Home
FACT CHECK: Overreaching in State of Union speech
By CALVIN WOODWARD | Associated Press – 5 hrs ago
WASHINGTON (AP) — President Barack Obama did some cherry-picking Tuesday night in defense of his record on jobs and laid out a conditional path to citizenship for illegal immigrants that may be less onerous than he made it sound.
A look at some of the claims in his State of the Union speech, a glance at the Republican counterargument and how they fit with the facts:
OBAMA: "After years of grueling recession, our businesses have created over 6 million new jobs."
THE FACTS: That's in the ballpark, as far as it goes. But Obama starts his count not when he took office, but from the point in his first term when job losses were the highest. In doing so, he ignores the 5 million or so jobs that were lost on his watch, up to that point.
Private sector jobs have grown by 6.1 million since February 2010. But since he became president, the gain is a more modest 1.9 million.
And when losses in public sector employment are added to the mix, his overall jobs record is a gain of 1.2 million.
___
OBAMA: "We have doubled the distance our cars will go on a gallon of gas."
THE FACTS: Not so fast.
That's expected to happen in 12 more years.
Under a deal the Obama administration reached with automakers in 2011, vehicles will have a corporate average fuel economy of 54.5 miles per gallon by 2025, twice the 27 miles per gallon, on average, that cars and trucks get today. Automobile manufacturers won't start making changes to achieve the new fuel economy standards until model year 2017. Not all cars will double their gas mileage, since the standard is based on an average of a manufacturers' fleet.
___
OBAMA: "Already the Affordable Care Act is helping to reduce the growth of health care costs."
THE FACTS: The jury is still out on whether Obama's health care overhaul will reduce the growth of health care costs. It's true that cost increases have eased, but many experts say that's due to the sluggish economy, not to the health care law, whose main provisions are not yet fully in effect.
___
OBAMA: "Real reform means establishing a responsible pathway to earned citizenship — a path that includes passing a background check, paying taxes and a meaningful penalty, learning English and going to the back of the line behind the folks trying to come here legally."
THE FACTS: The seemingly stern admonition that illegal immigrants must go to the back of the line, often heard from the president, doesn't appear to have much practical effect except in the most obvious sense. Everyone who joins a line, whether for a movie, a coffee or citizenship, starts at the back of that particular line. It's not clear he is saying anything more than that illegal immigrants won't get to cut in line for citizenship once they've obtained provisional legal status.
Like those living abroad who have applied to come to the U.S. legally, illegal immigrants who qualify for Obama's proposed path to citizenship will surely face long waits to be processed. But during that time, they are already in the U.S. and will get to stay, work and travel in the country under their new status as provisional immigrants, while those outside the U.S. simply have to wait.
Sending illegal immigrants to the "back of the line" is something of a distinction without a difference for some legal immigrants who dutifully followed all the rules before coming to the United States.
For instance, some legal immigrants who are in the U.S. on an employer-sponsored visa can't easily change jobs, or in some cases take a promotion, without jeopardizing their place in line to get a green card. In other cases, would-be legal immigrants in other countries wait for years to be able to settle in the U.S.
Obama is using "back of the line" somewhat figuratively, because there are multiple lines depending on the applicant's relationship with family already in the U.S. or with an employer. Generally, a foreign-born spouse of a U.S. citizen or someone with needed skills and a job offer will be accepted more quickly than many others.
But even as a figurative point, his assertion may cloak the fact that people who came to the U.S. illegally and win provisional status have the great advantage over applicants abroad of already being where they all want to go.
___
OBAMA: "Study after study shows that the sooner a child begins learning, the better he or she does down the road. ... And for poor kids who need help the most, this lack of access to preschool education can shadow them for the rest of their lives. ... Every dollar we invest in high-quality early education can save more than $7 later on — by boosting graduation rates, reducing teen pregnancy, even reducing violent crime."
