Analysis: Why Iraqi constitutional amendments not successful?
August 8, 2016 - 2:25 PM
Although Article 142 of the constitution defines the mechanisms and methods for amending the constitution, differences have prevented the parliament's political blocs from doing so, though they have made efforts to do so. In 2006, the Iraqi parliament formed another committee with the duty of amending the constitution but it failed to reach an ultimate agreement on the articles that needed amendment.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
AhlulBayt News Agency - Collapse of Iraq's Ba'athist regime of Saddam Hussein allowed the world to see an Iraq much different from what it was in the past. The first significant step in post-Saddam time was presenting a new constitution that was approved in 2005. But since it approval, the Iraq constitution has been a debate case of the opposing Iraqi parties, and so far it failed to get an agreed-upon amendment. As the process to review the new Iraqi constitution started, the political discontent of the Sunni Arabs began, and it was the consistency between the Shiite and Kurdish parties that allowed completion of constitution amendment process, and subsequently it winning a major vote of the nation in the referendum in 2005. However even after enactment of fresh constitution and the post-2003 government's winning of legitimacy, a number of articles of the constitution prepared the ground for eruption of dispute and, later, crisis in Iraq. Article 140 is an example of a sticking point in the country's constitution.
Article 140 is taken from the Iraqi interim constitution's Article 58. The article was included in the constitution following major political developments in post-2003 Iraq. Broken in three clauses, the Article 58 was put into interim constitution, aiming at removing the discrimination of the Ba'athist regime. The first clause calls for the transitional government to move in association with Dispute Resolution Council to eliminate all forms of discriminations by the toppled regime against the Kurds and Shiites of the country. The clause secured for the Iraqi natives the right to get back their seized properties, receive compensation, hold job opportunities, and freely express their national and racial identity. The second clause calls for returning the administrative borders of Iraq's provinces to pre-Ba'athist regime time of 1968. The third clause demands an ultimate settlement for the disputed territories including Kirkuk. This urges implementation of the second clause until the mentioned plans are implemented and a transparent census is conducted by a direct call from residents of Kirkuk.
The Article 58 resurfaced under the new name of Article 140 following approval of permanent constitution of Iraq. Two key clauses were included in the Article 140 of the permanent constitution that critically made grounds for divisions. The divisions finally led to calls for a new amendment of constitution after 2007. The first clause tasks the government with arranging for conclusion of implementation process of Article 58 of the interim constitution with all of its clauses. The second clause foresees implementation of Article 58 in three stages of normalization, census, and finally conducting referendum in Kirkuk and other disputed areas in a bid to address the demands of the residents. The deadline for completing the process was determined 31 December 2007. The law enforcer was the government. While the deadline for implementation of clauses of Article 140 was until end of 2007, after more than 9 years, even its initial stages are not implemented yet. Many of the Arab and Turkmen political leaders highlight the Article 140, arguing that Article 58 was unfairly included in Iraq interim constitution. Between 2007 and 2008 the Iraqi parliament raised the bid for reforming the country's constitution. But until now no serious amendment is introduced to the constitution. Why the constitution amendment process is faced by impediments in Iraq? To answer this significant question, two major reasons must be taken into consideration: the ideality and deterrence of the disputes.
Idealistic approach
Iraq’s interim constitution included two key phrases of democratization of the domestic policy and peacefulness of the foreign policy. With some changes, they became the backbone of the permanent constitution of Iraq. This constitutional outlook won approval of a majority of the Iraqi political players. It presented itself as a strategic aim for building the future of Iraq. It must be kept in mind that the two principles are, in fact, in accord with the American liberalism or “democratic peace theory" which notes that the democracies never engage in fighting each other. But the social, and mosaic-style, structure of Iraq under duress of conditions and time cannot hold an uncontested control over the groups without using some levels of violence. The Kurds, Shiites, and Sunnis are the major political players in the country. They hold different and sometimes conflicting demands and interests. On the other hand, since 2007 up to now an enthusiasm for nationality has failed to take the place of a sense of belonging to sub-identity. In other words, the Iraqi constitution has aimed at diversity, something in full accordance with civic nationalism. This model, however, failed so far to find place in the Iraqi society.
The deterrent differences
Although Article 142 of the constitution defines the mechanisms and methods for amending the constitution, differences have prevented the parliament's political blocs from doing so, though they have made efforts to do so. In 2006, the Iraqi parliament formed another committee with the duty of amending the constitution but it failed to reach an ultimate agreement on the articles that needed amendment.
