Home
[size=36]American report: Saddam misled Washington and the invasion of Iraq was a disaster[/size]
Political | 03:48 - 06/05/2024
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Follow-up - Mawazine News
“Foreign Policy” magazine published an article, by writer David Polanski, in which he talked about the book “Achilles’ Trap” by writer Steve Cole, who considers that the invasion of Iraq in 2003 was a disaster, and that the war itself was as much a creation of the media as it was Government-made; Major media outlets, from The New York Times to The Atlantic to The New Yorker, helped legitimize the war.
In his article, which was translated by Mawazine News, the writer explained that there were many American failures in Iraq, including what was described as a “failure of understanding.” Whereas former Iraqi President Saddam Hussein could never understand the intentions of the United States.
He continued that despite his cunning; He remained fundamentally paranoid of the United States, whether during the years of tacit alliance during the 1980s or the subsequent period of hostility, which led him to deceive when candor would have served him better. This ultimately led to tragic results when the United States launched its invasion of Iraq in pursuit of weapons of mass destruction that did not exist at the time.
The writer added that Cole's main focus on the bilateral relationship between the United States and Iraq provides insight, but it also risks excluding the role of the global system as a whole, over which the United States enjoyed unparalleled dominance in the post-Cold War period, during the years leading up to the invasion of Iraq in 2017. 2003. So while it is true that Saddam Hussein misled the United States and misread its intentions, it is even more true that the United States, with its global capabilities and commitments, chose to bring much attention and concern to Iraq.
The writer pointed out that since the end of the Cold War; US policymakers proved unable to define national interests and set global priorities, with the result that there was no way to explain why one region or country deserved more attention than any other.
This strategic ambiguity at the highest levels regarding the relative importance of the Middle East and US goals there continued throughout the 1990s. By the time 9/11 occurred, track reliance alone had already raised Iraq's importance to the US government beyond any reasonable proportion. Vague hope has been replaced by false clarity regarding its goals.
The writer stated that none of this can be attributed to Saddam's dangerous adventures or to the diplomatic dynamic between the two countries. So, although it is true that each misread the basic intentions of the other, ultimately the problem of misunderstanding is neither sufficient nor necessary to explain what happened in the spring of 2003.
The author said that the “chain of errors” explanation better explains the 1991 Gulf War. , which neither party really wanted. Cole offers a vivid account of that history as well, which, among its strengths, rightly defends then-Ambassador April Glaspie from the unfair blame she endured in the wake of Saddam Hussein's invasion of Kuwait.
The writer stated that the United States failed to deter Iraq from invading Kuwait. But apart from the fact that almost no one, including other Arab leaders, expected this; Cole's telescopic view makes Iraq on the eve of Saddam Hussein's decision to invade appear much larger and more important from a global perspective than it actually was.
He noted that in August 1990, the Tiananmen Square massacre had been barely a year old, the Soviet Union had not yet disintegrated, and the process of German reunification was still underway. Even after the invasion of Kuwait, it was not self-evident for the (first) Bush administration to conclude that the operation deserved an American response of this magnitude.
By contrast, the drive for war during the eighteen-month period between the September 11 attacks and the beginning of Operation Iraqi Freedom was so great that it is difficult to imagine a plausible counterfactual in which war could be avoided.
In fact, Cole's reports make clear, in some ways despite his larger thesis, that there was no reasonable standard of evidence that would satisfy U.S. leaders regarding the veracity of Saddam Hussein's claims, and this was indeed true during the Clinton presidency.
The author continued, saying that although this was to some extent a story of misreading intentions and confirmation bias, it is fundamentally a story about the beliefs that American policymakers held about the world, all of which intensified dramatically in the wake of the September 11 attacks. Specifically; They believed that bad regimes and bad leaders represented the greatest source of international threats, that U.S. policy should focus on replacing both as needed, and that the benefits of doing so might exceed the costs.
By emphasizing procedural errors over more fundamental failures in strategy and geopolitical thinking, Cole initially dilutes the force of his criticism. It allows us to see how doubtful the analyzes of Saddam Hussein's capabilities and intentions were, but not to the degree that they seemed very convincing to both US decision-makers and the majority of the broader public at the time.
