haven’t paid taxes or don’t have a Social Security number
Buried in the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation Act (”FAST Act”) signed into law last week is an unrelated rider to provide for revocation of the passport and/or refusal to issue a passport to anyone against whom the IRS has assessed a lien or levy for $50,000 or more in tax debt, or who doesn’t provide a valid Social Security number.Since a change in Federal regulations in 2009 eliminated the last exception for crossing land borders to or from Canada and Mexico, it is a violation of Federal law “for any citizen of the United States to depart from or enter, or attempt to depart from or enter, the United States unless he bears a valid United States passport.”
This requirement for a passport can be “waived” at the “discretion” of the Department of State. But there is no right to a waiver, no formal procedures or standards for requesting such a waiver, and no apparent mechanism for judicial review of denial of a waiver.
So denying or revoking a US passport amounts to closing the US borders to that US citizen.
It’s not clear at whom, or at what conduct, this new provision in US law is directed.
Are Congress and the President concerned that suspected criminal violators of the tax laws might flee the country before they can be charged or arrested? So much for the presumption of innocence, the distinction between tax debts and crimes, and the Constitutional prohibition on imprisonment for debt.
Is the intent to prevent tax debtors from spiriting their untaxed assets out of the country before they can be seized? If so, restrictions on personal movement are both overbroad and likely to be ineffectual. Most international transfers of wealth occur electronically, and most cross-border shipments of tangible goods are in the form of unaccompanied freight, not accompanied luggage.
Is the goal to exile tax debtors from US territory? Under international human rights treaty law, the right to enter the country of one’s citizenship is [url=http://www.equalrightstrust.org/ertdocumentbank//general comment 27.pdf]the most absolute[/url] of the rights of freedom of movement: “There are few, if any, circumstances in which deprivation of the right to enter one’s own country could be reasonable.”
Denial or revocation of a US passport under this new law is an elaborate five-step process, although most of the steps are purely clerical:
- The IRS “assesses” a tax liability of at least $50,000 in 2016, or the equivalent amount adjusted according to the cost of living index in future years.
- The IRS issues a lien or levy for the tax assessment (again, for at least $50,000 or the latest adjusted equivalent).
- The Commissioner of Internal Revenue certifies the existence of this assessment and lien or levy to the Secretary of the Treasury (the head of the parent department of the IRS), and notifies the citizen of this certification and of their right to challenge it in court.
- The Secretary of the Treasury transmits the IRS certification to the Secretary of State
- Once the State Department receives this certification, it must not issue a new passport to the citizen, and may (apparently at the standardless discretion of the Secretary of State) revoke any current passport.
There are some options, but they are entirely at the discretion of the Secretary of State:
The law also permits (although it does not require — more standardless discretion for the Secretary of State) the denial of any application for a US passport that doesn’t include a valid Social Security number.If the Secretary of State decides to revoke a passport…, the Secretary of State, before revocation, may — (i) limit a previously issued passport only for return travel to the United States; or (ii) issue a limited passport that only permits return travel to the United States.
There’s an impunity clause in the law, although it’s unclear to what if any extent it is Constitutional, that attempts to protect government agents from liability for violating US citizens’ right to travel:
There is a procedure for judicial review, but only of the certification of a tax assessment and lien or levy:The Secretary of the Treasury, the Secretary of State, and any of their designees shall not be liable to an individual for any action with respect to a certification by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.
The new law is silent on what, if any, redress is available, or through what procedures, for a US citizen whose right to travel is violated when they are denied a passport, their passport is revoked or restricted, or they are subsequently prevented from entering or leaving the US. Responsibility for the deprivation of rights is divided among three Departments: Treasury certifying a tax debt, State denying or revoking a US passport, and DHS enforcing the passport requirement at airports and borders.After the Commissioner notifies an individual … , the taxpayer may bring a civil action against the United States in a district court of the United States or the Tax Court to determine whether the certification was erroneous or whether the Commissioner [of Internal Revenue] has failed to reverse the certification. If the court determines that such certification was erroneous, then the court may order the Secretary [of the Treasury] to notify the Secretary of State that such certification was erroneous.
A citizen could bring an action for a writ of mandamus ordering the State Department to issue a passport, which in some other cases has prompted the State Department to issue a passport before the case could be decided.
Or a citizen could bring an action for an injunction prohibiting the DHS from interfering with their entry or exit to or from the US.
In either case, we look forward to a declaratory judgement that this law is unconstitutional, and violates US obligations as a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
This entry was posted on Wednesday, December 9th, 2015 at 11:36 am and is filed under Freedom To Travel, Papers, Please. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
6 Responses to “No passports for US citizens who haven’t paid taxes or don’t have a Social Security number”
[list defaultattr=]
[*] John Says:
December 9th, 2015 at 9:24 pm
Any thoughts on whether a bankruptcy discharge of the subject tax liability would entitle one to be decertified, and eligible for a passport?
