In Major Victory For Gold And Silver Traders, Manipulation Lawsuit Against Gold-Fixing Banks Ordered To Proceed

by Tyler Durden
Oct 5, 2016 2:45 PM
Back in April, precious metal traders felt vindicated when Deutsche Bank agreed to settle a July 2014 lawsuit alleging precious metal manipulation by a consortium of banks. As a reminder, In July 2014 we reported that a group of silver bullion banks including Deutsche Bank, Bank of Nova Scotia and HSBC (later UBS was also added to the defendants) were accused of manipulating prices in the multi-billion dollar market. The lawsuit, which was originally filed in a New York district court by veteran litigator J. Scott Nicholson, a resident of Washington DC, alleged that the banks, which oversee the century-old silver fix manipulated the physical and COMEX futures market since January 2007. The lawsuit subsequently received class-action status. It was the first case to target the silver fix.
The alleged conspiracy started by 1999, suppressed prices on roughly $30 billion of silver and silver financial instruments traded each year, and enabled the banks to pocket returns that could top 100 percent annualized, the plaintiffs said.
Many expected that this case would never go anywhere and that the defendant banks would stonewall indefinitely: after all their legal budgets were far greater than the plaintiffs.
Which is why so many were surprised to learn six montsh ago that not only had this lawsuit against precious metals manipulation not been swept away, but that the lead defendant, troubled German bank Deutsche Bank agreed to settle the litigation over allegations it illegally conspired with Bank of Nova Scotia and HSBC Holdings Plc to fix silver prices at the expense of investors. Terms of the settlement were not disclosed, but the accord will include a monetary payment by the German bank.
As we reported, at the time, it was clear that "there would have been neither a settlement nor a payment if the banks had done nothing wrong." As Reuters further noted, Deutsche Bank has signed a binding settlement term sheet, and is negotiating a formal settlement agreement to be submitted for approval by U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni, who oversees the litigation. A Deutsche Bank spokeswoman declined to comment. Lawyers for the investors did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
What was also notable is that in a curious twist, the [url=http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/imageroot/2016/04/09/silver settlement letter_0.jpg]settlement letter revealed a striking development[/url], namely that the former members of the manipulation cartel had turned on each other. To wit:
When dismissing UBS from the settlement, Caproni said this was appropriate because there was nothing showing it manipulated prices, even if it benefited from distortions. "At best, plaintiffs allege that UBS engaged in parallel conduct by offering (along with the fixing members) below-market quotes," Caproni said in her 61-page decision.
However, far more important, was her ruling that investors may pursue antitrust and manipulation claims against Bank of Nova Scotia ("ScotiaBank") and HSBC Holdings Plc, clearing the way for silver manipulation price-fixing litigation.
Caproni said the investors sufficiently, "albeit barely," alleged that Deutsche Bank, HSBC and ScotiaBank violated U.S. antitrust law by conspiring opportunistically to depress the Silver Fix from January 2007 to December 2013. To wit:
This means that a US Federal Court has found that a lawsuit - the first of its kind - has merit and will now proceed to rule on the following claims versus HSBC and Bank of Nova Scotia:
And so the discovery process begins, which will expose just how much market manipulation takes place in the silver (initially as there is a parallel lawsuit taking place with regard to gold) market by major banks. To wit:
In any case, the judge ruled that "the parties must appear for a pretrial conference on October 28, 2016 at 3:00 p.m. in courtroom 443 of the Thurgood Marshall Courthouse, 40 Foley Square, New York, NY 10007."
The lawsuit is one of many in the Manhattan court in which investors have accused banks of conspiring to rig rates and prices in financial and commodities markets: courtesy of this ruling, alleged "manipulator" banks will now be far more eager to reach a settlement or else risk a full blown discovery process.
The full lawsuit is below.
USE LINK FOR LAWSUIT -
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-10-05/major-victory-gold-silver-traders-judge-approves-manipulation-lawsuit-against-hsbc-s

by Tyler Durden
Oct 5, 2016 2:45 PM
Back in April, precious metal traders felt vindicated when Deutsche Bank agreed to settle a July 2014 lawsuit alleging precious metal manipulation by a consortium of banks. As a reminder, In July 2014 we reported that a group of silver bullion banks including Deutsche Bank, Bank of Nova Scotia and HSBC (later UBS was also added to the defendants) were accused of manipulating prices in the multi-billion dollar market. The lawsuit, which was originally filed in a New York district court by veteran litigator J. Scott Nicholson, a resident of Washington DC, alleged that the banks, which oversee the century-old silver fix manipulated the physical and COMEX futures market since January 2007. The lawsuit subsequently received class-action status. It was the first case to target the silver fix.
