Which NHL team has the worst defense core?
September 1, 2017, 10:29 AM ET [45 Comments]
HockeyBuzz Hotstove
RSS • Archive • CONTACT
Follow me on Twitter @ToddCordell
Factoring in star power, emerging talent, and depth, we discuss which team has the worst defense core in the NHL.
Todd Cordell
The New Jersey Devils.
I really like Damon Severson but he's kind of on an island by himself. Andy Greene is still useful but his best days are behind him and his age is starting to show.
John Moore and Ben Lovejoy are playing way over their heads on the 2nd pairing and, after that, there are a ton of unproven players in Steve Santini, Mirco Mueller, and Will Butcher, among others. Even if one or two of the kids step up, the defense will probably still be an issue this season.
Honorable mention goes to Detroit. Mike Green is still good and, like New Jersey, they have a couple young defenders who could be solid down the road but they also have some anchors on the back end with Jonathan Ericsson and a rapidly declining Niklas Kronwall.
James Tanner
It's actually really hard to say who is the worst - the problem with teams that have a less-than-ideal amount of name-brand players is that they have a lot of guys you're not immediately familiar with.
I'll give the Knights a pass cause they're new, but the Red Wings are in a world of their own making. Mike Green is now seven years removed from his 70 point peak. He's alright.
DeKayser? Daley? An Ancient Niklas Kronwell?
This group is a mess.
When your best player is a guy known mostly for padding his stats off Alex Ovechkin's PP goal feasts of the last decade, you're pretty screwed.
Detroit's roster is arguably worse than the Knights - Maybe Ken Holland wasn't such a genius after all. Maybe getting two Hall of Famers in the seventh round (or whatever) makes you look better than you are. Who knows?
Adam French
Like the last question, there are several candidates and it's close. Vancouver lurks in this discussion again, as does New Jersey and Vegas. I choose New Jersey though.
Their defense looks like this.
Damon Severson : 80gp 3g 28a 31p (-31! AHHHH)
John Moore : 63gp 12g 10a 22p
Andy Greene : 66gp 4g 9a 13p
Steven Santini : 38gp 2g 5a 7p
Ben Lovejoy : 82gp 1g 6a 7p
Dalton Prout : 29gp 0g 6a 6p
Mirco Müeller : AHL
Will Butcher : NCAA
Once upon a time Andy Greene was an underrated top-4 minute muncher. Nothing fancy, but just solid. He's far from those days and is turning 35 with declining numbers.
Severson is a very promising young defenseman, but his +/- does tell a story. Hate the stat overall as much as you want and with good reason. It does have its uses in specific context. Like if you are -31 on a team where the next guy is -21. It's a rather large gap.
Lovejoy and Prout are basically pylons. Any team hoping to make the playoffs would have them as a 7/8 option at best, or AHL insurance policy.
Santini is a good prospect, but has always projected at best to be a solid defensive defenseman that can skate. Not exactly sexy.
John Moore is thrust into a larger role than he can handle simply because the Devils defense is that putrid. Like Loverout, he would be a 5/6 at best if you wanted to contend.
Lastly we have new additions Müller and Butcher. The two 22 year olds are having opposite career trajectories. Müller was selected 18th overall in 2013 and has been developing slowly in the AHL and is now considered essentially a bust/reclamation project. While Butcher was selected 123rd overall in 2013 and has been in the NCAA where good numbers and mystique make him the hottest commodity on earth. Weird how that works. If Müller can be a 5/6 defenseman, that's great for New Jersey. Butcher...if he can develop into a PP threat and 3/4 guy that would be ideal. However going into this season I will use history as a precedent for NCAA defensemen going into their rookie year. Gilroy (Hobey Baker Winner) 69gp 4g 11a 15p, Prow (Finalist) AHL, Reilly (Finalist) AHL etc. I don't expect him to be the Ghost Bear or Krug. More likely Dekeyserish.
Overall...it's a weak defense.
September 1, 2017, 10:29 AM ET [45 Comments]
HockeyBuzz Hotstove
RSS • Archive • CONTACT
Follow me on Twitter @ToddCordell
Factoring in star power, emerging talent, and depth, we discuss which team has the worst defense core in the NHL.
Todd Cordell
The New Jersey Devils.
I really like Damon Severson but he's kind of on an island by himself. Andy Greene is still useful but his best days are behind him and his age is starting to show.
John Moore and Ben Lovejoy are playing way over their heads on the 2nd pairing and, after that, there are a ton of unproven players in Steve Santini, Mirco Mueller, and Will Butcher, among others. Even if one or two of the kids step up, the defense will probably still be an issue this season.
Honorable mention goes to Detroit. Mike Green is still good and, like New Jersey, they have a couple young defenders who could be solid down the road but they also have some anchors on the back end with Jonathan Ericsson and a rapidly declining Niklas Kronwall.
James Tanner
It's actually really hard to say who is the worst - the problem with teams that have a less-than-ideal amount of name-brand players is that they have a lot of guys you're not immediately familiar with.
