The Prospect Tease
August 11, 2017, 1:15 PM ET [35 Comments]
John Jaeckel
Chicago Blackhawks Blogger • RSS • Archive • CONTACT
Just 5 summers ago, the Blackhawks #2 ranked prospect—in what was at that time supposedly a top 10 NHL talent pipeline—was defenseman Adam Clendening. Another top 5 Hawk prospect at that time was LW Jeremy Morin.
Since then, Clendening has played in 81 NHL games with 4 teams, compiling 22 points. Morin has played in 70 NHL games since with 2 teams and compiled 19 points.
Ugh.
10 years ago, the Hawks’ top 10 prospects—which included the likes of Toews, Kane, and Byfuglien—also included Cam Barker, Evan Brophey, Danny Richmond, and Jack Skille.
Skille and Barker were top 10 NHL draft selections, as was 2008 pick Kyle Beach.
Many of these players put up huge junior numbers. Some, like Kane, became NHL successes. Some, like Beach, didn’t.
The truth is, huge production in junior or college hockey pretty much can’t be counted on as a clear or direct indicator of future NHL success.
An old friend of mine, who himself played in the OHL and later in the pro minors, later was the GM of an OHL club, and finally an agent for a handful of former Hawk prospects about 10-15 years ago. Of one of those prospects—who was highly touted—he said:
“He gets away with things in junior that he can’t in the NHL. So I don’t know how good he’s going to be at the next level. He doesn’t have the speed to do the same things he’s doing now. There’s such a big difference between junior and the NHL.”
As it turned out, the prospect in question ended up being a fairly productive NHL player for several seasons. But the point stands. Some make that leap, some don’t.
For every Kane, there’s a Rob Schremp. Or an Alexandre Daigle. Or a Beach. A Morin. Or an Akim Aliu.
I had another friend who was once invited to Red Wings pro camp. It didn’t last long.
“The guys at that level are so fast and it’s so physical. I was a great player at the lower levels. But I couldn’t handle it.”
Comparing top tier NCAA hockey to the pros, former Hawk Jim Cummins once said:
“Guys in college skate around like they’re ten feet tall with those full cages. You can’t do that up here.”
Yet, every year as summer inches toward fall, bloggers and fans get bored and itchy and start creating lists of prospect rankings—typically based on reputation and numbers at the lower levels of hockey alone.
I know, I used to do the same thing—even “professionally” as a writer for the now defunct hockeysfuture.com.
What I’ve learned—and why I now tend to pump the brakes on prospect rankings and projections—is this:
1) Speed is a big differentiator
Straight line speed is not the sole determinant of who succeeds in the NHL and who doesn’t. But the road to NHL success is littered with guys like Beach, Morin, and Barker who could dominate at the lower levels (in Morin’s lone OHL season, as a 19 year old, he racked up 83 points in 58 games) but lacked the speed necessary to translate their games to the NHL level.
And, if anything—due to rules changes, and resulting officiating and coaching trends in the NHL, speed is an even more important aspect of the game today than it was even just five years ago.
I had a reader “lecture” me on the “elite” nature of the OHL a couple of weeks ago. His point being that I shouldn’t discount “outstanding” production in that league. I had to explain to the reader that over 90% of the players in the OHL are 16-19 years old and never play pro hockey—because they lack either the speed, size, talent or combinations thereof to reach the next level. And logically, there are “high end” prospects who can compile big numbers against those players, because of some unique skill like stickhandling or shooting—but can’t duplicate it at the next level due to a deficit of speed, size, or willingness versus pro players.
That isn’t to say that a player with average skating can’t make it and succeed in today’s NHL. But that player better have some highly commendable skills in other areas—as well as a lot of humility and work ethic—to overcome a lack of speed.
2) Size is not critical, but willingness absolutely is
Hawk fans don’t have to go too far back to the glory days when Teuvo Teravainen was going to be the next Patrick Kane—or some facsimile thereof. The jury is still sort of out on TT as an NHL player. And in terms of sheer talent, the more extreme expectations on him were probably a bit overblown and unfair. He does, however, have skill, that much has never been in question.
The issue with Teravainen has been (and by some accounts still is) an aversion to the weight room and to contact on the ice—which has limited him as a player in the NHL.
But for every TT, there’s a Theo Fleury or a Marty St. Louis, or a Kane. Smaller guys who are fairly fearless—and have other NHL attributes (like hands, a shot and especially speed) in abundance.
3) It’s a marathon, not a sprint
Most NHL players are drafted at age 17. That is, those who are drafted.
