Cuba to US: We don’t want your food
As the White House tries to open up a trade relationship, Cuba shuts off the spigot. What’s going on?
By Danny Vinik
As President Obama’s Commerce Secretary Penny Pritzker journeys to Havana tomorrow to promote the idea of a warmer U.S. trade relationship with Cuba, she's shadowed by an awkward fact: The existing trade between the two nations is vanishing, and nobody is quite sure why.
Strange as it might sound for a country under a 53-year embargo, Cuba does buy a significant quantity of American goods every year, thanks to a little-known exception that allows American companies to sell food and medical supplies there. But as the two countries grow diplomatically closer, that business relationship has dropped off sharply.
Agricultural exports to Cuba slid from $710 million to $291 million between 2007 and in 2014. In the first seven months of this year, they’ve fallen to $122 million, a 41 percent drop. In July, the only agricultural product that Cuba imported from the United States was poultry, according to the U.S. Cuba Trade and Economic Council.
As Pritzker arrives on Tuesday for two days of high-level talks with senior Cuban officials, the drop-off is a stark reminder of how much control the Cuban government can exert over the relationship—and the limits of the White House’s ability to promote U.S. interests.
"What the Obama administration does is only 50 percent of the equation. This is also about what the Cuban government wants,” said John Kavulich, the president of the U.S-Cuba Trade and Economic Council. “And right now the Cuban government is showing a less than enthusiastic focus on what the president’s done.”
In part the numbers are going down because of pure economics: falling commodity prices push down the value of all trade. Many experts also point to the fact that Cuba can buy agricultural products in a global market. The U.S. has some major competitive advantages—high-quality products and a coastline less than 100 miles from Cuban soil—but American producers still have international competition. And a U.S. law forbids domestic producers from selling agricultural goods on credit to Cuba, putting U.S. producers at a disadvantage.
But many experts say economics is only part of the reason for the decline in exports. They also point a finger at politics. All U.S. agricultural goods must be sold to one state-owned company, Alimport, and many Cuba observers generally believe the Castro regime uses it as a political lever. During much of the 2000s, Alimport purchased U.S. agricultural products from dozens of states with the hope of garnering support from the states’ respective lawmakers to repeal the embargo.
"Alimport can certainly make decisions on imports that aren’t purely economic,” said Michael Gershberg, the special counsel at Fried Frank who focuses on trade issues. “If they receive orders from the government to make decision based on political reasons, that can certainly have an effect [on purchases].”
When the strategy failed, the Cuban government moved in the opposite direction: Instead of buying from many different states, it decided to dramatically cut back on all U.S. agricultural products.
“They tried the carrot. That didn’t work,” said Parr Rosson, the head of the department of agricultural economics at Texas A&M University. “This may be the stick.”
As diplomatic relations improved over the past year, the “stick” approach remains. In 2007, U.S. producers sold $109 million worth of corn and $67 million worth of soybeans to Alimport. Through July of this year, they’ve sold less than $5 million worth of corn and less than $7 million worth of soybeans. In fact, total U.S. food sales to Cuba fell to less than $4 million in July, one of the lowest numbers since the law allowing such U.S. agricultural exports took effect in 2001.
Just a few years ago, WestStar Food, a Texas agricultural company specializing in pinto beans, was selling 5,000 tons of beans to Cuba each year, worth around $3.2 million at today’s prices. Then those sales disappeared. “We haven’t exported anything there for almost four years now,” WestStar’s president, Patrick Wallesen, said. “For the most part, the way I see it, they pretty much quit buying everything except chicken and grains.”
At the diplomatic level, all the formal moves have been toward openness: Secretary of State John Kerry reopened the U.S. embassy in Havana in August; a month later the Commerce and Treasury departments relaxed a rule to allow U.S. companies to establish warehouses, storefronts and offices in Cuba. The government also loosened its telecom restrictions, allowing U.S. telecom and Internet providers to do business on the island. It’s possible that those moves will open new business channels—but it’s also possible the farm sales are a sign Cuba isn’t biting
“The U.S. can do what it can do,” said David Salmonsen, the senior director for congressional relations at the American Farm Bureau Federation. “Fully having normal trade relations will help. But the focus at the same time is on what does Cuba want to do.”
Despite the Obama administration’s desire to renew diplomatic relations with the Cuban government, increased trade still requires cooperation on the part of the Cubans. Pritzker’s visit to Havana this week is intended to push Cuba towards a more open business climate. But if President Raul Castro intends to restrict purchases of U.S. agricultural products as leverage to pressure American politicians into repealing the embargo entirely—a job that falls to Congress—the White House is stuck.