THE FACTS: Dozens of studies have shown Head Start graduates are more likely to complete high school than their at-risk peers who don't participate in the program. But a study last year by the Department of Health and Human Services that found big vocabulary and social development gains for at-risk students in pre-kindergarten programs also found those effects largely faded by the time pupils reached third grade. The report didn't explain why the kids saw a drop-off in performance or predict how they would fare as they aged.
___
OBAMA: "I urge this Congress to pursue a bipartisan, market-based solution to climate change, like the one John McCain and Joe Lieberman worked on together a few years ago. But if Congress won't act soon to protect future generations, I will. I will direct my Cabinet to come up with executive actions we can take, now and in the future, to reduce pollution, prepare our communities for the consequences of climate change and speed the transition to more sustainable sources of energy."
THE FACTS: Obama failed to get a global warming bill through Congress when both Houses were controlled by Democrats in 2010. With Republicans in control of the House, the chances of a bill to limit the gases blamed for global warming and to create a market for businesses to trade pollution credits are close to zero. The Obama administration has already acted to control greenhouse gases through existing law. It has boosted fuel-efficiency standards and proposed rules to control heat-trapping emissions from new power plants. And while there are still other ways to address climate change without Congress, it's questionable regulation alone can achieve the reductions needed to start curbing global warming.
___
FLORIDA SEN. MARCO RUBIO, in the Republican response: "The real cause of our debt is that our government has been spending $1 trillion more than it takes in every year. That's why we need a balanced-budget amendment."
THE FACTS: That statement may reflect the math behind recent debt, but it doesn't get directly to the cause — the worst recession since the Depression and its aftereffects. The deficit is not only caused by spending, but by reduced tax revenues. And during the recession, revenues from both individual and corporate taxes fell markedly.
The steep increases in debt and the measures that should be taken to ease the burden are central to the debate in Washington. But there is no serious move afoot to amend the Constitution to prohibit deficit spending.
The ability to take on debt has been used by governments worldwide and through U.S. history to shelter people from the ravages of a down economy, wage war and achieve many other ends. An effort to amend the Constitution for any purpose faces daunting odds; this would be no exception. Most state constitutions demand a balanced budget, but states lack some big obligations of the federal government, including national defense. And Washington's ability to go deeper into debt provides states with at least a minimal safety net in times of high unemployment.
___
Associated Press writers Tom Raum, Dina Cappiello, Andrew Taylor, Christopher S. Rugaber, Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar, Alicia A. Caldwell and Philip Elliott contributed to this report.
http://news.yahoo.com/fact-check-overreaching-state-union-speech-032654575--politics.html
By CALVIN WOODWARD | Associated Press – 5 hrs ago
WASHINGTON (AP) — President Barack Obama did some cherry-picking Tuesday night in defense of his record on jobs and laid out a conditional path to citizenship for illegal immigrants that may be less onerous than he made it sound.
A look at some of the claims in his State of the Union speech, a glance at the Republican counterargument and how they fit with the facts:
OBAMA: "After years of grueling recession, our businesses have created over 6 million new jobs."
THE FACTS: That's in the ballpark, as far as it goes. But Obama starts his count not when he took office, but from the point in his first term when job losses were the highest. In doing so, he ignores the 5 million or so jobs that were lost on his watch, up to that point.
Private sector jobs have grown by 6.1 million since February 2010. But since he became president, the gain is a more modest 1.9 million.
And when losses in public sector employment are added to the mix, his overall jobs record is a gain of 1.2 million.
___
OBAMA: "We have doubled the distance our cars will go on a gallon of gas."
THE FACTS: Not so fast.
That's expected to happen in 12 more years.
Under a deal the Obama administration reached with automakers in 2011, vehicles will have a corporate average fuel economy of 54.5 miles per gallon by 2025, twice the 27 miles per gallon, on average, that cars and trucks get today. Automobile manufacturers won't start making changes to achieve the new fuel economy standards until model year 2017. Not all cars will double their gas mileage, since the standard is based on an average of a manufacturers' fleet.
___
OBAMA: "Already the Affordable Care Act is helping to reduce the growth of health care costs."