The difference of the Iraqi parliament's blocs is completely justified. But due to the significance of forming the committee and the articles that needed amendment, the political blocs must determine that during the 11 years of implementation of new constitution what articles have proved productive and useful. But it must be taken into account that some constitution articles are not implemented yet, like the Article 140 which urges normalization of status of such ethnic groups as Arabs, Turkmens, and Kurds in regions like Kirkuk where they are dispersed. The article is broken into three stages: restoring the former status, conducting census of the earlier and current population, and holding referendum.
Furthermore, the articles that define the identity of Iraq are subjected to amendment because the constitution asserts an Arab identity for Iraq.
Additionally, some argue that the powers of the PM must be reduced. The subtracted powers must be distributed between the PM and the parliament speaker. Perhaps the most controversial articles of the Iraqi constitution are as follows: the Article 140 which is linked to structure of the regions especially Kirkuk, the powers of the president, distribution of financial sources as well as sharing of power, the law of provinces, the multiple citizenship issue, and the individual rights.
According to Article 142 of constitution of Iraq, a referendum on the amended articles is only called successful if a majority of the voters in a national level approve it. It is unsuccessful if two thirds of voters from three or more provinces reject it. This means that even if 15 provinces accept the amendment and two thirds of other three provinces reject it, then the reforms are not introduced to the country's constitution. On the other side, the Iraqi constitution holds no ideal or a specific goal in terms of the foreign policy. In fact, the foreign policy is slighter in comparison to the domestic policy in terms of significance in the constitution. Perhaps it is for this reason that Iraq is plagued by home conflicts. Without setting itself free from the chains of the domestic disputes Iraq would not be able to have a say in foreign policy.
The constitution asserts that the amendments must win the whole approval of the Constitutional Reforms Committee. In other words, these conditions have made the process of review and amendment of constitution highly difficult. On top of intense differences about Kirkuk, the powers of president and parliament speaker, the provinces law, dual nationality, the individual rights, and moving from parliamentary to presidential system, the deep gaps over specifications and identity of the government must be added.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
» Parliamentary bloc disputes: Vital laws await and divisions grow
» Türkiye: Exporting Iraqi oil via Ceyhan is an alternative and an opportunity to diversify transporta
» Economist rules out any move to amend salary scale
» Al-Surji: 3 reasons behind the weakness of the Iraqi position towards the Turkish incursion
» Minister of Planning: There are no political obstacles preventing the population census
» Al-Sudani sponsors the signing of 3 contracts for industrial projects
» 19 MoUs Signed on First Day of Belt and Road Summit
» Issuance of more than 191 thousand national cards for those covered by social protection
» Housing Fund: We will issue 16,000 transactions of bonds by this date
» Parliamentary Services calls for investing in open lands and turning them into parks: Citizens need
» Iranian Minister of Roads: We will hold consultations with Iraq regarding strategic railway link
» Pezeshkian discusses with Iranian traders obstacles to developing trade with Iraq
» Banking Association Advisor: International Payments and Banking Technologies Conference a Platform t
» Parliamentary Committee Rejects “Free” Oil Export via Aqaba Port
» Unprecedented renaissance.. Iraq's economy recovers and its debts fall to "lowest levels"
» Government confirmation regarding the population census: It will be conducted on time and without ob
» The President of the Republic confirms Iraq's keenness to enhance economic cooperation with its brot
» Transferring youth from social care to education and municipalities
» Exceptional relationship
» Iranian President to {Media Network}: We are determined to strengthen our relations with Iraq
» 14 new memoranda of understanding between Baghdad and Tehran
» Today.. Al-Sudani opens the 25th edition of the Baghdad International Book Fair
» Iraq and Iran towards a strategic partnership
» Strategic Planning for {Sabah}: Census will revitalize services
» The Protection Authority issues more than {1100} smart cards
» Establishment of the Arab Academy for Agricultural Training
» Construction of two residential cities in Muthanna
» Education announces its programming plan for educational television
» Transportation: Efforts to re-raise the Iraqi flag on our ships
» Great preparations to celebrate the birth of the Prophet
» "The killer of the poor".. Why do the poor of Iraq resort to committing suicide with "rat poison"? -
» Three-pronged strategy reduces smuggling in Diyala by 80% in 16 months - Urgent
» Resources discusses winter agricultural plan
» Suspended since 2015.. Accusations against the regional government of procrastinating the issue of e
» With the document.. 4 parliamentary questions directed to the Governor of Baghdad regarding the dela
» Erbil enters Baghdad through Tehran.. Pezeshkian is the region’s lifeline with “power of influence”
» Iranian press "neglects" Pezeshkian's visit.. What is the connection with the reference Sistani?
