In Major Victory For Gold And Silver Traders, Manipulation Lawsuit Against Gold-Fixing Banks Ordered To Proceed

by Tyler Durden
Oct 5, 2016 2:45 PM
Back in April, precious metal traders felt vindicated when Deutsche Bank agreed to settle a July 2014 lawsuit alleging precious metal manipulation by a consortium of banks. As a reminder, In July 2014 we reported that a group of silver bullion banks including Deutsche Bank, Bank of Nova Scotia and HSBC (later UBS was also added to the defendants) were accused of manipulating prices in the multi-billion dollar market. The lawsuit, which was originally filed in a New York district court by veteran litigator J. Scott Nicholson, a resident of Washington DC, alleged that the banks, which oversee the century-old silver fix manipulated the physical and COMEX futures market since January 2007. The lawsuit subsequently received class-action status. It was the first case to target the silver fix.
The alleged conspiracy started by 1999, suppressed prices on roughly $30 billion of silver and silver financial instruments traded each year, and enabled the banks to pocket returns that could top 100 percent annualized, the plaintiffs said.
Many expected that this case would never go anywhere and that the defendant banks would stonewall indefinitely: after all their legal budgets were far greater than the plaintiffs.
Which is why so many were surprised to learn six montsh ago that not only had this lawsuit against precious metals manipulation not been swept away, but that the lead defendant, troubled German bank Deutsche Bank agreed to settle the litigation over allegations it illegally conspired with Bank of Nova Scotia and HSBC Holdings Plc to fix silver prices at the expense of investors. Terms of the settlement were not disclosed, but the accord will include a monetary payment by the German bank.
As we reported, at the time, it was clear that "there would have been neither a settlement nor a payment if the banks had done nothing wrong." As Reuters further noted, Deutsche Bank has signed a binding settlement term sheet, and is negotiating a formal settlement agreement to be submitted for approval by U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni, who oversees the litigation. A Deutsche Bank spokeswoman declined to comment. Lawyers for the investors did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
What was also notable is that in a curious twist, the [url=http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/imageroot/2016/04/09/silver settlement letter_0.jpg]settlement letter revealed a striking development[/url], namely that the former members of the manipulation cartel had turned on each other. To wit:
When dismissing UBS from the settlement, Caproni said this was appropriate because there was nothing showing it manipulated prices, even if it benefited from distortions. "At best, plaintiffs allege that UBS engaged in parallel conduct by offering (along with the fixing members) below-market quotes," Caproni said in her 61-page decision.
However, far more important, was her ruling that investors may pursue antitrust and manipulation claims against Bank of Nova Scotia ("ScotiaBank") and HSBC Holdings Plc, clearing the way for silver manipulation price-fixing litigation.
Caproni said the investors sufficiently, "albeit barely," alleged that Deutsche Bank, HSBC and ScotiaBank violated U.S. antitrust law by conspiring opportunistically to depress the Silver Fix from January 2007 to December 2013. To wit:
This means that a US Federal Court has found that a lawsuit - the first of its kind - has merit and will now proceed to rule on the following claims versus HSBC and Bank of Nova Scotia:
And so the discovery process begins, which will expose just how much market manipulation takes place in the silver (initially as there is a parallel lawsuit taking place with regard to gold) market by major banks. To wit:
In any case, the judge ruled that "the parties must appear for a pretrial conference on October 28, 2016 at 3:00 p.m. in courtroom 443 of the Thurgood Marshall Courthouse, 40 Foley Square, New York, NY 10007."
The lawsuit is one of many in the Manhattan court in which investors have accused banks of conspiring to rig rates and prices in financial and commodities markets: courtesy of this ruling, alleged "manipulator" banks will now be far more eager to reach a settlement or else risk a full blown discovery process.
The full lawsuit is below.
USE LINK FOR LAWSUIT -
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-10-05/major-victory-gold-silver-traders-judge-approves-manipulation-lawsuit-against-hsbc-s

by Tyler Durden
Oct 5, 2016 2:45 PM
Back in April, precious metal traders felt vindicated when Deutsche Bank agreed to settle a July 2014 lawsuit alleging precious metal manipulation by a consortium of banks. As a reminder, In July 2014 we reported that a group of silver bullion banks including Deutsche Bank, Bank of Nova Scotia and HSBC (later UBS was also added to the defendants) were accused of manipulating prices in the multi-billion dollar market. The lawsuit, which was originally filed in a New York district court by veteran litigator J. Scott Nicholson, a resident of Washington DC, alleged that the banks, which oversee the century-old silver fix manipulated the physical and COMEX futures market since January 2007. The lawsuit subsequently received class-action status. It was the first case to target the silver fix.
