NH Supreme Court Affirms No Duty to Retreat When Acting in Self-Defense
January 23, 2024
It feels like it’s a rare occasion these days for any court with more than one judge to issue a unanimous decision, much less one that comes down on the side of our right to keep and bear arms, but that’s exactly what happened in New Hampshire on Monday as the state Supreme Court sided with a man who drew his gun to ward off an aggressor in a road rage incident, only to find himself charged (and convicted of a crime).
It was almost three years go when Joshua D. Shea’s was convicted on a single charge of criminal threatening with a deadly weapon, but the court has now thrown out that conviction after ruling that the judge overseeing the case erred by instructing the jury to consider whether Shea had the opportunity to retreat from the encounter. As the court pointed out in its ruling, lawmakers had removed any such duty to retreat from state statutes a decade earlier, and the judge had no basis to demand the jury consider the long-repealed law when weighing the evidence against Shea.
“After 2011, a person is justified in using deadly force when he reasonably believes that another person is about to use unlawful, deadly force against him, and he is not required to retreat if he is anywhere he has a right to be and was not the initial aggressor,” wrote Associate Justice Anna Barbara Hantz Marconi.
Shea claims he pulled his gun after another driver threatened to “beat his ass” following a close call on Route 28 in Epsom, according to the ruling’s recitation of the case. While the complainant claimed Shea pointed the gun at him, Shea testified he merely showed the gun to warn the other man off.
The incident started when the other man pulled his car in front of Shea’s truck as they drove on Route 28, forcing Shea to slam on his brakes and hit his horn. After the two men “exchanged middle fingers” they both pulled into a gas station parking lot off a traffic circle, according to the ruling.
In the gas station parking lot, according to Shea’s testimony at trial, the complainant began “aggressively swearing and saying he was going to . . . rip (Shea) out of [his] car.”
Shea further testified that the complainant said he would “beat (Shea’s) ass,” and asked the defendant to pull into the parking lot next door where there were no cameras.
At this point, Shea testified, the complainant began walking toward Shea’s truck and he was in serious fear for his safety. Shea testified he unclipped his pistol from its holster and warned the other driver he had a gun. Shea says he brought the gun up to his chest to show the man the gun, while the other man claimed Shea pointed the gun at him.
Despite the fact that no duty to retreat exists in New Hampshire law, Judge Andrew Schulman still informed the jury that one of the factors in the case was whether Shea “could have completely and safely left the area without any risk to himself or others.” In doing so, the judges ruled, Schulman went above and beyond what is allowed by law and contradicted what the state legislature has had to say about retreating in the face of danger; namely, that there is no requirement to do so if they were not the initial aggressor. Even when deadly force is not used, merely the display of a firearm to prevent the threat from escalating, the gun owner has no duty to retreat or present their back to the individual threatening to commit an act of violence against them.
I have to say, it’s nice to be able to cover a decision involving our right to self-defense that doesn’t include anti-gun judges trying to twist the law to suit their own purpose. Granted, four of the five justices on the court were appointed by Republican Gov. Chris Sununu, but even the lone justice named to the bench by Democrat John Lynch didn’t try to play any games with the decision. The five justices all made it clear that folks who aren’t the aggressor are not compelled to walk, run, or drive away instead of taking steps to lawfully protect themselves, and I’m glad that the court reiterated that fact in no uncertain terms. Hopefully Schulman’s jury instruction was just an aberration to begin with, but now there’s no excuse for any other Granite State judge to assert a duty to retreat that doesn’t exist in state law, and that’s a big win for those of us who believe in the human right of self-defense.
https://thepatrioticnews.com/2024/01/23/nh-supreme-court-affirms-no-duty-to-retreat-when-acting-in-self-defense/?utm_source=news.thepatrioticnews.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=73d1329c-3b8f-4b25-ba9d-dd6e28fd7a7e
January 23, 2024
It feels like it’s a rare occasion these days for any court with more than one judge to issue a unanimous decision, much less one that comes down on the side of our right to keep and bear arms, but that’s exactly what happened in New Hampshire on Monday as the state Supreme Court sided with a man who drew his gun to ward off an aggressor in a road rage incident, only to find himself charged (and convicted of a crime).
It was almost three years go when Joshua D. Shea’s was convicted on a single charge of criminal threatening with a deadly weapon, but the court has now thrown out that conviction after ruling that the judge overseeing the case erred by instructing the jury to consider whether Shea had the opportunity to retreat from the encounter. As the court pointed out in its ruling, lawmakers had removed any such duty to retreat from state statutes a decade earlier, and the judge had no basis to demand the jury consider the long-repealed law when weighing the evidence against Shea.
