Home
Government seeks 'authority to determine what is sin'
In its Supreme Court battle over Obamacare’s abortion-pill mandate, the government wants to “determine what is in fact a sin,” contends a religious-rights legal group.
The high court has agreed to hear the case of the Denver-based Little Sisters of the Poor nuns, who refused to comply with the requirement that the insurance policies for their employees cover abortion pills.
The nuns have refused to sign over the responsibility to their insurance company, arguing it also would be a violation of their faith to facilitate someone else committing a sin.
Now a friend-of-the-court brief submitted by the Thomas More Law Center on behalf of dozens of clients charges the government is seeking to become the arbiter of religious beliefs.
The group’s chief counsel, Richard Thompson, called the mandate “a monumental attack on religious liberty.”
“If this appeal is lost, the government becomes the head of every religious denomination in the country by its assumed authority to determine what is in fact a sin,” he said.
The brief argues that the neither the government nor the lawyers on the Supreme Court bench “can determine whether an act does or does not violate a person’s religious beliefs.”
“Rather, the Supreme Court must accept the non-profits’ assertions that the notification requirement is indeed against their religion.”
To accept otherwise, the brief says, “is to supplant the church and the Bible with the government, allowing the Supreme Court and the government to interpret [tenets] of faith.
“This slippery slope would subject all religious exercise to the whim of the government’s approval.”
The brief points out that it’s already been decided that the fines for noncompliance are a substantial burden, leaving essentially the question of “whether compliance is actually against the petitioners’ religion.”
“This is something that is for petitioners to determine, not the court,” the Thomas More Law Center says.
“The court is not the arbiter of sacred Scripture and cannot determine whether the notification form and letter are attenuated enough from the provision of contraceptives that they do not substantially burden petitioners’ religion,” the brief says. “Delving into this inquiry requires the court to interpret petitioners’ religious beliefs on the morality of the different levels of complicity with sin.
“Therefore, the court can only determine whether petitioners are being compelled to do something that violates their faith – here, filling out the notification form or writing a notification letter to HHS, both of which trigger the dissemination of contraceptives and abortifacients to their employees in connection with their employee health plans.”
The brief point out that a woman’s right to get contraceptives is not unlimited.
“This does not mean they have a right to free contraceptives and abortifacients. Moreover, this right certainly does not mean that a person has the right to obtain contraceptives and abortifacients – either directly or indirectly – from their employer at the expense of pillaging the employer’s religious liberty,” the brief states.
The Little Sisters charge the government is forcing them to violate their faith by giving them a choice between providing contraceptives and abortion pills directly or ordering them to sign over their responsibility to someone else.
“These notification requirements trigger the non-profits’ insurers to provide free contraceptives and abortifacients to the women in the non-profits’ health plans. This notification requirement makes the non profits complicit in the provision of a service that they find sinful, thereby causing them to sin themselves,” the brief explains.
The law center argues there should not even be a case.
“The government already subsidizes contraceptives and abortifacients through its programs and could find ways to expand or increase the efficacy of those existing programs,” the brief says.
“The government could offer grants, go directly to insurers, or engage in countless other options that do not involve the cooperation of petitioners.”
Further, providing “free contraceptives and abortifacients” is not a compelling government interest, the law center argues, quoting the Supreme Court itself.
“The many exemptions already provided for under the regulations necessarily destroy any argument that the HHS mandate serves a compelling interest.”
It was the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that took on the authority of determining what is sin.
Another recent brief challenged: “Perhaps the apex among a host of acts of governmental arrogance in this case was displayed not by HHS, but when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit acted as if it had ecclesiastical powers of absolution, having decreed that by just signing a paper, Little Sisters would not be ‘morally complicit in providing contraceptive coverage.'”
The brief said one would expect that “on the issue of who the God of Heaven and Earth will hold ‘morally complicit,’ it would be the Little Sisters which would have the greater expertise than a federal judge.”
Read more at http://www.wnd.com/2016/01/government-seeks-authority-to-determine-what-is-sin/#sOQcrsLhO3H3vlX5.99
Legal team warns of ramifications of wrong decision at Supreme Court
In its Supreme Court battle over Obamacare’s abortion-pill mandate, the government wants to “determine what is in fact a sin,” contends a religious-rights legal group.
The high court has agreed to hear the case of the Denver-based Little Sisters of the Poor nuns, who refused to comply with the requirement that the insurance policies for their employees cover abortion pills.
The nuns have refused to sign over the responsibility to their insurance company, arguing it also would be a violation of their faith to facilitate someone else committing a sin.
Now a friend-of-the-court brief submitted by the Thomas More Law Center on behalf of dozens of clients charges the government is seeking to become the arbiter of religious beliefs.
The group’s chief counsel, Richard Thompson, called the mandate “a monumental attack on religious liberty.”
“If this appeal is lost, the government becomes the head of every religious denomination in the country by its assumed authority to determine what is in fact a sin,” he said.
The brief argues that the neither the government nor the lawyers on the Supreme Court bench “can determine whether an act does or does not violate a person’s religious beliefs.”