I'll give the Knights a pass cause they're new, but the Red Wings are in a world of their own making. Mike Green is now seven years removed from his 70 point peak. He's alright.
DeKayser? Daley? An Ancient Niklas Kronwell?
This group is a mess.
When your best player is a guy known mostly for padding his stats off Alex Ovechkin's PP goal feasts of the last decade, you're pretty screwed.
Detroit's roster is arguably worse than the Knights - Maybe Ken Holland wasn't such a genius after all. Maybe getting two Hall of Famers in the seventh round (or whatever) makes you look better than you are. Who knows?
Adam French
Like the last question, there are several candidates and it's close. Vancouver lurks in this discussion again, as does New Jersey and Vegas. I choose New Jersey though.
Their defense looks like this.
Damon Severson : 80gp 3g 28a 31p (-31! AHHHH)
John Moore : 63gp 12g 10a 22p
Andy Greene : 66gp 4g 9a 13p
Steven Santini : 38gp 2g 5a 7p
Ben Lovejoy : 82gp 1g 6a 7p
Dalton Prout : 29gp 0g 6a 6p
Mirco Müeller : AHL
Will Butcher : NCAA
Once upon a time Andy Greene was an underrated top-4 minute muncher. Nothing fancy, but just solid. He's far from those days and is turning 35 with declining numbers.
Severson is a very promising young defenseman, but his +/- does tell a story. Hate the stat overall as much as you want and with good reason. It does have its uses in specific context. Like if you are -31 on a team where the next guy is -21. It's a rather large gap.
Lovejoy and Prout are basically pylons. Any team hoping to make the playoffs would have them as a 7/8 option at best, or AHL insurance policy.
Santini is a good prospect, but has always projected at best to be a solid defensive defenseman that can skate. Not exactly sexy.
John Moore is thrust into a larger role than he can handle simply because the Devils defense is that putrid. Like Loverout, he would be a 5/6 at best if you wanted to contend.
Lastly we have new additions Müller and Butcher. The two 22 year olds are having opposite career trajectories. Müller was selected 18th overall in 2013 and has been developing slowly in the AHL and is now considered essentially a bust/reclamation project. While Butcher was selected 123rd overall in 2013 and has been in the NCAA where good numbers and mystique make him the hottest commodity on earth. Weird how that works. If Müller can be a 5/6 defenseman, that's great for New Jersey. Butcher...if he can develop into a PP threat and 3/4 guy that would be ideal. However going into this season I will use history as a precedent for NCAA defensemen going into their rookie year. Gilroy (Hobey Baker Winner) 69gp 4g 11a 15p, Prow (Finalist) AHL, Reilly (Finalist) AHL etc. I don't expect him to be the Ghost Bear or Krug. More likely Dekeyserish.
Overall...it's a weak defense.
» Service Council Chairman: We are ready to launch any electronic form as soon as job grades are avail
» MilitiaMan " The World is Watching" Thursday Night 5-19-2022
» KTFA Members "News and Views" Thursday Afternoon 5-19-2022
» Documents: The legal cordon "tightens" the Ministry of Oil regarding the region's oil, and the Feder
» Dozens of parliamentarians sign to settle defense mobilization salaries
» The supply of electric power in an Iraqi governorate has fallen to a third
» Reservations and controversy in Parliament’s reading of “Food Security”
» The Prime Minister directs to change {Green} and return its original names
» Iraq asks America to answer 14 files of convicts residing on its soil
» Opening it may topple big heads.. Parliamentary Integrity: “Corruption files” are closed with a “pol
» Washington imposes sanctions on Hezbollah financial companies in Iraq
» Transportation announces the reception of three commercial ships in the northern port of Umm Qasr
» Iraq and Jordan sign a memorandum of understanding on the exploitation of natural resources
» The Central Bank and Kurdistan Integrity sign a cooperation agreement to reduce money laundering
» The Supreme Judicial Council calls on political forces not to include him in their disputes
» Ministry of Commerce: There will be no famine in Iraq
» Dollar exchange rates in local markets
» Alsumaria publishes a picture of the bank account of the Minister of Transport
» State of Law: UNAMI is out of context
» Count him as an escape.. A legal expert comments on the dismissed governor of Salah al-Din sending h
» In the document .. Initiating a criminal case against the Minister of Oil for his failure to impleme
» Irada movement calls for respect for what is issued by the judiciary and directs a request to the po
» Can the proposed food security law be challenged? Legal expert explains
» Political blockage.. Is external mediation the solution?