“After 2011, a person is justified in using deadly force when he reasonably believes that another person is about to use unlawful, deadly force against him, and he is not required to retreat if he is anywhere he has a right to be and was not the initial aggressor,” wrote Associate Justice Anna Barbara Hantz Marconi.
Shea claims he pulled his gun after another driver threatened to “beat his ass” following a close call on Route 28 in Epsom, according to the ruling’s recitation of the case. While the complainant claimed Shea pointed the gun at him, Shea testified he merely showed the gun to warn the other man off.
The incident started when the other man pulled his car in front of Shea’s truck as they drove on Route 28, forcing Shea to slam on his brakes and hit his horn. After the two men “exchanged middle fingers” they both pulled into a gas station parking lot off a traffic circle, according to the ruling.
In the gas station parking lot, according to Shea’s testimony at trial, the complainant began “aggressively swearing and saying he was going to . . . rip (Shea) out of [his] car.”
Shea further testified that the complainant said he would “beat (Shea’s) ass,” and asked the defendant to pull into the parking lot next door where there were no cameras.
At this point, Shea testified, the complainant began walking toward Shea’s truck and he was in serious fear for his safety. Shea testified he unclipped his pistol from its holster and warned the other driver he had a gun. Shea says he brought the gun up to his chest to show the man the gun, while the other man claimed Shea pointed the gun at him.
Despite the fact that no duty to retreat exists in New Hampshire law, Judge Andrew Schulman still informed the jury that one of the factors in the case was whether Shea “could have completely and safely left the area without any risk to himself or others.” In doing so, the judges ruled, Schulman went above and beyond what is allowed by law and contradicted what the state legislature has had to say about retreating in the face of danger; namely, that there is no requirement to do so if they were not the initial aggressor. Even when deadly force is not used, merely the display of a firearm to prevent the threat from escalating, the gun owner has no duty to retreat or present their back to the individual threatening to commit an act of violence against them.
I have to say, it’s nice to be able to cover a decision involving our right to self-defense that doesn’t include anti-gun judges trying to twist the law to suit their own purpose. Granted, four of the five justices on the court were appointed by Republican Gov. Chris Sununu, but even the lone justice named to the bench by Democrat John Lynch didn’t try to play any games with the decision. The five justices all made it clear that folks who aren’t the aggressor are not compelled to walk, run, or drive away instead of taking steps to lawfully protect themselves, and I’m glad that the court reiterated that fact in no uncertain terms. Hopefully Schulman’s jury instruction was just an aberration to begin with, but now there’s no excuse for any other Granite State judge to assert a duty to retreat that doesn’t exist in state law, and that’s a big win for those of us who believe in the human right of self-defense.
https://thepatrioticnews.com/2024/01/23/nh-supreme-court-affirms-no-duty-to-retreat-when-acting-in-self-defense/?utm_source=news.thepatrioticnews.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=73d1329c-3b8f-4b25-ba9d-dd6e28fd7a7e
Today at 6:55 am by Rocky
» “Money for survival”: Al-Saihoud: Al-Sudani prevented the economics of the parties, so they turned a
Today at 6:54 am by Rocky
» Iraqi banks are in crisis: structural imbalance, double taxation and deep corruption
Today at 6:51 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani's Advisor: Iraq is witnessing an economic transformation and a big leap with the spread of
Today at 6:47 am by Rocky
» Iraq buys nearly 52 tons of gold in three years
Today at 6:45 am by Rocky
» Arab Monetary Fund: Digital transformation is a key factor in reshaping the banking sector
Today at 6:44 am by Rocky
» Iraq's closest allies: Americans will remain in the Kurdistan Region and Baghdad will not change the
Today at 6:40 am by Rocky
» First cybersecurity platform reveals government interest in protecting data of individuals and insti
Today at 5:11 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani: The government was subjected to attempts to “distort and obstruct” its work
Today at 5:09 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani's advisor: The government's internal debt decreased by two trillion dinars
Today at 5:07 am by Rocky
» MP: Personal Status Law Amendments are More Fair than Current Law
Today at 5:05 am by Rocky
» Sudanese advisor: A joint announcement on the schedule for the withdrawal of US forces will be issue
Today at 5:04 am by Rocky
» Due to manipulation and forgery... 25 thousand transactions for those affected by terrorist operatio
Today at 5:03 am by Rocky
» Call for the Bar Association to cleanse its legal body of lawyers who abuse it
Today at 5:01 am by Rocky
» Major General Rasool: Iraq's borders are fully secured
Today at 5:00 am by Rocky
» Central Bank: Electronic payment systems have contributed to enhancing Iraq’s compliance with anti-m
Today at 4:58 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani's Advisor: Iraq is witnessing an economic transformation and a big leap with the spread of
Today at 4:57 am by Rocky
» Al-Alaq: 70 digital banks have applied to the Central Bank for a license
Today at 4:54 am by Rocky
» Al-Hanthal: We seek to reach a 60% financial inclusion rate by 2025
Today at 4:53 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani's advisor explains: What is the impact of applying e-governance on corruption in Iraq?