The writer added that Cole usefully answered the questions of “how” and “what” happened regarding the invasion of Iraq, while the question of “why” remains unanswered. Cole rightly highlights the role of both neoconservative democracy promoters (Paul Wolfowitz) and aggressive militarists ( Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, and others) were ultimately involved in the decision to invade, but even here his account ignores how popular the decision actually was, at least initially,
and many people inside and outside of government found themselves supporting the invasion despite little knowledge of the technical requirements of the program Effective weapons of mass destruction or Saddam Hussein's distortions of it.
Addressing the "why" question will require a more comprehensive examination of the flaws in how the policymaking establishment sees, and in many ways may still see, the world and America's place in it It's another thing to acknowledge how crazy it was, and how few geostrategic barriers there were to constrain those impulses.
“Foreign Policy” magazine published an article, by writer David Polanski, in which he talked about the book “Achilles’ Trap” by writer Steve Cole, who considers that the invasion of Iraq in 2003 was a disaster, and that the war itself was as much a creation of the media as it was Government-made; Major media outlets, from The New York Times to The Atlantic to The New Yorker, helped legitimize the war.
In his article, which was translated by Mawazine News, the writer explained that there were many American failures in Iraq, including what was described as a “failure of understanding.” Whereas former Iraqi President Saddam Hussein could never understand the intentions of the United States.
He continued that despite his cunning; He remained fundamentally paranoid of the United States, whether during the years of tacit alliance during the 1980s or the subsequent period of hostility, which led him to deceive when candor would have served him better. This ultimately led to tragic results when the United States launched its invasion of Iraq in pursuit of weapons of mass destruction that did not exist at the time.
The writer added that Cole's main focus on the bilateral relationship between the United States and Iraq provides insight, but it also risks excluding the role of the global system as a whole, over which the United States enjoyed unparalleled dominance in the post-Cold War period, during the years leading up to the invasion of Iraq in 2017. 2003. So while it is true that Saddam Hussein misled the United States and misread its intentions, it is even more true that the United States, with its global capabilities and commitments, chose to bring much attention and concern to Iraq.
The writer pointed out that since the end of the Cold War; US policymakers proved unable to define national interests and set global priorities, with the result that there was no way to explain why one region or country deserved more attention than any other.
This strategic ambiguity at the highest levels regarding the relative importance of the Middle East and US goals there continued throughout the 1990s. By the time 9/11 occurred, track reliance alone had already raised Iraq's importance to the US government beyond any reasonable proportion. Vague hope has been replaced by false clarity regarding its goals.
The writer stated that none of this can be attributed to Saddam's dangerous adventures or to the diplomatic dynamic between the two countries. So, although it is true that each misread the basic intentions of the other, ultimately the problem of misunderstanding is neither sufficient nor necessary to explain what happened in the spring of 2003.
The author said that the “chain of errors” explanation better explains the 1991 Gulf War. , which neither party really wanted. Cole offers a vivid account of that history as well, which, among its strengths, rightly defends then-Ambassador April Glaspie from the unfair blame she endured in the wake of Saddam Hussein's invasion of Kuwait.
The writer stated that the United States failed to deter Iraq from invading Kuwait. But apart from the fact that almost no one, including other Arab leaders, expected this; Cole's telescopic view makes Iraq on the eve of Saddam Hussein's decision to invade appear much larger and more important from a global perspective than it actually was.
He noted that in August 1990, the Tiananmen Square massacre had been barely a year old, the Soviet Union had not yet disintegrated, and the process of German reunification was still underway. Even after the invasion of Kuwait, it was not self-evident for the (first) Bush administration to conclude that the operation deserved an American response of this magnitude.
By contrast, the drive for war during the eighteen-month period between the September 11 attacks and the beginning of Operation Iraqi Freedom was so great that it is difficult to imagine a plausible counterfactual in which war could be avoided.
In fact, Cole's reports make clear, in some ways despite his larger thesis, that there was no reasonable standard of evidence that would satisfy U.S. leaders regarding the veracity of Saddam Hussein's claims, and this was indeed true during the Clinton presidency.
The author continued, saying that although this was to some extent a story of misreading intentions and confirmation bias, it is fundamentally a story about the beliefs that American policymakers held about the world, all of which intensified dramatically in the wake of the September 11 attacks. Specifically; They believed that bad regimes and bad leaders represented the greatest source of international threats, that U.S. policy should focus on replacing both as needed, and that the benefits of doing so might exceed the costs.