THE FACTS: The jury is still out on whether Obama's health care overhaul will reduce the growth of health care costs. It's true that cost increases have eased, but many experts say that's due to the sluggish economy, not to the health care law, whose main provisions are not yet fully in effect.
___
OBAMA: "Real reform means establishing a responsible pathway to earned citizenship — a path that includes passing a background check, paying taxes and a meaningful penalty, learning English and going to the back of the line behind the folks trying to come here legally."
THE FACTS: The seemingly stern admonition that illegal immigrants must go to the back of the line, often heard from the president, doesn't appear to have much practical effect except in the most obvious sense. Everyone who joins a line, whether for a movie, a coffee or citizenship, starts at the back of that particular line. It's not clear he is saying anything more than that illegal immigrants won't get to cut in line for citizenship once they've obtained provisional legal status.
Like those living abroad who have applied to come to the U.S. legally, illegal immigrants who qualify for Obama's proposed path to citizenship will surely face long waits to be processed. But during that time, they are already in the U.S. and will get to stay, work and travel in the country under their new status as provisional immigrants, while those outside the U.S. simply have to wait.
Sending illegal immigrants to the "back of the line" is something of a distinction without a difference for some legal immigrants who dutifully followed all the rules before coming to the United States.
For instance, some legal immigrants who are in the U.S. on an employer-sponsored visa can't easily change jobs, or in some cases take a promotion, without jeopardizing their place in line to get a green card. In other cases, would-be legal immigrants in other countries wait for years to be able to settle in the U.S.
Obama is using "back of the line" somewhat figuratively, because there are multiple lines depending on the applicant's relationship with family already in the U.S. or with an employer. Generally, a foreign-born spouse of a U.S. citizen or someone with needed skills and a job offer will be accepted more quickly than many others.
But even as a figurative point, his assertion may cloak the fact that people who came to the U.S. illegally and win provisional status have the great advantage over applicants abroad of already being where they all want to go.
___
OBAMA: "Study after study shows that the sooner a child begins learning, the better he or she does down the road. ... And for poor kids who need help the most, this lack of access to preschool education can shadow them for the rest of their lives. ... Every dollar we invest in high-quality early education can save more than $7 later on — by boosting graduation rates, reducing teen pregnancy, even reducing violent crime."
THE FACTS: Dozens of studies have shown Head Start graduates are more likely to complete high school than their at-risk peers who don't participate in the program. But a study last year by the Department of Health and Human Services that found big vocabulary and social development gains for at-risk students in pre-kindergarten programs also found those effects largely faded by the time pupils reached third grade. The report didn't explain why the kids saw a drop-off in performance or predict how they would fare as they aged.
___
OBAMA: "I urge this Congress to pursue a bipartisan, market-based solution to climate change, like the one John McCain and Joe Lieberman worked on together a few years ago. But if Congress won't act soon to protect future generations, I will. I will direct my Cabinet to come up with executive actions we can take, now and in the future, to reduce pollution, prepare our communities for the consequences of climate change and speed the transition to more sustainable sources of energy."
THE FACTS: Obama failed to get a global warming bill through Congress when both Houses were controlled by Democrats in 2010. With Republicans in control of the House, the chances of a bill to limit the gases blamed for global warming and to create a market for businesses to trade pollution credits are close to zero. The Obama administration has already acted to control greenhouse gases through existing law. It has boosted fuel-efficiency standards and proposed rules to control heat-trapping emissions from new power plants. And while there are still other ways to address climate change without Congress, it's questionable regulation alone can achieve the reductions needed to start curbing global warming.
___
FLORIDA SEN. MARCO RUBIO, in the Republican response: "The real cause of our debt is that our government has been spending $1 trillion more than it takes in every year. That's why we need a balanced-budget amendment."
THE FACTS: That statement may reflect the math behind recent debt, but it doesn't get directly to the cause — the worst recession since the Depression and its aftereffects. The deficit is not only caused by spending, but by reduced tax revenues. And during the recession, revenues from both individual and corporate taxes fell markedly.
