Papers, Please!
Challenging ID Demands
The Identity Project explores and defends the fundamental American right to move freely around our country and to live without constantly having to prove who we are or why we are here.
Home The Issue Who We Are What We Do Secure Flight Featured Cases Policy Analysis Lawyer's Corner Take Action Press Room Contact Us Friends

« The human rights of migrants in transit
Since a change in Federal regulations in 2009 eliminated the last exception for crossing land borders to or from Canada and Mexico, it is a violation of Federal law “for any citizen of the United States to depart from or enter, or attempt to depart from or enter, the United States unless he bears a valid United States passport.”
This requirement for a passport can be “waived” at the “discretion” of the Department of State. But there is no right to a waiver, no formal procedures or standards for requesting such a waiver, and no apparent mechanism for judicial review of denial of a waiver.
So denying or revoking a US passport amounts to closing the US borders to that US citizen.
It’s not clear at whom, or at what conduct, this new provision in US law is directed.
Are Congress and the President concerned that suspected criminal violators of the tax laws might flee the country before they can be charged or arrested? So much for the presumption of innocence, the distinction between tax debts and crimes, and the Constitutional prohibition on imprisonment for debt.
Is the intent to prevent tax debtors from spiriting their untaxed assets out of the country before they can be seized? If so, restrictions on personal movement are both overbroad and likely to be ineffectual. Most international transfers of wealth occur electronically, and most cross-border shipments of tangible goods are in the form of unaccompanied freight, not accompanied luggage.
Is the goal to exile tax debtors from US territory? Under international human rights treaty law, the right to enter the country of one’s citizenship is [url=http://www.equalrightstrust.org/ertdocumentbank//general comment 27.pdf]the most absolute[/url] of the rights of freedom of movement: “There are few, if any, circumstances in which deprivation of the right to enter one’s own country could be reasonable.”
Denial or revocation of a US passport under this new law is an elaborate five-step process, although most of the steps are purely clerical:
There are some options, but they are entirely at the discretion of the Secretary of State:
There’s an impunity clause in the law, although it’s unclear to what if any extent it is Constitutional, that attempts to protect government agents from liability for violating US citizens’ right to travel:
A citizen could bring an action for a writ of mandamus ordering the State Department to issue a passport, which in some other cases has prompted the State Department to issue a passport before the case could be decided.
Or a citizen could bring an action for an injunction prohibiting the DHS from interfering with their entry or exit to or from the US.
In either case, we look forward to a declaratory judgement that this law is unconstitutional, and violates US obligations as a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
This entry was posted on Wednesday, December 9th, 2015 at 11:36 am and is filed under Freedom To Travel, Papers, Please. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
[list defaultattr=]
[*] John Says:
December 9th, 2015 at 9:24 pm
Any thoughts on whether a bankruptcy discharge of the subject tax liability would entitle one to be decertified, and eligible for a passport?
[*]New Collection Challenges | War Tax Talk Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 6:39 am
[...] Another good blog on the passport topic on the website Papers, Please! from The Identity Project. [...]
[*]Marsha Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 7:50 am
Does this mean Al Sharpton?
[*]Edward Hasbrouck Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 7:59 am
@John - Yes, there is a provision in the law for reversal of a certification of tax debt (and for judicial review of the decision on whether to reverse a certification) in several circumstances including if the debt “has been fully satisfied or has become legally unenforceable.”
[*]Aileen Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 8:18 am
So, is this effectively a “no fly” list? Because if so, then if Obama’s wishes go forward, they won’t be able to own guns either. And after the IRS’s persecution of Tea Party members through tax audits etc… I’d say we can look forward to anyone who disagrees with the current government being found guilty of tax fraud, owing that debt and then not only being not allowed to travel/leave the country but being disarmed as well.
[*]Mae Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 11:46 am
You would think if their a deadbeat on their finances the government would be happy to get rid of them. The way to get your money is to let them out but not allow them back IN until they have the money they owe you.
[/list]
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website
Copyright © 2015 The Identity Project • [url=feed:http://papersplease.org/wp/feed/]Entries (RSS)[/url] / [url=feed:http://papersplease.org/wp/comments/feed/]Comments (RSS)[/url]
Top / Home / Contact Us / Donate Now
http://papersplease.org/wp/2015/12/09/no-passports-for-us-citizens-who-havent-paid-taxes-or-dont-have-a-social-security-number/
Challenging ID Demands
The Identity Project explores and defends the fundamental American right to move freely around our country and to live without constantly having to prove who we are or why we are here.
