Unstoppable Gas Leaks in Texas Even Worse than California’s, Media Silent
Published: February 23, 2016
All told, the Aliso Canyon leak thrust an estimated 96,000 metric tons of potent methane — not to mention benzene, nitrogen oxides, and other noxious substances — into the atmosphere over a period of months. So vast was the impact of the leak, it has been likened in impactful scope to BP’s Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico.
California, however, isn’t the only state dealing with mammoth methane leakage.
Texas is dealing with a comparable disaster that has been overlooked by officials and the media, in part, because the state’s methane emanates from a powerful industry’s infrastructure. According to the Texas Observer’s Naveena Sadasivam:
“Every hour, natural gas facilities in North Texas’ Barnett Shale region emit thousands of tons of methane — a greenhouse gas at least 20 times more potent than carbon dioxide — and a slate of noxious pollutants such as nitrogen oxides and benzene.
“The Aliso Canyon leak was big. The Barnett leaks, combined, are even bigger.”
At its peak, the SoCal Gas leak emitted 58,000 kilograms of methane per hour. By comparison, researchers with universities in Colorado and Michigan, partnering with the Environmental Defense Fund, estimate around 60,000 kilograms are spewed every hour by over 25,000 natural gas wells in operation on the Barnett Shale — with the Dallas/Fort Worth Metroplex at the center. This amounts to around 544,000 tons of methane every year. But contrary to the magnitude of the Aliso Canyon event, emissions caused by oil and gas extraction from the Barnett Shale — and a second large formation, Eagle Ford Shale — won’t cease as long as hydraulic fracturing remains the boon it has been to the fossil fuel industry.
An eight-month long study of Eagle Ford by the Center for Public Integrity, the Weather Channel, and InsideClimate News found “a system that does more to protect the industry than the public.”
Due to a scarcity of air quality monitoring stations, with only five permanent monitors to cover Eagle Ford’s nearly 20,000 square miles, state officials simply don’t know the extent of pollutants in the air. Many facilities are permitted to police themselves, and aren’t required to submit those findings. Not that regulators would have an easy time enforcing a reporting mandate, as the “Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ), which regulates most air emissions, doesn’t even know some of these facilities exist.”
David Sterling, chair of the University of North Texas Health Science Center, told InsideClimate News, “As much as I would like to believe that industry can police itself, history has shown that that has not worked without sufficient oversight.” With TCEQ’s budget having fallen 34 percent between 2010 and 2014, it’s virtually impossible to imagine such oversight increasing in the future.
There is a dearth of accountability for lawbreakers in Texas’ oil and gas industry. As the study discovered, in a period of nearly two years beginning in January 2010, 284 complaints against the industry — and “164 documented violations” — led to just two non-punitive fines, the larger of which was a mere $14,250.
Though alarming, that gap in accountability isn’t a surprise.
“Texas officials tasked with overseeing the industry are often its strongest defenders,” stated the study. “The Texas Railroad Commission, which issues drilling permits and regulates all other aspects of oil and gas production, is controlled by three elected commissioners who accepted more than $2 million in campaign contributions from the industry during the 2012 election cycle, according to data from the National Institute on Money in State Politics.”
Texas lawmakers are often personally tied to the industry, as “nearly one in four state legislators, or his or her spouse, has a financial interest in at least one energy company active in the Eagle Ford,” according to an analysis of personal financial forms by CPI cited by the study.
Residents located in the two Texas shale production regions experience many similar symptoms to those in Porter Ranch near Aliso Canyon, such as nosebleeds, dizziness, nausea, and various respiratory ailments. Those symptoms could be due to any number of pollutants and toxins. As the study described:
“Chemicals released during oil and gas extraction include hydrogen sulfide, a deadly gas found in abundance in Eagle Ford wells; volatile organic compounds (VOCs) like benzene, a known carcinogen; sulfur dioxide and particulate matter, which irritate the lungs; and other harmful substances such as carbon monoxide and carbon disulfide. VOCs also mix with nitrogen oxides emitted from field equipment to create ozone, a major respiratory hazard.