» Document .. Federal Oil announces that it will "take over" the management of the export of crude fro
» KTFA Members "News and Views" Wednesday PM 5-18-2022
» Noon Agency publishes the text of the proposed food security bill in Parliament
» Al-Maliki..we are surprised by the insistence on legislating the food security law and standing agai
» Ur State Company signs a contract worth more than 13 billion dinars to supply electricity to the cen
» "Rights" calls on the Al-Kazemi government to resort to the advances and cover the expenses
» Iraq asks America to answer 14 files of convicts residing on its soil
» The Iraqi parliament completes a report and discussion of a proposed law banning normalization with
» A jump in the proportion of foreign remittances from the dollar in the auction of the Central Bank o
» Center calls on Baghdad and Erbil to implement UN recommendations and warnings about the seriousness
» Kurdish politician: Killings increased in Kurdistan for this reason
» The Parliamentary Rights Movement calls on the Al-Kazemi government to resort to the advances and co
» Independents are the most affected"... The war of words between the coordination framework and the t
» The resignation of five deputies from the extension movement
» $30 billion to support food security in countries affected by the Ukraine crisis.. Iraq is commentin
» Iraq signs a contract with a Chinese company to drill 22 oil wells
» The Central Bank of Iraq increases its capital to 5 trillion dinars
» Including light Basra .. The OPEC basket is declining by more than two dollars
» Because of the lack of support, Salah El-Din is likely to reduce wheat production by 40%
» The Triple Alliance: An exceptional opportunity to reduce Iran's influence in Iraq
» The President of the Supreme Judicial Council receives the Governor of Dhi Qar Muhammad Al-Ghazi
» The Federal Supreme Court responds to the President's inquiry
» Al-Maliki..we are surprised by the insistence on legislating the food security law and standing agai
» In the video, "George Bush" slip of the tongue exposes the reality of the occupation of Iraq in 2003
» Acute threat!: The US Air Force will participate in the major Israeli maneuver to destroy the Irania
» The Democratic Current files a lawsuit against the Speaker of the House of Representatives
» 99% of them have not received compensation.. the destruction prevents two-thirds of the people of Si
» Blackshart before the Security Council: The Iraqis are waiting for the power battles to end
» Economic offices account for 15% of provincial budgets
» There was no breakthrough in the crisis a month ago...and "dissolving Parliament" is an option after
» In the document.. Al-Maamouri sends a request to the Speaker of Parliament regarding 315 contracts
» In the document.. the second deputy speaker of parliament reveals his financial disclosure
» Governmental Adviser: The judiciary's decision on the food security law will affect the white paper
» Iraq announces transferring the brunt of mass graves crimes to the international community
» Nazim: The government's cooperation with Parliament may lead us to a law that overcomes challenges
» The Speaker of Parliament assigns a former Turkmen minister the duties of Provincial Affairs Adviser
» Parliamentary Finance: Tables of food security amounts will not exceed 25 trillion dinars
» A representative for the Democrat: Representatives in the framework signed the sending of the Food S
» Finance begins launching employee salaries
» Independent Deputy: We have not received any response to our initiative
» A representative of the state of law comments on the new food security law
» Deputy: The capital, Baghdad, is facing a serious environmental problem
» The House of Representatives holds its session headed by Al-Halbousi
» The House of Representatives begins the first reading of the proposed law on emergency support for f
» A slight rise in the "dollar" against the Iraqi dinar in the local markets
» Oil recovers from early losses and hits $110 a barrel
» The Central Bank of Iraq decides to increase its capital to (5) trillion dinars
» The joint operations determine the percentages of completion of the security barrier on the Iraqi-Sy
» Representative of the State of Law: The continuation of the political blockage will lead to the coll
» An electric power transmission line was sabotaged south of Baghdad
» The Minister of Electricity instructs to exclude the examination centers from the programmed cut
» Finance begins launching employee salaries for the month of May[/size]
» Collecting signatures of more than 200 deputies to dismiss the governor of Salah El-Din - Urgent
» The coordination considers "emergency support" an acquisition of power and accuses the trio
» The agenda of the House of Representatives in its session today, Thursday
» Triple Alliance: No red lines in dialogue
» Deputy: The Independent Initiative is the only solution to overcoming the political blockage
» One last chance...a new initiative from the Kurdistan Democratic Party
» Claims to stop the investment project for electric stations by the company "KAR": includes legal vio
» Finance begins to launch funding for state employees’ salaries for the month of May
» Dollar exchange rates in local markets
» Holly, MilitiaMan, Pimpy and more.......Wednesday AM 5-18-2022
» We have reached a dead end..A representative of the "coordinating framework" talks about new options
» Iraq balks at greater Chinese control of its oilfields
» The Iraqi government thwarts plans to sell oil stakes to China and dominate it
» Reuters: Iraq is concerned about the Chinese encroachment in its oil fields
» Kurdistan Regional Government extends 15 percent exemption from loans until next month
» Parliamentary Finance proposes the “Emergency Support for Food Security and Development” law as an a
» The President of the Republic discusses ways to strengthen relations with Switzerland
» Al-Kazemi identifies the reason for the high real estate prices in areas in Baghdad
» The Strategic Planning and Parliamentary Federal Service Committee selects the age president and his
» Al-Maliki's Coalition Invites The Political Blocs Regarding The Initiative Of The Independents
» Iraq's delegate to the United Nations submits an official complaint against Turkey, calling on all T
» America confirms its continued support for Iraq to achieve security and stability