Judge rejects Obama's executive privilege claim over Fast and Furious records
The Justice Department's own public disclosures undercut the president's privilege claim, Judge Amy Berman Jackson ruled.
By Josh Gerstein
01/19/16 01:16 PM EST
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter
A federal judge has rejected President Barack Obama's assertion of executive privilege to deny Congress access to records pertaining to Operation Fast and Furious, a gunrunning probe that allegedly allowed thousands of weapons to flow across the border into Mexico.
U.S. District Court Judge Amy Berman Jackson ruled Tuesday that the Justice Department's public disclosures about its response to the so-called "gun walking" controversy undercut Obama's executive privilege claim.
"There is no need to balance the need against the impact that the revelation of any record could have on candor in future executive decision making, since any harm that might flow from the public revelation of the deliberations at issue here has already been self-inflicted," Jackson wrote. "The Department itself has already publicly revealed the sum and substance of the very material it is now seeking to withhold. Since any harm that would flow from the disclosures sought here would be merely incremental, the records must be produced."
Jackson said she wasn't questioning the propriety of Obama's claim of privilege, but ruling that the claim could not be sustained in view of other information the Justice Department had released on the topic, chiefly an Office of Inspector General report released in September 2012.
"This ruling is not predicated on a finding that the withholding was intended to cloak wrongdoing on the part of government officials or that the withholding itself was improper," the judge wrote.
The standoff over the records led to a House vote in June 2012 holding then-Attorney General Eric Holder in contempt of Congress for failing to turn over the records. The House later initiated a lawsuit to try to force disclosure of the files. The case was repeatedly delayed in an unsuccessful effort to broker a settlement.
The administration initially asked Jackson to throw out the suit altogether, arguing that the legislative and executive branches should use their own methods to sort out the dispute. However, the judge ruled in 2013 that the fight was an appropriate one for the courts to resolve. She also rejected the administration's efforts to appeal the case at that time, before she issued a definitive ruling.
Jackson, an Obama appointee, left open the possibility in her ruling Tuesday that some of the disputed records could still be held back from Congress because they contain sensitive information on law enforcement techniques, implicate foreign policy concerns or discuss matters covered by attorney-client privilege.
The administration could appeal the ruling. Asked about the decision at a regular briefing for reporters Tuesday, White House press secretary Josh Earnest had no immediate comment.
A Justice Department spokeswoman said solely that the agency was "reviewing the decision."
Read more: http://www.politico.com/story/2016/01/judge-rejects-obamas-executive-privilege-claim-over-fast-and-furious-records-217970#ixzz3xpV7yDIU
The Justice Department's own public disclosures undercut the president's privilege claim, Judge Amy Berman Jackson ruled.
By Josh Gerstein
01/19/16 01:16 PM EST
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter
A federal judge has rejected President Barack Obama's assertion of executive privilege to deny Congress access to records pertaining to Operation Fast and Furious, a gunrunning probe that allegedly allowed thousands of weapons to flow across the border into Mexico.
U.S. District Court Judge Amy Berman Jackson ruled Tuesday that the Justice Department's public disclosures about its response to the so-called "gun walking" controversy undercut Obama's executive privilege claim.
"There is no need to balance the need against the impact that the revelation of any record could have on candor in future executive decision making, since any harm that might flow from the public revelation of the deliberations at issue here has already been self-inflicted," Jackson wrote. "The Department itself has already publicly revealed the sum and substance of the very material it is now seeking to withhold. Since any harm that would flow from the disclosures sought here would be merely incremental, the records must be produced."
Jackson said she wasn't questioning the propriety of Obama's claim of privilege, but ruling that the claim could not be sustained in view of other information the Justice Department had released on the topic, chiefly an Office of Inspector General report released in September 2012.
"This ruling is not predicated on a finding that the withholding was intended to cloak wrongdoing on the part of government officials or that the withholding itself was improper," the judge wrote.
The standoff over the records led to a House vote in June 2012 holding then-Attorney General Eric Holder in contempt of Congress for failing to turn over the records. The House later initiated a lawsuit to try to force disclosure of the files. The case was repeatedly delayed in an unsuccessful effort to broker a settlement.