As for Patrick Wallesen, he’s not confident that the Cuban government will be interested in his company’s beans anytime soon. But he’s hopeful that someday, that will change.
“If they would allow me to lease a warehouse and import product into Cuba,” he said, “I would be there tomorrow.”
http://www.politico.com/agenda/story/2015/10/cuba-to-us-we-dont-want-your-food-000263
As the White House tries to open up a trade relationship, Cuba shuts off the spigot. What’s going on?
By Danny Vinik
As President Obama’s Commerce Secretary Penny Pritzker journeys to Havana tomorrow to promote the idea of a warmer U.S. trade relationship with Cuba, she's shadowed by an awkward fact: The existing trade between the two nations is vanishing, and nobody is quite sure why.
Strange as it might sound for a country under a 53-year embargo, Cuba does buy a significant quantity of American goods every year, thanks to a little-known exception that allows American companies to sell food and medical supplies there. But as the two countries grow diplomatically closer, that business relationship has dropped off sharply.
Agricultural exports to Cuba slid from $710 million to $291 million between 2007 and in 2014. In the first seven months of this year, they’ve fallen to $122 million, a 41 percent drop. In July, the only agricultural product that Cuba imported from the United States was poultry, according to the U.S. Cuba Trade and Economic Council.
As Pritzker arrives on Tuesday for two days of high-level talks with senior Cuban officials, the drop-off is a stark reminder of how much control the Cuban government can exert over the relationship—and the limits of the White House’s ability to promote U.S. interests.
"What the Obama administration does is only 50 percent of the equation. This is also about what the Cuban government wants,” said John Kavulich, the president of the U.S-Cuba Trade and Economic Council. “And right now the Cuban government is showing a less than enthusiastic focus on what the president’s done.”
In part the numbers are going down because of pure economics: falling commodity prices push down the value of all trade. Many experts also point to the fact that Cuba can buy agricultural products in a global market. The U.S. has some major competitive advantages—high-quality products and a coastline less than 100 miles from Cuban soil—but American producers still have international competition. And a U.S. law forbids domestic producers from selling agricultural goods on credit to Cuba, putting U.S. producers at a disadvantage.
But many experts say economics is only part of the reason for the decline in exports. They also point a finger at politics. All U.S. agricultural goods must be sold to one state-owned company, Alimport, and many Cuba observers generally believe the Castro regime uses it as a political lever. During much of the 2000s, Alimport purchased U.S. agricultural products from dozens of states with the hope of garnering support from the states’ respective lawmakers to repeal the embargo.
"Alimport can certainly make decisions on imports that aren’t purely economic,” said Michael Gershberg, the special counsel at Fried Frank who focuses on trade issues. “If they receive orders from the government to make decision based on political reasons, that can certainly have an effect [on purchases].”
When the strategy failed, the Cuban government moved in the opposite direction: Instead of buying from many different states, it decided to dramatically cut back on all U.S. agricultural products.
“They tried the carrot. That didn’t work,” said Parr Rosson, the head of the department of agricultural economics at Texas A&M University. “This may be the stick.”
As diplomatic relations improved over the past year, the “stick” approach remains. In 2007, U.S. producers sold $109 million worth of corn and $67 million worth of soybeans to Alimport. Through July of this year, they’ve sold less than $5 million worth of corn and less than $7 million worth of soybeans. In fact, total U.S. food sales to Cuba fell to less than $4 million in July, one of the lowest numbers since the law allowing such U.S. agricultural exports took effect in 2001.
Just a few years ago, WestStar Food, a Texas agricultural company specializing in pinto beans, was selling 5,000 tons of beans to Cuba each year, worth around $3.2 million at today’s prices. Then those sales disappeared. “We haven’t exported anything there for almost four years now,” WestStar’s president, Patrick Wallesen, said. “For the most part, the way I see it, they pretty much quit buying everything except chicken and grains.”
At the diplomatic level, all the formal moves have been toward openness: Secretary of State John Kerry reopened the U.S. embassy in Havana in August; a month later the Commerce and Treasury departments relaxed a rule to allow U.S. companies to establish warehouses, storefronts and offices in Cuba. The government also loosened its telecom restrictions, allowing U.S. telecom and Internet providers to do business on the island. It’s possible that those moves will open new business channels—but it’s also possible the farm sales are a sign Cuba isn’t biting
“The U.S. can do what it can do,” said David Salmonsen, the senior director for congressional relations at the American Farm Bureau Federation. “Fully having normal trade relations will help. But the focus at the same time is on what does Cuba want to do.”