“Studies show that, depending on the concentration and length of exposure, these chemicals can cause a range of ailments, from minor headaches to neurological damage and cancer. People in the Eagle Ford face an added risk: hydrogen sulfide, also known as H2S or sour gas, a naturally occurring component of crude oil and natural gas that lurks underground.”
Texas’ shale facilities are responsible for 8 percent of the nation’s methane emissions, already; but the combination of faulty equipment and lack of monitoring sites mean occasional large methane releases from wells — called “super-emitters” — won’t necessarily be noticed immediately.
“If one well was a super-emitter the day we measured them, it could change the next day,” explained Daniel Zavala-Araiza, lead researcher of a 2015 Barnett Shale methane study by the Environmental Defense Fund, in the Observer. “It’s not just about finding a handful of sites. You need to be looking continuously to keep finding the ones that are malfunctioning … If you don’t have frequent monitoring, there’s no way you’re going to know when one of these super-emitters begins spewing.”
In fact, a recent study by Harvard University points the finger at the United States as the cause of an enormous spike in global methane emissions over the past decade, accounting for 30 – 60 percent of all “human-caused atmospheric emissions.”
“I believe the U.S. probably is responsible for this much of an increase in global methane emissions,” said Roger Howarth, a methane researcher at Cornell University, who is unaffiliated with the Harvard study, theGuardian reported. “And, the increase almost certainly must be coming from the fracking and from the increase in use of natural gas.”
Texas residents unfortunate enough to find their homes positioned near oil or gas facilities aren’t left with much recourse to combat the state’s infamous industry. Shale gas production more than doubled between 2009 and 2014, though it has slowed slightly with the recent glut. As InsideClimate News reported, state Representative Harvey Hilderbran tellingly asserted to a media panel in 2014:
“I believe if you’re anti-oil and gas, you’re anti-Texas.”
http://www.blacklistednews.com/Unstoppable_Gas_Leaks_in_Texas_Even_Worse_than_California%E2%80%99s%2C_Media_Silent/49234/0/38/38/Y/M.html
Published: February 23, 2016
By Claire Bernish at theantimedia.org
Texas — After the mammoth methane gas leak that spewed uncontrollably from a damaged well in California’s Aliso Canyon was finally capped last week, residents of nearby Porter Ranch began trepidatiously returning to their homes. Lingering doubts over whether Southern California Gas Company will continue using the underground storage field have left many wondering if concerns for their safety are being considered at all — particularly considering the company has, so far, only been charged with misdemeanor violations.All told, the Aliso Canyon leak thrust an estimated 96,000 metric tons of potent methane — not to mention benzene, nitrogen oxides, and other noxious substances — into the atmosphere over a period of months. So vast was the impact of the leak, it has been likened in impactful scope to BP’s Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico.
California, however, isn’t the only state dealing with mammoth methane leakage.
Texas is dealing with a comparable disaster that has been overlooked by officials and the media, in part, because the state’s methane emanates from a powerful industry’s infrastructure. According to the Texas Observer’s Naveena Sadasivam:
“Every hour, natural gas facilities in North Texas’ Barnett Shale region emit thousands of tons of methane — a greenhouse gas at least 20 times more potent than carbon dioxide — and a slate of noxious pollutants such as nitrogen oxides and benzene.
“The Aliso Canyon leak was big. The Barnett leaks, combined, are even bigger.”
At its peak, the SoCal Gas leak emitted 58,000 kilograms of methane per hour. By comparison, researchers with universities in Colorado and Michigan, partnering with the Environmental Defense Fund, estimate around 60,000 kilograms are spewed every hour by over 25,000 natural gas wells in operation on the Barnett Shale — with the Dallas/Fort Worth Metroplex at the center. This amounts to around 544,000 tons of methane every year. But contrary to the magnitude of the Aliso Canyon event, emissions caused by oil and gas extraction from the Barnett Shale — and a second large formation, Eagle Ford Shale — won’t cease as long as hydraulic fracturing remains the boon it has been to the fossil fuel industry.