Today at 4:52 am by Rocky
» Baghdad to host tomorrow the conference "Electronic Payment towards Financial Stability in Iraq"
Today at 4:50 am by Rocky
» With high-level government and parliamentary attendance... Launch of the "Electronic Payment towards
Today at 4:48 am by Rocky
» List of gold and dollar prices in local markets in Iraq
Today at 4:45 am by Rocky
» After returning to Iran, Pezeshkian: We signed strategic plans with Iraq in travel and trade
Today at 4:43 am by Rocky
» The budget is exposed to 3 strong shocks.. A representative reveals the extent of its impact on liqu
Today at 4:42 am by Rocky
» Corruption is disrupting the “beating heart of democracy” in Iraq
Today at 4:40 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani calls on clerics to support the government in the responsibility of managing the general a
Today at 4:39 am by Rocky
» Washington Post: America plans to keep troops in Kurdistan to protect the region from "factions"
Today at 4:38 am by Rocky
» Economist reveals reasons for OPEC quotas' decreased effectiveness in controlling prices
Today at 4:36 am by Rocky
» Al-Rasheed: Selling dollars to travelers exclusively through our branches
Today at 4:34 am by Rocky
» What happened in Bezeshkian's meeting with the leaders of the Coordination Framework in Baghdad?
Today at 4:32 am by Rocky
» He confirmed the existence of extensive discussions to address the financial deficit.. Al-Sudani’s a
Today at 4:31 am by Rocky
» He confirmed the existence of extensive discussions to address the financial deficit.. Al-Sudani’s a
Today at 4:30 am by Rocky
» He confirmed the existence of extensive discussions to address the financial deficit.. Al-Sudani’s a
Today at 4:29 am by Rocky
» Will Pezeshkian's visit to Kurdistan pave the way for a new phase in Tehran-Erbil relations?
Today at 4:28 am by Rocky
» Parliamentarian reveals the extent of the budget’s impact on liquidity and state obligations: It is
Today at 4:27 am by Rocky
» Right to Information Law Stirs Controversy Again, Journalists Confront It
Today at 4:26 am by Rocky
» The House of Representatives decides to resume its sessions next Monday
Today at 4:23 am by Rocky
» OPEC Secretary General: Iraq has contributed to providing prominent and multiple contributions to th
Today at 4:22 am by Rocky
» Central Bank Governor Ali Al-Alaq: 70 digital banks have submitted a license application to the Cent
Today at 4:21 am by Rocky
» The Central Bank of Iraq announces the volume of Iraqi funds circulating in international digital ba
Today at 4:20 am by Rocky
» In Alsumaria Newsletter: The Parliament’s Stalled Laws, the Basra Fire, and the Bankruptcy of the Po
Today at 4:19 am by Rocky
» Oil rents and lack of economic diversification.. What is their relationship to the “13 million missi
Today at 4:16 am by Rocky
» CONFIRMS Debate Earrings Were Earpieces—Caught RED-HANDED!
Yesterday at 5:03 am by Rocky
» MM&C 9/12/24 Economic renaissance and unprecedented progress.. Iraq maximizes its non-oil revenues a
Yesterday at 5:00 am by Rocky
» Rafidain explains the benefits of electronic payment
Yesterday at 4:56 am by Rocky
» International Coalition.. Withdrawal by Government-Political Agreement
Yesterday at 4:52 am by Rocky
» Russia: $19 billion is the size of our investments in the energy sector in Iraq
Yesterday at 4:48 am by Rocky
» When will the government resort to amending the budget law? An economic expert explains
Yesterday at 4:46 am by Rocky
» After the decline in oil, a government advisor: We have the capabilities to confront the problems of
Yesterday at 4:45 am by Rocky
» Salaries are “sacred” but the price will be high… Is Iraq ready?
Yesterday at 4:42 am by Rocky
» The “Access to Information” Act classifies documents as secret and undermines access to them.
