Home
How A Little Metadata Made It Possible To Find FBI Director James Comey's Secret Twitter Account
Published: March 31, 2017
For a few years now, our intelligence overseers have been insisting that we shouldn't be too concerned about surveillance programs that collect "just metadata" because that doesn't really reveal too much. But, of course, we've shown how "just metadata" can ruin a career diplomat's life, and former NSA/CIA boss Michael Hayden has admitted that the US kills people based on metadata.
Either way, I find it fascinating that reporter Ashley Feinberg needed just a few small bits of innocent metadata from FBI Director James Comey to track down his secret Twitter account. It took her all of four hours or so. Just last night, Comey admitted that he was on Twitter, leading lots of people to go searching for the account since there is no official one. I won't describe all of how Feinberg tracked it down (it involves some pretty excellent sleuthing and is worth reading) but suffice it to say, it's metadata that gives Comey away. The account, @projectexile7, was then almost certainly confirmed as Comey's based on metadata about who was following it, who it was following, and what it liked:
Go read the full article by Feinberg. Of course, I doubt it will change Comey's views on "just metadata", but it is yet another representation of how powerful a little bit of such data can be in tracking someone down.
http://www.blacklistednews.com/How_A_Little_Metadata_Made_It_Possible_To_Find_FBI_Director_James_Comey%27s_Secret_Twitter_Account/57639/0/38/38/Y/M.html
Published: March 31, 2017
Source: Tech Dirt
For a few years now, our intelligence overseers have been insisting that we shouldn't be too concerned about surveillance programs that collect "just metadata" because that doesn't really reveal too much. But, of course, we've shown how "just metadata" can ruin a career diplomat's life, and former NSA/CIA boss Michael Hayden has admitted that the US kills people based on metadata.
Either way, I find it fascinating that reporter Ashley Feinberg needed just a few small bits of innocent metadata from FBI Director James Comey to track down his secret Twitter account. It took her all of four hours or so. Just last night, Comey admitted that he was on Twitter, leading lots of people to go searching for the account since there is no official one. I won't describe all of how Feinberg tracked it down (it involves some pretty excellent sleuthing and is worth reading) but suffice it to say, it's metadata that gives Comey away. The account, @projectexile7, was then almost certainly confirmed as Comey's based on metadata about who was following it, who it was following, and what it liked:
And, yes, I do find it hilarious that Ben Wittes — among the loudest cheerleaders for programs that scoop up metadata — is part of the reason the account was recognized as Comey's.But how to be sure? There is only one person currently following the account: Benjamin Wittes of Lawfare. Wittes is no Twitter neophyte. He is an active user with more than 25,000 followers, and he only follows 1,178 accounts—meaning he is not a subscriber to the “followback” philosophy. If he is following a random egg—and is the only account following it—there is probably a reason.
That reason could be the fact that, as Wittes wrote here, he is a personal friend of James Comey. (We’ve reached out to Wittes for comment but have yet to hear back.)
Project Exile happens to be a federal program that James Comey helped develop when he was a U.S. attorney living in Richmond. And then, of course, there are the follows.
ProjectExile7 follows 27 other accounts, the majority of which are either reporters, news outlets, or official government and law enforcement accounts. The New York Times' Adam Goldman and David Sanger and the Washington Post's Ellen Nakashima and David Ignatius, all of whom have been aggressively covering the FBI investigation into Trump’s contacts with Russian agents, made the list, as did Wittes and former Bush Administration colleague Jack Goldsmith. Donald Trump is on there, too, but @projectexile7 seems to have begun following him relatively recently (its first follow was @nytimes).
There are two outliers: William & Mary News (where Comey attended undergrad) and our colleagues at The Onion (everyone deserves to have fun)
Go read the full article by Feinberg. Of course, I doubt it will change Comey's views on "just metadata", but it is yet another representation of how powerful a little bit of such data can be in tracking someone down.
http://www.blacklistednews.com/How_A_Little_Metadata_Made_It_Possible_To_Find_FBI_Director_James_Comey%27s_Secret_Twitter_Account/57639/0/38/38/Y/M.html
» Postponing the parliament session to vote on the budget to this date
» 90% of it went abroad.. The Central Bank of Iraq sells more than 205 million dollars during today's
» The Ministry of Environment announces the launch of sustainable solutions to confront the climate cr
» Militia Man & Crew patron-only new video: "Two Sides of the Story"
» Parliamentary Finance details the revenues of Kurdistan's oil exports within 365 days.. How was the
» An economist explains a mechanism to shorten registration on new cities
» Al-Sudani: The budget amendments are political, not technical, and this is about voting on them
» Almost Final Confirmation From The Framework About The Budget Pass Session.. Will We Witness A Vote?