Home The Issue Who We Are What We Do Secure Flight Featured Cases Policy Analysis Lawyer's Corner Take Action Press Room Contact Us Friends

« The human rights of migrants in transit
No passports for US citizens who haven’t paid taxes or don’t have a Social Security number
Buried in the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation Act (”FAST Act”) signed into law last week is an unrelated rider to provide for revocation of the passport and/or refusal to issue a passport to anyone against whom the IRS has assessed a lien or levy for $50,000 or more in tax debt, or who doesn’t provide a valid Social Security number.Since a change in Federal regulations in 2009 eliminated the last exception for crossing land borders to or from Canada and Mexico, it is a violation of Federal law “for any citizen of the United States to depart from or enter, or attempt to depart from or enter, the United States unless he bears a valid United States passport.”
This requirement for a passport can be “waived” at the “discretion” of the Department of State. But there is no right to a waiver, no formal procedures or standards for requesting such a waiver, and no apparent mechanism for judicial review of denial of a waiver.
So denying or revoking a US passport amounts to closing the US borders to that US citizen.
It’s not clear at whom, or at what conduct, this new provision in US law is directed.
Are Congress and the President concerned that suspected criminal violators of the tax laws might flee the country before they can be charged or arrested? So much for the presumption of innocence, the distinction between tax debts and crimes, and the Constitutional prohibition on imprisonment for debt.
Is the intent to prevent tax debtors from spiriting their untaxed assets out of the country before they can be seized? If so, restrictions on personal movement are both overbroad and likely to be ineffectual. Most international transfers of wealth occur electronically, and most cross-border shipments of tangible goods are in the form of unaccompanied freight, not accompanied luggage.
Is the goal to exile tax debtors from US territory? Under international human rights treaty law, the right to enter the country of one’s citizenship is [url=http://www.equalrightstrust.org/ertdocumentbank//general comment 27.pdf]the most absolute[/url] of the rights of freedom of movement: “There are few, if any, circumstances in which deprivation of the right to enter one’s own country could be reasonable.”
Denial or revocation of a US passport under this new law is an elaborate five-step process, although most of the steps are purely clerical:
- The IRS “assesses” a tax liability of at least $50,000 in 2016, or the equivalent amount adjusted according to the cost of living index in future years.
- The IRS issues a lien or levy for the tax assessment (again, for at least $50,000 or the latest adjusted equivalent).
- The Commissioner of Internal Revenue certifies the existence of this assessment and lien or levy to the Secretary of the Treasury (the head of the parent department of the IRS), and notifies the citizen of this certification and of their right to challenge it in court.
- The Secretary of the Treasury transmits the IRS certification to the Secretary of State
- Once the State Department receives this certification, it must not issue a new passport to the citizen, and may (apparently at the standardless discretion of the Secretary of State) revoke any current passport.
There are some options, but they are entirely at the discretion of the Secretary of State:
The law also permits (although it does not require — more standardless discretion for the Secretary of State) the denial of any application for a US passport that doesn’t include a valid Social Security number.If the Secretary of State decides to revoke a passport…, the Secretary of State, before revocation, may — (i) limit a previously issued passport only for return travel to the United States; or (ii) issue a limited passport that only permits return travel to the United States.
There’s an impunity clause in the law, although it’s unclear to what if any extent it is Constitutional, that attempts to protect government agents from liability for violating US citizens’ right to travel:
There is a procedure for judicial review, but only of the certification of a tax assessment and lien or levy:The Secretary of the Treasury, the Secretary of State, and any of their designees shall not be liable to an individual for any action with respect to a certification by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.
The new law is silent on what, if any, redress is available, or through what procedures, for a US citizen whose right to travel is violated when they are denied a passport, their passport is revoked or restricted, or they are subsequently prevented from entering or leaving the US. Responsibility for the deprivation of rights is divided among three Departments: Treasury certifying a tax debt, State denying or revoking a US passport, and DHS enforcing the passport requirement at airports and borders.After the Commissioner notifies an individual … , the taxpayer may bring a civil action against the United States in a district court of the United States or the Tax Court to determine whether the certification was erroneous or whether the Commissioner [of Internal Revenue] has failed to reverse the certification. If the court determines that such certification was erroneous, then the court may order the Secretary [of the Treasury] to notify the Secretary of State that such certification was erroneous.
A citizen could bring an action for a writ of mandamus ordering the State Department to issue a passport, which in some other cases has prompted the State Department to issue a passport before the case could be decided.
Or a citizen could bring an action for an injunction prohibiting the DHS from interfering with their entry or exit to or from the US.