Yesterday at 4:41 am by Rocky
» Movement leader talks about US military movements inside Iraq
Yesterday at 4:33 am by Rocky
» Legal expert clarifies charges related to audio recordings of officials
Yesterday at 4:32 am by Rocky
» Coinciding with Pezeshkian's visit... indicators of Iranian exports to Iraq
Yesterday at 4:28 am by Rocky
» Al-Hakim calls on Parliament to vote on the Programmers Syndicate Law
Yesterday at 4:23 am by Rocky
» Nineveh Council: The province is free of tribal "debts" and 80% of disputes end without problems
Yesterday at 4:22 am by Rocky
» US Embassy in Baghdad Holds Iran-Backed Groups Responsible for Tuesday's Attack
Yesterday at 4:21 am by Rocky
» Central Bank denies forged letter regarding dollar sale
Yesterday at 4:19 am by Rocky
» After Al-Sudani’s statement... What is the importance of moving towards “privatizing” government com
Yesterday at 4:17 am by Rocky
» Confirmed the existence of 3 partnerships with Baghdad in energy.. Turkey: We have great potential f
Yesterday at 4:16 am by Rocky
» The Iraqi Integrity Commission and the Jordanian Anti-Corruption Commission discuss the mechanisms f
Yesterday at 4:14 am by Rocky
» A new front in the conflict with parliament.. organizations and journalists confront a law related t
Yesterday at 4:12 am by Rocky
» Political stalemate deepens crises.. Delaying the selection of the Speaker of the House of Represent
Yesterday at 4:11 am by Rocky
» Iraq receives 13 offers from Egyptian companies to implement road and bridge projects
Yesterday at 4:09 am by Rocky
» Shatt al-Arab pollution crisis: an existential threat to food sources and ecosystems
Yesterday at 4:08 am by Rocky
» With Pezeshkian's visit, Tehran aims to increase trade exchange to 50 billion with Baghdad
Yesterday at 4:07 am by Rocky
» Minister of Health approves the distribution of trainee doctors, graduates of 2020-2021
Yesterday at 4:05 am by Rocky
» Interrogation is almost suspended in the Iraqi parliament.. What are the reasons for the absence of
Yesterday at 4:04 am by Rocky
» Iraq 'concerned' about climate change threats to historical monuments
Yesterday at 4:03 am by Rocky
» International ruling against the Central Bank obliges Iraq to pay $11 million
Yesterday at 4:00 am by Rocky
» Alsumaria headlines: Central Bank fine and judicial investigations into integrity leaks
Yesterday at 3:58 am by Rocky
» Of a different kind.. A new espionage campaign in Iraq
Yesterday at 3:55 am by Rocky
» The second in two decades.. Iraq is "empty" of Americans again and Baghdad "will request their retur
Yesterday at 3:54 am by Rocky
» Details of a lengthy meeting in Iraq revealed, from which Pezeshkian left "frustrated"
Yesterday at 3:52 am by Rocky
» US dismay at Pezeshkian’s choice of Iraq as his “first stop”…and domestic political support for with
Yesterday at 3:51 am by Rocky
» Amendments to laws concerning state employees
Yesterday at 3:49 am by Rocky
» What does Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian's visit to Kurdistan mean?
Yesterday at 3:48 am by Rocky
» In numbers.. Indicators of the development of Iranian exports to Iraq
Yesterday at 3:46 am by Rocky
» Washington identifies group accused of bombing diplomatic facility near Baghdad airport
Yesterday at 3:45 am by Rocky
» utube 9/10/24 MM&C IQD Update-Iraq Dinar-#iraqidinar-#xrpIraq Reconciling-Unif
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 6:55 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary request to host Al-Sudani amid threats to the Federal Court
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 6:51 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani stresses the importance of partnership with the private sector to meet market needs
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 6:50 am by Rocky
» Iraq, Saudi Arabia discuss joint legal files
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 6:48 am by Rocky
» Al-Maliki: Combined efforts of political forces prevents the collapse of Iraq
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 6:47 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary bloc disputes: Vital laws await and divisions grow
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:17 am by Rocky
» Türkiye: Exporting Iraqi oil via Ceyhan is an alternative and an opportunity to diversify transporta
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:16 am by Rocky
» Economist rules out any move to amend salary scale
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:13 am by Rocky
» Al-Surji: 3 reasons behind the weakness of the Iraqi position towards the Turkish incursion
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:12 am by Rocky
» Minister of Planning: There are no political obstacles preventing the population census
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:11 am by Rocky
» Al-Sudani sponsors the signing of 3 contracts for industrial projects
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:09 am by Rocky
» 19 MoUs Signed on First Day of Belt and Road Summit
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:06 am by Rocky
» Issuance of more than 191 thousand national cards for those covered by social protection
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:04 am by Rocky
» Housing Fund: We will issue 16,000 transactions of bonds by this date
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:03 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Services calls for investing in open lands and turning them into parks: Citizens need
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:02 am by Rocky
» Iranian Minister of Roads: We will hold consultations with Iraq regarding strategic railway link
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:01 am by Rocky
» Pezeshkian discusses with Iranian traders obstacles to developing trade with Iraq
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 5:00 am by Rocky
» Banking Association Advisor: International Payments and Banking Technologies Conference a Platform t
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 4:59 am by Rocky
» Parliamentary Committee Rejects “Free” Oil Export via Aqaba Port
Thu 12 Sep 2024, 4:58 am by Rocky