Home
How A Little Metadata Made It Possible To Find FBI Director James Comey's Secret Twitter Account
Published: March 31, 2017
For a few years now, our intelligence overseers have been insisting that we shouldn't be too concerned about surveillance programs that collect "just metadata" because that doesn't really reveal too much. But, of course, we've shown how "just metadata" can ruin a career diplomat's life, and former NSA/CIA boss Michael Hayden has admitted that the US kills people based on metadata.
Either way, I find it fascinating that reporter Ashley Feinberg needed just a few small bits of innocent metadata from FBI Director James Comey to track down his secret Twitter account. It took her all of four hours or so. Just last night, Comey admitted that he was on Twitter, leading lots of people to go searching for the account since there is no official one. I won't describe all of how Feinberg tracked it down (it involves some pretty excellent sleuthing and is worth reading) but suffice it to say, it's metadata that gives Comey away. The account, @projectexile7, was then almost certainly confirmed as Comey's based on metadata about who was following it, who it was following, and what it liked:
Go read the full article by Feinberg. Of course, I doubt it will change Comey's views on "just metadata", but it is yet another representation of how powerful a little bit of such data can be in tracking someone down.
http://www.blacklistednews.com/How_A_Little_Metadata_Made_It_Possible_To_Find_FBI_Director_James_Comey%27s_Secret_Twitter_Account/57639/0/38/38/Y/M.html
Published: March 31, 2017
Source: Tech Dirt
For a few years now, our intelligence overseers have been insisting that we shouldn't be too concerned about surveillance programs that collect "just metadata" because that doesn't really reveal too much. But, of course, we've shown how "just metadata" can ruin a career diplomat's life, and former NSA/CIA boss Michael Hayden has admitted that the US kills people based on metadata.
Either way, I find it fascinating that reporter Ashley Feinberg needed just a few small bits of innocent metadata from FBI Director James Comey to track down his secret Twitter account. It took her all of four hours or so. Just last night, Comey admitted that he was on Twitter, leading lots of people to go searching for the account since there is no official one. I won't describe all of how Feinberg tracked it down (it involves some pretty excellent sleuthing and is worth reading) but suffice it to say, it's metadata that gives Comey away. The account, @projectexile7, was then almost certainly confirmed as Comey's based on metadata about who was following it, who it was following, and what it liked:
And, yes, I do find it hilarious that Ben Wittes — among the loudest cheerleaders for programs that scoop up metadata — is part of the reason the account was recognized as Comey's.But how to be sure? There is only one person currently following the account: Benjamin Wittes of Lawfare. Wittes is no Twitter neophyte. He is an active user with more than 25,000 followers, and he only follows 1,178 accounts—meaning he is not a subscriber to the “followback” philosophy. If he is following a random egg—and is the only account following it—there is probably a reason.
That reason could be the fact that, as Wittes wrote here, he is a personal friend of James Comey. (We’ve reached out to Wittes for comment but have yet to hear back.)
Project Exile happens to be a federal program that James Comey helped develop when he was a U.S. attorney living in Richmond. And then, of course, there are the follows.
ProjectExile7 follows 27 other accounts, the majority of which are either reporters, news outlets, or official government and law enforcement accounts. The New York Times' Adam Goldman and David Sanger and the Washington Post's Ellen Nakashima and David Ignatius, all of whom have been aggressively covering the FBI investigation into Trump’s contacts with Russian agents, made the list, as did Wittes and former Bush Administration colleague Jack Goldsmith. Donald Trump is on there, too, but @projectexile7 seems to have begun following him relatively recently (its first follow was @nytimes).