An eight-month long study of Eagle Ford by the Center for Public Integrity, the Weather Channel, and InsideClimate News found “a system that does more to protect the industry than the public.”
Due to a scarcity of air quality monitoring stations, with only five permanent monitors to cover Eagle Ford’s nearly 20,000 square miles, state officials simply don’t know the extent of pollutants in the air. Many facilities are permitted to police themselves, and aren’t required to submit those findings. Not that regulators would have an easy time enforcing a reporting mandate, as the “Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ), which regulates most air emissions, doesn’t even know some of these facilities exist.”
David Sterling, chair of the University of North Texas Health Science Center, told InsideClimate News, “As much as I would like to believe that industry can police itself, history has shown that that has not worked without sufficient oversight.” With TCEQ’s budget having fallen 34 percent between 2010 and 2014, it’s virtually impossible to imagine such oversight increasing in the future.
There is a dearth of accountability for lawbreakers in Texas’ oil and gas industry. As the study discovered, in a period of nearly two years beginning in January 2010, 284 complaints against the industry — and “164 documented violations” — led to just two non-punitive fines, the larger of which was a mere $14,250.
Though alarming, that gap in accountability isn’t a surprise.
“Texas officials tasked with overseeing the industry are often its strongest defenders,” stated the study. “The Texas Railroad Commission, which issues drilling permits and regulates all other aspects of oil and gas production, is controlled by three elected commissioners who accepted more than $2 million in campaign contributions from the industry during the 2012 election cycle, according to data from the National Institute on Money in State Politics.”
Texas lawmakers are often personally tied to the industry, as “nearly one in four state legislators, or his or her spouse, has a financial interest in at least one energy company active in the Eagle Ford,” according to an analysis of personal financial forms by CPI cited by the study.
Residents located in the two Texas shale production regions experience many similar symptoms to those in Porter Ranch near Aliso Canyon, such as nosebleeds, dizziness, nausea, and various respiratory ailments. Those symptoms could be due to any number of pollutants and toxins. As the study described:
“Chemicals released during oil and gas extraction include hydrogen sulfide, a deadly gas found in abundance in Eagle Ford wells; volatile organic compounds (VOCs) like benzene, a known carcinogen; sulfur dioxide and particulate matter, which irritate the lungs; and other harmful substances such as carbon monoxide and carbon disulfide. VOCs also mix with nitrogen oxides emitted from field equipment to create ozone, a major respiratory hazard.
“Studies show that, depending on the concentration and length of exposure, these chemicals can cause a range of ailments, from minor headaches to neurological damage and cancer. People in the Eagle Ford face an added risk: hydrogen sulfide, also known as H2S or sour gas, a naturally occurring component of crude oil and natural gas that lurks underground.”
Texas’ shale facilities are responsible for 8 percent of the nation’s methane emissions, already; but the combination of faulty equipment and lack of monitoring sites mean occasional large methane releases from wells — called “super-emitters” — won’t necessarily be noticed immediately.
“If one well was a super-emitter the day we measured them, it could change the next day,” explained Daniel Zavala-Araiza, lead researcher of a 2015 Barnett Shale methane study by the Environmental Defense Fund, in the Observer. “It’s not just about finding a handful of sites. You need to be looking continuously to keep finding the ones that are malfunctioning … If you don’t have frequent monitoring, there’s no way you’re going to know when one of these super-emitters begins spewing.”
In fact, a recent study by Harvard University points the finger at the United States as the cause of an enormous spike in global methane emissions over the past decade, accounting for 30 – 60 percent of all “human-caused atmospheric emissions.”
“I believe the U.S. probably is responsible for this much of an increase in global methane emissions,” said Roger Howarth, a methane researcher at Cornell University, who is unaffiliated with the Harvard study, theGuardian reported. “And, the increase almost certainly must be coming from the fracking and from the increase in use of natural gas.”