» The President of the Supreme Judicial Council receives the Saudi Ambassador
» Chairman of the Integrity Commission thanks the Iraqi judiciary for opening an investigation into th
» Economist: The interests of producers and consumers are achieved through a fair price for oil
» Parliamentary Investment Committee gives “advice” on new memoranda signed with Iran
» Parliament supports Kirkuk government and we are ready to be a link for the return of boycotters
» Al-Sudani snatches the "stay" card from the angry "framework"... and the dispute between them intens
» Iraq launches drone industry
» Iraqi Parliament Faces Political Paralysis: Partisan Disagreements Disrupt Legislation and Weaken Ov
» Turkish violations of Iraqi territory exceed 25 thousand cases after 2003
» Federal Minister of Justice meets with the Head of the Kurdistan Regional Government Representation
» Iraq exports 108 million barrels of oil during last August
» Al-Mandlawi to Bazeshkian: Memoranda of Understanding between Iraq and Iran contribute to advancing
» Rafidain Bank identifies three advantages of electronic payment systems
» Iraqi judiciary issues new ruling against Zaid al-Talaqani
» Al-Yekti: Türkiye has 50 military barracks in Iraq and aspires to occupy Mosul and Kirkuk
» Oil volatility widens fears of financial crisis, Sudani advisor ‘worried’ about 2025
» Civil Service Council: Completion of the second phase of hiring certificate holders and top students
» Trade participates in UNESCO Digital Education Week
» Iranian President arrives in Erbil on second day of his visit to Iraq
» Dollar exchange rate drops against dinar in Iraq
» What are the repercussions of Donald Trump's victory in the upcoming elections on the global econom
» utube 9/10/24 MM&C IQD Update-Iraq Dinar-#iraqidinar-#xrpIraq Reconciling-Unif
» utube 9/9/24 MM&C Iraq Dinar-Central Bank-#Iraqidinar #exchangerate #iraqidinarexchangerate Baghda
» US Embassy in Iraq confirms yesterday's attack: No casualties
» Iraq calls for common understanding on debt repayment, Iran urges strategic program
» Criticisms of the Iraqi parliament’s discussion of cancelling the economic unity agreement
» Will Iraq succeed in harmonizing its labor legislation with international standards?
» Al-Maliki's coalition: The Sunni house did not leave the decision of the presidency to the parliamen
» Waiting for legislation.. Laws on the table of the Parliamentary Health Committee
» MP calls on government to pressure Washington to fulfill its obligations towards Iraq
» Prime Minister: Iraq rejects the use of its territory as a launching pad to threaten neighboring cou
» Parliamentary Agriculture Committee stresses the need to legislate the law on agricultural land rent
» Al-Sudani: Iraq's position was clear as a government to expand economic partnership with Iran
» Al-Sudani during a press conference with Bazeshkian: The ties between Iraq and Iran are historic
» Resources: Iraq is the first country in the Middle East to monitor groundwater electronically
» Bitcoin ETFs Lose $1.2 Billion in 8 Days
» Communications: Blocking of websites is done in accordance with final and binding judicial decisions
» The Council of Ministers issues a number of decisions to complete stalled projects
» Signing of 14 bilateral memoranda of understanding between Iraq and Iran
» Work: Two million families covered by protection salaries
» Ratification of a joint agreement between Baghdad and Erbil regarding taxes
» It was launched a few days ago.. What are the objectives of social research on beggars in Iraq?
» Iranian Foreign Minister to Al-Sabah: We look forward to broader horizons with Iraq
» Implementation of the largest water project in Erbil
» Nineveh Exhibition for Construction, Reconstruction and Energy Launches
» Offers from Egyptian companies to implement projects in Iraq
» Work: Two million families covered by protection salaries
» Electricity to {Sabah}: Adopting the combined cycle in all stations
» Desertification and drought swallow 23 percent of agricultural land
» 77 trillion dinars is the country's revenue in 7 months
» Contribute to increasing revenues
» Two experts: Food prices are stable thanks to government support
» With the imminent launch of Al-Faw Port...an international decision to fine Iraqi ports $120 million
» Joint agreement between Baghdad and Erbil to unify tax work
» The first of its kind in Iraq.. Arrest of a member of the Dhi Qar Council on charges of "electronic
» The President of the Supreme Judicial Council receives a delegation from the Arab Union for Combatin
» Kurdistan is a stop for Bezeshkian after Baghdad.. What does Erbil want from Tehran?
» Extensive bilateral talks between the President of the Republic and the Iranian President
» Meeting between Al-Sawad and Baker Hughes USA to develop oil and gas in Iraq
» A "secret" agreement to continue Mandalawi... no new parliament speaker
» Iraqi Oil holds expanded meeting with ALEXANDROS JV in the United States