By emphasizing procedural errors over more fundamental failures in strategy and geopolitical thinking, Cole initially dilutes the force of his criticism. It allows us to see how doubtful the analyzes of Saddam Hussein's capabilities and intentions were, but not to the degree that they seemed very convincing to both US decision-makers and the majority of the broader public at the time.
The writer added that Cole usefully answered the questions of “how” and “what” happened regarding the invasion of Iraq, while the question of “why” remains unanswered. Cole rightly highlights the role of both neoconservative democracy promoters (Paul Wolfowitz) and aggressive militarists ( Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, and others) were ultimately involved in the decision to invade, but even here his account ignores how popular the decision actually was, at least initially,
and many people inside and outside of government found themselves supporting the invasion despite little knowledge of the technical requirements of the program Effective weapons of mass destruction or Saddam Hussein's distortions of it.
Addressing the "why" question will require a more comprehensive examination of the flaws in how the policymaking establishment sees, and in many ways may still see, the world and America's place in it It's another thing to acknowledge how crazy it was, and how few geostrategic barriers there were to constrain those impulses.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
» utube 6/18/24 MM&C Iraq Dinar - IQD Update - Liberation of Economy - 6.5 Billion Dinars ($4.9 Bill
» Financial Control: We are about to build a new strategy
» Nearby building a new strategy for financial oversight in Iraq
» Will the grant for displaced people be affected in the 2024 budget?
» Al-Sudani announces 3 projects to develop the sports sector in Iraq
» Romanowski's successor in Baghdad.. Are you redistributing roles and what is Israel's influence in t
» Minister of Labor: The government pays great attention to caring for the elderly
» Registering one million Iraqis in (health insurance)
» The CAS International Court praises the Iraqi judiciary for establishing the Center for Sports Settl
» The Prime Minister's Advisor reveals two projects related to the local government in Kirkuk
» Minister of Immigration: The Prime Minister is keen to deliver the $4 million grant to families retu
» Revealing two paths to resolve the political impasse in Kirkuk
» Millions of security services have not resolved the worrying issue... the escalation of murders and
» International Finance: Economic reform in Iraq is witnessing an increasing pace and we have invested
» Water Resources issues guidance on water pumping stations
» Parliamentary Defense: The scheduling of security laws will take place after the legislative recess
» Kurdistan Federation: Legislating the oil and gas law will resolve the disputes between Baghdad and
» Kurdistan Federation: Legislating the oil and gas law will resolve the disputes between Baghdad and
» A parliamentary invitation to manage the Ministry of Electricity by the Sudanese
» Deputy: America failed strategically in the face of the steadfastness of the resistance forces
» A representative reveals a movement to change a paragraph in the election law that prohibits the exp
» An invitation is sent to the Sudanese... Parliamentary Energy explains the reasons for the collapse
» Iraq announces that 1,000 new schools will soon enter service by this date
» Ecuador "stands in solidarity with Iraq" and is plunged into darkness following the collapse of the
» Parliamentary Investment determines Baghdad’s need for housing units.. Will prices fall?
» Economic determination of “bubble” real estate prices in Baghdad.. What about selling a square meter
» Accounting project...quick procedures and expectations regarding the completion date - urgent
» The Minister of Labor announces the inclusion of the elderly in the ministry’s services and seeks a
» "Despite the hot weather"... the economy revives in Baghdad during the Eid
» The huge numbers of Kurdistan tourists occupy specialists... How can they be converted into huge sum
» Erbil counts the number of visitors, accidents, births, and sacrifices during Eid
» A reality that cannot be hidden behind... Everything about the secrets of electricity and its “chron
» Including the rotation of positions.. A Sudanese advisor reveals two projects to form a Kirkuk gover
» Jacobson, “Professor” Romanowski... a clear expression of a “new American strategy” in Iraq - urgent
» An employee buys a house in Baghdad only to be surprised by a field of cannon shells in his garden
» The “Iraqi Resistance” holds an extraordinary meeting regarding the presence of American forces
» Parliamentary Defense: The scheduling of security laws will take place after the legislative recess
» Resistance Coordination: We are able and determined to end the issue of the presence of American for
» An employee at the Agricultural Bank in Maysan was arrested and seized 131 million dinars
» Continuing commissions even if the card is not used.. Baghdad Council calls for “monitoring Sweeg”
» The electricity problem cannot be solved by exemptions and dismissals, Mr. President!!