The average age for an NHL debut is about 21. That’s four years where a lot can happen, good or bad.
Some guys come out of nowhere, like the undrafted Ed Belfour, or a sixth round pick like Steve Larmer, or Byfuglien who was taken in the 8th round.
Many guys taken higher, as pointed out ad nauseum, never really develop or fail to meet projections.
Sometimes, it merely takes some players longer than others to meet expectations. The Blackhawks’ own Richard Panik bounced through three NHL organizations before settling in and flourishing last year on Jonathan Toews’ right wing.
Important to note also, Panik’s junior numbers were never what you’d call “exceptional”—yet today he is a productive top 6 winger in the NHL, primarily because of an NHL-level size/speed combination—and willingness.
It’s with all this in mind that we can look forward to this year’s pro camp, and questions that are yet to be answered.
Is last year’s camp phenom, undrafted QMJHL winger Alex Fortin, the real thing or just a one-year flash in the pan? A couple of highly intriguing traits Fortin showed last year—above average speed (as compared to pro competition) and the ability to make and finish plays at top speed. Yet Fortin lacks the big junior pedigree, barely a point per game player. So another stellar camp—or one where he comes back to earth—will go a long way in determining whether Fortin is one of those “out of nowhere guys” or not.
The recently-concluded prospect camp was supposed to be “The Camp of (Alex) Debrincat.” It wasn’t. OHL scoring champ DeBrincat had some moments—especially in camp scrimmages versus other prospects, but he struggled in one on one drills (especially against bigger players) and at times looked slow or disinterested.
Or will another camp invitee step up, like Fortin did last year, and grab the spotlight?
The point is, all the hype and projections and rankings aside, we won’t really know until they lace the skates up and play. As pros. Or at least with and against pros. And even then, the story itself will likely deviate from the scripted expectations.
All I have for now,
» Service Council Chairman: We are ready to launch any electronic form as soon as job grades are avail
» MilitiaMan " The World is Watching" Thursday Night 5-19-2022
» KTFA Members "News and Views" Thursday Afternoon 5-19-2022
» Documents: The legal cordon "tightens" the Ministry of Oil regarding the region's oil, and the Feder
» Dozens of parliamentarians sign to settle defense mobilization salaries
» The supply of electric power in an Iraqi governorate has fallen to a third
» Reservations and controversy in Parliament’s reading of “Food Security”
» The Prime Minister directs to change {Green} and return its original names
» Iraq asks America to answer 14 files of convicts residing on its soil
» Opening it may topple big heads.. Parliamentary Integrity: “Corruption files” are closed with a “pol
» Washington imposes sanctions on Hezbollah financial companies in Iraq
» Transportation announces the reception of three commercial ships in the northern port of Umm Qasr
» Iraq and Jordan sign a memorandum of understanding on the exploitation of natural resources
» The Central Bank and Kurdistan Integrity sign a cooperation agreement to reduce money laundering
» The Supreme Judicial Council calls on political forces not to include him in their disputes
» Ministry of Commerce: There will be no famine in Iraq
» Dollar exchange rates in local markets
» Alsumaria publishes a picture of the bank account of the Minister of Transport
» State of Law: UNAMI is out of context
» Count him as an escape.. A legal expert comments on the dismissed governor of Salah al-Din sending h
» In the document .. Initiating a criminal case against the Minister of Oil for his failure to impleme
» Irada movement calls for respect for what is issued by the judiciary and directs a request to the po
» Can the proposed food security law be challenged? Legal expert explains
» Political blockage.. Is external mediation the solution?