In either case, we look forward to a declaratory judgement that this law is unconstitutional, and violates US obligations as a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
This entry was posted on Wednesday, December 9th, 2015 at 11:36 am and is filed under Freedom To Travel, Papers, Please. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
6 Responses to “No passports for US citizens who haven’t paid taxes or don’t have a Social Security number”
[list defaultattr=]
[*] John Says:
December 9th, 2015 at 9:24 pm
Any thoughts on whether a bankruptcy discharge of the subject tax liability would entitle one to be decertified, and eligible for a passport?
[*]New Collection Challenges | War Tax Talk Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 6:39 am
[...] Another good blog on the passport topic on the website Papers, Please! from The Identity Project. [...]
[*]Marsha Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 7:50 am
Does this mean Al Sharpton?
[*]Edward Hasbrouck Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 7:59 am
@John - Yes, there is a provision in the law for reversal of a certification of tax debt (and for judicial review of the decision on whether to reverse a certification) in several circumstances including if the debt “has been fully satisfied or has become legally unenforceable.”
[*]Aileen Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 8:18 am
So, is this effectively a “no fly” list? Because if so, then if Obama’s wishes go forward, they won’t be able to own guns either. And after the IRS’s persecution of Tea Party members through tax audits etc… I’d say we can look forward to anyone who disagrees with the current government being found guilty of tax fraud, owing that debt and then not only being not allowed to travel/leave the country but being disarmed as well.
[*]Mae Says:
December 10th, 2015 at 11:46 am
You would think if their a deadbeat on their finances the government would be happy to get rid of them. The way to get your money is to let them out but not allow them back IN until they have the money they owe you.
[/list]
Leave a Reply
Name (required)Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website
Copyright © 2015 The Identity Project • [url=feed:http://papersplease.org/wp/feed/]Entries (RSS)[/url] / [url=feed:http://papersplease.org/wp/comments/feed/]Comments (RSS)[/url]
Top / Home / Contact Us / Donate Now
http://papersplease.org/wp/2015/12/09/no-passports-for-us-citizens-who-havent-paid-taxes-or-dont-have-a-social-security-number/
» The Minister of Construction is discussing with a delegation from the World Bank the support of road
» An economic center warns of government decisions to raise fuel prices within the 2023 budget
» The Minister of Planning is discussing with the regional director of the International Monetary Fund
» Representative agriculture: Turkey's water releases are a temporary tactic to pacify Iraq
» Parliamentary action on political leaders to legislate a law before submitting it to Parliament
» The National: Baghdad is seeking an agreement with the region to resume oil exports at full capacity
» Parliamentary Human Rights talks about the imminent enactment of three important laws
» Al-Fatlawi: Türkiye has an economic opportunity to develop its relations with Iraq
» The President of the Judicial Council visits the Federal Court in the Emirates
» The markets of Baghdad and Kurdistan are closing down at dollar prices
» Al-Sudani’s advisor reveals the reasons for the continued rise of the dollar and confirms a “imminen
» A government official is likely to delay the payment of pensioners' salaries today
» The Iraqi Central Bank’s sales of dollars increased to more than 238 million
» Finance urges the participation of international experts in the process of developing the performanc
» For the first time.. the Anti-Money Laundering Council is moving to impose banking dealings in the s
» Iraq receives compensation of about 70 million dollars for the effects of climate change
» Kurdistan announces the distribution of more than two billion dinars to farmers within 3 years
» Investment: projects that simulate the experience of the city of "Al-Rafail" in 3 governorates
» The Central Bank talks about the "signs" of its measures: the dollar began to decline against the di
» More than 5% share of renewable energy in the electricity capacity in Iraq
» Al-Halbousi's deputy talks about the salaries of state employees
» The Parliamentary Foreign Ministry calls for resolving the “Ambassadors’ file”
» Parliament gives priority to 4 laws out of 127
» A political welcome to end the "war mandate" on Iraq
» New talk from the Central Bank regarding the exchange rate and the possibility of printing a denomin
» International interest in financing small and medium enterprises in Iraq
» Deputy for the framework: Parliamentary agreement to return the budget to the government
» Al-Sudani: We will provide the necessary environment for the local elections scheduled for this year
» The President of the Republic stresses the importance of consolidating cooperation and societal coex
» Kurdistan Union: International pressures behind setting the date for the regional parliament electio
» Israel enters into a crisis because of "Kurdistan's oil"
» Iraq is the fifth largest oil exporter to South Korea last February
» Parliamentary Finance reveals the reasons for the delay in reading the 2023 budget
» A new decline in dollar prices in the local markets
» The central bank’s dollar sales increased by 16%
