Home
How A Little Metadata Made It Possible To Find FBI Director James Comey's Secret Twitter Account
Published: March 31, 2017
For a few years now, our intelligence overseers have been insisting that we shouldn't be too concerned about surveillance programs that collect "just metadata" because that doesn't really reveal too much. But, of course, we've shown how "just metadata" can ruin a career diplomat's life, and former NSA/CIA boss Michael Hayden has admitted that the US kills people based on metadata.
Either way, I find it fascinating that reporter Ashley Feinberg needed just a few small bits of innocent metadata from FBI Director James Comey to track down his secret Twitter account. It took her all of four hours or so. Just last night, Comey admitted that he was on Twitter, leading lots of people to go searching for the account since there is no official one. I won't describe all of how Feinberg tracked it down (it involves some pretty excellent sleuthing and is worth reading) but suffice it to say, it's metadata that gives Comey away. The account, @projectexile7, was then almost certainly confirmed as Comey's based on metadata about who was following it, who it was following, and what it liked:
Go read the full article by Feinberg. Of course, I doubt it will change Comey's views on "just metadata", but it is yet another representation of how powerful a little bit of such data can be in tracking someone down.
http://www.blacklistednews.com/How_A_Little_Metadata_Made_It_Possible_To_Find_FBI_Director_James_Comey%27s_Secret_Twitter_Account/57639/0/38/38/Y/M.html
Published: March 31, 2017
Source: Tech Dirt
For a few years now, our intelligence overseers have been insisting that we shouldn't be too concerned about surveillance programs that collect "just metadata" because that doesn't really reveal too much. But, of course, we've shown how "just metadata" can ruin a career diplomat's life, and former NSA/CIA boss Michael Hayden has admitted that the US kills people based on metadata.
Either way, I find it fascinating that reporter Ashley Feinberg needed just a few small bits of innocent metadata from FBI Director James Comey to track down his secret Twitter account. It took her all of four hours or so. Just last night, Comey admitted that he was on Twitter, leading lots of people to go searching for the account since there is no official one. I won't describe all of how Feinberg tracked it down (it involves some pretty excellent sleuthing and is worth reading) but suffice it to say, it's metadata that gives Comey away. The account, @projectexile7, was then almost certainly confirmed as Comey's based on metadata about who was following it, who it was following, and what it liked:
And, yes, I do find it hilarious that Ben Wittes — among the loudest cheerleaders for programs that scoop up metadata — is part of the reason the account was recognized as Comey's.But how to be sure? There is only one person currently following the account: Benjamin Wittes of Lawfare. Wittes is no Twitter neophyte. He is an active user with more than 25,000 followers, and he only follows 1,178 accounts—meaning he is not a subscriber to the “followback” philosophy. If he is following a random egg—and is the only account following it—there is probably a reason.
That reason could be the fact that, as Wittes wrote here, he is a personal friend of James Comey. (We’ve reached out to Wittes for comment but have yet to hear back.)
Project Exile happens to be a federal program that James Comey helped develop when he was a U.S. attorney living in Richmond. And then, of course, there are the follows.
ProjectExile7 follows 27 other accounts, the majority of which are either reporters, news outlets, or official government and law enforcement accounts. The New York Times' Adam Goldman and David Sanger and the Washington Post's Ellen Nakashima and David Ignatius, all of whom have been aggressively covering the FBI investigation into Trump’s contacts with Russian agents, made the list, as did Wittes and former Bush Administration colleague Jack Goldsmith. Donald Trump is on there, too, but @projectexile7 seems to have begun following him relatively recently (its first follow was @nytimes).
There are two outliers: William & Mary News (where Comey attended undergrad) and our colleagues at The Onion (everyone deserves to have fun)
Go read the full article by Feinberg. Of course, I doubt it will change Comey's views on "just metadata", but it is yet another representation of how powerful a little bit of such data can be in tracking someone down.
http://www.blacklistednews.com/How_A_Little_Metadata_Made_It_Possible_To_Find_FBI_Director_James_Comey%27s_Secret_Twitter_Account/57639/0/38/38/Y/M.html
» Ports Authority notes the fate of the five berths in the Grand Faw Port
» MP: Why is the regional government fighting the civil banks war and leaving the core of the issue?
» Political researcher: The amendment will include sovereign ministries
» Retirement: End of service bonus paid to more than 7,000 retirees
» Al-Mashhadani stresses the importance of the role of the Audit Bureau in combating administrative an
» Al-Mashhadani and Al-Hakim discuss parliament’s approval of important laws
» Parliamentary consensus to pass controversial laws soon
» Currency Auction.. Increase in the Central Bank of Iraq’s sales of foreign remittances
» Interior Ministry dismantles 600 drug networks, electronic passport to be introduced soon - Press co
» utube 11/2/24 MM&C Report-Iraq 3 Presidents-National-Constitutional Entitlements-Open Market Operati
» utube 11/5/24 MM&C MM&C News Report-ICC-Investors-RIYADA BANK-Port of Faw-3 Presidents Seated-Removi
» Foreign Minister warns of major and dangerous economic repercussions
» Roadmap for Reform
» Government reshuffle looms over Al-Sudani’s cabinet.. The compass of change is heading towards 4 min
» Parliamentary move to legalize foreign labor in Basra
» Parliament intends to amend the retirement law and return the service age to 63 years
» Parliamentary move to question a senior official and complete procedures against the Minister of Com
» Legal expert explains the mechanism for forming the Kurdistan Regional Government
» Silk Road imposes a state of maximum alert suddenly
» Sheikh Raouf: There is an urgent need to find a constructive, corrective opposition in Kurdistan
» Green light from Baghdad to build the first waste recycling plant in eastern Iraq
» MP: Al-Mashhadani discussed 3 important files with parliamentary blocs
» MP: Al-Mashhadani's election will not affect the completion of legislation
» Parliamentary Oil: Investment in associated gas in fields exceeds 60%
» IMF: Foreign investment outperforms sovereign funds in generating growth in Gulf
» Categories exempted from the curfew in the population census.. Get to know them
» Kurdish investment trend in central and southern Iraq.. What are the reasons?