The administration initially asked Jackson to throw out the suit altogether, arguing that the legislative and executive branches should use their own methods to sort out the dispute. However, the judge ruled in 2013 that the fight was an appropriate one for the courts to resolve. She also rejected the administration's efforts to appeal the case at that time, before she issued a definitive ruling.
Jackson, an Obama appointee, left open the possibility in her ruling Tuesday that some of the disputed records could still be held back from Congress because they contain sensitive information on law enforcement techniques, implicate foreign policy concerns or discuss matters covered by attorney-client privilege.
The administration could appeal the ruling. Asked about the decision at a regular briefing for reporters Tuesday, White House press secretary Josh Earnest had no immediate comment.
A Justice Department spokeswoman said solely that the agency was "reviewing the decision."
Read more: http://www.politico.com/story/2016/01/judge-rejects-obamas-executive-privilege-claim-over-fast-and-furious-records-217970#ixzz3xpV7yDIU
» After adjusting the exchange rate.. Sudanese advisor: to achieve a promising economy
» Al-Sudani details the achievements of his government: We stopped appointments and contracts because
» Prime Minister: All state files are covered by work, not just the five priorities that we have set i
» The Prime Minister confirms proceeding with the fifth licensing round for gas investments, which wil
» Sadiqoun bloc on the occasion of devaluing the dollar: Damn Kadhimi and Baathism
» Electricity and the dollar.. The most important thing that came to the Sudanese press conference - U
» The Sudanese financial advisor reveals the latest course of the decision to reduce the price of the
» The Service Council announces the approval of the appointment of those covered by the Medical Profes
» Prime Minister: Selling the dollar at the new price will start tomorrow and there are no red lines i
» The Ministry of Labor talks about a new mechanism to occupy the unemployed
» Expert on reducing the exchange rate: new inflation hits the Iraqi economy
» Parliament praises the decision to reduce the price of the dollar and calls for the speedy sending o
» Central Bank: We will continue to work on the sustainability of the Iraqi financial and banking syst
» Does the depreciation of the dollar contribute to stability?
» The Iraqi Parliament calls for a review of the mechanisms of work of government and private banks
» The Iraqi government issues a number of new decisions
» Al-Rafidain announces the opening of a dollar outlet at Baghdad Airport
» The first comment from the Central Bank following the decision to adjust the exchange rate
» The Central Bank: to start selling the dollar at the new price of 1,300 dinars, starting tomorrow
» Al-Sudani advises the Iraqis about the dollar and reiterates: The dinar is stronger
» Among them concerns the dollar and energy .. Alsumaria publishes the full decisions of the Council o
» Al-Samarrai considers adjusting the exchange rate an "important step"
» Parliament announces the agenda for next Thursday's session
» Al-Darraji: The US Federal Reserve will hold private banks accountable in the coming months
» Al-Azm: We support the Cabinet’s move to reduce the dollar exchange rate
» KTFA Monday Night CC "WalkingStick Wants to Talk To You KTFA" 2-6-2023
» All the decisions that came out of the Council of Ministers meeting for today
» An expert comments on the new exchange rate: Iraq is the biggest loser
» The Iraqi government announces a number of "dollar" decisions and financial support for Syria and Tu
» Al-Sudani announces a draft of the oil and gas law and sets its date
» Iraqi dinar value to be restored to highest level in two years
» Al-Rafidain announces the opening of the dollar outlet at Baghdad International Airport
» Saleh: The 2023 budget will adopt the new exchange rate, and the reserve has risen to $115 billion.