» The House of Representatives renews its support for the Hajj Authority to complete its bright roles
» utube 6/18/24 Iraqi Dinar ???? It’s Very Good Today News Guru Intel Update Value Exchange Rate IQ
» Member of Parliamentary Defense: The necessity of completing the Popular Mobilization Law
» Progress confirms that the Speaker of Parliament passes through Al-Halbousi... and Sunni forces: He
» The Pentagon: The presence of the Peshmerga within the Iraqi forces contributed to reducing the abil
» Al-Sudani discusses with a Saudi minister holding the “sixth session” of the Coordination Council be
» Hundreds of agricultural acres in Badra are transformed into residential homes
» The Minister of Health inspects the rehabilitation stages in Al-Imam Al-Kazemin (peace be upon him)
» Stability in dollar exchange rates in Baghdad, Basra and Erbil
» Sunni divisions and ambitions are stumbling blocks in front of the parliamentary seat. A politician
» Parliamentary Energy: Gas investment represents one of the most important current projects for gener
» Iraq will not reap any economic benefit from extending the Basra-Oqaba oil pipeline
» Al-Fatah calls on the government to limit the role of the new American ambassador to Iraq
» The new American ambassador...provocative statements and hidden intentions
» The European Union Court bargains with Iraqi women to agree to asylum
» With a value of $79 million... Iraq is the eighth largest importer of Egyptian agricultural crops
» Due to the “major failure”... parliamentary intentions to question the Minister of Electricity
» After the "failure of the summer test"... the Minister of Electricity is promised an "interrogation"
» Rationing is suffocating Iraq: The electricity crisis is renewed as the temperature rises
» The electricity situation “turns around”: unlike last year.. the region is “happy” and the center an
» The most prominent of which is “assassination activity”... A reading of the “fiery” statements of th
» Accumulated since 2011.. Basra sends an invitation to Baghdad regarding 45 trillion dinars it owes
» Hidden hands do not want reconstruction and construction there.. “Corruption fever” drains 1,500 bil
» Sudanese Advisor: Parties within the framework do not support early elections, and the Commission ne
» Behind the scenes of an exciting session of merchants and restaurant owners who “invested” in the ex
» Al-Sudani stresses to Saudi Arabia the importance of reconsidering Iraq’s share of Hajj seats
» Al-Sudani: Iraq is on the right path
» Iraq is ranked second in the Arab world among countries producing hydroelectric energy
» Iraq and France are discussing signing a security memorandum of understanding and ways to enhance mi
» The Sudanese advisor reassures: Iraq is safe from any financial risks
» Representatives: Al-Sudani’s visit to Washington resulted in advanced arms deals
» Political disagreements continue over the position of Speaker of the House of Representatives
» Dollars are still flowing from Iraq to buy Turkish real estate
» Washington and its strategic vision for the Middle East
» Egyptian market turmoil pushes its companies towards Iraq
» Corrupt politicians win votes and occupy positions... What about democracy?
» The US Ambassador on the State Department’s decision: Confronting Iran’s influence
» Sharp political polarization in Iraq after Al-Maliki called for early elections
» Counselor Mazhar Saleh: The international community praised Iraq's financial and banking system
» Political bloc: An important meeting soon to decide the presidency of the House of Representatives
» 20 tons were seized and more than 9,000 medicine boxes of unknown origin were seized in Baghdad
» Ten Iraqi cities are on the list of regions with the highest temperatures in the world (table)
» Oil clarifies the details of the memorandum of understanding signed with the American Honeywell
» Sovereign Guarantees Committee: The plate glass factory in Najaf will provide 500 job opportunities
» A Sudanese advisor explains: Is Iraq safe from any international financial risks?
» Iraq is the first Arab country in developing oil pipelines
» Despite the problems, Iraqis live the Eid atmosphere according to their traditions
» Due to desertification, Iraq loses 15% of its agricultural land
» Domestic tourism... huge amounts of money for the region and a joy for market owners
» The "American veto" on supplying Iraq with two types of weapons fades
» Parliamentary comment on the failure to recover fugitive major corruption figures
» A researcher comments on introducing education into Iraqi prisons: a step towards “love of life”
» Parliamentary Legal: Representatives enjoy vacation and there is no emergency session
» The countdown to the closure of the camps has begun.. What are the reasons for the reluctance of dis
» Integrity closes the doors to wasting public money and corruption mafias, the biggest challenges of
» The Electricity Spokesman identifies the entities not included in the decision to cancel the excepti
» Rafidain Bank launches loans for purchasing housing units (document)