» Iraq exports more than 6 million barrels of oil to America in a month
» The Private Banks Association supports the Prime Minister’s directives to localize private sector em
» Parliamentary confirmation to support financial oversight in combating corruption
» Next Sunday.. Celebrating Baghdad Day
» Sayyid Sistani's commandments
» New services for health insurance subscribers
» Al-Sudani directs ministries to leave (cash)
» Mr. Sistani sets a roadmap for Iraq’s prosperity
» OPEC+ postpones production increase
» Government Advisor to {Sabah}: Turkish companies’ expertise has given them importance in implementin
» The future of smart cities in Iraq is on the table for discussion
» Expectations of achieving agricultural self-sufficiency within 3-5 years
» Ministry of Agriculture: Launches the Electronic Inquiry System Service
» Electricity contract employees demonstrate in Maysan to demand permanent employment
» The Council of Ministers holds its regular session headed by Al-Sudani
» Iraqi oil exports to America amounted to more than 6 million barrels during the past month
» Launching the major national campaign to raise awareness of the Social Security Law
» Private Banks Association: We support the Prime Minister’s directives to localize private sector emp
» Parliamentary Committee: The Social Security Fund has become sovereign and the legislation of the la
» Britain launches programme inside Iraq to combat 'Kurdish human trafficking gangs' in France
» Warnings of delay in forming the regional government: will push regional and international parties t
» Dollar prices rise again in Baghdad Stock Exchange and Exchanges
» Al-Sudani praises the assistance provided by the United Nations mission to Iraq in facing challenges
» The Private Banks Association announces its support for Al-Sudani’s approach to localizing private s
» Interior: We have achieved a very significant decrease in crime rates across the country
» The Private Banks Association announces its support for Al-Sudani’s approach to localizing private s
» Iraq, Saudi Arabia sign MoU for military cooperation, boost bilateral ties
» Transportation: Direct flights to 4 global cities
» Prime Minister stresses importance of Mr. Sistani's diagnosis of Iraq's needs
» “To enhance national security”.. Parliamentary Committee: Intelligence Service Law is ready to be pr
» Optimism for a bountiful agricultural season.. Kurdistan Region records record high rainfall amounts
» Al-Sistani’s “Seven Commandments” occupy Iraqi politics.. A reading of the position of the authority
» As the date approaches, will Article 140 hinder the population census?
» Prime Minister directs unification of efforts in the Iraqi Media Network
» “Framework” coups with Sunni facades on the map of local governments in preparation for the 2025 ele
» Parliament intends to extend the legislative session for a month
» Difficult tests facing Parliament.. What are the scenarios for the remainder of the current session?
» Parliamentary Security: Iran will launch a new strike against “Israel” within a short period.. What
» Barzani to Romanowski: We have started negotiations to form the tenth government and no veto on any
» Al-Sudani directs the localization of private sector salaries and sets a date for the departure of c
» Bakhtiar Haji meets a delegation from the General Directorate of Civil Defense in the Kurdistan Regi
» New Cities Authority sets timeframes for project completion, reveals details of its services
» Oil announces completion of drilling and rehabilitating 15 wells during the past month
» Ministerial Council for Economy: Taking the necessary measures and decisions that contribute to mark
» Parliamentary Legal: There is a trend to extend the legislative term of Parliament
» What is the truth about extending the legislative term of the House of Representatives?
» The "Freedom of Demonstration" Law is Ready for Voting.. How Was It Amended?
» Mr. Al-Sadr on the US elections: It is shameful for an Arab to pin his hopes on a senile or insane p
» Laws stuck hostage to disputes between blocs
» Doubts after the decline in power supply at the beginning of each month.. Is there a deal between ge
» Integrity and the Financial Supervision Bureau agree to activate the cooperation agreement between t
» Al-Mashhadani faces 170 suspended laws.. Will they be approved or deported?
» Parliamentary demands to cancel the security agreement with Washington
» MP: Oil derivatives smuggling has decreased by 80% in Iraq
» After years of controversy, the Minority Protection Act is submitted for the first reading
» Al-Sayhoud: The ministerial reshuffle is useless for several reasons
» Iraqi government makes changes to the General Secretariat: Al-Juhaishi succeeds Al-Halbousi
» Extension of the legislative term of the Iraqi parliament for an additional month to pass laws
» Prime Minister: The necessity of strengthening Iraq's position to be at the forefront of the region'
» Parliamentary Transportation: We are determined to pass the Civil Aviation Authority Law
» Baghdad Council: Study of the reality of companies applying to implement projects
» Water Resources announces its control over the oil slick in the Tigris River
» Reconstruction: A new government vision for distributing serviced lands among those entitled to them
» Parliamentary Immigration Committee demands increasing the amount of the return grant
» Accreditation of specialized graduates to support quality control
» Heritage markets and buildings in Mosul after its reconstruction
» Specialized committee to ensure acceptance of cybersecurity outputs
» The Ministry of Interior issues mechanisms to regulate the work of private security companies
» Baghdad Council: Study of the reality of companies applying to implement projects
» Welcome to the trends of establishing an administrative capital
» Securities trade more than 88 billion shares