The alleged conspiracy started by 1999, suppressed prices on roughly $30 billion of silver and silver financial instruments traded each year, and enabled the banks to pocket returns that could top 100 percent annualized, the plaintiffs said.
Many expected that this case would never go anywhere and that the defendant banks would stonewall indefinitely: after all their legal budgets were far greater than the plaintiffs.
Which is why so many were surprised to learn six montsh ago that not only had this lawsuit against precious metals manipulation not been swept away, but that the lead defendant, troubled German bank Deutsche Bank agreed to settle the litigation over allegations it illegally conspired with Bank of Nova Scotia and HSBC Holdings Plc to fix silver prices at the expense of investors. Terms of the settlement were not disclosed, but the accord will include a monetary payment by the German bank.
As we reported, at the time, it was clear that "there would have been neither a settlement nor a payment if the banks had done nothing wrong." As Reuters further noted, Deutsche Bank has signed a binding settlement term sheet, and is negotiating a formal settlement agreement to be submitted for approval by U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni, who oversees the litigation. A Deutsche Bank spokeswoman declined to comment. Lawyers for the investors did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
What was also notable is that in a curious twist, the [url=http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/imageroot/2016/04/09/silver settlement letter_0.jpg]settlement letter revealed a striking development[/url], namely that the former members of the manipulation cartel had turned on each other. To wit:
That was the last time we heard of that particular lawsuit until today, when overnight US District Judge Valerie Caproni dismissed UBS Group AG as a defendant in from the lawsuit.
“In addition to valuable monetary consideration, Deutsche Bank has also agreed to provide cooperation to plaintiffs, including the production of instant messages, and other electronic communications, as part of the settlement. In Plaintiff’s estimation, the cooperation to be provided by Deutsche Bank will substantially assist Plaintiffs in the prosecution of their claims against the non-settling defendants.”
When dismissing UBS from the settlement, Caproni said this was appropriate because there was nothing showing it manipulated prices, even if it benefited from distortions. "At best, plaintiffs allege that UBS engaged in parallel conduct by offering (along with the fixing members) below-market quotes," Caproni said in her 61-page decision.
However, far more important, was her ruling that investors may pursue antitrust and manipulation claims against Bank of Nova Scotia ("ScotiaBank") and HSBC Holdings Plc, clearing the way for silver manipulation price-fixing litigation.
Caproni said the investors sufficiently, "albeit barely," alleged that Deutsche Bank, HSBC and ScotiaBank violated U.S. antitrust law by conspiring opportunistically to depress the Silver Fix from January 2007 to December 2013. To wit:
More importantly, she said the following:
Plaintiffs clear the plausibility standard, albeit barely, with respect to their pricefixing and unlawful restraint of trade claims under Section 1 based on allegations that the Fixing Members conspired opportunistically to depress the Fix Price between January 1, 2007 and December 31, 2013.
As a result, "the Clerk of Court is respectfully directed to close the open motions at docket numbers 73 and 75. Plaintiffs’ deadline to show good cause why leave to replead should be granted is October 17, 2016."
The Fixing Members’ Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED with respect to Plaintiffs’ antitrust claims for price fixing and unlawful restraint of trade from the beginning of the Class Period through December 31, 2006, and from January 1, 2014 through the end of the Class Period. The Fixing Members’ Motion to Dismiss is further GRANTED with respect to Plaintiffs’ manipulative device claims from the beginning of the Class Period through August 15, 2011, and with respect to Plaintiffs’ claims for bid-rigging, and unjust enrichment.
The Fixing Members’ Motion to Dismiss is DENIED with respect to Plaintiffs’ antitrust claims for price fixing and unlawful restraint of trade from January 1, 2007 through December 13, 2013. The Fixing Members’ Motion to Dismiss is further DENIED with respect to Plaintiffs’ price manipulation claims, Plaintiffs’ manipulative device claims after August 15, 2011 and Plaintiffs’ aiding and abetting and principal-agent claims.