Texas residents unfortunate enough to find their homes positioned near oil or gas facilities aren’t left with much recourse to combat the state’s infamous industry. Shale gas production more than doubled between 2009 and 2014, though it has slowed slightly with the recent glut. As InsideClimate News reported, state Representative Harvey Hilderbran tellingly asserted to a media panel in 2014:
“I believe if you’re anti-oil and gas, you’re anti-Texas.”
http://www.blacklistednews.com/Unstoppable_Gas_Leaks_in_Texas_Even_Worse_than_California%E2%80%99s%2C_Media_Silent/49234/0/38/38/Y/M.html
» Expert: Fears that the government will resort to printing a monetary block at an amount of 82-87 tri
» Al-Sudanese directs to simplify the procedures for merchants' dealings in the concerned / expanded s
» Pavel Talabani is discussing with the German ambassador ways to overcome the differences between the
» Foreign Ministry: An Iraqi delegation to Washington to discuss basic issues related to financial and
» with the video. . The National Security Agency announces the arrest of a group of owners of large co
» A call for major demonstrations tomorrow in Tahrir Square to reduce the exchange rate of the dollar
» The Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces issues directives to tackle currency smuggling and arrest
» Sanad ... a meeting in Turkey between the Iraqi delegation and a delegation representing the US Fede
» The dollar crisis will not be resolved soon... a "disappointed" statement from the parliamentary fin
» A good opportunity before prices rise.. Iraq is racing against time to buy wheat immediatelyproposal
» A bank releases good news for merchants: dollars at the official rate and “no commission” transfersp
» Iraq's chambers of commerce and economic elites in the Sudanese office: 10 urgent points to reduce t
» The Ministry of Education denies that "the illiteracy rate in Iraq has reached 47 percent."proposals
» Iraq market: trading of shares worth 5 billion dinars within a week
» Blaskhart calls for expediting the approval of the budget and giving priority to diversifying the ec
» Petroleum products: The fuel card will be applied in all governorates
» Foreign Ministry: The Iraqi delegation will discuss in Washington the rise of the dollar and financi
» Al-Halbousi: Parliament supports the Iraqi government and the bilateral cooperation agreement with S
» The Russian Foreign Minister will visit Iraq next Sunday
» Deputy: The budget bill will be on the cabinet table next week
» The President of the Republic: Approving the budget is a starting point for the development process
» KTFA Wednesday Night CC "The World Pours Into Iraq's Reforms" 2-1-2023
» KTFA Members "Wednesday News" 2-1-2023
» An Iraqi delegation to Washington: pledges to cut dollar smuggling routes
» A financial expert warns the Central Bank of resorting to storing the local currency because of the
» The New York Times: Baghdad is losing green spaces to the real estate boom
» Minister of Industry: Iraq is a safe environment for investment
» Work: The value of our loans is 8 million, despite the law allowing 20 million
» Financial expert Mahmoud Dagher issues a warning about local currency storage
» Saudi Foreign Minister to the President of the Republic: What we hear about Iraq gives hope and econ
» After the dollar's jump to more than 170,000.. security raids, stock exchanges and exchanges stopped
» A deputy close to Al-Sudani attacks Al-Halbousi again: He distributes the committees to the heads of
» In their meeting that took place yesterday.. What did Al-Abadi and Al-Sudani discuss in terms of mea
» Details of the Council of Ministers decision to create job grades
» Gulf Electrical Interconnection Authority: Next month, we will start working in southern Iraq, and i
» Al-Kaldani, Al-Samarrai and Talabani confirm their support for the steps of the Sudanese government
» A detailed map of the parliament's work... 70 laws on the way to legislation, including governmental
» Kurdistan is on a quiet fire.. An Iranian threat to invade and a decision from Baghdad may change th
» The President of the Republic calls on the Ministries of Justice and the Interior to resolve the cas
» The Kurdistan government attacks the Federal Ministry of Oil: it puts pressure on companies in the r
» A deputy stresses the need to hold manipulators accountable at dollar exchange rates and invites rel
» About 7 billion tons annually.. A specialist determines the value of Iranian gas debts to Iraq
» US network: Washington controls the entire energy sector in the Kurdistan region
» The Minister of Labor directs to survey all areas inhabited by Bedouins in Muthanna