» Parliament’s Finances Reveal The Fate Of Kurdistan’s Budget Amendments.. “The Agreement Has Been Ach
» Legal expert: Passing the budget without taking into account the decisions of the Federal Court will
» Al-Zajrawi: Transferring 6 trillion dinars to support the investment budget of the governorates and
» Barzani's advisor: The regional government is not a caretaker
» Move to reconsider granting investment licenses.. What is the fate of malls and residential complexe
» Dollar prices fell against the dinar in Baghdad and Erbil
» Central Iraqi sales decreased by 11% in today's auction
» "Manipulation and speculation".. Economists attribute the dollar's rise in the parallel market to "n
» Dollar exchange rates in the local markets
» Al-Abadi's coalition reveals the secrets of the agreement between the coordination framework and Bar
» US Ambassador Romanowski urges the Kurdistan Regional Administration to hold urgent elections
» Sunnis and Kurds announce their positions on the budget voting session
» Al-Alaq confirms that the Central Bank of Iraq is serious about supporting the small and medium ente
» Emir of Qatar in Baghdad soon
» Securities expect a decline in the price of the dollar after the approval of the budget
» Iraq and Switzerland are looking to build partnerships in the financial and economic sectors
» The Central Bank hints at the possibility of canceling some fines on banks
» Preventing the leveling of agricultural lands to widen the streets
» Iraq lays the first building block in building an advanced digital health system
» Parliamentary Energy: The next two years will witness the end of the electricity crisis
» Up to 150 million dinars.. Al-Rafidain launches construction loans for employees
» Chambers of Commerce identify three reasons behind the rise in the exchange rate of the dollar in th
» A statement from the Dawa Party regarding al-Maliki's connection to accounts that "offend the audito
» The framework ends a "long meeting" and heralds the approval of the most important project budget in
» Alekti resolves his position to attend the session to pass the budget
» Washington is hinting at an Iraqi role in the Pacific and Atlantic
» A parliamentary source reveals to (Baghdad Today) the reasons for postponing the budget session unti
» Al-Barti on today's session: Things are positive, and we are afraid of surprises in the last moments
» The Central Bank sells more than 200 million dollars with the decline of the Iraqi dinar in the mark
» Saudi Arabia expects to operate the electrical interconnection project with Iraq by the end of 2025
» In the document.. The Retirement Authority announces the completion of a study on the issue of incre
» New military operations for US forces in Iraq
» The Foreign Minister arrives in Riyadh to participate in the meeting of the international coalition
» Foreign Ministry: Iraq works to improve services, infrastructure, economy and fight corruption
» The House of Representatives postpones its session to eight o'clock this evening
» Briar Rashid: The House of Representatives has no choice but to vote on the draft budget law
» The tripartite budget project blown parliamentary disputes
» Postponement of the budget vote session
» Iraqi-Saudi meetings are "expected" to exchange security and intelligence information
» An Iraqi parliamentary delegation participates in the meetings of the Arab Parliament
» Dollar exchange rates in the Iraqi market today
» The Kurdistan Democratic Party decides its position on attending the budget session
» Frank26 is Going Live!!! Tuesday Night 6-6-2023
» Al-Rasheed Bank begins raising a new batch of electronic advances
» A slight increase in the exchange rates of the dollar in the local markets
» Close about 20 smuggling corridors between Iraq and Iran
» The budget spreads its papers on the table of secret settlements..and the representatives are protes
» The Council of Ministers holds its regular session headed by Al-Kazemi
» Statement from Commerce regarding the 'electronic automation form stamp'
» Democratic deputy: We will overcome the differences in tomorrow's session
» The end of a lengthy meeting of the framework and the announcement of an agreement to pass the budg
» Hannoun: The Central Bank will support the initiative to support small and medium enterprises
» USAID: We are committed to cooperating with our Iraqi partners to bring about positive change.. Thes
» The Central Bank denies depriving banks and companies from participating in the external transfer pl
» Details of a meeting between the Minister of Finance and a number of deputies
» Democrat lawmaker reveals 'drastic changes' on eve of budget session
» Emir of Qatar in Baghdad.. Economic and investment issues will be present
» Warnings of running out of Iraqi cash reserves due to indicators of the international economy
» A manipulation that almost made a profit of 1.2 billion dinars.. The abundant wheat season "tempts"
» Members of Parliamentary Finance: The political forces hijacked the budget
» The Electoral Commission clarifies the mechanism of work of the monitoring teams and the conditions
» Oil Allocates 40,000 residential plots of land in Basra for workers in the oil sector
» Minister of Oil: Allocating (40) thousand residential plots of land in Basra for workers in the oil
» The Minister of Oil reveals to Alsumaria the possibility of compensating Iraq for Iranian gas
» Iraq and Hungary are discussing the strategic development path project
» The Central Bank of Iraq denies the allegations of stopping some electronic payment cards
» A parliamentarian detonates a surprise about the budget, hours before it is approved
» Here, There and Everywhere
» In the presence of Al-Sudani, the framework agrees to pass the budget tomorrow
» The Central Bank of Iraq gives approval to open a government bank in Kurdistan within the unified ba
» Counterfeit currencies penetrate Iraq's borders and cause an increase in the value of the dollar
» Finance is discussing with the Swedish ambassador to build partnerships in the financial, economic a
» Independent deputies announce attendance at tomorrow's session: it may pass without the Democrat
» The Central Bank: directed to build a national lending strategy that will come into effect in early
» Planning begins with the implementation of the social and economic survey of the family in Iraq
» The Iraqi Trade Bank warns against trading in (the Belarusian ruble) and (the Venezuelan bolivar)
» Parliamentary Finance: Efforts to transfer the region's oil to be used locally and to preserve the a
» Politician: Exporting oil through SOMO will reveal the parties with which the region deals
» Budget 2023.. Al-Sudanese is betting on the majority to support the service government
» Disclosure of a prior and comprehensive political agreement to pass the budget tomorrow
» Economic: Legislation of the oil and gas law has become binding on the government and parliament
» Iraqi-Japanese talks to complete the signing of agreements related to the oil industries
» Housing crisis.. Al-Sudani: We will provide serviced plots of land and will not suffice with complex
» Al-Sudani: The development road includes the largest industrial city in the Middle East
» The World Bank lowers its forecasts for the economies of the Middle East in 2023
» It witnessed an increase during Al-Kazemi’s rule.. The World Bank: Iraq’s GDP growth declined by 1.1
» Report: Saudi Aramco is seeking large oil opportunities in Iraq
» The Aviation Authority announces the activation of 8 air transport agreements
» The use of POS devices, start-up and future prospects
» Sales of the Central Bank of Iraq exceed 230 million dollars in today's auction