The alleged conspiracy started by 1999, suppressed prices on roughly $30 billion of silver and silver financial instruments traded each year, and enabled the banks to pocket returns that could top 100 percent annualized, the plaintiffs said.
Many expected that this case would never go anywhere and that the defendant banks would stonewall indefinitely: after all their legal budgets were far greater than the plaintiffs.
Which is why so many were surprised to learn six montsh ago that not only had this lawsuit against precious metals manipulation not been swept away, but that the lead defendant, troubled German bank Deutsche Bank agreed to settle the litigation over allegations it illegally conspired with Bank of Nova Scotia and HSBC Holdings Plc to fix silver prices at the expense of investors. Terms of the settlement were not disclosed, but the accord will include a monetary payment by the German bank.
As we reported, at the time, it was clear that "there would have been neither a settlement nor a payment if the banks had done nothing wrong." As Reuters further noted, Deutsche Bank has signed a binding settlement term sheet, and is negotiating a formal settlement agreement to be submitted for approval by U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni, who oversees the litigation. A Deutsche Bank spokeswoman declined to comment. Lawyers for the investors did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
What was also notable is that in a curious twist, the [url=http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/imageroot/2016/04/09/silver settlement letter_0.jpg]settlement letter revealed a striking development[/url], namely that the former members of the manipulation cartel had turned on each other. To wit:
That was the last time we heard of that particular lawsuit until today, when overnight US District Judge Valerie Caproni dismissed UBS Group AG as a defendant in from the lawsuit.
“In addition to valuable monetary consideration, Deutsche Bank has also agreed to provide cooperation to plaintiffs, including the production of instant messages, and other electronic communications, as part of the settlement. In Plaintiff’s estimation, the cooperation to be provided by Deutsche Bank will substantially assist Plaintiffs in the prosecution of their claims against the non-settling defendants.”
When dismissing UBS from the settlement, Caproni said this was appropriate because there was nothing showing it manipulated prices, even if it benefited from distortions. "At best, plaintiffs allege that UBS engaged in parallel conduct by offering (along with the fixing members) below-market quotes," Caproni said in her 61-page decision.
However, far more important, was her ruling that investors may pursue antitrust and manipulation claims against Bank of Nova Scotia ("ScotiaBank") and HSBC Holdings Plc, clearing the way for silver manipulation price-fixing litigation.
Caproni said the investors sufficiently, "albeit barely," alleged that Deutsche Bank, HSBC and ScotiaBank violated U.S. antitrust law by conspiring opportunistically to depress the Silver Fix from January 2007 to December 2013. To wit:
More importantly, she said the following:
Plaintiffs clear the plausibility standard, albeit barely, with respect to their pricefixing and unlawful restraint of trade claims under Section 1 based on allegations that the Fixing Members conspired opportunistically to depress the Fix Price between January 1, 2007 and December 31, 2013.
As a result, "the Clerk of Court is respectfully directed to close the open motions at docket numbers 73 and 75. Plaintiffs’ deadline to show good cause why leave to replead should be granted is October 17, 2016."
The Fixing Members’ Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED with respect to Plaintiffs’ antitrust claims for price fixing and unlawful restraint of trade from the beginning of the Class Period through December 31, 2006, and from January 1, 2014 through the end of the Class Period. The Fixing Members’ Motion to Dismiss is further GRANTED with respect to Plaintiffs’ manipulative device claims from the beginning of the Class Period through August 15, 2011, and with respect to Plaintiffs’ claims for bid-rigging, and unjust enrichment.
The Fixing Members’ Motion to Dismiss is DENIED with respect to Plaintiffs’ antitrust claims for price fixing and unlawful restraint of trade from January 1, 2007 through December 13, 2013. The Fixing Members’ Motion to Dismiss is further DENIED with respect to Plaintiffs’ price manipulation claims, Plaintiffs’ manipulative device claims after August 15, 2011 and Plaintiffs’ aiding and abetting and principal-agent claims.
This means that a US Federal Court has found that a lawsuit - the first of its kind - has merit and will now proceed to rule on the following claims versus HSBC and Bank of Nova Scotia:
- employment of a manipulative device claims
- bid-rigging, and unjust enrichment.
- price fixing and unlawful restraint
- price manipulation claims
- aiding and abetting and principal-agent claims.