» In numbers... The Council of Ministers' decision to create job grades
» A government directive to construct a train between the holy city of Karbala and Najaf
» Foreign Minister to his Saudi counterpart: We have continuous cooperation in the field of security a
» Conscious / a political movement calling on al-Sadr to end his retreat
» Aware / Al-Zubaidi: America is playing its tricks against Iraq through its control of oil revenues
» Ina / Al-Sudani directs to audit the revenues generated by mobile phone companies
» Ina / Al-Tamimi: The Democratic call for structuring the Federal Court is illegal
» As part of his series of meetings, the delegation of the Kurdistan Democratic Party visits the headq
» Masrour Barzani is discussing with the British ambassador holding parliamentary elections in the reg
» Al-Sudani and Al-Abadi are looking for "effective solutions" to control the dollar prices
» Fuad Hussein: We are looking forward to providing Iraq with electric energy through the Saudi or Gul
» The $100 category exceeds the barrier of 170,000 dinars in the markets of Baghdad and Erbil
» Currency auction sale.. Central bank sales of dollars decreased by more than 38%
» A Turkish company submits proposals for the construction of residential cities and roads projects in
» Finance announces the direct financing of the salaries of retirees for the current month of February
» Oil prices rise with the decline of the dollar and the decision of OPEC +
» Basra Oil expects the acquisition rates of "Iraq and Qatar" in the Total project
» SOMO: The average price of a barrel of oil exported to Jordan was less than 9 dollars over the past
» Trade reveals the fate of the ration card after the delay in approving the budget
» The governor of Baghdad obliges the companies executing the projects to double the working hours
» Al-Sudani: All possibilities are contained in adjusting the exchange rate of the dollar
» With a circulation close to a trillion dinars.. The Iraq Stock Exchange reveals the most important i
» The most prominent of which is a comprehensive economic crisis.. Mahmoud Dagher summarizes the conse
» Iraq's oil revenues rise by 1.1% in January
» Theft of the century involves new defendants, including a former tax director
» A plan to consolidate private university education
» The distribution of parliamentary committees arouses the discontent of components and independents
» The opening of Iraqi schools in European countries early next year
» Trade: No new additions to the ration card items
» A “slow” rapprochement between the two Kurdish parties
» Al-Asadi: About two million are unemployed
» Investment directs companies to adopt the official price
» Planning It manages repair and reconstruction projects
» Specialists warn of a decline in the "monetary mass" of the dinar
» An American vision: Al-Sudani is active, cunning, and pragmatic, and he can play the role of mediato
» To solve the dollar crisis.. A parliamentary proposal to convert car purchases into Iraqi dinars
» An American network: The recent federal decision will raise home and car premiums by 10%
» Parliamentary Finance begins to discuss the Workers' Retirement Law in preparation for its passage
» Awareness movement declares opposition to the framework government and looks forward to ending al-Sa
» Recovering $80 million...and integrity: fighting corruption is a collective responsibility
» The foreign minister and the US ambassador discuss the axes and agenda for Washington's visit
» وزير الهجرة تبحث مع السفير الإيطالي أوضاع المكونات وملف الهجرة غير الشرعية
» Youth Minister: If the visa expires, the process of visiting Iraq will continue
» Continuous health control campaigns implemented by the health control staff in the Karkh side to imp
» International report: The performance of the Iraqi government during the first 100 days was not sati
» The United States refuses to postpone dollar conversion restrictions due to Iranian provocations
» With a financial contribution.. Education intends to open Iraqi schools in European countries
» Al-Sudani directs government institutions to give full space to media directors
» Billions of dollars... Reasons why Qatar seeks to invest in Iraq's oil
» Work determines the controls for granting loans to citizens
» The foreign minister and the US ambassador discuss the agenda for the Iraqi delegation's visit to Wa
» Al-Sudani directs to audit the revenues generated by the mobile phone companies
» Parliamentary Planning Committee: Making amendments to the constitution has become necessary
» Integrity reveals an exaggeration in purchasing medical devices at 700 million dinars in Nineveh