There are two outliers: William & Mary News (where Comey attended undergrad) and our colleagues at The Onion (everyone deserves to have fun)
Go read the full article by Feinberg. Of course, I doubt it will change Comey's views on "just metadata", but it is yet another representation of how powerful a little bit of such data can be in tracking someone down.
http://www.blacklistednews.com/How_A_Little_Metadata_Made_It_Possible_To_Find_FBI_Director_James_Comey%27s_Secret_Twitter_Account/57639/0/38/38/Y/M.html
» Militia Man & Crew Fitch Affirms Iraq at 'B-'; Outlook Stable
» utube 12/09/23 Iraqi Dinar:Exciting News Iraqi Dinar RV Of IQD Done Desperately Today Good News C
» utube 12/08/23 Militia Man & Crew Iraq Dinar International - Gateway - Local Currency - Sustainab
» Regional mediation between Baghdad and Erbil to resolve the “financial crisis”
» Al-Sudani directs that officers and members of the holding units be referred for investigation and t
» More than a billion dollars in sales from the Iraqi Central Bank within a week
» Adviser to the Prime Minister: Initiating procedures for establishing the Carbon Economic Company
» Romanowski comments on "the positions of the main Iraqi forces" following the bombing of the America
» Between production and export.. How much does Iraq lose as a result of its voluntary reduction in oi
» Iraq rejects attempts to target "fossil fuels" at the climate conference
» Al-Halbousi directs to hold a meeting for his supporters in Jordan
» Parliamentary efforts to increase the salaries of members of the Popular Mobilization Forces
» Anbar tribes warn of an American plan to disrupt the security situation ahead of the local elections
» Parliamentary Defense reveals the most important contents of the report on the American aggression a
» Deputy: Residential investment complexes will not solve the crisis due to their high prices
» A parliamentarian reveals “secret meetings” regarding choosing Al-Halbousi’s replacement and sets a
» Iraq is ranked 81st in the world in terms of per capita carbon emissions
» Local administration: The investigation committee is investigating the reason for the high casualty
» A reading of the regulatory procedures for Iraq’s foreign trade
» Iraq's oil exports to America decreased last week
» A center indicating that the Iraqi citizen is exposed to “major depletion” due to the dollar and gas
» Foreign Minister: Iraq is a safe environment for investment and open to Spanish companies
» Prime Minister: We have more work to do to recover our people’s money and pursue the corrupt
» Integrity: Iraq has taken serious steps in the field of combating corruption
» “We reserve the decisive response.” Washington informs Sudanese of its decision regarding the attack
» Judge Zidane: Confronting drugs requires a comprehensive national strategy
» “International mediation” between Baghdad and Erbil... a meeting of ambassadors to resolve the “fina
» Exporting Iraqi products to Kuwait
» In continuation of supporting the category of returnees... the Ministry of Immigration distributes (
» The Iraqi Stock Exchange index rose by 7.1% last November
» A scandal that shakes Iraq...the loss of 35 trillion dinars in print
» The Prime Minister's advisor points out the economic strengths of the partnership between Iraq and S
» Pentagon: Hezbollah and Harakat al-Nujaba are behind the attacks against our forces
» Iran is pressing to activate the Iraq-Syria transit line
» Al-Abadi on the bombing of the American embassy: Security and stability are not a commodity in the m
» The coordination framework declares its support for the government’s measures and its keenness to pr
» US Secretary of Defense to Sudanese: We reserve the right to respond
» Sudanese Advisor: The government is determined to take measures to protect the security and interest
» Al-Sudani warns against direct response to targeting the American embassy without government approva
» The Foreign Minister to his Spanish counterpart: Iraq today represents a safe environment for invest
» Head of the Supreme Judicial Council: Combating drugs requires a comprehensive national strategy
» Al-Sudani calls on the Presidency of the Republic to ratify all death sentences for those convicted
» Integrity and the US State Department discuss extending cooperation between the two countries in the
» Iraq plans to invest in the population increase and turn it into effective development engines
» The Sudanese government plans to establish 44 new pharmaceutical factories in Iraq
» Iraq and France are discussing enhancing economic cooperation and developing trade exchange
» Election Commission: Voting time will start from seven in the morning until six in the evening