» Parliament adjourns its session after completing the reading of 3 laws
» Government advisor: The Iraqi economy is strong and has great resources
» The Council of Ministers approves the amendment of the exchange rate of the dollar against the dinar
» Advisor to the Prime Minister: A new strategy began with reforming the currency management system an
» Al-Sudani directs to reformulate the 2023 budget at an exchange rate of 1,350 dinars
» Mazhar Muhammad Salih: The Iraqi economy is able to withstand foreign currencies
» The House of Representatives ends the first reading of the draft law on the Media and Communications
» The House of Representatives holds its session in the presence of 224 deputies
» The House of Representatives ends the first reading of two bills
» MilitiaMan, Nader From the Mid East and Dr. Kia Pruitt Monday 2-6-2023
» Member of the State of Law: The Sudanese government's actions against currency smuggling to neighbor
» The Iranian Foreign Ministry talks about Iraqi commitments to finance two joint projects
» Kurdistan seeks help from the Sudanese to stop corruption in the regionproposals from
» "The silence will explode within weeks." Demonstrations by the Sadrist movement may worsen the situa
» Parliament ends the first reading of the first amendment law proposal to the Aliens Residence Law
» For the fourth consecutive month, Iraq is declining in its oil exports to India
» The Ministerial Council of Economy issues decisions and recommendations for the development of Iraqi
» The Chambers of Commerce announce a procedure to introduce small traders into the Central Bank platf
» The Iraqi Bank opens a new branch in Dohuk
» Al-Mandalawi calls for monitoring the work of dollar selling outlets inside banks
» The Iraqi Embassy in Turkey issues directives to the Iraqi community in Gaziantep
» Parliamentary leaks reveal the content of a plan to reduce the exchange rate
» 15 new residential cities in Baghdad and the provinces
» The Federal Court postpones its session on extending the session of the Kurdistan Parliament to Marc
» The proceeds of selling the dollar through the central bank window on Tuesday
» Research Center: The Iraqi delegation in Washington will discuss three files
» Coordination Framework: Dismissals await a number of governors after the completion of the investiga
» Minority representatives denounce their exclusion from parliamentary committee chairs and demand a r
» The President of the Republic: Terrorist incidents are rare in Iraq
» The Iraqi Central Bank issues a new statement on digital currencies
» Financial expert: Iraq's budget will not be affected by the reduction in the dollar exchange rate
» For the third day in a row..the Central Bank of Iraq's dollar cash sales increased
» Iraq retreats to second place in its oil exports to India for the fourth month in a row
» Siemens reviews its steps to develop the electric power system in Iraq
» The price of the dollar decreased by 5% after the central bank directed to devalue the dollar
» 8 trillion dinars needed by Iraq to establish new residential cities
» Parliamentary Finance: New promises to send the budget during the current week
» Water resources: Iraqi dams were not affected by the earthquake
» An economist for "Al-Iqtisad News": The real estate market in Iraq is living in a bubble stage
» The Iraqi Stock Exchange carried out more than 14,000 transactions worth 62 billion dinars during th
» Parliamentary Committee: The Retirement and Social Security Law will see the light within a month
» The exchange rate and a barrel of oil restrict budget legislation
» Parliamentary efforts to support the study of the Central Bank to reduce the exchange rate of the do
» Understandings to double appointment of geologists
» Financial control obliges the region to hand over all oil production
» Siemens adds a thousand megawatts during the current year
» Governor of Diwaniyah Agency: Implementation of 45 projects within food security
» Minister of Finance and Economy: We will distribute the salaries of Kurdistan Region employees elect
» Lavrov calls for distancing his country's relations with Iraq from Western sanctions
» Dismissals await a number of negligent conservatives
» Parliamentary Health: 70% of the drugs on the market are not subject to control and are smuggled
» The stability of the dollar exchange rate depends on the results of the Iraqi delegation's negotiati
» The Minister of Immigration stresses the necessity of communicating with the Ministry's categories o
» Iraq discusses economic cooperation with Russia and requests an end to the Ukrainian war
» Al-Maliki's coalition disavows "accounts that offend" the leaders of the Coordination Framework and
» The suspension of social networking sites throughout Iraq
» Sudanese adviser confirms the reduction of the exchange rate of the dollar
» The file of the return of the displaced is on the table of the Presidents of the Republic and the Po
» The State Administration Coalition is discussing the election law in preparation for holding it on t
» The Ministerial Council of Economy is considering activating the single window system for the indust
» State administration stresses the importance of strengthening bilateral relations with Washington
» Disclosure (attempts) to reduce the exchange rate in the budget to 135 thousand dinars
» Parliamentary Committee: The Retirement and Social Security Law will be voted on within a month
» Advisor to the Prime Minister: The exchange rate of the dollar will be reduced in accordance with th
» The dollar falls against the dinar