[*]New Collection Challenges | War Tax Talk Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 6:39 am
[...] Another good blog on the passport topic on the website Papers, Please! from The Identity Project. [...]
[*]Marsha Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 7:50 am
Does this mean Al Sharpton?
[*]Edward Hasbrouck Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 7:59 am
@John - Yes, there is a provision in the law for reversal of a certification of tax debt (and for judicial review of the decision on whether to reverse a certification) in several circumstances including if the debt “has been fully satisfied or has become legally unenforceable.”
[*]Aileen Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 8:18 am
So, is this effectively a “no fly” list? Because if so, then if Obama’s wishes go forward, they won’t be able to own guns either. And after the IRS’s persecution of Tea Party members through tax audits etc… I’d say we can look forward to anyone who disagrees with the current government being found guilty of tax fraud, owing that debt and then not only being not allowed to travel/leave the country but being disarmed as well.
[*]Mae Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 11:46 am
You would think if their a deadbeat on their finances the government would be happy to get rid of them. The way to get your money is to let them out but not allow them back IN until they have the money they owe you.
[/list]
Leave a Reply
Name (required)Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website
Copyright © 2015 The Identity Project • [url=feed:http://papersplease.org/wp/feed/]Entries (RSS)[/url] / [url=feed:http://papersplease.org/wp/comments/feed/]Comments (RSS)[/url]
Top / Home / Contact Us / Donate Now
http://papersplease.org/wp/2015/12/09/no-passports-for-us-citizens-who-havent-paid-taxes-or-dont-have-a-social-security-number/
» utube 12/08/23 Iraqi Dinar Today 2023 / Iraqi Dinar News Today / Iraqi Dinar
» utube 12/08/23 Militia Man & Crew Iraq Dinar International - Gateway - Local Currency - Sustainab
» The Prime Minister blesses the activation of the partnership between the Iraqi and Saudi private sec
» Planning: 11 axes to invest in the population increase and transform it into effective development e
» Advisor Mazhar Saleh: The economic geography of Iraq and Saudi Arabia constitutes an important found
» Al-Maliki: The best way to remove the corrupt is to go to the election ballots
» Al-Sudani: Parliament members have the final say in choosing the president
» The Kurdistan Region warns of a mass migration of Iraqis to other countries in the future
» "Embassy missiles" fall on the National Security headquarters, and the agency threatens the "bombers
» There are more obstacles than solutions.. The housing sector in Iraq: The need for more than 5 milli
» China reduces entry visa fees for Iraqis wishing to enter its territory (table)
» Al-Abadi on the bombing of the American embassy: Security and stability are not a commodity in the m
» Political conflicts and tension between Al-Halbousi and the governor.. What is happening in Anbar?
» Fatah leader: America created Al-Hawl camp to threaten the security of 7 Arab countries
» The Minister of Immigration instructs to solve the problems of returning families in Diyala
» Why was Iraq's "voluntary" reduction the largest in OPEC+?
» Regional Government: January 10th, official working hours in all Kurdistan districts
» Coinciding with International Anti-Corruption Day...the Ministry of Immigration holds a ceremony in
» The Federal Court rules that the instructions for conducting daily business in the Al-Kadhimi govern
» Head of the Kurdistan Council of Ministers: Our talks with the federal government will continue, and
» Three types of water violations were identified... Water Resources announces the introduction of gro
» Australian readiness to consolidate relations with the Kurdistan Region in the fields of investment
» There are more obstacles than solutions.. The housing sector in Iraq: The need for more than 5 milli
» The US Embassy in Baghdad urges the Iraqi government to protect diplomatic personnel
» Sudanese directs the prosecution of the perpetrators of the attack by launching projectiles towards
» Provincial council candidates are competing for two hundred and seventy-five seats
» With a new decision.. How will Iraq lose 6% of its oil exports?