Despite the Obama administration’s desire to renew diplomatic relations with the Cuban government, increased trade still requires cooperation on the part of the Cubans. Pritzker’s visit to Havana this week is intended to push Cuba towards a more open business climate. But if President Raul Castro intends to restrict purchases of U.S. agricultural products as leverage to pressure American politicians into repealing the embargo entirely—a job that falls to Congress—the White House is stuck.
As for Patrick Wallesen, he’s not confident that the Cuban government will be interested in his company’s beans anytime soon. But he’s hopeful that someday, that will change.
“If they would allow me to lease a warehouse and import product into Cuba,” he said, “I would be there tomorrow.”
http://www.politico.com/agenda/story/2015/10/cuba-to-us-we-dont-want-your-food-000263
» Rental sources for the legitimacy of achievement and governance in Iraq
» Parliamentary Foreign Ministry: Al-Sudani will present in Turkey the file of dollar smuggling throug
» Sudanese advisor reveals the most important axes of the decision table between Iraq and Turkey
» Parliamentary Oil announces the direct study of a very important controversial law
» Cabinet Secretariat: We look forward to the development projects support platform being an opportuni
» Member of Parliament Finance: We have not seen the budget yet
» What is the truth about the dispute between Exxon Mobil and Iraq? .. An expert answers
» Enhancing the role of the private sector and digitizing the economy at the Iraqi-European negotiatio
» The House of Representatives intends to host the Sudanese government
» The Foreign Minister stresses the importance of the European Union's role in promoting democracy in
» Saudi Arabia resumes its flights with Iraq and is considering opening new consulates and ports
» Sudanese advisor: The "dream" project from FAO to Europe is on the discussion table with Erdogan
» The Parliamentary Finance details its "criticisms" on the budget: serious consequences and its defic
» The head of the Investment Authority puts Turkey in front of the "water for investment" equation
» Parliamentary Finance: The return of stability in the exchange rate of the dollar depends on taking
» Al Mandalawi calls on the Businessmen Council to encourage their counterparts to invest in Iraq
» MilitiaMan and Crew: 3-19-2023 U-tube
» Monday Night KTFA CC "The Whale Song" 3-20-2023
» Iraq is heading to offer a sixth licensing round for oil exploration in the west of the country
» American analyzes compare the wars in Iraq and Ukraine and reveal that Saddam fell into the trap of
» Among them is the end-of-service reward.. The Retirement Authority reveals paragraphs that need lega
» A report questioning the economic feasibility of Iraqi ports, including Al-Faw, for several reasons
» Al-Sudani congratulated Newroz: Our Iraq is moving towards the sustainability of civil peace and the
» Opening a center for the Pension Authority at the headquarters of the Ministry of Education to compl
» Retirement and social security..important laws awaiting legislation in Parliament
» Al-Shabki: The oil and gas law will impose the region's authority over areas belonging to Nineveh
» A political warning of rising tensions over the election law
» Expert: The US Secretary of Defense visited Iraq to ensure the survival of his forces
» Al-Rafidain: 5-year period for repayment of advances to employees and retirees
» An economist diagnoses a major imbalance in the budget
» The ports announce the timelines for the completion of the projects of the great port of Faw
» A warning against dragging Iraq towards normalization through the Aqaba oil pipeline
» Parliamentary criticism of passing the election law at dawn and leaving the budget discussion
» Al-Sudani overthrows the Al-Halbousi Secrets and Corruption Fund, amid calls for the arrest of more
» Kurdish dissatisfaction with the continued presence of Turkish forces in northern Iraq to revive the
» The dollar opens trading on Tuesday, exceeding 156 thousand dinars
» Energy Police seize a den for recycling and smuggling of oil derivatives in Anbar
» Parliamentary Committee: The Industrial Investment Law provides a safe and attractive environment fo
» Why does not Iraq re-adopt the coin?