» Customs Authority employees announce an open sit-in until their demands are met
» Iraq is among the list of countries with the most US bonds.. Here is the order
» Low prices of “foreign and Iraqi” gold in Baghdad markets
» A directive from the Minister of Interior “Abdul Amir Al-Shammari” regarding the employees of the In
» “Do not rush to celebrate.” A British view of the French court's decision on Kurdistan's oil: an emp
» Al-Mandalawi: Minimum salaries should be sufficient to meet the needs of employees and face market f
» An agreement to approve the amendment of the salary scale for employees
» The World Bank calls on Iraq to take advantage of the oil recovery by switching to renewable energy
» The Federal Court postponed consideration of extending the work of the Kurdistan Parliament to May
» MPs upset about not presenting the budget: We fear behind-the-scenes agreements
» Al-Sudani does not act as a framer, and the latter fears that he will eat his fans in the elections
» The judiciary clarifies the mechanism of control over financial institutions and the activities of t
» The Minister of Labor announces the disbursement of a financial reward for retired workers
» Mandalawi confirms Iraq's endeavor to strengthen its foreign relations and frame them with solid agr
» Minister of Electricity: There will be an increase in production and more stability next summer
» Minister of Water Resources: Changing locations in institutions is important
» Al-Maliki: My hand is still extended to Al-Sadr and other politicians, and I refuse to keep the riva
» Prime Minister: We have initiated a set of administrative reforms and decisive initiatives to combat
» The Minister of Finance is discussing with the International Monetary Fund support for economic refo
» The Minister of Oil announces the start of gas investment operations in the Akkas field at a rate of
» Saudi Arabia makes proposals for the development of agriculture in Iraq
» Central Bank: We have taken a set of packages to support the strength of the dinar, and its signs be
» The Central Bank sets its procedures to support the strength of the Iraqi dinar
» In Baghdad.. A meeting brings together the ambassadors of Saudi Arabia and Iran
» The US Senate votes to cancel the authorizations for the Iraq war
» Oil prices are declining.. What is the relationship of Kurdistan supplies?
» The exchange rates of the dollar in the Iraqi market today
» Customs Authority employees announce an open sit-in.. These are their demands (photos)
» Judy, MilitiaMan, Walkingstick and more......Wednesday AM 3-29-2023
» The Turkish Energy Minister denies fining his country $1.4 billion in the case of exporting Kurdista
» Integrity: the arrest of a wanted former trade official after his return from outside Iraq
» Report: Paving the Silk Road passes through pumping more Chinese loans to transit countries
» The Finance Committee breaks its silence: Al-Halbousi is alone discussing the budget in his private
» What is the benefit of the return of Iranian-Saudi relations to Iraq? Parliament answers
» Ports: 3 Travelers Were Arrested In Possession Of 522 Master Card Cards Intended For Smuggling
» Seizing A Factory For Industrial Fraud And Counterfeiting Trademarks, And Arresting Its Owner In Bag
» Iraq and Romania are discussing a mechanism for mutual coordination to support expertise between the
» The Agricultural Bank launches car purchase advances
» Al-Sudani calls for solving citizens' problems without waiting for the Prime Minister's directives
» Parliamentary Work: We have obligated local and foreign companies to employ the Iraqi workforce and
» Iraq Ports Company: The completion rate of the Al-Faw Grand Port project has reached more than 44.5%
» The head of the Service Council mortgages the launch of appointments to two issues and talks about t
» The Iraq Stock Exchange ends the day's trading, down 0.49%
» The arrest of a former official in the Ministry of Commerce after his return from abroad
» “Al-Kazemi incites Washington by inciting against Al-Sudani.” An American network warns the former p
» Deputy likely date of inclusion of the draft budget law on the agenda of Parliament
» The Central Bank of Iraq announces the imminent issuance of a decision regarding the possibility of
» Rashid: The United Nations has shown interest in helping Iraq solve water problems
» Exposing corruption and waste of public money worth 123 billion dinars in Basra (documents)
» After abolishing it years ago.. Restoring the provincial councils for the benefit or for the interes
» With rising prices, drought and lack of subsidies threaten the livestock market in Iraq
» The Iraqi Central Bank wants to issue a denomination of 20,000 dinars: we will issue a decision to p
» International trade obliges Iraq to pay compensation to Ankara in the arbitration case
» Declining Central Bank of Iraq sales of dollars
» An Iraqi bank launches car purchase advances
» International Trade orders Iraq to pay compensation to Ankara in the arbitration case
» Experts: Growing crude sales to China reflect positively on the economy
» Integrity monitors 5,000 lagging projects worth $20 billion over 5 years
» The maximum limit is 150 million.. An Iraqi company determines deposit compensation rates
» DNO begins closing oil fields in Kurdistan
» Minister of Labor We await approval of the budget to include 600,000 families with social protection
» Al-Sudani calls for expediting registration for health insurance: services at subsidized prices
» Investors Association: Foreign investors are now selling their shares from Iraqi companies