» Georgetown Center for Studies: The killing of Americans in Iraq and the regional war is “a matter of
» Iraq.. Online food delivery will generate $845 million in 2023
» The US embassy in Baghdad confirms that it was hit by two missiles
» Directives from Sudanese regarding the bombing of the American embassy in Baghdad
» “No vacation until the end of the year.” The Minister of Finance issues a directive to the employees
» utube 12/5/23 Militia Man & Crew Iraq Dinar - Reality - Internationalism - Investors - Revaluatio
» The Ministry of Commerce decides to open sales outlets for those covered by social care in installme
» Minister of Oil: Iraq's decision to reduce OPEC Plus to achieve balance and stability in the markets
» Despite sending money from Baghdad.. Politician: The regional government refuses to release employee
» Baghdad is a cash cow...and the regional government steals the camel with what it carries
» Anbar Environment monitors violations of land conversion in Ramadi
» Federation of Arab Stock Exchanges: The Iraqi Stock Exchange accounted for 61% of November trading
» The Minister of Labor reveals a campaign to grant loans and plans to expand the employment process f
» Southern Gas: The agreement with the French company Total includes 4 main projects
» Sudanese directs to suspend working hours on Sunday
» Revealing the latest developments in choosing the new President of Parliament
» Media and Communications signs a contract with Azerbaijan to protect civil aviation radio navigation
» Al-Party accuses “sectarian” parties of delaying sending the $700 billion to the region
» The Kurdistan Oil Industry Association announces the joining of an American company
» A fine of 3 times the price.. Iraq reveals how to deal with goods that “violate specifications”
» Regional Government: Next Sunday, official working hours in all government departments
» A deputy reveals the loss of 35 trillion dinars and determines the extent of smuggling
» Al-Nouri: Most of the Central Bank’s decisions are political and do not have an economic content
» Representatives: The region’s failure to adhere to the decisions of the Baghdad government is causin
» 15 illegal outlets in Kurdistan cost the Iraqi treasury a billion dollars annually
» Naguib Sawiris: We are negotiating with government agencies to build an entire city outside Baghdad
» Commerce decides to open sales outlets for those covered by premium care at cost
» Directed to legislate a law that activates partnership between the public and private sectors
» The management of the North Refineries Reconstruction and Rehabilitation Project sets the date for o
» Problems between the region and foreign companies delay the export of oil through Ceyhan
» Parliamentarian: Baghdad has nothing to do with the salary crisis of the region’s employees
» Prime Minister: The Development Road Project will contribute to achieving economic development for t
» Iraq and 4 Arab countries possess more than one million tons of global gold reserves
» The stock market announces weekly trading indicators
» “Incompetent” figures are removed.. An expert indicates the influence of “tribal and partisan favori
» Al-Sudani: The path of development will contribute to achieving economic development for the region
» The current stability in Iraq is “temporary,” and this is what Al-Sudani succeeded in doing..An anal
» Shipments worth millions of dollars arrive in Iraq
» Government source: New shipments of dollar supplies arrive in Iraq
» In pictures: Iraqi Special Forces achieve first place in a global exercise in Pakistan
» Dismantling international drug networks in southern Iraq
» “Our soldiers are in a trap.” An American report calls for “courage” to withdraw from Iraq and Syria
» Labor launches electronic application to recruit foreign workers
» Audit Bureau: More than 5,000 financial reports will be issued in 2023
» Advisor to the Ministry of Oil: Iraq achieved 4% of its climate commitments this year
» Iraq is at the top of the 5 largest oil deals within a month
» A year later... where did Resolution 320 arrive at converting agricultural land to residential?
» The judiciary orders the Communications and Media Commission to adopt the Internet Services Licensin
» It does not include cuts or imposing a ban. The Commander-in-Chief approves the plan to secure local
» The discovery of about 50 archaeological sites and new heritage buildings in Kirkuk
» Iraq's exports of oil and its products to America exceed 70 million barrels within 7 months
» Salah al-Din Municipalities: A government move to refer cleaning work to the private sector
» The Sudanese government sends 700 billion to the region again
» Integrity: The Authority’s authority will extend to the private sector
» Preliminary designs for the construction of the Vanguard Bridge
» Maritime studies students prepare for the opening of the Grand Al-Faw Port
» Electricity signs a strategic contract with two companies
» Sudanese: We are serious about restoring the business environment and rehabilitating the institution
» The absence of programs and the presence of material temptations in {electoral propaganda}
» Experts: Integrity deals a strong blow to the corrupt
» Audit Bureau: More than 5,000 financial reports will be issued in 2023
» Dhi Qar adopts a plan to zero all requests for land plots and distributes more than 10,000 residenti
» The Kurdistan government demands Baghdad to achieve justice, pay salaries, and amend the budget
» Employees complain about their low salaries: The government does not appreciate our efforts
» OPEC production declined last month to control the oil market
» Al-Sudani and Talabani discuss “national issues and files” and the progress of implementing the gove
» America is pressing to save the normalization of Zionism.. Calls for Al-Halbousi to be tried on char
» Sudanese: $26 billion was not subject to customs duties and taxes
» 9 million Iraqis live in Baghdad
» "Sponsored ads" drained nearly a million dollars from the pockets of candidates in Iraq
» "Comprehensive discussions"... A Kurdish delegation will visit Baghdad soon, and Erbil announces the