» Iraq and the United States of America discuss bilateral cooperation relations in the security fields
» Al-Sudani chairs a security meeting to discuss targeting the American embassy
» A list of the exchange rates of the dollar against the Iraqi dinar today.. recorded an increase
» Al-Sudani receives a call from the US Secretary of Defense.. This is what it said
» Al-Sudani calls on the Presidency of the Republic to approve the execution of those convicted of dru
» utube 12/08/23 Iraqi Dinar Today 2023 / Iraqi Dinar News Today / Iraqi Dinar
» The Prime Minister blesses the activation of the partnership between the Iraqi and Saudi private sec
» Planning: 11 axes to invest in the population increase and transform it into effective development e
» Advisor Mazhar Saleh: The economic geography of Iraq and Saudi Arabia constitutes an important found
» Al-Maliki: The best way to remove the corrupt is to go to the election ballots
» Al-Sudani: Parliament members have the final say in choosing the president
» The Kurdistan Region warns of a mass migration of Iraqis to other countries in the future
» "Embassy missiles" fall on the National Security headquarters, and the agency threatens the "bombers
» There are more obstacles than solutions.. The housing sector in Iraq: The need for more than 5 milli
» China reduces entry visa fees for Iraqis wishing to enter its territory (table)
» Al-Abadi on the bombing of the American embassy: Security and stability are not a commodity in the m
» Political conflicts and tension between Al-Halbousi and the governor.. What is happening in Anbar?
» Fatah leader: America created Al-Hawl camp to threaten the security of 7 Arab countries
» The Minister of Immigration instructs to solve the problems of returning families in Diyala
» Why was Iraq's "voluntary" reduction the largest in OPEC+?
» Regional Government: January 10th, official working hours in all Kurdistan districts
» Coinciding with International Anti-Corruption Day...the Ministry of Immigration holds a ceremony in
» The Federal Court rules that the instructions for conducting daily business in the Al-Kadhimi govern
» Head of the Kurdistan Council of Ministers: Our talks with the federal government will continue, and
» Three types of water violations were identified... Water Resources announces the introduction of gro
» Australian readiness to consolidate relations with the Kurdistan Region in the fields of investment
» There are more obstacles than solutions.. The housing sector in Iraq: The need for more than 5 milli
» The US Embassy in Baghdad urges the Iraqi government to protect diplomatic personnel
» Sudanese directs the prosecution of the perpetrators of the attack by launching projectiles towards
» Provincial council candidates are competing for two hundred and seventy-five seats
» With a new decision.. How will Iraq lose 6% of its oil exports?
» Georgetown Center for Studies: The killing of Americans in Iraq and the regional war is “a matter of
» Iraq.. Online food delivery will generate $845 million in 2023
» The US embassy in Baghdad confirms that it was hit by two missiles
» Directives from Sudanese regarding the bombing of the American embassy in Baghdad
» “No vacation until the end of the year.” The Minister of Finance issues a directive to the employees
» utube 12/5/23 Militia Man & Crew Iraq Dinar - Reality - Internationalism - Investors - Revaluatio
» The Ministry of Commerce decides to open sales outlets for those covered by social care in installme
» Minister of Oil: Iraq's decision to reduce OPEC Plus to achieve balance and stability in the markets
» Despite sending money from Baghdad.. Politician: The regional government refuses to release employee
» Baghdad is a cash cow...and the regional government steals the camel with what it carries
» Anbar Environment monitors violations of land conversion in Ramadi
» Federation of Arab Stock Exchanges: The Iraqi Stock Exchange accounted for 61% of November trading
» The Minister of Labor reveals a campaign to grant loans and plans to expand the employment process f
» Southern Gas: The agreement with the French company Total includes 4 main projects
» Sudanese directs to suspend working hours on Sunday
» Revealing the latest developments in choosing the new President of Parliament
» Media and Communications signs a contract with Azerbaijan to protect civil aviation radio navigation
» Al-Party accuses “sectarian” parties of delaying sending the $700 billion to the region
» The Kurdistan Oil Industry Association announces the joining of an American company
» A fine of 3 times the price.. Iraq reveals how to deal with goods that “violate specifications”