» The Council of Ministers approves six recommendations to support and localize the pharmaceutical ind
» He Ruled Out Voting On It Soon.. Al-Maliki Reveals The Secrets Of The Struggle Over The Budget
» Al-Mandalawi: We reached understandings with the Jordanian side regarding the Iraqi community and fa
» Representative of the Prime Minister: Newroz celebrations are an opportunity to take care of the env
» Al-Sudani: Nowruz passes us by this year, and our Iraq is taking important steps towards sustaining
» Moayad Al-Lami at the "Baghdad International Dialogue" Conference: The procedures of the Joint Opera
» Chihoud: The one-constituency election law will achieve the public interest of the Iraqi people
» Al-Rafidain determines the amounts of loans granted to employees, employees of the Ministry of Inter
» Baghdad and Riyadh are discussing the mechanisms of the Saudi soft loan for the reconstruction of Ir
» The Central Bank launches a new electronic platform
» Central Bank: We have large allocations to support and finance green economy projects
» In pictures, the Central Bank launches the e_Donate platform application
» Al-Mandalawi calls on the Businessmen Council to encourage their counterparts from countries of the
» After the Minister of Interior's directive.. How are the Iraqi security services involved in drug us
» NATO assures Fouad Hussein of its full respect for Iraq's sovereignty and territorial integrity
» Basra crude prices drop by more than 4%
» An Iraqi association launches the first financial electronic application in Iraq related to humanita
» Integrity: Saad Kambesh committed violations in a hotel purchase contract worth 47 billion dinars
» Service Issues administrative orders to those covered by appointment in 9 institutions and ministrie
» American leaders: American forces will remain in Iraq forever to protect his government
» The stability of oil prices.. Brent records 73.84 dollars per barrel
» A slight rise in the exchange rates of the dollar in the local markets
» The arrest of the former head of the Sunni Endowment Office, on the background of corruption files
» Low gold prices in Baghdad markets
» A stabilizing factor.. European praise for Iraq's role in the region
» Al-Sudani assures the Saudi Trade Minister of openness towards developing partnership with the Kingd
» The Iraqi government issues a number of decisions - Urgent
» The governor of Karbala defends the provincial councils and denies the interference of any party by
» To participate in the water conference.. The President of the Republic leaves Iraq for America
» Al-Sistani refused to meet him.. Details of Bremer’s rule in Iraq: I made two mistakes and the decis
» Bakhtiar Hajji visits the Ministry of Trade and Industry of the Kurdistan Regional Government
» The Minister of Immigration announces the launch of an electronic service to communicate with Iraqi
» A new decision from the Ministry of Interior regarding granting licenses to possess and carry weapon
» Al-Sudani: Our visit to Turkey assumes special importance at this particular time, with the positive
» Parliament sets next Saturday to complete the vote on the provisions of the election law
» Globally.. Iraq climbs one rank with the cheapest price of gasoline
» Twenty years ago, in April 2003, American soldiers toppled the statue of Saddam Hussein in Al-Firdou
» How did the invasion of Iraq change the American military doctrine?
» Bush wanted to send an army to overthrow Saddam and an army to rebuild Iraq
» One of them is related to end-of-service benefits.. Retirement talks about paragraphs that need lega
» Advisor to the Prime Minister: This is the government's message to all countries
» OPEC Secretary General from Baghdad: Achieving stability and balance between supply and demand is on
» Al-Rafidain determines the period for repaying the advances of employees and retirees
» Demonstrations in central Baghdad.. Demands to amend the salary scale of employees
» Sudanese headed by an official delegation leaving the country for Turkey
» An American institution reveals secret Iranian documents regarding the results of the Iraq war
» Qubad Talabani calls for transforming the current rapprochement with Baghdad into a permanent agreem
» Cabinet Secretariat: Tomorrow, Tuesday, will be an official holiday on the occasion of Nowruz holida
» A historian reveals the intentions of the American invasion of Iraq: the establishment of the “Great
» Parliamentary investment: a number of amendments that will occur in the investment law in the countr
» Warnings of the consequences of neglecting the Chinese agreement on the Iraqi economy
» Because of corruption.. Middle East: Iraq lost 320 billion dollars
» An Iraqi-Jordanian agreement to coordinate the work of the Chambers of Commerce and Industry and to
» Efforts to attract Saudi capital and investors to the Iraqi market
» Political insistence on enacting a "delayed" law 16 years ago - urgent
» Continuous meetings of the investment chief in Saudi Arabia...and agreements on the way to implement
» Iraq sells its oil below the planned price. The deficit increases before the budget sees the light
» After the Council of Ministers' decision... What is the story of the "settlement" with the Korean Ko
» Salaries and entitlements... A bond reveals exciting details about the Kurdistan region's share of t