The steep increases in debt and the measures that should be taken to ease the burden are central to the debate in Washington. But there is no serious move afoot to amend the Constitution to prohibit deficit spending.
The ability to take on debt has been used by governments worldwide and through U.S. history to shelter people from the ravages of a down economy, wage war and achieve many other ends. An effort to amend the Constitution for any purpose faces daunting odds; this would be no exception. Most state constitutions demand a balanced budget, but states lack some big obligations of the federal government, including national defense. And Washington's ability to go deeper into debt provides states with at least a minimal safety net in times of high unemployment.
___
Associated Press writers Tom Raum, Dina Cappiello, Andrew Taylor, Christopher S. Rugaber, Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar, Alicia A. Caldwell and Philip Elliott contributed to this report.
http://news.yahoo.com/fact-check-overreaching-state-union-speech-032654575--politics.html
» Ports Authority notes the fate of the five berths in the Grand Faw Port
» MP: Why is the regional government fighting the civil banks war and leaving the core of the issue?
» Political researcher: The amendment will include sovereign ministries
» Retirement: End of service bonus paid to more than 7,000 retirees
» Al-Mashhadani stresses the importance of the role of the Audit Bureau in combating administrative an
» Al-Mashhadani and Al-Hakim discuss parliament’s approval of important laws
» Parliamentary consensus to pass controversial laws soon
» Currency Auction.. Increase in the Central Bank of Iraq’s sales of foreign remittances
» Interior Ministry dismantles 600 drug networks, electronic passport to be introduced soon - Press co
» utube 11/2/24 MM&C Report-Iraq 3 Presidents-National-Constitutional Entitlements-Open Market Operati
» utube 11/5/24 MM&C MM&C News Report-ICC-Investors-RIYADA BANK-Port of Faw-3 Presidents Seated-Removi
» Foreign Minister warns of major and dangerous economic repercussions
» Roadmap for Reform
» Government reshuffle looms over Al-Sudani’s cabinet.. The compass of change is heading towards 4 min
» Parliamentary move to legalize foreign labor in Basra
» Parliament intends to amend the retirement law and return the service age to 63 years
» Parliamentary move to question a senior official and complete procedures against the Minister of Com
» Legal expert explains the mechanism for forming the Kurdistan Regional Government
» Silk Road imposes a state of maximum alert suddenly
» Sheikh Raouf: There is an urgent need to find a constructive, corrective opposition in Kurdistan
» Green light from Baghdad to build the first waste recycling plant in eastern Iraq
» MP: Al-Mashhadani discussed 3 important files with parliamentary blocs
» MP: Al-Mashhadani's election will not affect the completion of legislation
» Parliamentary Oil: Investment in associated gas in fields exceeds 60%
» IMF: Foreign investment outperforms sovereign funds in generating growth in Gulf
» Categories exempted from the curfew in the population census.. Get to know them
» Kurdish investment trend in central and southern Iraq.. What are the reasons?