This means that a US Federal Court has found that a lawsuit - the first of its kind - has merit and will now proceed to rule on the following claims versus HSBC and Bank of Nova Scotia:
- employment of a manipulative device claims
- bid-rigging, and unjust enrichment.
- price fixing and unlawful restraint
- price manipulation claims
- aiding and abetting and principal-agent claims.
And so the discovery process begins, which will expose just how much market manipulation takes place in the silver (initially as there is a parallel lawsuit taking place with regard to gold) market by major banks. To wit:
Or perhaps not: as Reuters reports, investors plan soon to seek preliminary approval of a settlement, their lawyer Vincent Briganti said on Wednesday. Terms have not been disclosed.
The parties, together with the parties in In re Commodity Exch., Inc., Gold Futures & Options Trading Litig., No. 14-md-2548 (VEC), must meet and confer regarding a proposed schedule for discovery and class certification. The parties are required to submit a joint proposal (if possible) or separate proposals (if a joint proposal is not possible) by October 21, 2016. Within that submission the parties must address whether discovery in this case should be consolidated with discovery in In re Commodity Exch., Inc., Gold Futures & Options Trading Litig., No. 14-md-2548 (VEC), and should include any other items they would like to discuss at the October 28, 2016 conference.
In any case, the judge ruled that "the parties must appear for a pretrial conference on October 28, 2016 at 3:00 p.m. in courtroom 443 of the Thurgood Marshall Courthouse, 40 Foley Square, New York, NY 10007."
The lawsuit is one of many in the Manhattan court in which investors have accused banks of conspiring to rig rates and prices in financial and commodities markets: courtesy of this ruling, alleged "manipulator" banks will now be far more eager to reach a settlement or else risk a full blown discovery process.
The full lawsuit is below.
USE LINK FOR LAWSUIT -
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-10-05/major-victory-gold-silver-traders-judge-approves-manipulation-lawsuit-against-hsbc-s
» The new Deputy Governor of the Central Bank begins his duties
» Sarwa Abdel Wahed: The federal government sent 400 billion to the region, but the amount "disappeare
» KTFA Wed. Night CC "They Added More to the Whale Song" 3-22-2023
» Al-Sudani directs the allocation of funds for farmers within the agricultural plan
» Al-Sudani invites Turkish businessmen to settle their industrial and commercial activities in Al-Faw
» Al-Rafidain announces the establishment of a mechanism regarding the clearance of the employee who i
» Parliamentary Oil: The price of oil in the budget is high and puts the government in an awkward posi
» Advisor to the Prime Minister explains the reason for the high prices of commodities and foodstuffs
» Parliamentary Health reveals four laws expected to be passed to develop the sector
» Miserable performance and public frustration.. Al-Halbousi wasted the most embarrassing period in Ir
» A new plan to increase domestic production and export the surplus outside Iraq
» A deputy calls on Parliament to cancel all "Baathist" laws
» They are honest: do not compromise and compromise on the American presence in the country
» Parliamentary Finance: Efforts to include allocations for the general population census in the 2023
» Parliamentarian: The tripartite budget has not yet reached the parliament committees
» A parliamentary agreement to prevent foreign companies from supervising voter vote servers
» Parliamentary Finance sets the official date for the start of the marathon budget talks
» Al-Toki clarifies the essence of the dispute over the electoral law
» The continued rise in the exchange rate of the dollar...concern in the markets and exhaustion of the
» An economist explains the importance of the railway link between Faw and Ankara
» Central bank sales exceed $ 261 million
» The Ministry of Oil begins experimenting with electronic payment at fuel filling stations
» Agriculture launches the electronic card project
» Planning continues the implementation of the large Diwaniyah sewage project, and the completion rate
» The land fleet transports (34,554) tons of local wheat for the Ministry of Commerce
» Integrity seizes a network of 25 employees accused of wasting 23.3 billion Iraqi dinars
» Transportation proceeds to cover one of the important streets in the ports of Umm Qasr
» Activists launch a sit-in campaign in front of the House of Representatives, in rejection of St. Leg
» Al-Sadr prevents his aids from traveling outside Iraq!