And so the discovery process begins, which will expose just how much market manipulation takes place in the silver (initially as there is a parallel lawsuit taking place with regard to gold) market by major banks. To wit:
Or perhaps not: as Reuters reports, investors plan soon to seek preliminary approval of a settlement, their lawyer Vincent Briganti said on Wednesday. Terms have not been disclosed.
The parties, together with the parties in In re Commodity Exch., Inc., Gold Futures & Options Trading Litig., No. 14-md-2548 (VEC), must meet and confer regarding a proposed schedule for discovery and class certification. The parties are required to submit a joint proposal (if possible) or separate proposals (if a joint proposal is not possible) by October 21, 2016. Within that submission the parties must address whether discovery in this case should be consolidated with discovery in In re Commodity Exch., Inc., Gold Futures & Options Trading Litig., No. 14-md-2548 (VEC), and should include any other items they would like to discuss at the October 28, 2016 conference.
In any case, the judge ruled that "the parties must appear for a pretrial conference on October 28, 2016 at 3:00 p.m. in courtroom 443 of the Thurgood Marshall Courthouse, 40 Foley Square, New York, NY 10007."
The lawsuit is one of many in the Manhattan court in which investors have accused banks of conspiring to rig rates and prices in financial and commodities markets: courtesy of this ruling, alleged "manipulator" banks will now be far more eager to reach a settlement or else risk a full blown discovery process.
The full lawsuit is below.
USE LINK FOR LAWSUIT -
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-10-05/major-victory-gold-silver-traders-judge-approves-manipulation-lawsuit-against-hsbc-s
» Militia Man & Crew Capital Bank Group sponsors a dinner party in honor of the Iraqi delegation part
» The Ministerial Council for the Economy decides not to grant new approvals and licenses to mills for
» Finance: The government cannot pay salaries or any other expenses directly to the region
» Take the money out of the homes.. Parliamentarian: The Central Bank does not have dinars to spend th
» Former member of the Basra Council: Activating the private sector is a solution for the unemployed
» Biden: We look forward to strengthening the partnership between Washington and Baghdad
» Increased pace of work on projects to relieve bottlenecks in Baghdad
» Al-Barti responds to the proposal to link the salaries of the region’s employees with Baghdad: It ca
» An upcoming visit by the Minister of Finance and Economy in the region to Baghdad
» Al-Sudani directs Finance to release the necessary allocations to hold the region’s elections
» I'm the Greatest
» Finance”: The Real Estate Bank will resume granting loans of 50-100 million dinars
» "Controversial points" between Baghdad and the region delay the approval of the oil and gas law
» 10/2/23 Militia Man & Crew Federal Budget Law Iraq - Published In Gazette - Iraq Dinar
» Distributing more than 900,000 “biometric” voter cards in Diyala
» Southern Electricity is implementing a massive campaign to remove bottlenecks and introduce secondar
» Kirkuk's "Achilles' heel" since 2003: A European report warns of escalating tension and suggests sol
» They live and disappear.. Iraq fears the “messages” of kidnapping foreigners and fears the reluctanc
» The files of the elections and the strategic agreement are on the table of Al-Maliki and the America
» Iraqi efforts to construct 36 rainwater dams to confront drought
» Iraq once again praises the results of the security agreement with Iran
» Parliamentary Finance discusses with the Minister of Planning and the governors the reasons for the
» Obelisk Hour: The general amnesty and Kirkuk are confirmed in the political agreement paper
» The Commission announces important dates and responds to concerns about cybersecurity
» The Baghdad International Book Fair records a distinguished Arab and foreign presence
» Before the OPEC+ meeting tomorrow... Iraq comments on the price of $100 per barrel
» Parliamentary energy calls for revealing the fate of compensation payments after Türkiye announced t
» Agriculture is reassuring: there is no scarcity of crops and the local product is available to meet
» In celebration of National Day.. The Sudanese issues a traffic order regarding the Green Zone
» Parliamentary dissatisfaction with the lack of school services in the southern governorates
» Parliamentary Committee: Food security will be achieved due to promising rainy season forecasts
» Al-Maliki to the US Ambassador: Iraq aspires to hold elections capable of providing services to the
» In the document... Education extends the working hours of all universities and regulates the attenda
» Iraq offers Russia participation in the development road project
» Al-Ghais: OPEC is optimistic about demand... and the lack of investment puts energy security at risk
» A senior American official reveals the value of Washington's remaining aid to Kiev
» A politician reveals the reason for Al-Halbousi’s silence regarding the Khor Abdullah file
» Rights: Al-Halbousi’s silence regarding Khor Abdullah confirms his complicity with Kuwait
» The US Army transports 95 tankers of stolen Syrian oil to northern Iraq