» Iraq exports more than 6 million barrels of oil to America in a month
» The Private Banks Association supports the Prime Minister’s directives to localize private sector em
» Parliamentary confirmation to support financial oversight in combating corruption
» Next Sunday.. Celebrating Baghdad Day
» Sayyid Sistani's commandments
» New services for health insurance subscribers
» Al-Sudani directs ministries to leave (cash)
» Mr. Sistani sets a roadmap for Iraq’s prosperity
» OPEC+ postpones production increase
» Government Advisor to {Sabah}: Turkish companies’ expertise has given them importance in implementin
» The future of smart cities in Iraq is on the table for discussion
» Expectations of achieving agricultural self-sufficiency within 3-5 years
» Ministry of Agriculture: Launches the Electronic Inquiry System Service
» Electricity contract employees demonstrate in Maysan to demand permanent employment
» The Council of Ministers holds its regular session headed by Al-Sudani
» Iraqi oil exports to America amounted to more than 6 million barrels during the past month
» Launching the major national campaign to raise awareness of the Social Security Law
» Private Banks Association: We support the Prime Minister’s directives to localize private sector emp
» Parliamentary Committee: The Social Security Fund has become sovereign and the legislation of the la
» Britain launches programme inside Iraq to combat 'Kurdish human trafficking gangs' in France
» Warnings of delay in forming the regional government: will push regional and international parties t
» Dollar prices rise again in Baghdad Stock Exchange and Exchanges
» Al-Sudani praises the assistance provided by the United Nations mission to Iraq in facing challenges
» The Private Banks Association announces its support for Al-Sudani’s approach to localizing private s
» Interior: We have achieved a very significant decrease in crime rates across the country
» The Private Banks Association announces its support for Al-Sudani’s approach to localizing private s
» Iraq, Saudi Arabia sign MoU for military cooperation, boost bilateral ties
» Transportation: Direct flights to 4 global cities
» Prime Minister stresses importance of Mr. Sistani's diagnosis of Iraq's needs
» “To enhance national security”.. Parliamentary Committee: Intelligence Service Law is ready to be pr
» Optimism for a bountiful agricultural season.. Kurdistan Region records record high rainfall amounts
» Al-Sistani’s “Seven Commandments” occupy Iraqi politics.. A reading of the position of the authority
» As the date approaches, will Article 140 hinder the population census?
» Prime Minister directs unification of efforts in the Iraqi Media Network
» “Framework” coups with Sunni facades on the map of local governments in preparation for the 2025 ele
» Parliament intends to extend the legislative session for a month
» Difficult tests facing Parliament.. What are the scenarios for the remainder of the current session?
» Parliamentary Security: Iran will launch a new strike against “Israel” within a short period.. What
» Barzani to Romanowski: We have started negotiations to form the tenth government and no veto on any
» Al-Sudani directs the localization of private sector salaries and sets a date for the departure of c
» Bakhtiar Haji meets a delegation from the General Directorate of Civil Defense in the Kurdistan Regi
» New Cities Authority sets timeframes for project completion, reveals details of its services
» Oil announces completion of drilling and rehabilitating 15 wells during the past month
» Ministerial Council for Economy: Taking the necessary measures and decisions that contribute to mark
» Parliamentary Legal: There is a trend to extend the legislative term of Parliament
» What is the truth about extending the legislative term of the House of Representatives?
» The "Freedom of Demonstration" Law is Ready for Voting.. How Was It Amended?
» Mr. Al-Sadr on the US elections: It is shameful for an Arab to pin his hopes on a senile or insane p
» Laws stuck hostage to disputes between blocs
» Doubts after the decline in power supply at the beginning of each month.. Is there a deal between ge
» Integrity and the Financial Supervision Bureau agree to activate the cooperation agreement between t
» Al-Mashhadani faces 170 suspended laws.. Will they be approved or deported?
» Parliamentary demands to cancel the security agreement with Washington
» MP: Oil derivatives smuggling has decreased by 80% in Iraq
» After years of controversy, the Minority Protection Act is submitted for the first reading
» Al-Sayhoud: The ministerial reshuffle is useless for several reasons
» Iraqi government makes changes to the General Secretariat: Al-Juhaishi succeeds Al-Halbousi
» Extension of the legislative term of the Iraqi parliament for an additional month to pass laws
» Prime Minister: The necessity of strengthening Iraq's position to be at the forefront of the region'
» Parliamentary Transportation: We are determined to pass the Civil Aviation Authority Law
» Baghdad Council: Study of the reality of companies applying to implement projects
» Water Resources announces its control over the oil slick in the Tigris River
» Reconstruction: A new government vision for distributing serviced lands among those entitled to them
» Parliamentary Immigration Committee demands increasing the amount of the return grant
» Accreditation of specialized graduates to support quality control
» Heritage markets and buildings in Mosul after its reconstruction
» Specialized committee to ensure acceptance of cybersecurity outputs
» The Ministry of Interior issues mechanisms to regulate the work of private security companies
» Baghdad Council: Study of the reality of companies applying to implement projects
» Welcome to the trends of establishing an administrative capital
» Securities trade more than 88 billion shares