» The House of Representatives reveals procedures to solve the problem of canceled contracts
» State of law reveals developments in the election law
» Deputy: Al-Sudani is determined to expel the PKK from Nineveh
» Al-Sudani's advisor: The cash leakage generated an illegal market that deals with usury and interest
» Al-Mandalawi: Iraq is keen on the strength of its regional and international relations
» Parliamentary Committee: Investment commissions are "tolerant" with investors
» Integrity recovers two trillion dinars over the past year
» Parliamentary Education: The salaries of the lecturers are insured
» Oriented to reduce energy waste and stress collection
» 5 regions in Baghdad within the service effort
» Al-Halbousi discusses the upcoming elections
» The President of the Republic: Iraq is implementing a strict water management plan
» Al-Sudani and Erdogan launch a global strategic project
» Iraq as Vice-Chairman of the Executive Council of the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical W
» Electricity adopts Chinese smart meters
» Nabil Jassim: The need to formulate a new discourse to regulate public broadcasting
» Al-Sudani: Iraqi-Turkish committees to secure fair water shares
» Parliamentary efforts to legislate the industrial investment law
» The Relief and Development Association launches the e-Donate platform
» Baghdad - Ankara
» Al-Muthanna Governorate tops the list of poverty in Iraq
» Education: Hundreds of schools await completion
» Calls for the development of new provinces in the country
» 77 bill stalled on the House table
» A qualitative leap for civil defense in 2023
» The central bank raises its sales to 213 million dollars
» Kufa Cement achieves a qualitative leap in production
» Claims to put a fixed item in the budget to face disasters and crises
» Justice comments on the amnesty law and clarifies its powers
» Decrease in oil prices.. Brent records 75.89 dollars per barrel
» Basra Gas reveals its future plans: We will stop 91% of the burning gas
» Central bank sales increased to more than 261 million dollars
» Former Iraqi Minister of Education: The 3-year budget is a smart move
» How Iraq's tripartite budget plan paves the way for a more stable economic and political future
» Iraq announces coordination with the countries of the region to confront climate change
» Al-Sadr directs eight prominent leaders not to travel within thirty days, and indicates that “import
» Justice comments on the amnesty law and clarifies its powers
» Iraq condemns the statements of the Israeli Minister of Finance regarding the Palestinian people
» The decline in the exchange rates of the dollar with the closure of the Baghdad Stock Exchange
» Adviser to the Ministry of Immigration participates in the closing conference on the Local Peace Agr
» A parliamentary split over the “age of the budget,” and a party objects to making it for three years
» Government measures related to the month of Ramadan, including reducing working hours
» The Independents are waving escalation against St. Lego's pass
» Chief of Integrity: Investigations of the theft of the century are ongoing and we are keen on their
» Government advisor: tangible improvement in the economy.. and directed to support investment
» The factions back down from "expelling the Turkish forces" in exchange for one month of water releas
» Parliamentary Education: The salaries of the lecturers are insured
» Tajikistan expresses its desire to open an embassy in Baghdad
» Deputy: Parliament has about 77 law proposals and is on the verge of enacting them
» Deputy: Passing the budget in Parliament requires consensus among all political parties
» On charges of corruption... a parliamentarian sets an "important" condition for holding Al-Kazemi an
» The President of the Republic: 40% of Iraq's lands are threatened by desertification due to the poli
» American newspaper: Kurdish parties are the biggest beneficiaries of the US invasion of Iraq
» What is the relationship of the "dry canal" with Turkey to the silk project?.. Al-Fatlawi answers
» The decree details the paragraphs of the budget...imaginary numbers in revenues and deficits
» Iraq accedes to Convention 102 on minimum standards for social security
» Parliamentary confirmations to make amendments to the budget related to the canceled contracts
» Al-Sudani: Iraq is serious today in expanding and developing aspects of cooperation with Turkey
» Iraq stresses the importance of activating the terms and paragraphs of the strategic partnership agr
» The Minister of Finance is discussing with a representative delegation the mechanisms of joint coord
» Chihoud: Al-Sudani's regional tours will put Iraq on the right track in improving and investing in i
» Economist: The Sudanese have moved away from the politics of arming with Turkey
» Oil: We aim to increase refining capacity through the implementation of a number of investment refin
» Al-Sudani reveals the details of his meeting with Turkish investors: This is about money transfers
» Iraq launches an appeal to the United Nations: We are facing the worst water crisis in our modern hi
» Electricity: The rise in Iranian gas releases to 25 million will contribute to the stability of proc
» The industry talks about a quantum leap in local cement production
» Iraq's ports are waiting for the largest floating book fair
» The Minister of Labor announces Iraq's accession to an agreement related to the social security stan