“Rather, the Supreme Court must accept the non-profits’ assertions that the notification requirement is indeed against their religion.”
To accept otherwise, the brief says, “is to supplant the church and the Bible with the government, allowing the Supreme Court and the government to interpret [tenets] of faith.
“This slippery slope would subject all religious exercise to the whim of the government’s approval.”
The brief points out that it’s already been decided that the fines for noncompliance are a substantial burden, leaving essentially the question of “whether compliance is actually against the petitioners’ religion.”
“This is something that is for petitioners to determine, not the court,” the Thomas More Law Center says.
“The court is not the arbiter of sacred Scripture and cannot determine whether the notification form and letter are attenuated enough from the provision of contraceptives that they do not substantially burden petitioners’ religion,” the brief says. “Delving into this inquiry requires the court to interpret petitioners’ religious beliefs on the morality of the different levels of complicity with sin.
“Therefore, the court can only determine whether petitioners are being compelled to do something that violates their faith – here, filling out the notification form or writing a notification letter to HHS, both of which trigger the dissemination of contraceptives and abortifacients to their employees in connection with their employee health plans.”
The brief point out that a woman’s right to get contraceptives is not unlimited.
“This does not mean they have a right to free contraceptives and abortifacients. Moreover, this right certainly does not mean that a person has the right to obtain contraceptives and abortifacients – either directly or indirectly – from their employer at the expense of pillaging the employer’s religious liberty,” the brief states.
The Little Sisters charge the government is forcing them to violate their faith by giving them a choice between providing contraceptives and abortion pills directly or ordering them to sign over their responsibility to someone else.
“These notification requirements trigger the non-profits’ insurers to provide free contraceptives and abortifacients to the women in the non-profits’ health plans. This notification requirement makes the non profits complicit in the provision of a service that they find sinful, thereby causing them to sin themselves,” the brief explains.
The law center argues there should not even be a case.
“The government already subsidizes contraceptives and abortifacients through its programs and could find ways to expand or increase the efficacy of those existing programs,” the brief says.
“The government could offer grants, go directly to insurers, or engage in countless other options that do not involve the cooperation of petitioners.”
Further, providing “free contraceptives and abortifacients” is not a compelling government interest, the law center argues, quoting the Supreme Court itself.
“The many exemptions already provided for under the regulations necessarily destroy any argument that the HHS mandate serves a compelling interest.”
It was the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that took on the authority of determining what is sin.
Another recent brief challenged: “Perhaps the apex among a host of acts of governmental arrogance in this case was displayed not by HHS, but when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit acted as if it had ecclesiastical powers of absolution, having decreed that by just signing a paper, Little Sisters would not be ‘morally complicit in providing contraceptive coverage.'”
The brief said one would expect that “on the issue of who the God of Heaven and Earth will hold ‘morally complicit,’ it would be the Little Sisters which would have the greater expertise than a federal judge.”
Read more at http://www.wnd.com/2016/01/government-seeks-authority-to-determine-what-is-sin/#sOQcrsLhO3H3vlX5.99
» Parliamentary Oil Committee reveals details of the Oil and Gas Law and the reason for not legislatin
» Oil and Gas Law.. The Unsolvable Knot
» Abdul Latif attacks Jordan and rejects the Basra-Aqaba pipeline project
» Revealing an agreement for 3 scenarios to decide the position of the Speaker of Parliament
» Parliamentarian reveals reasons for suspending the oil and gas law
» Integrity Commission calls for removing encroachment on 26 properties belonging to the General Compa
» Despite its economic importance, cotton cultivation is suffering in Iraq: Will it disappear?
» Government confirmation: "Ur Gate" contributed to reducing the phenomenon of corruption
» Allocating one trillion dinars for it.. Al-Sudani issues a directive regarding Diwaniya service proj
» Disclosure of the latest developments in the Baghdad Metro project
» Parliamentary Integrity points out observations on the work of some ministers: Pressures brought abo
» Central Bank of Iraq sales exceed one billion dollars in a week
» Parliamentary Oil Committee reveals details of the Oil and Gas Law and the reason for not legislatin
» Electronically.. Trade launches supply operations in Muthanna
» Record number of dollar sales by the Central Bank in a week
» Al-Sudani's advisor: Iraq is in the process of paying off long-term development loans to the World B
» Parliamentary Oil Committee calls for speeding up the legislation of the Oil and Gas Law
» MM&C 7/4/24 Tabaqchali: An Unfolding Structural Economic Transformation in Iraq
» utube 7/4/24 MM&C IQD Updates - Iraqi Dinar - Relations w / Baghdad & Kurdistan - Good - Financial
» Significant decline in oil derivatives exports to Jordan
» MP calls for expulsion of Turkish forces from Iraq
» Al-Salami reveals collecting parliamentary signatures to amend Article 57
» Unveiling a strategic line that supplies electricity to 6 cities in western Nineveh
» Al-Shammari arrives in Karbala to review the mechanism for implementing the Muharram plan
» MP sets timing for deciding on House of Representatives presidency
» Al-Zayer on the deterioration of electricity: failed companies and corrupt contractors
» Iraq ranks 61st globally and 7th in the Arab world among the safest countries in the world
» Will the exchange rate reach 1600 dinars?