» Parliamentary Integrity opens a corruption file worth 38 billion dinars in one of the security servi
» Al-Ittihad: We have no relationship with the Labor Party, and Turkey provides pretexts to bomb Sulay
» The army relies on "fixed points" to secure electricity lines coming from Baghdad towards Diyala
» The popular movement calls on the Kurdish forces to state their position on canceling the Khor Abdul
» Until further notice.. Postponing the winter agricultural plan in Anbar
» Kirkuk rejects Barzani's authority.. The people's desire "fails" the region's plans
» Parliamentary Integrity reveals details of 3 important laws to combat corruption
» Baghdad Governorate announces the achievement of advanced completion rates at Al-Nahrawan Hospital a
» Al-Araji discusses multiple files with the advisor to the President of the Republic
» State of law: For this reason, the implementation of the federal budget law was delayed
» The coordination framework defends Al-Abadi after he was attacked by MP Muhammad Nouri
» Transportation is moving to inventory accounts for its ineffective formations
» The judiciary sentences a political analyst who defamed the Prime Minister
» In the document, the Central Bank gives exchange companies 6 months to implement this order
» Iraq is among the cheapest countries in the world for the price of gasoline
» “Retaliatory” measures against money changers and looming demonstrations.. How did the Central Bank
» Disagreement in the results of counting and sorting.. A political front speaks of a “serious defect”
» An “unreasonable” and proposed measure to resolve the Kurdistan employee salaries crisis: The author
» The dollar is at a new high amid strong data
» Erbil is "desperate" to export oil through Ceyhan and companies are besieging the region with "debts
» Again.. the dollar is flying high against the dinar, recording 158 thousand
» "Sumer" and "Akd" were launched on the way... Iraq is planning to build a fleet of giant tankers to
» Video: Karbala Statistics Department talks about conducting an electronic population census and the
» American report: Because of Iranian influence, Iraq cannot be a partner with Washington
» Experts: Sudanese demand that the international coalition leave Iraq is “far from reality”
» Iraq and Russia conclude a memorandum of understanding in the field of combating corruption and prev
» Media and communications call for intensifying efforts to show the importance of the National Day an
» In pictures: Arab artists arrive in Baghdad to participate in the Iraq International Festival
» Planning announces the preparation of a new electronic system for classifying contracting companies
» In pictures...rare documents regarding Iraq's entry into the League of Nations
» Deputy: 11 countries want to invest in the path of development...the number will reach 50 soon
» Syria accuses America of stealing its oil and transporting it to its bases in Iraq
» Al-Sudani: Iraq will remain a pillar of stability in the region and the world
» There was much disagreement about it and it was chosen 4 years ago.. What do you know about Iraq’s N
» After Sunday's attack, a huge security operation in Turkey against the PKK included 18 provinces
» The Ministers of Interior and Defense and senior security leaders congratulate the Alsumaria Foundat
» The rise in dollar exchange rates in Iraqi markets today
» On Iraqi National Day.. Washington re-introduces the slogan “comprehensive partnership” with Baghdad
» Foreign Affairs: Disagreements over many issues with Türkiye, especially water
» An economic expert proposes a "magic solution" to avoid the crisis of the high price of the dollar
» Famous Bank: The Middle East is going through a golden age
» Kurdistan's violations... began with corruption deals. Will they end with obedience and loyalty to I
» In the document, the Central Bank gives exchange companies 6 months to implement this order
» Rusafa Municipality: A move to automate real estate transactions and building permits
» Baghdad and Moscow concluded a memorandum of understanding in the field of combating corruption
» Transportation forms a committee to analyze immobile bank accounts in the ministry
» Decisions of the 29th session of the Ministerial Council for the Economy
» Compulsory conscription will be absent for a long time this time.. The idea of a “security contrac
» The Ministerial Council for the Economy takes a package of decisions regarding mills... and raising
» An Iraqi company unveils a fertilizer that increases crop productivity by 40%
» American Foreign Policy: Washington must set red lines for the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan
» A new law changes Iraq's strategy to combat drugs
» Parliamentary Finance announces its agreement with the Minister of Planning to resolve the issues of
» Parliament adjourns its session until next Wednesday
» Advisor Mazhar Saleh: Sovereign guarantees encourage the business environment in Iraq
» Exchange companies under categories (A, B)
» After months of suspension and years of disputes.. What is the Iraqi-Turkish oil line?
» The Central Bank denies the scarcity of cash liquidity and describes its currency and gold reserves
» An economic expert details the cash conversion cycle of the Iraqi dinar