» Document .. Federal Oil announces that it will "take over" the management of the export of crude fro
» KTFA Members "News and Views" Wednesday PM 5-18-2022
» Noon Agency publishes the text of the proposed food security bill in Parliament
» Al-Maliki..we are surprised by the insistence on legislating the food security law and standing agai
» Ur State Company signs a contract worth more than 13 billion dinars to supply electricity to the cen
» "Rights" calls on the Al-Kazemi government to resort to the advances and cover the expenses
» Iraq asks America to answer 14 files of convicts residing on its soil
» The Iraqi parliament completes a report and discussion of a proposed law banning normalization with
» A jump in the proportion of foreign remittances from the dollar in the auction of the Central Bank o
» Center calls on Baghdad and Erbil to implement UN recommendations and warnings about the seriousness
» Kurdish politician: Killings increased in Kurdistan for this reason
» The Parliamentary Rights Movement calls on the Al-Kazemi government to resort to the advances and co
» Independents are the most affected"... The war of words between the coordination framework and the t
» The resignation of five deputies from the extension movement
» $30 billion to support food security in countries affected by the Ukraine crisis.. Iraq is commentin
» Iraq signs a contract with a Chinese company to drill 22 oil wells
» The Central Bank of Iraq increases its capital to 5 trillion dinars
» Including light Basra .. The OPEC basket is declining by more than two dollars
» Because of the lack of support, Salah El-Din is likely to reduce wheat production by 40%
» The Triple Alliance: An exceptional opportunity to reduce Iran's influence in Iraq
» The President of the Supreme Judicial Council receives the Governor of Dhi Qar Muhammad Al-Ghazi
» The Federal Supreme Court responds to the President's inquiry
» Al-Maliki..we are surprised by the insistence on legislating the food security law and standing agai
» In the video, "George Bush" slip of the tongue exposes the reality of the occupation of Iraq in 2003
» Acute threat!: The US Air Force will participate in the major Israeli maneuver to destroy the Irania
» The Democratic Current files a lawsuit against the Speaker of the House of Representatives
» 99% of them have not received compensation.. the destruction prevents two-thirds of the people of Si
» Blackshart before the Security Council: The Iraqis are waiting for the power battles to end
» Economic offices account for 15% of provincial budgets
» There was no breakthrough in the crisis a month ago...and "dissolving Parliament" is an option after
» In the document.. Al-Maamouri sends a request to the Speaker of Parliament regarding 315 contracts
» In the document.. the second deputy speaker of parliament reveals his financial disclosure
» Governmental Adviser: The judiciary's decision on the food security law will affect the white paper
» Iraq announces transferring the brunt of mass graves crimes to the international community
» Nazim: The government's cooperation with Parliament may lead us to a law that overcomes challenges
» The Speaker of Parliament assigns a former Turkmen minister the duties of Provincial Affairs Adviser
» Parliamentary Finance: Tables of food security amounts will not exceed 25 trillion dinars
» A representative for the Democrat: Representatives in the framework signed the sending of the Food S
» Finance begins launching employee salaries
» Independent Deputy: We have not received any response to our initiative
» A representative of the state of law comments on the new food security law
» Deputy: The capital, Baghdad, is facing a serious environmental problem
» The House of Representatives holds its session headed by Al-Halbousi
» The House of Representatives begins the first reading of the proposed law on emergency support for f
» A slight rise in the "dollar" against the Iraqi dinar in the local markets
» Oil recovers from early losses and hits $110 a barrel
» The Central Bank of Iraq decides to increase its capital to (5) trillion dinars
» The joint operations determine the percentages of completion of the security barrier on the Iraqi-Sy
» Representative of the State of Law: The continuation of the political blockage will lead to the coll
» An electric power transmission line was sabotaged south of Baghdad
» The Minister of Electricity instructs to exclude the examination centers from the programmed cut
» Finance begins launching employee salaries for the month of May[/size]
» Collecting signatures of more than 200 deputies to dismiss the governor of Salah El-Din - Urgent
» The coordination considers "emergency support" an acquisition of power and accuses the trio
» The agenda of the House of Representatives in its session today, Thursday
» Triple Alliance: No red lines in dialogue
» Deputy: The Independent Initiative is the only solution to overcoming the political blockage
» One last chance...a new initiative from the Kurdistan Democratic Party
» Claims to stop the investment project for electric stations by the company "KAR": includes legal vio
» Finance begins to launch funding for state employees’ salaries for the month of May
» Dollar exchange rates in local markets
» Holly, MilitiaMan, Pimpy and more.......Wednesday AM 5-18-2022
» We have reached a dead end..A representative of the "coordinating framework" talks about new options
» Iraq balks at greater Chinese control of its oilfields
» The Iraqi government thwarts plans to sell oil stakes to China and dominate it
» Reuters: Iraq is concerned about the Chinese encroachment in its oil fields
» Kurdistan Regional Government extends 15 percent exemption from loans until next month
» Parliamentary Finance proposes the “Emergency Support for Food Security and Development” law as an a
» The President of the Republic discusses ways to strengthen relations with Switzerland
» Al-Kazemi identifies the reason for the high real estate prices in areas in Baghdad
» The Strategic Planning and Parliamentary Federal Service Committee selects the age president and his
» Al-Maliki's Coalition Invites The Political Blocs Regarding The Initiative Of The Independents
» Iraq's delegate to the United Nations submits an official complaint against Turkey, calling on all T
» America confirms its continued support for Iraq to achieve security and stability