» Iraq's lungs are suffering.. Gaseous pollutants increase the incidence of cancer in Basra
» Government plan to raise gasoline production to 35 million liters per day
» Parliamentary Committee announces the establishment of the first water management council.. What wil
» US messages to Iraqi leaders: Dollar cash flow may stop
» Al-Mandlawi: Iraq is keen to involve Polish companies in investment opportunities
» The Iraqi Private Sector and Improving the Investment Environment in the National Development Plan 2
» Dollar exchange rates in local markets.. Learn about them
» How much is Iraq's loan from the IMF?
» Barzani in Baghdad to end Erbil's problems with the center
» Basra pursues land contract fraud
» PM to Barzani: We have made significant progress in building trust
» Baghdad Council threatens to confiscate illegal generators
» Iraqi Creatives Museums and Cultural Centers
» Oil: Gas investment reached 62%
» Barzani in Baghdad
» Private universities and the labor market
» Experts expect the money supply to invest in stocks
» Stock market trading exceeds 281 billion shares
» Extensive government measures to curb the “madness” of housing unit prices
» World Bank: Iraq is among the middle-income countries
» Experts praise agricultural policies and call for supporting farmers
» In response to an appeal via "Baghdad Today", Al-Badran adopts adding a district to the project plan
» The Central Bank in Erbil debunks fears and speculations about the localization of salaries in the r
» Iraqi innovation turns plastic waste into electricity fuel
» Withdrawing advances "without the employees' knowledge".. Maysan Education threatens Rafidain Bank
» Iraq begins establishing first water management council
» Drought in Kurdistan reaches 'dangerous' stages, residents overuse groundwater
» Due to the "assessment exam", a minister fails the final exams at a private university
» Al-Samarrai appreciates the efforts of the Fiqh Council: Its moderate discourse completes the consti
» Al-Sudani expresses to Starmer his aspiration for the continuation of bilateral relations between Ir
» The Central Bank explains the mechanism for travelers to obtain dollars
» Will Iraq witness a new displacement?
» Holiday in the region on the occasion of the first of Muharram
» Al-Hakim warns of new targeting of Iraq and directs an invitation to the government regarding electr
» Sudanese to new British PM: Support international peace
» The President of the Republic congratulates the new Iranian President
» Find out the dollar exchange rate in local markets
» MP: Parliament did not perform its supervisory role over the executive authority
» Development Road.. Formation of a government committee for this file
» MM&C 7/4/24 Official: Iraq's accession to the World Trade Organization is imminent
» utube 7/2/24 MM&C IQD Update Part 2 - Iraqi Dinar - Automation for Revenues - Singapore Agreement
» utube 7/2/24 MM&C part 1 Iraqi DinarPart 1 - IQD Update - Progession of Intergr
» Slight increase in inflation rate for last May
» The President of the Republic stresses the importance of expanding the horizons of cooperation and a
» Border outlets announce the completion of the first phase of network connectivity by 100 percent
» Transparency: Sulaymaniyah and Halabja imports during the past week amounted to more than 17 billion
» MM&C 7/2/24 The dollar in the parallel market.. Al-Sudani’s advisor presents a different vision and
» Between Development and Silk... American-Chinese Conflict on the Iraqi Arena
» In the oil fields...gas flaring rates in Iraq are decreasing
» Iraq's North Oil Company production rises to about 400,000 barrels per day
» Al-Sudani: Iraq is witnessing the highest growth rate in the region
» In numbers.. Numbers of those covered by health insurance in its first and second phases
» Planning: Alternatives to slums will be found based on population census.
» Parliamentary Committee to Al-Eqtisad News: The Oil and Gas Law is Almost Complete, and This is What
» Central Bank: Delivery of dollars to travelers will be exclusively through company and bank outlets
» Electricity announces the operation of the (400 kv) line and the Al-Faw secondary station to relieve
» Government source announces the amount of debts collected for the benefit of the Trade Bank of Iraq
» To stop greed and exploitation.. the work of private generators on the parliament's table
» An "important" reason reduces citizens' interest in buying northern cars
» Water Resources: Water storage has tripled
» Daily.. North Oil Company's production increases to about 400 thousand barrels
» Parliamentary Electricity Committee prepares for "a series of hostings".. What is the reason for gen
» In response to an appeal via "Baghdad Today", Al-Badran adopts adding a district to the project plan
» Sweden takes action after three of its citizens sentenced to death in Iraq
» Iraq prepares to declare itself pollution-free
» Parliamentary Finance: The Staff Law will be passed in the next legislative session
» Iran looks with interest at President Barzani's visit to Baghdad, Turkey supports resolving Iraqi co
» Marwan Ahmed: 75,000 employees in Erbil will receive their salaries this month via (My Account)
» Parliamentary Services Reveals the “Optimal Solution” to Control Real Estate Prices
» President Barzani and Maliki discuss mechanisms for cooperation with the parties of the framework an